Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why marriage before children is so important?

187 replies

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 13:02

Excuse my ignorance on this but time and time again I see comments from people on MN’s telling people not to have a child with somebody before marriage - comments I see are along the lines of ‘it’s so risky’ , ‘leaving yourself open’ ‘asking for disaster’

I might just be really naive but can somebody please explain the risks involved?

Myself and DP are TTC now, and all these comments are making me really uneasy, should I genuinely be worried?
We were due to get married this year and then the plan was to start ttc but we have postpone the wedding due to COVID and didn’t want to postpone having a baby too. Should I genuinely get be worried about this? And get married first?

OP posts:
Nocares · 16/02/2021 15:00

People posting here come from a place of privilege in regards to marriage.

A lot of people are actually in private rented accommodation and claim some element of tax credits or are entitled too if they become a single parent with housing benefits on top.

Therefore realistically marriage is neither here nor there for a large portion of the population.

The financial element is only if assets and large sums of money are involved.

If your not a home owner or don't have any large sums of cash then marriage is neither here nor there.

I myself own my own home and a great salary, so my dp would benefit from marrying me and I would be the one taking all the risks..

Dixiechickonhols · 16/02/2021 14:58

Scarface Yes that’s an upsetting scene in the recent TV Programme it’s a sin where man has died and his mother (NOK) has arranged a religious funeral excluding his long term boyfriend.
Unmarried you could be excluded from or have no say in any funeral arrangements. There were several examples of this given by mumsnetters on a similar recent thread.

Zolrets · 16/02/2021 14:54

@Dixie Sadly end of life family arguments happen even when there is a marriage. Second family’s bring a whole other set of issues. I know of one person who married a terminally ill partner and had the upset of being referred to as ‘the wife of 6 months’ by the extended family. Sharing a name, rather than the fact of being married, can be what helps a bit - I found it easier when my Dad died and I handled the estate as I had the same name, compared to my married sister who does not. As I said, it’s not black and white - don’t marry and assume it’s all sorted, don’t live with someone and assume the same. Best protection is financial independence.

canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 14:51

You can have your nok as anyone you chose.
Mine is still a trusted friend.
When I have been in relationships, including a marriage, this never changed on my medical and work details. Same with my wishes in terms of dnr

oakleaffy · 16/02/2021 14:51

The “Less financially well off” of the two is helped by marriage.

Looking at it with cold hard reality, an awful lot of relationships founder, especially with children added.
Even married couples who spent a fortune on fertility treatments end up divorced.

Marriage protects the lesser earner.

ScarfaceCwaw · 16/02/2021 14:49

A not uncommon scenario I've seen on here: woman fully intends on returning to work. However, child turns out to have SEN or physical health problems and cannot go to childcare. One partner is effectively forced to give up work. Which one is it likely to be, unless the mother outearns the man by a lot? Becoming a SAHP is not always a choice, and any workplace penalty is 99% guaranteed to be paid by the woman regardless of who earns more beforehand. The studies show consistently that becoming a father benefits men's careers and hurts women's.

I wanted to be married for both financial and emotional reasons. I didn't want to have children other than with someone who was willing to stand in front of an officiant with me and pledge in a formal, legally binding way that he'd stick with me and be a team with me for life.

Also, you know, you could look up all the reasons that LGBT people campaigned for years to be able to marry their loved ones, and all the things that people suffered because they were unable to.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/02/2021 14:45

I was going to post on similar lines to NYCDreaming When pregnant with first child I did same job and earnt same as DH. She was born with a serious disability undetected on scans then I developed a serious health condition triggered by pregnancy which resulted in me being disabled. My earning capacity was impacted as a result of both of these. I am married but if I hadn’t been I can easily see how it wouldn’t have got done while we reeled from what life had dealt us leaving me at a disadvantage if we split.

Boredsobored · 16/02/2021 14:44

Because it takes more effort to get married than it does to ejaculate!

Ok, that's a bit crude. But I wanted to marry my husband and have a relationship with him first and foremost. It's nice to have that commitment and marriage means a lot to me/ us.

But it's not the be all and end all. My aunty and uncle got married after 20 years together, it was a brilliant wedding and they're a lovely couple with 3 kids they're proud of and lot of grandkids.

Many couples try to have kids first and get married later - a lot do split up but a lot also tie the knot.

JustLyra · 16/02/2021 14:42

@Streamlinerose

I personally think some of these reasons are a load of shit, like ‘leaving the woman vulnerable’.

My DP pays for DC to go to nursery three days a week whilst I study full time on maternity leave.. I am actively improving my life prospects whilst ‘off on maternity leave’.

We’re not married.
Both have equal personal assets in addition to an equal share of the equity in the property.
If we split we’d have DC 50/50 so the time for study/work does not change.

When I return to work I’d have graduated and will be looking for a nice swanky grad job with both experience and education under my belt.

If you’re vulnerable then quite frankly that’s on you and the dynamic in your relationship.

If you have babies without savings, without a plan then that makes you vulnerable. Not the lack of marriage. You can’t then turn around after falling pregnant and choosing to go ahead with it without a safety net and blame the man for not putting a ring on it.

You’re assuming that if you split your partner would have the DC 50% of the time.

Many, many women discover that things change when they split.

My ex wanted kids. To the point he funded IVF to have our girls. Then when they were 6 months old he changed his mind.

He was the kind of guy everyone would have said would have his kids 50/50, play fair with finances etc. He changed. Barely saw them. Childcare is only the responsibility of the RP and I was left with the entire bill or changing my entire career plan.

Your plan is entirely reliant on another person

itispersonal · 16/02/2021 14:40

I'm from the opposite, I don't want to get married because I don't want my rented house to automatically become half his or my inheritance. I am financially better off not being married to him. Especially when 50% of marriages end in divorce

SpringisSpinning · 16/02/2021 14:35

All sorts of reasons why it's better and easier, if you or your partner died you mean nothing in legal terms.. At all.
He dies or even falls seriously ill, your not next of kin

You can't get personal info, do this or that... Nothing.. Because legally you are nothing.

It's not something people think about until its too late
His parents would have the say on where he is buried and how, what happens to ashes.. You can't access any bank accounts in his sole name..

Dixiechickonhols · 16/02/2021 14:35

Zolrets It’s potentially less straightforward though if not married. MIL’s boyfriend has just died and she would have found it far easier as wife to see him in hospital - his adult children did not want her there compounded by covid restrictions limiting visitors. Arguing with his daughter and having to explain situation to hospital staff caused MIL extra distress. Whilst English hospitals may take a more practical view people die abroad on holiday etc you cannot assume your partner will be treated as NOK.

Hannahusky · 16/02/2021 14:34

I think it's also that if your relationship hits hard times or even just you both end up going through hard times, you will feel much more likely to try to work through it if you're married. I know that sounds really old fashioned but I do believe it. My MiL used to say it and I used to think wise up but I think she's onto something as time goes on. I think this is partially why unmarried parents are more likely to separate.

sma1978 · 16/02/2021 14:33

I'll also add, I am now actively trying to teach my teenage daughter, she must be able to rely on herself, and not be dependant on someone else.

Miseryl · 16/02/2021 14:31

I didn't marry either of the fathers of my kids. It would disadvantage me if I did as I earn more than them both and my assets are far higher.

sma1978 · 16/02/2021 14:29

It really depends on your own situation.
Yes if you don't work and become a SAHM, you are financially dependent on your partner, you don't have to be married for that to happen either. That is the risk though.
I had a 20 year reletionship, never married, had 2 kids, who are still school age. Relationship ended last year. But I worked full time, as the main earner. Other than a few months of maternity each time, I have always worked. Our home was rented. When the relationship ended 18 months ago, I was in a much better position than he was, and still is. So it really all depends on your own personal circumstances. Not just right now but down the line years from now.

Zolrets · 16/02/2021 14:24

@RedskyBynight pretty much said it on the first page ‘

It's not marriage that's necessary per se but having financial security.

If you intend to keep working full time, split bills in a fair way, have your name on the mortgage/tenancy agreement, have wills naming each other as beneficiaries .... then you may well be fine.*

But on Mumsnet the prevailing thinking seems to overestimate the value of marriage and underestimate what can be done to make ANY relationship more secure in terms of finance for both parties. I haven’t heard anyone mention next of kin and medical consent yet, that’s normally (erroneously) popped up by now...

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 16/02/2021 14:21

Neither DH nor I wanted to pay inheritance tax if ether of us died. That was a big driver towards marriage. We want more to be left for the kids.

canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 14:20

Are you both clear about which savings pot will be used to cover those times?

canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 14:19

Registry office and once restrictions are lifted have your party. That's a wedding.

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 14:18

Oh and maternity leave, I’ll be taking 9 months, 6 of which are on full pay. The 3 on statutory pay we will be able to cover the shortfall with savings.
DP also has 3 months paternity on 85% which he can take staggered over the first 12 months. He is happy to take this and it’s encouraged at his work.

OP posts:
canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 14:16

Spousal maintenance isn't applied to all divorces.
Married or not, if the other parent is a deadbeat they will walk away, and the resident parent is still left going though CMA unless they are very high earners.

Sugarandteaandmum · 16/02/2021 14:15

The thing is, you don't know what you will want to do when your baby is 9 months old, when you're ttc. You might have a horrific birth injury (sorry, but it is possible, childbirth is an existential risk to you even nowadays). You might feel bonded to your baby and no longer want your high flying career. You and DP don't know how you will each change and what you will want so you need to demonstrate commitment to the family on into future. You demonstrate it by having the baby. He has to do something more. On a population level, women seem always to "blink first" in a staring competition with partners over the child's welfare. That puts you at an innate disadvantage as ultimately you will probably care more about what happens to your child - nursery or SAH parent? Pay for their upkeep or just walk away? Your DP will hold all the cards and you will be left thinking "I hope he's nice enough not to use this advantage". Too precarious for me.

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 14:15

Thanks everyone for responses! Mostly seems to be financial reasons, which is understandable. DP is the higher earner and we do have a joint account which we pay both salaries into and pay everything out of this. Child care would be included in that as I will be going back to work FT and I do have my own pension. We also pay into a joint savings account each month too. Any savings we had before we met we have kept separate (mine is considerably more from inheritance).

We have thought about getting married at the registry office and then having a wedding at a later date. We both agreed we probably wouldn’t bother with the big wedding if we were already married legally as it seemed a bit pointless. But reading the responses I think it seems like legally we should get married now and then we can decide on the ‘wedding’ part at a later date.

OP posts:
HappyasLaura · 16/02/2021 14:12

So many reasons but mainly financial. It’s usually women’s careers that take a backseat when it comes to the child rearing years. Which affects earnings, earning potential and pension contributions. All of which you’ll have zero entitlement to, should you split up without being married.

It doesn’t have to be marriage, it could be a civil partnership also. It’s just protection so for those that don’t believe in marriage, I would hope that they have factored in the fact that they wouldn’t be entitled to any maintenance, except for the children, if they split up.
Would wouldn’t you want to protect yourself.
No one who ever has children intends to split up, and yet 50% of relationships break down. 🤷‍♀️