Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents in dc's class lying about homeschooling!!!

294 replies

Pastasau · 07/02/2021 22:32

On both dc's WhatsApp groups, a certain few parents have been going on & on about how their kids are doing the bare minimum, no time to do the extra work set & they are absolutely not pushing the schoolwork & do not force the kids to finish any of it...
However dc had a social zoom call with some friends from the class, one said she wasn't allowed to go on as she had a zoom with her tutor, the other friend whose mom is the one appearing most relaxed & nonchalant about the school work has her dd up at 6.30 to do 2 hours work before the actual schooling begins! Her dd told my dd her mom recaps all the lessons for an hour after the live lessons, insists all work is done, all extras plus the schedule of work she sets herself!
Aibu to think some parents are blatently lying when they say they are relaxed & easygoing about the work? And why lie?

OP posts:
Wearywithteens · 08/02/2021 10:00

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

BigBadVoodooHat · 08/02/2021 09:59

@BigBadVoodooHat but you’re not protecting people’s feelings when the consequences of what you’re doing means that their kids are seen to fall behind are you?

What anyone says, or doesn't say, and what anyone does, or doesn't do, in terms of homeschooling has absolutely no bearing on the outcome for other children.

Other children's educational attainment is not a 'consequence' of other people's claim about what they ae or are not doing.

I'm struggling to understand the causality you're implying here. If I say I do 100 hours of school work a week, or I say I do 1 hour of schoolwork a month, how does that cause someone else's children to fall behind?

Nothing anyone else says about what they're doing has a direct consequence for your child. What you do has a direct consequence for your child.

Rosehassometoes · 08/02/2021 09:55

@MrsToadlike

I think what you said here:

‘Could be competitive - you know, downplay what you are doing to try and trick everyone else into doing very little to give your child a head start.’

I think a chance for some to jump to top of the class when schools return. Will only work if some others drop the ball.

Souther · 08/02/2021 09:51

@Pastasau

It doesn't impact my child whatsoever but why lie & be so goady on the class whatsapp saying they're "prioritising play" "only doing a handful of the work" "letting the kids be kids" when the kids have an entirely different story. It's so hypocritical.. I mentioned as well as others on the group when it was brought up that we had completed todays agenda to be met with "we did nothing here, not forcing the kids, they only get one childhood"!
So would you feel better if they were posting things like. 'Yup we finished the work it was a piece of cake.' ' The wprk isnt pushing my kids so we are doing loads of extra work' ' We are on a strict timetable. We are waking at 6.30 and doing 2 hours extra work a day.' ' yup me and the kids are finding lockdown learning a breeze.' Cos I'm sure if they were posting the above you'd still be on here complaining about them.
tawnytowel · 08/02/2021 09:51

Its not a competition

It is though. Everything about school is a competition for some people, otherwise most wouldn’t be doing it.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/02/2021 09:50

Welcome to normality original poster! This is expected and not a rarity. Many parents are leveraging and maxing out the quasi working from home lockdown while others complain their lives are turned upside down because of working from home and home tutoring.

I personally know how competitive some primary school classes are in this pandemic as little children are still innocent and tell it as it is (thankfully) unlike their competitive and secretive parents working military style operations around the clock to get their child ahead of the game. So in summary from my experience as much as there is the “oh I can’t be bothered with it” brigade there are many behind the scenes force feeding their children much extra educational nourishment and it’s not just pay as you go fee paying schools but also more sought after over subscribed tax payer paid for state schools too. People realise in this once in a lifetime pandemic as the economy crashes who will be best equipped to survive!

tawnytowel · 08/02/2021 09:49

@BigBadVoodooHat but you’re not protecting people’s feelings when the consequences of what you’re doing means that their kids are seen to fall behind are you?

tawnytowel, so if the parents told the truth and said their dcs are doing great, do you actually feel happy for them if you were struggling?

I’d have a lot more respect for them yeah. Happy - meh, whatever floats their boat. I’d also feel a lot less concerned if my kid was told they were behind compared to those children (they’re not) as I think we all know the issues lie with the parents not with the kids. I can afford to tutor, I could also make time to set extra work before and after school but I don’t because I’d rather mine were happy and able to stand on their own two feet.

Devlesko · 08/02/2021 09:49

Call them out on it. "Oh, your dd said ...."
It's like kids at school saying they haven't revised for a test when you know they have, because they are conscientious.

Souther · 08/02/2021 09:47

I'm ot sure how it impacts on you how much work they are doing.
Its not a competition.
Just do how much you want to do and let them do how much they want to.
Its not impacting on you or your kids, so I'm not sure why you care so much.

Ikora · 08/02/2021 09:44

I agree it means very different things to different people. One of my brothers and his wife would say I was a bit slack. But they had a 100% tiger parenting style. Both their daughters have Science doctorates like themselves but it was a totalitarian regime of study.

My sons friends thought I was strict and I do think compared to his English friends I was.

MrsToadlike · 08/02/2021 09:42

As someone up the thread said, it's a tale as old as time.

It's as if the girls I went to school with, who claimed to have done no revision then came out of their exams with straight A-grades, have grown up and become parents themselves...and the pattern continues with their children.

Could be competitive - you know, downplay what you are doing to try and trick everyone else into doing very little to give your child a head start. But I suspect more realistically they're concerned they'll be labelled 'keen' or a try hard.

I don't have school age children yet, but my toddler whatsapp group with fellow mummies is absolutely filled with photos of them doing all sorts of wholesome and educational activities with their little ones. I'm not sure what's worse - downplaying what you do with your children or taking photos of it and sharing them every day.

Charles11 · 08/02/2021 09:36

Most threads about dc doing well and working hard get accusations of smugness, sarcastic applauses and award messages and all manner of things.
People are also sensitive if their dc aren’t doing well, so why would you say they were if others aren’t?

HeckyPeck · 08/02/2021 09:34

*they're

Shelovesamystery · 08/02/2021 09:34

@tawnytowel

Honestly this is such crap! Lying about it out of the kindness of your hearts and for the benefit of others, hilarious.

In life you only lie if you’re embarrassed about something, you know it’s wrong, you know it’s sly, or you intentionally want to mislead people.

Because you know what, it’s not kind and it does affect other people. When those parents you care so much about then get told that their children are “behind” they’re not going to appreciate your “grace” then are they. No - and that’s exactly what you want them to be told, because it’s the knock on effect of giving your own kids extra help in order for them to come first. Which is all you really care about.

Otherwise you wouldn’t lie about it.

So you've never told a white lie or bended the truth to save someone's feelings? To make them feel better or, at least, a bit less shit?

You sound really angry. People are in different positions in this. I am furloughed with a y1 child who enjoys doing most of her school work. Should I just refuse to do it with her (when I've got nothing else to do anyway) because it's not fair that some kids don't have a parent on furlough? I think the whole situation is terrible and really unfair to parents who have multiple children and/or trying to juggle work with homeschooling. I don't want to make those parents feel worse because my DD is lucky to be the only school age child in the house and have a parent with loads of free time. How would that help the situation?

Like I said most of the time I just keep quiet. But when I can see that another parent is looking for help or support I try to help and show a bit of solidarity at the same time.

HeckyPeck · 08/02/2021 09:33

I'd assume their lying because from the quotes from the OP that they've been saying when others are saying they're struggling they sound like twats and twats are likely to also be liars in my experience.

Belladonna12 · 08/02/2021 09:30

Why assume that the parents are the ones that are lying rather than the DC? I find it hard to believe that many people are getting their DC up hours before class starts for example. I remember my DDs' friends exaggerating like this when they were at primary school.

HeckyPeck · 08/02/2021 09:28

I think though these groups can be very pressurised to all say the same thing

I get that, but it sounds like these people are lying and pretending they're doing the opposite to everyone else
So more like:

Everyone else: it's been a struggle so we only managed to get some done/well we got it done today but it was a battle!
Liars: oh well we prioritise our child's mental health so we're not making them do anything. They only get to be children once after all.

Lying about doing nothing but also taking the others down a peg or two is nasty not about trying to fit in.

Tianatiers · 08/02/2021 09:26

Yes there is definitely culture on class what's apps of competitive rubbish parenting but when it comes to it the ones going on about how much they don't care are blatantly the ones actually going above and beyond in reality. It's pretty pathetic actually. Don't pay any attention to what others are doing, you just do you.

SpringIsComingAlways · 08/02/2021 09:23

I'd just carry on doing what us right for you and yours and ignore them.
Reminds me of the type at uni that would pretend they did no work, when really studying all hours and then feign shock when great results...'oh I'm so shocked I barely looked at the work ' Hmm

Lanzo · 08/02/2021 09:20

This is a massive thing in London private schools and you have to assume most parents are doing it quite a lot. It is tough on the the children e.g. if you have a crap maths teacher but mystifyingly a large number of the class are doing really well - usually because they have tutors or parents are helping a lot. You do have to ignore it and do it your way but it can cause confidence issues for your child. Some parents love pretending it all comes down to natural ability. Different cultures seem to have different attitudes to this. Some will see support as an indication that their child is struggling and won’t mention any assistance they are giving whilst others see it as practically child abuse not to push and tutor their children and will happily talk about tutoring etc.

BigBadVoodooHat · 08/02/2021 09:18

In life you only lie if you’re embarrassed about something, you know it’s wrong, you know it’s sly, or you intentionally want to mislead people.

People may lie for all of the above reasons. They may also lie to save other people’s feelings or to avoid an awkward or unpleasant situation: these ‘white lies’ are the lies that allow society to function smoothly. Everybody knows that. Everybody does that.

Only a twat would tell a friend they look hideous in their new dress. Only a twat would tell their friend they’re doing twenty extra hours of schooling a week if that friend was struggling to cover the minimum.

ZoeTurtle · 08/02/2021 09:16
  1. They don't want to make other people feel bad.
  1. They're trying to fit in and think this is what others want to hear.
  1. They're trying to 'trick' the rest of you so their children can get ahead while yours fall behind.

Just mute the WhatsApp group, OP.

DrBlackbird · 08/02/2021 09:15

Kind of seems some PPs are missing the OP's point. Parents may well not wish to admit to their DC doing all / extra school work so as not be knobs. That's fine. It does seem odd for DP's to then stress how DC do absolutely no work / make up stories about time on Minecraft?.

Reminds me of one DM dictating a shopping list to her 3 yr old DC. I was genuinely amazed that this child was 'writing' as a 3 yr old. DM finally admitted she'd been intensively coaching DC weekly for a year. My conclusion: she was a ultra competitive DM but did not want to admit to this + liked the glory of having a 'naturally' brilliant DC.

TastyTicklemore · 08/02/2021 09:08

Because she doesn't want to be ostracized and bitched about for doing her best because her doing her best isn't a slant on other people doing their best.

This would be my guess, too.

fiveoldteddies · 08/02/2021 09:08

HA yes I wonder what my dc tell about me, because dc talking to their friends are always telling the truth...