Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why marriage before children is so important?

187 replies

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 13:02

Excuse my ignorance on this but time and time again I see comments from people on MN’s telling people not to have a child with somebody before marriage - comments I see are along the lines of ‘it’s so risky’ , ‘leaving yourself open’ ‘asking for disaster’

I might just be really naive but can somebody please explain the risks involved?

Myself and DP are TTC now, and all these comments are making me really uneasy, should I genuinely be worried?
We were due to get married this year and then the plan was to start ttc but we have postpone the wedding due to COVID and didn’t want to postpone having a baby too. Should I genuinely get be worried about this? And get married first?

OP posts:
TheWordWomanIsTaken · 16/02/2021 17:45

@VinylDetective

Marriage is something that doesn’t matter in the slightest until a relationship ends either by death or separation.

If your spouse dies you automatically inherit their assets tax free and qualify for any death in service benefits. If you separate, marriage means a more or less fair division of assets. It’s a very cheap and easy way of providing financial security.

In England and Wales it is not the case that you automatically inherit your spouse's assets. Assets do pass between spouses without attracting IHT and then the deceased's allowance can 'roll-over' to any children effectively doubling it at that point. BUT, without a will, intestacy laws kick in. And they do not mean automatic transfer to the spouse.
Candyfloss99 · 16/02/2021 17:39

If you earn more than your partner and won't be a SAHM then do not get married.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 16/02/2021 17:37

A friend of mine lost her DP in an accident. She had a young child and another on the way.

The house was in his name, so she got nothing.
She wasn't named on his pension (admittedly not a marriage issue), so she got nothing.
They weren't married, so she wasn't entitled to widowed parent benefits.
She couldn't access any of his finances or bank accounts as she wasn't his legal NoK.

At a time of immense grief and stress, she found herself homeless, pregnant and with a toddler. She had to move area, move house, get a new job and basically start over again. Had they been married, she could have stayed in the house, claimed widows' benefits and kept her job.

A very sad situation all-round. She wishes more than anything that she'd insisted on marriage before having children.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/02/2021 17:34

canigooutyet You’d think that about but lots are really stupid as you put it eg move into boyfriend’s house. House is his name/mortgage. He pays mortgage she pays bills. Plan is we’ll buy a joint family house in x years time. They have a baby and plans get put on hold. They split before move happens. She has to leave immediately and gets nothing even if house has increased in value.
Married version of above living in house solely owned by husband is she can at least register property rights to stay/house can’t be sold without her knowledge to give her some time to get sorted. Even if it’s ultimately sold or repossessed she will be entitled to share of any equity possibly more than 50%.
I assumed most couples bought jointly bought these days was surprised how many don’t - often property predates relationship or due to mortgage position eg woman not earning can’t get mortgage.

LST · 16/02/2021 17:19

It isn't always op. Me and dp aren't married. We have 2 dc. I could pay the bills on my own if I had to. Fair enough if you're planning on not working it would be a different story, but if you are and earn around the same it makes no difference.

thepeopleversuswork · 16/02/2021 17:18

It makes me quite angry that people talk about protecting the women. It should be about protecting the children

But in the vast majority of cases protecting the women does protect the children.

How often do you see children forced to move into cramped accommodation or move schools etc because the woman has decided she can't be arsed and run off with her secretary?

That's the whole point of marriage. Marriage doesn't wave a wand and guarantee that a couple will continue to love each other or remain together. It guarantees that whichever partner has less financial security (usually the woman) will get some protection in the event of a split.

thepeopleversuswork · 16/02/2021 17:12

The other interesting element to this as has been touched on is that growing numbers of women out-earn their partners and have larger asset pools and if you're in this position it makes less sense to be married.

It's certainly true that in a scenario with a youngish woman with no assets who plans to be a SAHM and be financially dependent on a partner it is foolish to have children without the protection of marriage.

But when older women with grown children and more financial independence want to establish the same set up without jeopardising their own assets the picture is much cloudier. The attraction of marriage is diminished when you have property in your name, a steady income and children whose inheritance could be jeopardised by your getting married (speaking from personal experience).

So much of the mythology and culture around marriage and the horrific Disneyfication of it in recent decades centres around the idea that it allows a woman to achieve her personal goals: children, financial security and a secure home.

As that picture changes and women are able to achieve those goals without marriage: and particularly as marriage actually risks jeopardising that financial security, I wonder how the perception of it in popular culture will change. I would really hope for one thing that women become savvier about it and start seeing it as it actually is a financial contract other than a load of bollocks about rings and table displays and white meringues.

Countrygirl2021 · 16/02/2021 17:05

Because you are more likely to have thought through being committed and staying together.bpeople with children by multiple partners or single parents are more likely to have not been married in the first place.

It makes me quite angry that people talk about protecting the women. It should be about protecting the children. .

ArchbishopOfBanterbury · 16/02/2021 17:04

We married before I was pregnant, and I'm definitely glad. He's a good dad, but he puts his work first, and I'm primary carer for the little one.

How "equal" a parent do you expect him to be? Will he take shared parental leave/go part time to reduce your childcare bills/take unpaid leave if your toddler is sick?

Usually all the career cost of babies is borne by the woman, who ends up as default parent.

He then gets to pay the breadwinner role, earning more, and paying more into a mortgage and pension. Which is fine, if those are shared assets of a marriage and he respects the unpaid work of parenting as an equal contribution.

If I were you, I'd separate the marriage from the wedding. Get married at a registry office before baby comes along, have a lovely wedding once covid permits.

PorcelainCatStack · 16/02/2021 16:54
  1. If he dies you won’t automatically inherit.
  1. You are not automatically considered next if kin although this varies place to place. A hospital for example may not be willing to listen to you or advise you of his care if necessary. This can vary greatly as next of kin is not defined in law, like I said but is a risk.
  1. If you become a SAHM you will rely on him financially and your pension and NI contributions will pause, therefore being lower than they would overall, whilst his won’t be affected.
  1. In the event you break up, you will be treated less fairly and with less rights than a wife would.
  1. Sometimes, house etc get put only in the mans name due to mortgage deals and not taking the woman into account if she’s not working. This means in theory that he owns the house. If applicable.
  1. Ultimately it’s all about death or breakup. If he dies you are not protected or entitled to the same as you would be if married. If you split up it can be a legal nightmare and subject to how you’ve balanced finances, you could be out of the house without access to any money or rights to any financial gain accrued whilst together.

Of course you can remain unmarried - you just need to consider all these risk factors and mitigate against them. No matter how much you love each other now, people can and do change.

HollyGoLoudly1 · 16/02/2021 16:52

You’re not entitled to spousal support if you split unmarried.

Afaik spousal support is almost unheard of anyway, married or not.

HollyGoLoudly1 · 16/02/2021 16:50

@ThatDoesntBelongInAIBU

I was going to say it’s beneficial for a child to grow up seeing a stable and committed relationship, but apparently it’s all about money.
You can be stable and committed without being married you know Confused

Equally, some marriages can be extremely unstable. That piece of paper doesn't magically change how couples behave towards one another.

Lelophants · 16/02/2021 16:44

Saying all this you know your relationship and this is real life. I have a friend who is similar and just wanted to get cracking. She has a very wealthy family to support her and she wasn't going to wait to ttc because of the pandemic so I get it!

Lelophants · 16/02/2021 16:42

Having kids puts pressure on even the very strongest relationships. First it's a real proof of commitment. Secondly, you get financial protection if it ever goes wrong. Even if you work full time you will undoubtedly still do the bulk of childcare and will presumably be on maternity leave, so your work will probably suffer more than dh. If you go part time or are a sahm definitely!

If married, you are entitled to half his wealth and will be supported longterm. If not there is nothing and lack of pension. Also very depressing considering how much you will have given up.

HoegaardenHappiness · 16/02/2021 16:38

Not read the thread but WILLs and stuff. If not married and he dies, you are not his next of kin. If he is a car accident then you are not in charge, his family are.

Get married from a legal point of view, then have a big wedding later. Seriously this is important stuff.

knittingaddict · 16/02/2021 16:33

@ItsJackieWeaverBitch

Generally you are more protected legally and financially if you are married when you have children. But. I wasn’t when I had mine and being unmarried made things a lot easier for me when I left my abusive ex and moved into a refuge with our kids. I had no financial ties to him that interfered with claiming benefits (which you need to do when taking a refuge space), I wasn’t saddled with his debts (and vice versa) and I didn’t have a long painful and costly process of divorcing him on top of all the other trauma. He is legally obligated to pay child maintenance whether he was married to me or not and from what I can tell it makes no difference enforcing that if the parents were ever married or not.
The person I spoke about it my earlier post was in a similar position to yours, but was married. It made no difference to her finances either. She left with £10 and no joint bank account and no joint debts, no property in her name (due to financial control. The refuge and the benefits people had no problem with her claiming benefits in her own name. She even got legal aid because she had no assets.

Couples who are not married could easily be more financially enmeshed than my relative was. In your situation it matters more how you organise your finances than whether you are married or not.

rawalpindithelabrador · 16/02/2021 16:31

What Heidi wrote. Never seen so many people foolishly put their financial security at stake over a bloody wedding. It's not important, it's the marriage that is.

canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 16:30

You only get the house or a share of it if it exists to begin with..

Married couple buy a house. Few years down the line one gives up work. As a couple they can afford mortgage etc.
They split.
The house is a unaffordable, marriage isn’t going to change this. After its sold there’s nothing to split.
Unmarried couple buy a house and both names on the deed. I mean you’d have to really stupid to hand over cash without protecting it. Same outcome as the married couple.

End up with a feckless with money type and as married that’s your problem as well.
Partners yea good luck with your issues.

MorganKitten · 16/02/2021 16:29

It isn’t, just another way for women to be judged

canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 16:21

I have told all my dc’s before they have children ensure they can support themselves and not be reliant on another person. After-all if you want things in life you have to work for them. If you want the luxury lifestyle nothing stopping you from working to achieve that.

And don’t be fooled that the other person is too important/busy to do normal everyday things like washing, shopping, sorting their relatives presents out etc.

After ending a relationship one of mine said I should have warned them about the Whats for dinner types 😂

JustLyra · 16/02/2021 16:20

[quote Streamlinerose]@JustLyra marriage doesn’t change that fact, separation whether through divorce or otherwise doesn’t change access after the fact. So that isn’t a ‘for marriage’ point.

Yes, DP and his family, would spend 50:50 with DC. That isn’t for me to explain how I’m certain of this to an anon online, only that it is.[/quote]
You have much more financial protection if you are married and the shit hits the fan.

Nothing is certain in life.

Squarepigeon · 16/02/2021 16:11

’You’re assuming that if you split your partner would have the DC 50% of the time.’

This ^ It’s not just about SAHMs, it’s also about the fact that it’s incredibly common for the woman to be the one who works reduced hours or at a lower level job to fit in school pick ups, school holidays, children’s illness etc. This doesn’t change when a couple splits up. Most couples don’t end up with a 50:50 custody split and (usually) the mother will have the children most weekdays. It’s going to effect their earning potential and/or leave them with childcare costs. If you’re married the court can balance this by eg giving the mother a greater share of the equity in the house. If you’re not married you get child maintenance (based on what your ex earns) and nothing else.

HeidiHaughton · 16/02/2021 16:11

I think when a man wants to and is ready to get married he'll get engaged and married in short order.
It's like their light goes on and the next suitable women they meet will be the one.
I'm wary of long relationships with no sign of marriage, when one of the partner wants to be married but is 'compromising' ie letting the other person decide unilaterally when or if marriage will happen. These men invariably leave after several years, meet someone and need no persuasion to marry with the next woman.

Jhusbusyman · 16/02/2021 16:09

@HazelWong

Everyone on here assumes that the woman earns very little and/or will give up work for years. In that scenario, marriage offers a great deal of protection. Divorce settlement will divide all assets, otherwise it's just child maintenance.

I earn about the same as my DH, we are married but not being married wouldn't leave me super vulnerable.

Some of my friends out earn their husbands and are hot advantaged at all

THIS.

I think whether marriage is a good idea or not depends on your own personal situation and your relationship.

I totally agree that women who do not earn a lot / give up career to raise kids need the protection of marriage. My mum did this without marriage and it has left her VERY financially vulnerable.

For me, I am a high earner, own house, savings and pension. If we were to divorce, I'd be the one who would lose a lot, so I do not want to marry.

I plan to work 3 days a week once I have had a baby. I would work 3 days a week whether I was a single parent or a parent with a partner. This is my personal choice so I would not feel bitter if we were to split due to 'loss of earnings' etc.

My partner is very straight forward and I have discussed that we should make wills once a baby is on the way. I trust he will do this. If not, it is more his loss than mine as I own our family home.

Like I said, it depends on your own financial / personal situation really.

Dacquoise · 16/02/2021 15:58

A friend of mine who I hadn't heard from for years popped up at Christmas. She had three children with her partner, now ex, not married. Didn't work all the time they were together, but enjoyed a very high standard of living with him as he owned his own business which he started after they met. Children all went to private school, huge multi million pound house, loads of holidays, race horse owner. Everyone around her was telling her to get married. Her partner was willing but she'd had a very short, disastrous first marriage and was put off.

Turns out the relationship has broken down, partner cut off the money and she has left to 'work' for a new partner. Seven years and counting waiting for a 'pay out' from ex partner. Unlikely to see a penny because they weren't married. Now mid fifties, starting again, no assets or pension to her name.

Swipe left for the next trending thread