Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why marriage before children is so important?

187 replies

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 13:02

Excuse my ignorance on this but time and time again I see comments from people on MN’s telling people not to have a child with somebody before marriage - comments I see are along the lines of ‘it’s so risky’ , ‘leaving yourself open’ ‘asking for disaster’

I might just be really naive but can somebody please explain the risks involved?

Myself and DP are TTC now, and all these comments are making me really uneasy, should I genuinely be worried?
We were due to get married this year and then the plan was to start ttc but we have postpone the wedding due to COVID and didn’t want to postpone having a baby too. Should I genuinely get be worried about this? And get married first?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
80sPrincess · 30/09/2023 19:57
  1. Too many women don't realise how much of a financial hit they'll take on once they've had a baby when they go on maternity leave, taking a financial hit with a man who isn't invested in you legally isn't the best idea
  1. Theres a great legal disadvantage to having children out of wedlock and most women don't realise it until its too late. E.g after partner dies, when they separate from their partner and don't realise how little they'll get from Child maintenance
  1. A baby can change bring about great challenge between the dynamic of the relationship and the last man you want to test that out with is one who wants the option of leaving you as soon as things get tough. The best man to do that with is one who is invested in you to the point that he's not afraid of being legally tied to you.
Landofthefree · 19/02/2021 11:20

@Eaststreet you need to think about what would happen if you had a child who needed constant care or if you became unwell in the future. Marriage would give you more protection if you were unable work full time and your relationship ended.

aprilanne · 19/02/2021 11:06

Some people still dont like the thought of there children being illegitimate

KnitFastDieWarm · 19/02/2021 11:01

I got married because I wanted to have a child and be able to take a career break knowing that I was legally and financially protected in the event of divorce/death. Marriage was the cheapest and most straightforward way to do that. I’m the least romantic person on earth and had no interest in the whole wedding thing; for me it was about legal practicalities.

ElsieMc · 19/02/2021 10:51

It is a private and personal matter. But it is primarily about commitment and finances. It is the final commitment in a relationship and it protects the woman (and ultimately the children) in a split or death. No-one likes talking about death but everyone will know someone who has been left in difficulties financially when legalities are not in place via property or inheritance. Capital gains, property etc it is a minefield. Do make a Will as well.

I worked with a colleague who was ultra sensitive about marriage - she ridiculed the staff who were. She was in a relationship with one of the partners, had a beautiful home and went on to have two children together. He was seeing another member of staff and what a mess when it was discovered - the house, finances, the children and the precarious position of her career.

It all sounds so old fashioned and it is but the law is just that. My parents weren't married and what a mess that all was.

0gfhty · 19/02/2021 10:39

I meant to say more couples I know are UNMARRIED

0gfhty · 19/02/2021 10:38

I think it's mostly about money and assets. It seems to be a more of a big issue for people on Mumsnet or maybe it depends on where you live, because out of the couples I know with children more are married. A few I know married later when their children were older, which made for a very nice wedding. A few I know have also separated but amicably and there hasnt been any discontent about financial and asset sharing. Perhaps I'm just lucky and have a community of reasonable people. Mumsnet seems a bit old fashioned in this respect.

Avidreader12 · 19/02/2021 10:36

I think your more likely to work at a relationship when married. I wanted to get married once we decided to have children but my partner never wanted to and it always felt like he had one eye on the door..yes we had a child and I tried to get similar protections in place life insurance, joint account, agreement as to finances childcare etc but my partner resented it. He wanted more and more independence over his own income and we split up because I felt increasingly like a single parent. Sorting out finances of a joint mortgage was a nightmare even though we were fairly amicable. The house was set up under deed of trust which helped but I think marriage if you are both committed to it would be better.

Racoonworld · 19/02/2021 10:31

Not enough money*

Racoonworld · 19/02/2021 10:30

For me it’s about commitment. I just don’t se why anyone would plan to have a child with someone who hasn’t yet fully committed to the relationship. Fine if you both never want to get married and have set up your situation to reflect that, but if you plan to get married someday then you should do it before having children. It’s much better for a child to be raised in a committed family then go through a breakup. If you’re not yet married then what’s the reason? Not ready to commit (don’t have a child), not been with the person long enough (don’t have a child), not enough month (don’t have a child) etc.

canigooutyet · 19/02/2021 10:25

Even when the courts used to do spousal and child maintenance as standard it often didn't get paid or was for ridiculous amounts. My dad had to pay out £1.70 a month for us both and most of that was spousal.
He never paid. Attachment to earnings, nothing new about them moving around jobs.

canigooutyet · 19/02/2021 10:21

NOK can be anyone you want, it doesn't have to be family or a spouse.

Your pension can also be nominated to anyone, even when I was in relationships it never went to them.

And married or not either can decide in their will to leave their share to cats protection league if they want.

If your name isn't on the deeds and you are not married it may be possible to still get a share of the house

www.inheritancedisputes.co.uk/news-articles/what-are-your-rights-if-your-name-not-deeds.html

Married or not if your name is on the deeds you have legal recourse.

Married or not, the children should still inherit and if affairs have gone unknown, it's usually when all those skeletons come falling out. Unless of course they have been disinherited through the will.

Redruby2020 · 17/02/2021 10:03

@Cam2020

It depeneds on your situation. There is recourse if a non marital relationship fails - men still have to pay towards the upkeep of their children (assuming they are on their birth certificate)! All purely based the rather narrow view of of women being SAHMs or only working part time and often a way for MNetters to feel superior.
If only it were that simple! I am going through the CMS at the moment, I have been told they are still doing checks on exP's address, and that if they can't get good proper evidence that he lives where stated, they would drop the case 🤦‍♀️ I am a bit devastated about this, but then think why was it not possible for that person to come to me with a financial plan. As he's on bail but 'allowed' to contact me about our son, he wanted to see him, but not have to pay for him it seems, quite happy throughout, letting the coper and more able one just carry on with what they have always done, cope!
DiamondBright · 16/02/2021 23:18

I've always worked but went to 0.8 FTE for about 11 years so I could fit work in around nursery/school drop off and pick up. I'm happy with where I am in my career now but I spent a long time at the same pay band and had reduced pension contributions during the years I was part time, if we hadn't been married when we split up I wouldn't have received a share of my exH's pension to bridge the gap and I would also have only got 50% of the equity in the house despite having dd full time and exH not having to provide any accommodation for her.

Redruby2020 · 16/02/2021 23:06

@HappyAsASandboy

I have heard lots of people say that they don't need marriage because they earn the same as their partner and the care and child bills will be split evenly. This is all very well if if actually happens, but it rarely does. Almost always one person becomes the "default" for child care emergencies/organising children's stuff etc, and that leaves less time for career work.

More importantly is what happens if you split up. Most women find it harder to walk away from their responsibilities to their children, and quite a lot of men find it easy. That means the mother is often left with the lions share of the child-rearing to do. If you're married, you're far far more likely to get a bigger proportion of assets during the split, could be awarded the right to stay in the home after the split in order to accommodate the kids etc etc. If you're not married, then you walk away with whatever you can prove you own in your own name.

Unless you own vastly more or earn vastly more than your partner, marriage is almost always a good idea. If you own everything and earn the most then you may be in a stronger position remaining unmarried.

Sorry also I forgot to add, yeah why is it some men find it easy to walk away?! I've never understood it, but it must be to do with our make up that women have a different side to them and not just because we carried the child, I think it's much more than that
2020iscancelled · 16/02/2021 23:05

Won’t rehash the many good answers above.

Will add that it is dependant on circumstances pertaining to the woman’s financial position.

I am the higher earner, not massively so atm as took a slight demotion to grow my skill set but I have been a much higher earner and have the potential for future higher earnings.

I also had a house when we met, DP did not. I put down the deposit on our joint home from equity.

I also have fairly decent savings and assets.

I stand to gain absolutely nothing in terms of financial security from DP and actually have a lot of risk to my financial position - and that of our young children.

So it does make me hesitant on some level, although we are engaged and planning a wedding post covid for all of the legal reasons PPs have talked about.

On the whole women are more vulnerable but not always, it feels awful to question if i shouldn’t get married to protect my security when we are usually slagging off men who think along those lines

Redruby2020 · 16/02/2021 23:04

@HappyAsASandboy

I have heard lots of people say that they don't need marriage because they earn the same as their partner and the care and child bills will be split evenly. This is all very well if if actually happens, but it rarely does. Almost always one person becomes the "default" for child care emergencies/organising children's stuff etc, and that leaves less time for career work.

More importantly is what happens if you split up. Most women find it harder to walk away from their responsibilities to their children, and quite a lot of men find it easy. That means the mother is often left with the lions share of the child-rearing to do. If you're married, you're far far more likely to get a bigger proportion of assets during the split, could be awarded the right to stay in the home after the split in order to accommodate the kids etc etc. If you're not married, then you walk away with whatever you can prove you own in your own name.

Unless you own vastly more or earn vastly more than your partner, marriage is almost always a good idea. If you own everything and earn the most then you may be in a stronger position remaining unmarried.

This is true. And thankfully we have a safety net in this country to help, not like it was years ago though where you could be on Income Support and kids in school. I think it is very unfair that as single parent if you claim anything they are nagging at you to go to work, so you really do end up doing it all, it's so unfair. Especially as like as has already been mentioned, there are men who have even paid for fertility treatment etc and you think they are so keen, and look what happens 😳 I was pushed in to having a child, literally, done for a few of his own reasons and all the things that flashed before my eyes/went through my mind at that moment, have all come true. He knew he had already manipulated and abused me enough, plus that I was worth ten of him, and would step up, so either way, lumbered, I've been told not to say that, but I don't get why we are made to feel we need to dress every situation up.
Guineapigbridge · 16/02/2021 22:57

I think the issue is one of commitment. It's easy for men to say they're committed to you. Much harder for them to demonstrate it. Marriage is a demonstration that he means it, that he's taken active steps to make it happen. Having a child with a man who hasn't taken any steps... you have a much higher chance that he's just not that into being properly committed.

One foot in is the same as one foot out, in my opinion.

Redruby2020 · 16/02/2021 22:55

@SpringisSpinning

All sorts of reasons why it's better and easier, if you or your partner died you mean nothing in legal terms.. At all. He dies or even falls seriously ill, your not next of kin

You can't get personal info, do this or that... Nothing.. Because legally you are nothing.

It's not something people think about until its too late
His parents would have the say on where he is buried and how, what happens to ashes.. You can't access any bank accounts in his sole name..

Thankgod for that! If it had been my exP and I'd passed away, he would of taken the lot!
Redruby2020 · 16/02/2021 22:54

@Hannahusky

I think it's also that if your relationship hits hard times or even just you both end up going through hard times, you will feel much more likely to try to work through it if you're married. I know that sounds really old fashioned but I do believe it. My MiL used to say it and I used to think wise up but I think she's onto something as time goes on. I think this is partially why unmarried parents are more likely to separate.
So if you are being abused good old marriage tells you, you must keep cracking at it 🙄
Redruby2020 · 16/02/2021 22:51

@canigooutyet

Spousal maintenance isn't applied to all divorces. Married or not, if the other parent is a deadbeat they will walk away, and the resident parent is still left going though CMA unless they are very high earners.
🙏 Yes this is what I was waiting for someone else to say!
Cam2020 · 16/02/2021 22:51

It depeneds on your situation. There is recourse if a non marital relationship fails - men still have to pay towards the upkeep of their children (assuming they are on their birth certificate)! All purely based the rather narrow view of of women being SAHMs or only working part time and often a way for MNetters to feel superior.

Redruby2020 · 16/02/2021 22:49

@GreenWillow

Unmarried couples are significantly more likely to split up than married ones.

Outcomes for DC of separated parents are significantly worse across the board than those for the DC of married parents.

Therefore, taken at population level, DC are going to be worse off if you are unmarried, than if you are married.

Obviously life gets in the way, and there are always families that buck this trend, but the trend nevertheless exists.

So what are the guarantees of child maintenance if you are married and divorce?
Clicketyclick21 · 16/02/2021 22:43

There's a good thread on a similar subject, lots of good advice on there on the legal implications of being an unmarried couple.
Search for it under this title:
What would happen to my partners money if he dies and we weren't married

mopphead · 16/02/2021 20:21

Depends on your financial circumstances, if you are the high earner it won't disadvantage you. If you don't have your own house yet also won't.

Also depends on your romantic relationship. A partner who you plan to marry but there have been delays is very different to a partner who refuses to marry you. Personally I wouldn't put off a wanted baby for this, but only you know.