Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be utterly shocked and heartbroken at how many intelligent, lovely friends and acquaintances have totally bought in to the radical global conspiracy theories...

393 replies

fuschia2000 · 07/02/2021 18:58

Seeing so much conspiracy stuff on Facebook threads, its totally alarming.... the folks can really make a good argument, with pseudo science, lots of data etc but we are looking at radical q'anon right wing conspiracy theories breaking through into the normal discussion groups and online groups.....

OP posts:
thenewduchessofhastings · 09/02/2021 12:36

Have deleted one friend and his wife as fed up of their long detailed daily political rants about how x party and x leaders would have done a better job/how terrible all torys are and how vile and stupid Tory voters are/bitching about brexit and are wanton anti Vaxers and one of them a few weeks ago was ranting on about how they don't know if they can anything to do with friends/family who have a vaccine and have been bleating on about Covid conspiracies and how the government is using it to control the masses.

The husband won't let me make a couple of tin foil hats to post to them.

cinnabarmoth · 09/02/2021 12:33

@CutePixie

"Until recently, it wasn’t even 28 days, you could’ve been tested 3 months before your death and still be included in the stats"

What constitutes recently? It was changed to 28 days back in August - they have only been reporting on UK Covid deaths since March I think, for obvious reasons - so the 'new' methodology has been around for longer than the 'old'.

publichealthmatters.blog.gov.uk/2020/08/12/behind-the-headlines-counting-covid-19-deaths/

LunaHeather · 09/02/2021 12:29

Triffid "And quite frankly, it's got Julia Hartley Brewer on there so no, I can't get too worked up if Youtube decided it was basically hate speech because based on what I know of her, that seems quite possible. But as always, things like this are dropped in to conversation/posts by people like you with the implication that they're so so awful and a sign of a big cover up or whatever. "

People like me? Like what?

And you assume something in particular because of one person on a radio channel?

This is how we got here. Is there ever a point at which people listen to a different point of view? Why so much polarisation? Where did nuanced discussion go?

Triffid1 · 09/02/2021 12:22

Re pharma, stop using the word "conspiracy" and ask yourself if pharma like to promote more expensive drugs.

Of course they do. But there's a big difference between actively looking for bulletproof solutions they can charge a fortune for and an industry-wide plan to prevent investigation into other options.

TO people who don't follow media, Talkradio is meaningless. And quite frankly, it's got Julia Hartley Brewer on there so no, I can't get too worked up if Youtube decided it was basically hate speech because based on what I know of her, that seems quite possible. But as always, things like this are dropped in to conversation/posts by people like you with the implication that they're so so awful and a sign of a big cover up or whatever.

I saw one where someone was suggesting it was some kind of big conspiracy theory that cabinet ministers in the UK don't have expertise in the areas they cover. I nearly pissed myself laughing at the cluelessness re how the UK political system works and may have linked to pictures of the Bullington Club in the comment section...

LunaHeather · 09/02/2021 12:07

Triffid if you don't know what I mean re Talk Radio etc I don't know how to explain it better.

Re pharma, stop using the word "conspiracy" and ask yourself if pharma like to promote more expensive drugs.

I read medical journals - not so much the Lancet now as it has lost the plot. Yes, those discussions have happened in journals. I'm not disputing that.

Hands up though - haven't read a medical journal since xmas.

Apart from getting drawn in on here, I do try not to get drawn in.

Triffid1 · 09/02/2021 11:55

Doctors and scientists with anti lockdown views are discredited, as are those wishing to try older, cheaper medical treatments. I try to avoid MSM since I realised but AFAIK even the Great Barrington Declaration was smeared and removed from search engines. It may be back now, .i don't know. I think some search engines and big sites played silly buggers with articles about Ivermectin too. TalkRadio was removed from YouTube for a while, I can't recall what excuse was given but it was flagged up because of freely exploring anti lockdown sentiment.

This is classic conspiracy theory bollocks. It's all so vague. It doesn't say what the bloody problem you're so worried about is. If I hadn't actually engaged on some of these issues with other people, not a word of this would make a bit of sense to me. It's all "oh well, of course they'd say that" or "you see these [nebulous] things or these [unknown] people were told to shut up".

Ivermectin is a classic example. Oooh, big pharma are trying to stop it being used as a way to help people because they'll make more money off vaccines/new drugs etc. But it's a ridiculous argument because

  1. Other cheap and cheerful existing drugs HAVE been announced as having some positive impact and ARE being used
  2. Reputable medical journals have discussed Ivermectic and worried that the quantity needed to treat Covid is dangerous for humans (bear in mind this is a drug designed to, if I recall, kill lice or similar?)
  3. The practicalities of pharmaceutical companies creating a big conspiracy to hide the efficacy of cheap drugs is laughable. In my experience, getting people all on the same page in a group of more than 2 is impossible but sure, there's not a single whistleblower from across the (massive) pharmaceutical industry who has seen documentation that says this drug must be hidden?

FFS.

Triffid1 · 09/02/2021 11:50

This is what I meant. PHE stats include everyone who died within 28 days of testing positive. They don’t double check. Until recently, it wasn’t even 28 days, you could’ve been tested 3 months before your death and still be included in the stats. Lots of terminally ill or very frail people died after testing positive and were counted as a Covid19 stat. No one seems to die of flu or pneumonia anymore.

Which is why the excess death stats are potentially more useful. And people not dying of flu is most likely the direct result of lockdown, social distancing etc. It is not as contagious so the various measures taken to control Covid have been extremely effective in controlling other infectious diseases.

knittingaddict · 09/02/2021 11:41

But many people die of covid after 28 days too and I assume that they aren't included in the figures. A work colleague of my husband was on a ventilator and in hospital for at least 3 months and he almost died. He probably wouldn't have been included in current figures for covid deaths if he had died. If anything the deaths from covid may be an underestimate.

There have been over 80,000 excess deaths since the start of the pandemic. How do you square that with your thoughts that too many people are being classed as death from covid?

CutePixie · 09/02/2021 11:13

@RichardMarxisinnocent

Did that actually happen though? Everyone who tested positive had that on their death certificate even if they got run over by a bus? As the actual cause of death? I've yet to see any evidence that it happened like that other than people claiming such on forums.

No they didn't have covid as cause of death on their death certificate if they got run over by a bus. They may however have been included in the COVID stats of deaths reported each day, because those stats look at everyone who tested positive for COVID in the previous 28 days, and at whether the person is alive or deceased. If deceased they are one of the people who died within 28 days of a positive COVID test. COVID may or may not have been their actual cause of death. There are other stats which show number of deaths where covid is mentioned on the death certificate. These people may or may not have had a positive covid test - the doctor certifying death may have put it as covid due to symptoms if they didn't have a test. Numbers for both sets of stats are similar.

This is what I meant. PHE stats include everyone who died within 28 days of testing positive. They don’t double check. Until recently, it wasn’t even 28 days, you could’ve been tested 3 months before your death and still be included in the stats. Lots of terminally ill or very frail people died after testing positive and were counted as a Covid19 stat. No one seems to die of flu or pneumonia anymore.
MechantGourmet · 09/02/2021 10:32

[quote cinnabarmoth]Trying to write anything coherent on a phone is so frustrating! Further to my previous post, I am not for a moment saying I the the Great Reset is wonderful, has no downsides and we should all support it, just that I don't think it's a sinister plot to enforce socialism. I think the article by Naomi Klein puts it very well
theintercept.com/2020/12/08/great-reset-conspiracy/[/quote]
Thank you for sharing this article @cinnabarmoth

PinkyParrot · 09/02/2021 10:21

Look at all those dodgy contracts worth millions of pounds of our taxes that were given to the mates of tory politicians under the cloak of a global emergency. Then those same politicians didn't want to support families who had fallen on hard times due to the pandemic over the school holidays.
Surely you are part of the problem - very valuable contracts were going to go to someone, no one's come up with a list of the good honest companies that should have got the contracts. I think 14 million was given to one of the vaccine companies for research - was that a bung? Or did it ensure we were/are ahead of the game when it came to vaccines. The gov made an increase in universal benefits at the start.
The big winners are American tech companies. They're going to try to rule the world. Cos in the U.K. are small fry.

ElephantsNest · 09/02/2021 10:03

[quote cinnabarmoth]Trying to write anything coherent on a phone is so frustrating! Further to my previous post, I am not for a moment saying I the the Great Reset is wonderful, has no downsides and we should all support it, just that I don't think it's a sinister plot to enforce socialism. I think the article by Naomi Klein puts it very well
theintercept.com/2020/12/08/great-reset-conspiracy/[/quote]
Thank you for sharing, this is a good quality article from a well regarded author, who sets out how the genuine concerns people have about elites exploiting the pandemic are being drowned out by batshit conspiracy theories. I am so upset that a friend of mine has fallen for 'the virus is not real' as it is plainly nonsense, but I entirely understand people who sense that the pandemic is being exploited to drive specific agendas.

Look at all those dodgy contracts worth millions of pounds of our taxes that were given to the mates of tory politicians under the cloak of a global emergency. Then those same politicians didn't want to support families who had fallen on hard times due to the pandemic over the school holidays.

knittingaddict · 09/02/2021 09:39

And by "speculative thought experiment" I don't mean anything was ever going to be done about it. They aren't experimenting on anyone.

It's unfortunate that conspiracy theorists can point to something real (although not what they say it is) and give their ludicrous ideas some spurious credibility, when it really is a massive twisting of facts.

knittingaddict · 09/02/2021 09:33

@cinnabarmoth

I will probably be shouted down, but isn't the Great Reset just a think tank plan around globally coordinating effort to try and and rebuild the economy/society more sustainably and equitably after the pandemic? The line about owning nothing and being happy seems to come from a speculative think piece written by one person in 2016, with the stated aim of generating discussion around the pros and cons of a situation we could be heading towards already, rather than being a stated aim of the WEF. The video that includes/quotes that line is pretty obviously based on that piece of writing. Both predate the 'Great Reset' stuff by a few years www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/11/how-life-could-change-2030/

There are definitely arguments to be made about whether the Great Reset is really much different from what the WEF have talked about before, and whether it's just rich people trying to assuage their guilt/look good, but I don't know that it's particularly sinister. Rich people and corporations already control and shape the world, if they can see the need/be persuaded to try to do this in a way that's fairer and more sustainable that's surely not a bad thing? Calling it 'The Great Reset' may not have been the wisest choice though!

Yes! That's exactly what I think it is. I imagine that there are loads of such speculative thought experiments going on all over the world, but they don't have sexy titles like The Great Reset. Unfortunate naming indeed.
NurseButtercup · 09/02/2021 08:38

@cinnabarmoth

I totally agree with you - the great reset was never positioned as this huge mind control agenda, literally just a think tank/futurologists.

Sadly the conspiracy theorists have weaved it into their anti- government, anti-vax, anti-bill gates anti- everything rhetoric.

cinnabarmoth · 09/02/2021 08:22

Trying to write anything coherent on a phone is so frustrating! Further to my previous post, I am not for a moment saying I the the Great Reset is wonderful, has no downsides and we should all support it, just that I don't think it's a sinister plot to enforce socialism. I think the article by Naomi Klein puts it very well
theintercept.com/2020/12/08/great-reset-conspiracy/

cinnabarmoth · 09/02/2021 07:51

I will probably be shouted down, but isn't the Great Reset just a think tank plan around globally coordinating effort to try and and rebuild the economy/society more sustainably and equitably after the pandemic? The line about owning nothing and being happy seems to come from a speculative think piece written by one person in 2016, with the stated aim of generating discussion around the pros and cons of a situation we could be heading towards already, rather than being a stated aim of the WEF. The video that includes/quotes that line is pretty obviously based on that piece of writing. Both predate the 'Great Reset' stuff by a few years
www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/11/how-life-could-change-2030/

There are definitely arguments to be made about whether the Great Reset is really much different from what the WEF have talked about before, and whether it's just rich people trying to assuage their guilt/look good, but I don't know that it's particularly sinister. Rich people and corporations already control and shape the world, if they can see the need/be persuaded to try to do this in a way that's fairer and more sustainable that's surely not a bad thing? Calling it 'The Great Reset' may not have been the wisest choice though!

PinkyParrot · 09/02/2021 07:45

My sil says that although covid is without a doubt real, it is being used to gradually bring in a cashless society and businesses to go bust, therefore people relying totally on the government for support,

The Gov runs on our money - ie the tax we pay - if everyone was on basic benefits they would pay no tax as below the threshold. So the gov would have no money.
So the above is utter drivel. When I was a teen about 50 years ago I thought the Gov gave me money towards my college fees - I had no idea they were recycling someone else's tax payment. I might have been more appreciative if I had realised that.

The pandemic has been great for Amazon, not so good for small local businesses. Because you, the people are doing all your shopping on it. If you stopped doing all your shopping on it it would be less rich, it's not some conspiracy from on high it is YOU giving amazon, google, netflix your hard earned cash for their products. Unfortunately, unlike the past, the rest of the world is too so they are sooooooooooo rich. Tooooo rich imv.

ChestnutStuffing · 09/02/2021 00:37

@Firstfrill

My sil says that although covid is without a doubt real, it is being used to gradually bring in a cashless society and businesses to go bust, therefore people relying totally on the government for support, which she says can be taken away at will. Its all pre planned apparently.
But is this crazy - we already know there are people who would very much like to achieve these things. Many many of the large businesses of the world would like to see many smaller businesses go bust. The pandemic has been great for Amazon, not so good for small local businesses.

There have been pushes from banks and governments to go cashless, it's taken some pushback to try and hold it back.

We know that after 9/11, many of the security things which were instituted were things that some state agents had wanted to institute for some time, particularly in the US. And they did because of the opportunity they had with 9/11, and they are still there.

We are in a cycle now of increasing authoritarianism in a number of areas. It makes people suspicious.

LunaHeather · 08/02/2021 23:45

@seashells11

Police officers were not arresting people for sitting on benches, they were arresting people for breaking lockdown rules

Which basically meant sitting on a bench, whish isn't actually breaking any laws. Lockdown rules aren't the law. Breaking rules isn't an arrestable offence as far as I know.

Yes, there do seem to be a lot of incidents of forces actually saying themselves "we did this" and it turns out they didn't differentiate between law and guidance.
longwayoff · 08/02/2021 23:18

Everyone has a mobile. Most people have a car. Many have biometric passports. Its practically impossible to get by without a bank card. We can all be located 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. So why the hell would Bill Gates need to track anyone with a secret bloody microchip? The lack of reasoning is absolutely terrifying.

seashells11 · 08/02/2021 23:16

Police officers were not arresting people for sitting on benches, they were arresting people for breaking lockdown rules

Which basically meant sitting on a bench, whish isn't actually breaking any laws. Lockdown rules aren't the law. Breaking rules isn't an arrestable offence as far as I know.

noodlezoodle · 08/02/2021 22:24

@Sadsiblingatsea

Lots of what you call ‘conspiracy theories’ are already here, OP. I never thought getting a job or being able to travel would be made dependent on having an untested medical treatment. Or that police officers would be arresting pensioners for sitting on benches or taking away quite basic freedoms. Try not to be so narrow minded.
Except that none of these things have actually happened as you describe them, have they?

The vaccine is very far from untested, and getting a job or travelling do not require a vaccine passport because vaccine passports aren't a thing.

Police officers were not arresting people for sitting on benches, they were arresting people for breaking lockdown rules.

LunaHeather · 08/02/2021 22:12

@Loustew12

Genuine question. Where do I go to see these wide range of views and critical thinkers? I've been crying out for open debate, either on TV, radio, newspapers. But it seems during covid we are not allowed to question the government approach whatever that happens to be? Do you think that, in itself, has caused people to dig deeper? And some have just gone too far?
Ironically, Lou, I am supposed to be limiting my time online and I've gone over it which is too far 😂

But yes, the views are being hidden and OFCOM rules are linked to that.

Doctors and scientists with anti lockdown views are discredited, as are those wishing to try older, cheaper medical treatments. I try to avoid MSM since I realised but AFAIK even the Great Barrington Declaration was smeared and removed from search engines. It may be back now, .i don't know. I think some search engines and big sites played silly buggers with articles about Ivermectin too. TalkRadio was removed from YouTube for a while, I can't recall what excuse was given but it was flagged up because of freely exploring anti lockdown sentiment.

Dr Malcolm Kendrick wrote a couple of excellent medical books - c2015 I think? - explaining how stats are so badly abused and saying "god help us if the modellers get their hands on medical policy".

Now I think he doesn't get published.

Michael Levitt, Nobel Prize winner - anti lockdown, largely ignored. Well, you don't need me to list the doctors and scientists who are anti lockdown, there's loads.

I've been off news for months now. Mum is a very pro establishment, trust the government person and even she is thinking this is the most controlled regime she's ever seen.

For me, watching the history of yesterday being rewritten daily does mean I question a lot of things. This pre-dates 2020.

There are so many utterly ludicrous things going on in the world, there's bound to be a different limitation for each of us in what we believe. But the crazy we see in the real world is real crazy- it's not been made up online. You might see it at work or in your child's school curriculum.

LunaHeather · 08/02/2021 21:49

[quote Standrewsschool]@lunaheather what codes?

I’ve seen stuff on Facebook about the manga carta 61, and the government have no right to govern etc[/quote]
About beliefs including racism

It needs the context of his explanation so I won't attempt to explain as it would be dreadful to get it wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread