Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jury service & breastfeeding

87 replies

Catscrat · 09/02/2021 11:05

Posting here for traffic....

I had a letter a couple of weeks ago summoning me for jury service.

I asked to be excused as I’m exclusively breastfeeding (DS is 9 months old). He’s never had formula and we haven’t had any luck with bottles when I’ve tried expressing milk. I’m also not returning to work after mat leave so no childcare lined up, though I didn’t put that on the form.

Just got notification that my request has been rejected Confused and now I’m majorly panicking!

Has anyone got any experience of this?

OP posts:
edgeware · 09/02/2021 12:47

Just for reference I did jury service when my breastfed DS was about 1 and a bit. Dad looked after him and DS just fed when I was around, we did few feeds in the day by then anyway. I was out by 2 pm every day anyway and didn’t start til 10! Only lasted a week. I was really stressed about it (and it wasn’t helped by finding out I had to sit on a pedophile case) but it was al fine in the end.

SweetPetrichor · 09/02/2021 12:38

@Raindough I've got jury service in a few weeks time and the jury attends a cinema where the court room is livestreamed in and the jury is livestreamed to the court. It limits the number of people in any one place and because cinema rooms are big, they can easily space the jury out. This is in Scotland...don't know about anywhere else.

Catscrat · 09/02/2021 12:35

@HosannainExcelSheets Oh that's interesting to know re childcare costs, thank you. Just realised the 12 month referral takes us right into Easter holidays next year so I won't have childcare for DD!

@Raindough Yes I think you still have to attend court in person. The thought of holding a jury over Zoom is quite something!

OP posts:
CB1128 · 09/02/2021 12:34

Try again! I was excused years ago as DS was small. He wasn’t a baby but a toddler and he was not in childcare at the time and no one to have him. dp and all our family would be at work and couldn’t have time off. It was a very easy process for me at the time and I never heard from them again.

listsandbudgets · 09/02/2021 12:29

Mine was postphoned by exactly a year due to breastfeeding. Someone has slipped up I think.

Catscrat · 09/02/2021 12:27

@Dopeyduck 6 weeks Shock that must've been really tough. Kudos to you for taking your time!

And thank you. I weaned DD when she was 2 when I went back to work, so maybe we'll ready by then anyway - it's just not wanting to be forced into it.

OP posts:
Dopeyduck · 09/02/2021 12:15

It’s technically work so you’re entitled to a private space to either feed the baby or express. 9 months is more tricky but in 12 months time you’ll be able to just give your baby a cup of expressed milk or they’ll be able to cope without milk for a working day and will catch up when your home.
DS is 14 months and I work full time shift work 9hr shifts and he is offered milk in a cup (which is usually declined) and we breastfeed on demand when I’m here. I did have to express the first couple of weeks but I don’t now. It’s worked out just fine.

Don’t stress, breastfeeding is versatile and so are babies. Disruption doesn’t mean the end. If you do have to go your breast feeding journey will just adapt.

I hate the ignorance of people as well though and I’m sorry you’ve had to stress about it.

I was called to court to give evidence (as a professional) when my baby was 6 weeks old. They would not delay or excuse me so you can be sure that I rocked up with DS and DH in tow and they accommodated a private room for us until I was called. Did I care that I was late having been called as DS was finishing feeding? I cared not. The judge did actually say that he appreciated me accommodating it despite my young baby but I was pretty fuming. Anyways.

Catscrat · 09/02/2021 12:13

@notalwaysalondoner That's fair enough, yes he could be left with a bottle from a nutritional point of view and it could be for only a few days, as you say. But breastfeeding is about the child's emotional needs too, and I'd rather not compromise on that. There's also the risk the trial would last longer.

@AStudyinPink Thank you, exactly this!

@Twizbe That sounds really positive. If only it was like that everywhere!

OP posts:
AStudyinPink · 09/02/2021 12:11

It is different though. A two year is /should be mainly eating solids. Breastfeeding is a great thing to do for them, but at two years old it is an extra, not a necessity. Under a year, they really need the milk.

But if they are still drinking milk through the day, you don’t change what they need to do jury service. It’s a reasonable deferral/excuse.

Lancrelady80 · 09/02/2021 12:05

@AStudyinPink

Surely by the time your child is two they can manage without being breastfed while you’re out between 9-5? Assuming that you’ll even be out that long. A lot of jury service is quite short too, just a few days. Surely by that age they could also take a bottle if you were out? I agree you should be exempt now but I think getting out of it based on breastfeeding when your child is older is unreasonable to be honest.

You don’t flex your child’s needs for this sort of thing. It needs to flex for the child. If the child is still feeding and that’s working in the child’s family, there’s no need for a bottle.

It is different though. A two year is /should be mainly eating solids. Breastfeeding is a great thing to do for them, but at two years old it is an extra, not a necessity. Under a year, they really need the milk.
HosannainExcelSheets · 09/02/2021 12:03

When I did jury service a few years ago (London) I was told by the jury manager that she was surprised I'd not asked to be excused because I had 3 pre-school children. Apparently most people do get excused if the cost of childcare can't be covered by the allowance.

I hope you're all sorted out now, but if not I'd definitely just turn up with your baby and feed them right there in the jurer waiting room. You won't be called 🤣

Somethingsnappy · 09/02/2021 12:01

Well done for sorting it out. A stressful morning you could probably have done without though! I definitely like the idea of showing up with the baby if they had not cooperated!

Raindough · 09/02/2021 11:58

What are courts currently like with the pandemic/social distancing? Do jurors still attend in person or can they sit via video link?

Twizbe · 09/02/2021 11:56

I had to give evidence in court when my eldest was about 4 months old and I was breastfeeding.

I was actually quite impressed, they had a lovely room where I could feed in private. In the court they got my evidence first so they could release me quicker. Baby slept the whole way through. It was a modern court building though so lots of access, comfy seats and a bit more family friendly.

AStudyinPink · 09/02/2021 11:54

Surely by the time your child is two they can manage without being breastfed while you’re out between 9-5? Assuming that you’ll even be out that long. A lot of jury service is quite short too, just a few days. Surely by that age they could also take a bottle if you were out? I agree you should be exempt now but I think getting out of it based on breastfeeding when your child is older is unreasonable to be honest.

You don’t flex your child’s needs for this sort of thing. It needs to flex for the child. If the child is still feeding and that’s working in the child’s family, there’s no need for a bottle.

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/02/2021 11:51

Well done OP, good result.

Catscrat · 09/02/2021 11:46

@Sunshineandflipflops you’d think, wouldn’t you?!

@NachoNachoMan being on a jury is my worst nightmare 🙈 though to be fair in a year’s time maybe I’ll want a break from looking after a toddler haha.

OP posts:
notalwaysalondoner · 09/02/2021 11:45

Surely by the time your child is two they can manage without being breastfed while you’re out between 9-5? Assuming that you’ll even be out that long. A lot of jury service is quite short too, just a few days. Surely by that age they could also take a bottle if you were out? I agree you should be exempt now but I think getting out of it based on breastfeeding when your child is older is unreasonable to be honest.

Catscrat · 09/02/2021 11:42

Thanks all, these replies made me chuckle.

Just rang up. The lady I spoke to said I didn’t put enough detail on my form and that’s why it was rejected Hmm Silly me thinking breastfeeding was enough of an excuse eh?!

I explained the situation and she said I can defer for up to a year and then see what my situation is then.

I asked what the facilities are for breastfeeding (given I breasted DD for 2+ years & anticipate doing that long with DS) and she said you can’t take a child in but they could give me a room to express in. So I could probably ask to be excused if I’m still breastfeeding and they can’t accommodate that.

So I’ve deferred for 12 months, I probably should’ve pushed for excusal but at least I don’t have to worry about it for a bit longer!

OP posts:
GeordieGreigsButtButtZoom · 09/02/2021 11:36

If you can't sort it out beforehand, turn up with the baby. I cannot see them selecting you!

Sunshineandflipflops · 09/02/2021 11:35

I was excused due to having a young baby and I wasn't even breastfeeding. This was 13 years ago but I would have expected things to have improved, not the opposite!

NachoNachoMan · 09/02/2021 11:32

I got my jury duty letter when my youngest was a few weeks old - had a toddler and a child at school. Toddler in nursery a few days a week to keep it familiar before returning to work, and I was taking and picking up the eldest from school. I was EBF to a baby which required 5 or 10 minutes feed every hour. I requested it to be postponed citing the breastfeeding and no childcare and they excused me! Never been invited since yet my brother has done it twice! Quite disappointed really 😂

snugglepuff · 09/02/2021 11:31

Your baby literally can't eat without you. You need to call them and explain... whoever has looked at your request hasn't read it properly!

AStudyinPink · 09/02/2021 11:28

You can then say NO to every option, except a proper staffed creche with qualified adults and breaks to go and feed.

Exactly. “Empty the court - little Jack needs his morning feed.” Can’t see it!

steppemum · 09/02/2021 11:24

@AStudyinPink

Walk in, put the baby on your knee and get your nipple out. You’ll be excused.
I was going to suggest something similar!

Turn up with baby and say you can't leave them as bf.

You can then say NO to every option, except a proper staffed creche with qualified adults and breaks to go and feed.