Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jury service & breastfeeding

87 replies

Catscrat · 09/02/2021 11:05

Posting here for traffic....

I had a letter a couple of weeks ago summoning me for jury service.

I asked to be excused as I’m exclusively breastfeeding (DS is 9 months old). He’s never had formula and we haven’t had any luck with bottles when I’ve tried expressing milk. I’m also not returning to work after mat leave so no childcare lined up, though I didn’t put that on the form.

Just got notification that my request has been rejected Confused and now I’m majorly panicking!

Has anyone got any experience of this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
J1990 · 07/03/2023 00:31

Catscrat · 11/02/2021 15:43

@Username12353784 Thanks, they let me defer it for 12 months. I’ve already had an email through with the date for next year. I wish they’d just excused me, as I’m still stressing about it!

@User0ne thank you, someone else mentioned that link too. Some useful advice. As they’ve deferred it I will have to see what my situation is next year as they could argue I may not be breastfeeding at that point (though I’m planning to still be!)

This is old I know but did you get called again?

Catscrat · 11/02/2021 15:43

@Username12353784 Thanks, they let me defer it for 12 months. I’ve already had an email through with the date for next year. I wish they’d just excused me, as I’m still stressing about it!

@User0ne thank you, someone else mentioned that link too. Some useful advice. As they’ve deferred it I will have to see what my situation is next year as they could argue I may not be breastfeeding at that point (though I’m planning to still be!)

OP posts:
User0ne · 11/02/2021 12:20

[quote FabulousIAm]This link may help www.laleche.org.uk/breastfeeding-and-jury-servic/[/quote]
Use this and challenge the decision. It's been made by someone who doesn't know anything about breastfeeding or how it would relate to maternity being a legally protected characteristic

littlemisslozza · 11/02/2021 11:44

I was called up about 10 years ago and gave the same reason as you, breastfeeding baby plus a toddler at home. Was completely excused, not deferred. Would like to be called up again sometime though.

Username12353784 · 11/02/2021 11:41

I commented on this the other day but haven’t got time to read through all the posts. Did you get it sorted op? I think you have grounds to be excused or deferred. I was a few years ago due to having a young child (not breast fed) mentioned in my pp and I was excused and never heard from them again.

AStudyinPink · 11/02/2021 11:22

Oh come on, I've extended fed three children and think it is a bit mad to claim that a 2 year old needs feeding between the hours of 9-5. Nor do children of this age need a bottle, they're old enough for a cup.

It’s not mad at all. I didn’t do extended feeding, but I recognise that some children do.

Catscrat · 10/02/2021 23:41

Didn’t anticipate this turning into quite such a debate Grin The breastfeeding thing was at the forefront of my mind in asking for the deferral, it may not be an issue in a year’s time as pp have pointed out. I’m not planning to send him to childcare till 2+ so don’t like the thought of having to leave him for 2 weeks of full days away from me if he’s not used to it. Would be totally different if he was at school like my older DD. I will cross that bridge when I come to it I guess!

OP posts:
Catscrat · 10/02/2021 23:26

@Crikeycroc thank you, I’ll see how things are in a year’s time!

OP posts:
Crikeycroc · 10/02/2021 22:01

As usual the usual British weirdness about breastfeeding prevails on this thread. Breastfeeding is recommended by the WHO until at least two years old. Not all two year olds feed twice per day especially if mum isn’t working outside the home. We should be supporting women willing to do this not inconveniencing them with jury duty.

OP if you are still breastfeeding when they summon you again get in touch with a breastfeeding advocacy group (?LLL, I’m not sure who to recommend, I’m not in the UK) and see what they can do.

OverTheRubicon · 10/02/2021 20:53

@AStudyinPink

Surely by the time your child is two they can manage without being breastfed while you’re out between 9-5? Assuming that you’ll even be out that long. A lot of jury service is quite short too, just a few days. Surely by that age they could also take a bottle if you were out? I agree you should be exempt now but I think getting out of it based on breastfeeding when your child is older is unreasonable to be honest.

You don’t flex your child’s needs for this sort of thing. It needs to flex for the child. If the child is still feeding and that’s working in the child’s family, there’s no need for a bottle.

Oh come on, I've extended fed three children and think it is a bit mad to claim that a 2 year old needs feeding between the hours of 9-5. Nor do children of this age need a bottle, they're old enough for a cup.

If people want to have a representative group of people on juries, it's not helpful if there are a huge range of reasons to back out.

NovemberRain2 · 10/02/2021 20:47

I'm dying to do it and would love to get called up!

I just think the rules should apply fairly, that's all. And if women keep deterring for childcare reasons, it's not necessarily just a few people is it?

shouldistop · 10/02/2021 20:38

@NovemberRain2 the slack? Grin how many times have you done jury duty that it's causing you such difficulties?
I am part of the working population btw and don't feel hard done by that a few people are excused from jury duty for childcare reasons.

NovemberRain2 · 10/02/2021 20:26

It might be for a few years. Or it might be much longer because you've got no one else to pick the kids up from school or because you have more babies. In the meantime, the rest of the working population has to pick up the slack. Please tell me how that's fair?

shouldistop · 10/02/2021 10:10

No but there should either be court provided care or children given priority for temp places. May not always be possible in areas of low supply but we can't just expect the rest of the adult population to work, look after kids AND do jury duty all the time.

Don't be ridiculous, people don't leave their children with strangers not of their choosing.
There's a small percentage of people who have no childcare whatsoever and for a small amount of time. It's hardly disrupting the justice system.

AStudyinPink · 10/02/2021 09:30

There’s no way I would leave my 9 month old in the care of someone I’ve never met before to be a on jury... no way!

Same. We choose the people we want to look after our babies with care.

OverTheRainbow88 · 10/02/2021 09:18

There’s no way I would leave my 9 month old in the care of someone I’ve never met before to be a on jury... no way!

AStudyinPink · 10/02/2021 09:11

No but there should either be court provided care or children given priority for temp places. May not always be possible in areas of low supply but we can't just expect the rest of the adult population to work, look after kids AND do jury duty all the time.

Of course we can. It’s temporary for a few years while kids are small. Court provided care would be a huge cost compared to just deferring people with small kids and completely pointless.

NovemberRain2 · 10/02/2021 08:17

No but there should either be court provided care or children given priority for temp places. May not always be possible in areas of low supply but we can't just expect the rest of the adult population to work, look after kids AND do jury duty all the time.

shouldistop · 09/02/2021 21:06

I agree it's a civic duty if possible, however a close family member of mine is a judge and he wouldn't be expecting people to magic up childcare that doesn't exist

shouldistop · 09/02/2021 21:04

@NovemberRain2 childcare can very well be a reason. I had to sign ds2 up for nursery before he was born and he won't be going until he's 1yo.
I also don't think childcare exists for small children that you can just use for a week or whatever for jury duty (let alone being able to settle your child in so they're not left with a stranger).
You can get out of work to do jury duty, you can't as easily leave your children.

NovemberRain2 · 09/02/2021 18:54

I dunno. It's civic duty and everyone needs to contribute. So fine to deter if they can't accomodate breastfeeding mothers but childcare shouldn't be a reason if they reimburse the cost.

In a way, SAHMs are best jurors if childcare can be arranged.

peak2021 · 09/02/2021 17:27

Glad to see that deferral has been agreed.

As for jury service, if only you could do it by video link say from your nearest court of any kind or a police station, even if not by Zoom from home. There is so much hanging about I found when I did jury service, including a policeman who could have been out catching criminals or at least processing paperwork for those he caught.

Catscrat · 09/02/2021 17:13

@kwest I hope you get called one day then! It's a shame, if courts had the facilities to accomodate parents with young children they'd probably get more representative juries.

OP posts:
Catscrat · 09/02/2021 17:08

@cliffdiver omg that sounds horrendous Shock - for both the defendant and you!

@Lancrelady80 Aghhhh sorry I totally misread your post!! Blush I get what you mean now. And thank you Smile

OP posts:
Aozora13 · 09/02/2021 16:52

Glad you got it sorted. I was called when my DD was 2 months old and deferred because I was breastfeeding. Was still in fact breastfeeding when I got called up again exactly a year later but she was only feeding morning and bedtime so wasn’t an issue. Work were delighted that almost immediately after 1 years maternity leave I was out for 2 weeks jury service!