Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why marriage before children is so important?

187 replies

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 13:02

Excuse my ignorance on this but time and time again I see comments from people on MN’s telling people not to have a child with somebody before marriage - comments I see are along the lines of ‘it’s so risky’ , ‘leaving yourself open’ ‘asking for disaster’

I might just be really naive but can somebody please explain the risks involved?

Myself and DP are TTC now, and all these comments are making me really uneasy, should I genuinely be worried?
We were due to get married this year and then the plan was to start ttc but we have postpone the wedding due to COVID and didn’t want to postpone having a baby too. Should I genuinely get be worried about this? And get married first?

OP posts:
Graphista · 16/02/2021 20:21

Sorry meant to add, that money ex took was eventually returned to me BECAUSE we were married. If we'd not been married I'd have had a hell of a job proving how much of it was mine if I even could (cash wages paid by clients) and pretty much not had a leg to stand on! He also took the car and the computer without any discussion whatsoever, which I was also compensated for via the divorce. We were not rich by any stretch just a normal fairly low income family but being married made SO many things so much easier!

One thing it made easier was socially. People deny this or think it's no longer an issue but there is still a stigma to being a single mum and if you weren't married to the dad either that's magnified. It SHOULDN'T be the case but it is. I've noticed on many an occasion I've been treated better as a "Mrs" by certain people/organisations than friends/family have been as "miss" totally outrageous, shouldn't happen, but I'm afraid it does. I've experienced and witnessed it in terms of medical staff, school staff, council staff, dwp staff...

On one occasion you'd have thought I went from "commoner" to "royalty" based on how one particular dwp staff members treatment of me totally changed once she realised I was married! Utterly ridiculous but still happens. I have friends and family now who are still reporting such treatment. One has not taken her husbands name and like the incident above has noticed a marked change in how she is treated when it becomes known to the snob that she is married but has kept her own name. Idiots!

Graphista · 16/02/2021 20:13

Regarding joint accounts a cautionary tale

I had joint accounts with my ex Current and savings and throughout the marriage money was all treated as "one pot" and we had equal spending money, never major arguments about money all good yea?

Then we split due to his infidelity

I was a Sahm at this point for complex reasons and had no income of my own. Within 2 days of our split he emptied the accounts without a word to me. I knew nothing until in that deeply embarrassing scene of being at the supermarket with a weeks worth of groceries to pay for and...card declined!

He KNEW I had no income of my own, though some of that money he'd withdrawn had been earned by me and the money he withdrew also included child benefit and child tax credits, money intended for our daughters needs.

He left me stuck in the arse end of nowhere with a baby with no transport, no money for transport and no money for basic essentials either.

Now admittedly these days I'd have been able to access funds far more quickly and easily as I'd have been able to quickly set up a new bank account and my parents would transfer money to me.

Back then it really wasn't that easy, I had to borrow from a neighbour I hardly knew, then my parents sent me a postal order that I could cash to repay the neighbour plus a bit more to be going on with until I could open a new sole account and arrange for child benefit snd child tax credits to go into that account.

It took WEEKS to sort out and I'm very lucky my parents were able to help me out. Not everyone has family or friends able/willing to help out in such a situation and it still takes bloody ages to get child benefit etc paid into a different account and I also started a claim for income support which took nearly 3 months until I got my 1st payment by which time I had found a job!

I will NEVER have a joint account with anyone ever again. It made me far too vulnerable.

Not everyone has the choice to not be a sahm/go out to work.

Back then I was fit and healthy and frankly the economy was doing a damn sight better too!

Within 5 years of the split I was disabled and dd was showing the first major signs of what I would later learn was her own disability, within 7 years after split I was no longer able to work.

Everyone's circumstances are different and they can change drastically on you.

Another friend of mine who split from her ex around the same time her child has learning difficulties and other health issues. It's impossible for her to get childcare and even if she could she would need so much time off work for his medical appointments and assessments and therapies etc that no employer could reasonably support her.

Yes some women are higher earners, some have more assets etc but by and large it's women who's careers and prospects are most harmed by becoming parents. It's women who come off worst financially following a split.

There's also the fact that marriage isn't only protective in the event of a split but also if one party becomes incapacitated or dies. Incapacitation being by far the worst scenario financially speaking, it's incredibly expensive to be very ill/disabled and needing care and support.

Nothing protects totally but planning and preparing as much as one can is the best option.

lojojomo · 16/02/2021 19:30

Most commonly on here what happens is:

Woman gives up work/ reduces work to look after kids
Man carries on with life and career, slowly becoming contemptuous of 'non contributing' woman - stops doing any housework, gives her tiny amounts of money, refuses to take any responsibility for childcare or nursery fees so it "doesn't make financial sense" for her to get back into work
Then she can't afford to leave, or he leaves and she loses her house, is impoverished at 45 and with a patchy career and hugely diminished earning potential (and comparatively reduced pension in later life too)

There are so many women on here this has happened to. Don't do all the work of life and end up struggling while he has a second family and decides he can't even manage the CSA minimum this month.

Half of all nonresident fathers are deadbeat dads and pay nothing at all to support their children. The average payment of those who do pay child support is £35 a week. So really the only protection you have for the security of your children is marital assets, which are divided on divorce, but not if you just split up.

Kazzyhoward · 16/02/2021 19:23

There are a whole host of legal protections arising upon marriage, which have evolved over a very long period of time, such as next of kin, inheritance, widows/widowers pension rights, etc. Yes, you can protect yourself in similar ways without being married, such as wills, powers of attorney, pension trust deeds, etc but all that is so much harder, especially with an unwilling/disinterested partner.

Getting married was a deal breaker for me, not only prior to having children, but prior to buying a house together (another serious commitment). I really find it difficult how two people can "commit" to eachother by having children, but shy away from what I think is a lesser commitment of marriage - after all, a married couple can get out of it by divorce, but when you have a child together, you're bound to eachother for life due to that child.

happymummy12345 · 16/02/2021 19:20

For me it was never a choice or a decision. I always loved the idea of marriage. I've never looked at or viewed marriage as security or beneficial for financial or legal reasons. To me marriage should be about love and telling your partner how much you love them. It's the vows you make.

In fact it meant so much to me that I first met my husband end of April 2014. We became a couple 9th may 2014. We decided to start trying for a baby in July 2014, we moved in together in October 2014, I got pregnant in November 2014, we found out I was pregnant 19th December 2014. We got engaged 13th January 2015, and got married 9th April 2015. Baby was due 30th August 2015, was actually born on 5th September 2015.

So we had been together exactly 11 months the day we got married. I know it's very quick, being married and expecting a baby within less than a year of being together, but it worked for us. We had discussed marriage and both agreed it was what we wanted, but we weren't officially engaged. But when we found out I was pregnant we both knew it was important to us to be married before the baby was born, and I didn’t want to be showing if possible, so we made sure we were. It was perfect.

Some people might think we only got married because I was pregnant, but that was never the case at all. We did it because I wanted us to all have the same name on as much of the paperwork as possible and especially on the birth certificate, it meant a lot to me. In fact my first appointment after the wedding was the second scan. We made sure we had plenty of time before the appointment so I could get my name changed on the system before my appointment. I did. That was obviously the first time I’d been called by my married name, I loved hearing it and seeing it on the paperwork and especially on the scan photos.

I know for a lot of people it doesn’t matter and isn’t really that important, and I mean no judgement at all. But for me it was very important and it did mean a lot.

knittingaddict · 16/02/2021 19:18

Spousal support is becoming less and less common though and usually only happens when the husband is earning really big money.

FlyingPandas · 16/02/2021 19:16

@SmokedDuck

Forming a houshold together is a type of household economy. Marriage, legally, is designed to protect the people in that economy, particularly the one who may have to give up more outside work.

That's not always predictable either. A couple may start intending to both carr on in their jobs, but all kinds of things can get in the way of that. A child with special needs, for one example, but plenty of couples simply find it doesn't work for both people to carry on in high level careers, the quality of life is shit or the kids needs aren't being met.

Marriage also protects against risk if one of the spouses dies. There are supports you won't be entitled to if your partner dies and you are unmarried. His assets won't go to you, you won't be able to make decisions about his funeral if the family don't want to involve you. (And similarly for him.)

You can make arrangements about much of this legally without getting married, but it's a lot easier to just get married - that's what the paperwork is for.

Very much yes to the “may both intend to carry on their jobs but life gets in the way”.

Quite a few posts on here from people saying “well when I have DC I will be going back to work FT / 3 days per week / whatever so I won’t be vulnerable”.

Things change, circumstances change, opinions, emotions, energy levels change. You have no idea how you’re going to feel until the DC are a reality. I was adamant - so adamant - that I’d never be a SAHM and had a highly paid professional job prior to DC. And then nearly had a breakdown trying to juggle that highly paid but very stressful professional job plus baby. I ended up becoming a SAHM for years and now work part time in a very different job.

I know so many people like me who either stopped working completely or changed to a very PT / less well paid role once DC came along - and very often because they had massively underestimated the logistical stress of it all. Women tend to be disproportionately affected by the caring responsibilities - this shouldn’t be the case of course but so often it is.

Obviously it’s not the same for everyone - but until you are managing the reality of the actual DC then your plans are only hypothetical and could very well change.

It just makes sense to be married even if you are currently the high earner or an equal one because you never know what could happen in future.

Muskox · 16/02/2021 19:14

It's not just about spousal support, it's about splitting the marital assets. So that if one spouse (usually the woman) has taken time out of her career and the man has been using his earnings in the meantime to build up savings things while she hasn't had the opportunity to do so, the woman is entitled to 50% of these assets (or more depending on the divorce settlement).

Whatafustercluck · 16/02/2021 19:04

Afaik spousal support is almost unheard of anyway, married or not.

Not true. It's a protection by which a woman who has given up her career to raise the children to enable her husband's career/ earning capacity can leave a relationship immediately if needed, until a divorce settlement is agreed. This allows her to move on, despite probably not having a job nor the recent relevant experience that employers ask you to evidence at interview.

It happened to my sister when she came out of an abusive relationship. Thankfully she had been married and was thus entitled to support.

SmokedDuck · 16/02/2021 19:01

Forming a houshold together is a type of household economy. Marriage, legally, is designed to protect the people in that economy, particularly the one who may have to give up more outside work.

That's not always predictable either. A couple may start intending to both carr on in their jobs, but all kinds of things can get in the way of that. A child with special needs, for one example, but plenty of couples simply find it doesn't work for both people to carry on in high level careers, the quality of life is shit or the kids needs aren't being met.

Marriage also protects against risk if one of the spouses dies. There are supports you won't be entitled to if your partner dies and you are unmarried. His assets won't go to you, you won't be able to make decisions about his funeral if the family don't want to involve you. (And similarly for him.)

You can make arrangements about much of this legally without getting married, but it's a lot easier to just get married - that's what the paperwork is for.

Fatladyslim · 16/02/2021 18:58

To rally depends on your own situations. I work ft as does dp, we own our house 50/50 and both earn similar amounts and have simular pensions. I'm not bothered about getting married, it would potentially leave me worse off in the long run of we separated as my family is notibly wealthier than his. I don't see it coming to that but neither of us are particularly bothered about getting married so at the moment we are just enjoying DS together without any firm plans. I didn't want to put off children, if he walked out tomorrow I would still be happy with the choice I made.

KindKylie · 16/02/2021 18:58

A friend of mine had 2 children in 2 years with her partner. They owned (with mortgage) a big house and he ran his own company. He persuaded her to give up her job before becoming controlling over money and then physically and emotionally abusive and then sleeping with other women and staying away all weekend while she did the childcare, housework and covered for him socially.

She's absolutely in such a disadvantaged position not having been married. Whilst clearly marrying such a horrible person would have been a mistake, it would have given her a better chance of not being completley screwed financially.

Babymamaroon · 16/02/2021 18:58

For us it was the biggest form of commitment we could take and meant our children were born into a very stable and loving environment.

Of course for many, being married provides neither of those, but that's what we wanted both for us and our future children.

Latterly, the financials etc make complete sense.

Showers3 · 16/02/2021 18:56

^ Apologies, I meant to write that statistically, parents who are married before a child is born tend to stay together longer than other (unmarried) couples or couples who get married after the birth.

Showers3 · 16/02/2021 18:54

I’m quite traditional myself, so always wanted to be married before having children like my parents and in laws. I couldn’t imagine taking on such a commitment without that stability. Irrespective of my beliefs though (which shouldn’t really matter to you), statistically, couples who are married tend to stay together for longer periods of a child’s life - including those born to parents who subsequently get married. I’m sure there are lots of socio-economic reasons as to why this might be though.

As an aside, this episode of the moral maze may be of interest to you: www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09ghmgj

sunflowersandbuttercups · 16/02/2021 18:48

Wouldn't the children have inherited in that case. Might not help in the immediate situation, but the assets shouldn't go to another relative in that case. It would be in trust for the children.

Yes, AFAIK the house was sold (as obviously the DC couldn't pay the mortgage) and the money put in trust for them as adults.

Miljea · 16/02/2021 18:48

@ThatDoesntBelongInAIBU

I was going to say it’s beneficial for a child to grow up seeing a stable and committed relationship, but apparently it’s all about money.

Sorry, had to butt in, immediately after reading my Quote:

Yes, yes, it is all about 'the money'.

Marriage is a legal transactional arrangement that far more times than not, protects women, particularly mothers.

knittingaddict · 16/02/2021 18:42

@sunflowersandbuttercups

A friend of mine lost her DP in an accident. She had a young child and another on the way.

The house was in his name, so she got nothing.
She wasn't named on his pension (admittedly not a marriage issue), so she got nothing.
They weren't married, so she wasn't entitled to widowed parent benefits.
She couldn't access any of his finances or bank accounts as she wasn't his legal NoK.

At a time of immense grief and stress, she found herself homeless, pregnant and with a toddler. She had to move area, move house, get a new job and basically start over again. Had they been married, she could have stayed in the house, claimed widows' benefits and kept her job.

A very sad situation all-round. She wishes more than anything that she'd insisted on marriage before having children.

Wouldn't the children have inherited in that case. Might not help in the immediate situation, but the assets shouldn't go to another relative in that case. It would be in trust for the children.
ZenNudist · 16/02/2021 18:36

If you actually want to get married then I'd do this before having dc. Life gets in the way. Children cost money and after mat leave you aren't going to want to have expensive wedding. Suggest getting married now then having a family party later.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 16/02/2021 18:35

So who was his NoK? Would it not be his children? Assuming it went to his family given what you have said but why on Earth would they kick her and his children out of the house?

I don't know the details.

HeidiHaughton · 16/02/2021 18:33

Lots of people don't give a damn about doing the decent thing when there's money to be gained. Why on earth do people think gay people wanted the full protection of marriage and not the inferior arrangements of civil partnerships.

HollyGoLoudly1 · 16/02/2021 18:29

@sunflowersandbuttercups

A friend of mine lost her DP in an accident. She had a young child and another on the way.

The house was in his name, so she got nothing.
She wasn't named on his pension (admittedly not a marriage issue), so she got nothing.
They weren't married, so she wasn't entitled to widowed parent benefits.
She couldn't access any of his finances or bank accounts as she wasn't his legal NoK.

At a time of immense grief and stress, she found herself homeless, pregnant and with a toddler. She had to move area, move house, get a new job and basically start over again. Had they been married, she could have stayed in the house, claimed widows' benefits and kept her job.

A very sad situation all-round. She wishes more than anything that she'd insisted on marriage before having children.

So who was his NoK? Would it not be his children? Assuming it went to his family given what you have said but why on Earth would they kick her and his children out of the house?
littlepattilou · 16/02/2021 17:49

@sunflowersandbuttercups

A friend of mine lost her DP in an accident. She had a young child and another on the way.

The house was in his name, so she got nothing.
She wasn't named on his pension (admittedly not a marriage issue), so she got nothing.
They weren't married, so she wasn't entitled to widowed parent benefits.
She couldn't access any of his finances or bank accounts as she wasn't his legal NoK.

At a time of immense grief and stress, she found herself homeless, pregnant and with a toddler. She had to move area, move house, get a new job and basically start over again. Had they been married, she could have stayed in the house, claimed widows' benefits and kept her job.

A very sad situation all-round. She wishes more than anything that she'd insisted on marriage before having children.

That's very sad, Sad but unfortunately, not uncommon.
SeasonFinale · 16/02/2021 17:48

If you are not going to marry for whatever reason (eg. higher earner, don't want to etc) at least get your financial matters in order; proper Wills, hold property in a way which allows you to pass it to your partner, insurance policies etc. That was the main issue with the Daily Mail article mentioned earlier.

Swipe left for the next trending thread