Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why marriage before children is so important?

187 replies

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 13:02

Excuse my ignorance on this but time and time again I see comments from people on MN’s telling people not to have a child with somebody before marriage - comments I see are along the lines of ‘it’s so risky’ , ‘leaving yourself open’ ‘asking for disaster’

I might just be really naive but can somebody please explain the risks involved?

Myself and DP are TTC now, and all these comments are making me really uneasy, should I genuinely be worried?
We were due to get married this year and then the plan was to start ttc but we have postpone the wedding due to COVID and didn’t want to postpone having a baby too. Should I genuinely get be worried about this? And get married first?

OP posts:
Streamlinerose · 16/02/2021 15:55

House deeds and mortgage in husband's name

That sort of proves the point about partially self inflicted vulnerability though imo, why did this happen if she were contributing? I don’t just mean financially but taking care of children is (at the absolute bare minimum) equivalent to the cost of full time child care which is extortionate. Therefore, she is contributing.

The deeds should have been in both names, if not, that’s of course a red flag far before everything goes tits up.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 16/02/2021 15:52

Having children is a much bigger commitment than marriage. That is why marriage should come first, because if you can't commit to marrying the person how on earth will you be able to raise a child together? If you don't see yourself staying with the person for at least the next couple of decades you shouldn't be having kids with them.

To some extent, yes. I wouldn't want any children of mine to have a dad who wasn't prepared to marry their mother "till death do us part, in sickness and in health, forsaking all others" etc etc. So I wouldn't choose a man like that to have children with, I'd think less of them if that's how they felt as it's easier for a man to walk a way if not married, even if there are children. I don't think many young unmarried men nowadays see having a child with someone as a big deal to be honest, which is terribly sad for the children involved. When there's Z-listers popping out babies with their boyfriends every 5 mins, then splitting up from them 18 months later it just gives people the impression that that's what you do as a man - donate your sperm and then be Disney Dad at weekends and holidays till you make another blended family with someone else who did the same.

There have been so many threads on here where the man has promised to get married "at some point" and keeps putting it off. The relationship ends and 6 months later he's engaged to someone else and the wedding's booked, with plans for kids soon after. I just don't think that some people are 100% convinced that they want to spend the rest of their lives with their other half, and not marrying means they have an easy get-out clause.

No, getting married doesn't mean that you have a guarantee that your husband won't turn out to be a lying cheating shit a few years down the line. But it does guarantee you and your children some protection if he does and if you have an expectation that the man you're with must marry you before you will have children with them then that must filter out a large proportion of irresponsible fickle ones who see you as "good enough for now."

Zolrets · 16/02/2021 15:47

@Eaststreet sorry, I didn’t answer your particular conundrum. You don’t say how old you are and how important having children is to you in the very near future. As someone who experienced fertility problems at 35, I have to admit that trying earlier would have been better in my case. Sure, women conceive naturally at 40 even 48 but bear in mind that seeking and undergoing fertility tests and treatment can take years. My IVF child was conceived at 40 born .when I was 41. I first tried ttc at 35 so you get an idea of what can happen and the timelines. Of course you can also get lucky first time so remember that too!

ScarfaceCwaw · 16/02/2021 15:46

Personally I'd be fucking ecstatic as long as everyone involved were at least making an informed decision on the subject of marriage Vs remaining unmarried. If you're informed as to the difference and better off unmarried or simply prefer it, jobs a goodun, truly happy for you. We're still some way off that though, as any read of this site will reveal.

I don't love the whole "actually I have all the assets so I won't be getting married" angle though, any more than I'd love it from a man refusing to marry the mother of his DC. I think at least when it's the female partner who has the assets you don't have the ingrained sexism of society disadvantaging the other partner, but in general I think that if you're going to commit to having DC with someone and thus having a powerful tie to them for decades, you do have to be willing to share and should want to see your child's other parent appropriately provided for, and the wheel of fortune often does turn over a long period. If you don't trust them enough to share assets with them, that doesn't sound like the ideal basis for a childrearing partnership. Obviously none of this applies if we're talking a second "marriage" or long relationship in which you don't intend to have DC and want to protect your assets for the DC of your first relationship.

ItsJackieWeaverBitch · 16/02/2021 15:42

Generally you are more protected legally and financially if you are married when you have children. But. I wasn’t when I had mine and being unmarried made things a lot easier for me when I left my abusive ex and moved into a refuge with our kids. I had no financial ties to him that interfered with claiming benefits (which you need to do when taking a refuge space), I wasn’t saddled with his debts (and vice versa) and I didn’t have a long painful and costly process of divorcing him on top of all the other trauma. He is legally obligated to pay child maintenance whether he was married to me or not and from what I can tell it makes no difference enforcing that if the parents were ever married or not.

MyGazeboisLeaking · 16/02/2021 15:41

@FanSpamTastic

The issue is not so much marriage as the financial imbalance that arises if you give up your career after having a baby and do not have a partner that values the contribution of a stay at home parent.

Many couples choose jointly to have a family but then do not consider how family finances will work afterwards. Childcare is very expensive and it often happens that the woman stays home to bring up young children or if she returns to work that the cost of childcare comes out of her salary. A woman may be expected to continue to pay half of household costs while having reduced income and to deplete her savings to do this.

Years out of the workplace impact career prospects and pension savings for a woman. Men tend not to have the same impact.

Unmarried couples have no automatic rights to receive any financial provision from a partner if they split up. A divorce has at least some financial provisions and things like pensions etc need to be taken into account.

Have you and your partner discussed how things would work eg who pays what while you are on maternity leave? Does he see childcare as a joint cost or only your cost? How will household bills be split when you are not working? Are savings joint or do you have yours and he has his? How much life insurance do you each need to maintain your lifestyle if something happens to you or to him? Many guys would be shocked at how much it would cost them to have a full time nanny, cleaner and PA but expect their partners to do it all for love!

This.

If you are by far the higher earner and/or have assets in your name etc, then its not such a problem.

If you are not independently financially secure and plan to make career sacrifices to bring up joint children, you are putting a your financial future at risk of your partners future generosity / whims and wishes.

Shetoshe · 16/02/2021 15:35

I think there's often an element of judgment on those posts. Yes people should be informed about the potential risks but there's often an assumption on here that a woman who has DC outside of marriage is some sort of reckless idiot and that her relationship isn't a "proper" one.

It absolutely isn't risky for everyone. I'm not married - by choice. I don't want to be married, I don't like the concept and it doesn't offer me any legal protections that I deem "worth" it. However, I'm not in the UK. Where I live there are legal protections for cohabiting couples so being a SAHM wasn't risky for me. The only tangible benefit of marriage is not paying inheritance tax - that still isn't enough to make me want to be contractually committed to another person. Once you're aware of how it impacts your personal financial situation and use your head and sort out wills, life insurance etc. then it needn't be a disaster.

mootymoo · 16/02/2021 15:33

It depends! If you earn less and want to take extended time off then it's in your best interest to marry for protection but if you are the stronger economic partner then it's probably not in your interest. Wills etc can get around most issues.

The downside to marriage is getting divorced is a pain, the paperwork I mean - both dp and I are still processing our respective divorces years on despite everything being amicable due to the adversarial nature of the British system. I'm almost tempted not to bother but that in its self causes different headaches.

Whether to marry or not is a personal decision, I kind of do want to marry again, but not for protection, more because I want to stand in front of family and friends with one of my best friends conducting the service and we all deserve an amazing party after the year we have had! (so 2023 maybe GrinConfused)

knittingaddict · 16/02/2021 15:33

I'll give you a true scenario that is close to home.

Together 11years.
Married 7 years.
2 small children.
House bought during relationship and they both lived in it from the start.
House deeds and mortgage in husband's name.
Abusive relationship.
Wife left the home with her children.

If they hadn't been married she would have received:
Child maintenance.

As she was married she received:
Child maintenance.
70% share of equity in the house.
50% share of her ex husband's pension.

Because they were married the wife could register her home rights with the land registry and prevent the ex from selling the house and pocketing the money. Marriage helps to protect the rights of the more vulnerable partner and I would always advise my daughters to get married before they have children.

Zolrets · 16/02/2021 15:32

Good point @Nocares. I am not married and in a relationship of 21 years. I think people are partly driven by emotion and morality when they overestimate the protection of marriage. Overall, I agree that there are some benefits to marriage to some people. But it’s not a universal panacea - you can still be left high and dry if you are the vulnerable one in a relationship. Best not to let that happen to begin with if that is within your control.

Nocares

People posting here come from a place of privilege in regards to marriage.

A lot of people are actually in private rented accommodation and claim some element of tax credits or are entitled too if they become a single parent with housing benefits on top.

Therefore realistically marriage is neither here nor there for a large portion of the population.

The financial element is only if assets and large sums of money are involved.

Ginevere · 16/02/2021 15:28

@Eaststreet if I were you, I’d do a quick registry office wedding and sort the rest letter. It really does make everything less complicated having a baby when you’re already married.

Also, check your maternity policy- I’m also entitled to 6 months full pay, and am planning to take 9 months with 3 months statutory, but the small print states that the pay I would have received over the final 3 months is incorporated into the first six. This means that I will get no pay for the thank 3, as I’ve already been paid it. Check if it’s the same for you, as it’s very common and means you’d have zero income.

HappyAsASandboy · 16/02/2021 15:23

I have heard lots of people say that they don't need marriage because they earn the same as their partner and the care and child bills will be split evenly. This is all very well if if actually happens, but it rarely does. Almost always one person becomes the "default" for child care emergencies/organising children's stuff etc, and that leaves less time for career work.

More importantly is what happens if you split up. Most women find it harder to walk away from their responsibilities to their children, and quite a lot of men find it easy. That means the mother is often left with the lions share of the child-rearing to do. If you're married, you're far far more likely to get a bigger proportion of assets during the split, could be awarded the right to stay in the home after the split in order to accommodate the kids etc etc. If you're not married, then you walk away with whatever you can prove you own in your own name.

Unless you own vastly more or earn vastly more than your partner, marriage is almost always a good idea. If you own everything and earn the most then you may be in a stronger position remaining unmarried.

Mrgrinch · 16/02/2021 15:22

For me it's because I'm a gypsy and it's not the done thing in my culture

canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 15:22

Marriage didn't help when one of mine was born with a disability. Nor did it help dealing with the aftermath of separating.
He wouldn't leave our home and of course had legal rights because we were married. 3 dc and myself had to go through the homeless system to get help.
After running up thousands and thousands of debt he ran. The house repossessed.
Bank account in joint names, whilst I was in A&E he was emptying them and nothing I could do.
He opted out of paying for a pension, so a share in what?
Cars would be bought in other people's, insurance to drive any car.
Property and land brought abroad but again not in his name.
Never mind all the liquid assets that he deliberately had undervalued.
And with the help of an accountant on paper he was broke.

Had I been financially dependent on him we would have been truly screwed. The joint money all gone but at least I did have some income whilst wtc claim went through.

Because he wanted to dodge his commitments I knew he would never divorce me. I was financially better off on paper and wasn't in any rush to give him anything.

DEspite still legally married, his gf and his family didn't seem to have any problems arranging his funeral.

HeidiHaughton · 16/02/2021 15:21

A trip to IKEA is also a good stress test.

Cherrypi · 16/02/2021 15:19

Organising a wedding is a good stress test for a relationship that is reversible unlike having a child which will mean they will forever be in your life in some form.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 16/02/2021 15:16

The biological realities of carrying, birthing & (if you choose it) breastfeeding a child fall solely upon women, and can be disadvantageous to your career and earning prospects.

I used to earn exactly the same as my husband. 4 years and two children on, he now earns half again more. I've had two maternity leaves, I reduced to 4 days a week as my career had already been paused due to the maternity leave & it didnt make sense to damage both our prospects. I'm lucky I'm a high earner in a decent company but many women never recover from it, particularly those who earn less than their childrens father and find the family is better off financially if they stop work before children start school.

Marriage gives a woman in that position far greater financial security's - in a divorce, the courts recognise and recompense women's sacrifice financially. In an informal separation this does not happen.

Streamlinerose · 16/02/2021 15:13

@JustLyra marriage doesn’t change that fact, separation whether through divorce or otherwise doesn’t change access after the fact. So that isn’t a ‘for marriage’ point.

Yes, DP and his family, would spend 50:50 with DC. That isn’t for me to explain how I’m certain of this to an anon online, only that it is.

imjackieweaver · 16/02/2021 15:12

I also thought the statistics say that children from married couple do better than children from cohabiting couples.

Rewis · 16/02/2021 15:12

Marriage is something that everyone should evaluate if it is beneficial for them. There are tons of cases where marriage is not a smart move. A lot marriage is beneficial for the other party but disadvantage for the other.

Talking from woman's perspective. Marriage might not make sense if you are planning on working full time, have more assets, have same or higher income as your partner. It does offer financial protection in case of divorce if you are planning on working part-time, be a sahm, become the default parent stopping career progression, Live in partners house etc. Cause then you are legally entitled for half of everything (ok. Not that simple but you get the gist)

thepeopleversuswork · 16/02/2021 15:10

I was going to say it’s beneficial for a child to grow up seeing a stable and committed relationship, but apparently it’s all about money.

Marriage is all about money. That's literally what it is. It's a financial contract that essentially indemnifies the financially weaker partner (usually the woman). Marriage has no bearing whatsoever on whether its a stable or committed relationship. Stable and committed relationships happen outside of marriage and marriages break down.

If you are planning to be the primary caregiver for a child or children for any period of time and don't have private income you should get married: your financial independence and earning power will probably be compromised by having children.

If you earn more than your partner you would be advised not to get married as you may find yourself having to pay out to him in the event of a divorce.

It never ceases to amaze me how poor women's understanding of this is.

ColdBrightClearMorning · 16/02/2021 15:08

[quote user1654236589623652]www.citizensadvice.org.uk/family/living-together-marriage-and-civil-partnership/living-together-and-marriage-legal-differences/[/quote]
Finally someone posted this!

This is all you need OP. You can decide whether you actually will benefit from marriage or not. Not everyone does. But it’s not just about you.

Being married before baby arrived was important for us, because it protects the lower earner if something goes wrong.

And the thing is, we wanted both of us to be protected. If we divorced. DH is the higher earner, but if I’d been the higher earned I’d have wanted to make sure he was protected if we separated too.

We’re in love, it’s not just about what’s best for one person, it’s what’s best for both. I wouldn’t want it where for example we had a baby, broke up, and DH had taken a hit to his earnings and career to care for our baby and wound up with no legal protection and right to support from me.

Imo you should get married to ensure the lower earner has some legal rights to support from the higher earner, whether that higher earner is you or your partner. We’re a team and even if we separate I want the law to back up that as family we still have a responsibility to one another, even if emotions turn sour.

There are plenty of other reasons, but it’s a legal contract that makes you family and a team in the eyes of the law and state. If you’re in a good position and want to bet you’ll stay that way then sure, don’t marry. But that’s no better than a guy who earns loads not wanting to marry his girlfriend in case they break up and he loses money imo.

SpringisSpinning · 16/02/2021 15:07

Yes amazing however love can fly out then door when impacted by something unexpected like partner illness or child disability.

Crunchymum · 16/02/2021 15:06

I think the simple answer is money,

Neither of have any (to get married with or that we need to protect) so we've never bothered.

We have a joint tenancy (we are renters as well as unmarried parents!! I can imagine the sharp intake of breath) but separate finances.
Oh and my 3 kids all have my DP's surname !!

Dixiechickonhols · 16/02/2021 15:03

It was never going to be easy scenario but wife but have definitely got her in more easily without a shadow of a doubt. His daughter couldn’t have told nurse she was only his friend for a start. A wife would have got one of the 2 end of life visitors slots (covid made situation worse)