Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be utterly shocked and heartbroken at how many intelligent, lovely friends and acquaintances have totally bought in to the radical global conspiracy theories...

393 replies

fuschia2000 · 07/02/2021 18:58

Seeing so much conspiracy stuff on Facebook threads, its totally alarming.... the folks can really make a good argument, with pseudo science, lots of data etc but we are looking at radical q'anon right wing conspiracy theories breaking through into the normal discussion groups and online groups.....

OP posts:
lightand · 08/02/2021 11:01

BG talks about lowering population, "if we do a really great job" by vaccine, health measures and now I have listened to it again, reproduction. Which could be where the fertility thing has originated from too. In the context of CO2.

AStudyinPink · 08/02/2021 10:59

I do think we neglected to properly protect vulnerable people when the internet was unleashed (don’t know how we could have done this, though).

There was no way, unless we’re happy to have a Bureau of Information - a Government body that tells us what is true. I’m not.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 08/02/2021 10:39

I do think we neglected to properly protect vulnerable people when the internet was unleashed (don’t know how we could have done this, though).

It was a landscape rife for misinformation and as someone said upthread, it coincided with lots of social changes: globalisalisation, accession of former Eastern bloc, Labours agenda on education and I think it left people desperately looking for some narrative to hold all these disparate ‘facts’ appearing online together. We don’t study history, etc this way - we contextualise everything. I think a lot of people were really scared, felt under pressure and opportunists filled a need that society had previously provided.

shouldreallynamechangemore · 08/02/2021 10:29

@LolaSmiles

DedlyMedally My anti conspiracy theory comes from the fact that those clinging to conspiracy theories are unusually obsessed with the idea of them being more intelligent, more enlightened, more knowledgeable, more free thinking etc than everyone else on the planet (who are obviously government loving sheeple who believe the government would never do anything wrong).

Meanwhile in the real world there's actually a good range of views and debate across the spectrum, and a lot of questions, and a lot of critical thinking.

This!!
shouldreallynamechangemore · 08/02/2021 10:28

@Helmetbymidnight

Jon Ronson gives an account of a young girl who lost a leg in the London bombings getting harassed by conspiracy theorists who thought the whole thing was a hoax and she was a MI5 operative. She eventually met with them and they still made her life hell. It's in his book The Psychopath Test. Something about this stuff makes people lose decency and empathy.

What about the people who claim Sandy Hook was fake. The hell they put the parents through is just off the scale.

If I recall there is quite a lot on this too. Really shocking. I can't remember why it is in a book on psychopathy. Think it is to do with the correlation between trolling and psycopathy. Not that everyone who believes this stuff is a psychopath but more vulnerable people get drawn in.
Helmetbymidnight · 08/02/2021 10:23

environmentalists talk about population growth all the time - are they all guilty too?- this is a clip of Bill Gates talking in passing about population growth while discussing C02 levels.

Why would it be taken down?

If this clip is being used as evidence 'to deduce' that Bill Gates started or wants Covid, or that he wants to use a microchip, blah blah, then these people are clearly struggling intellectually. I would imagine they've never listened to a lecture about anything in their life.

SpringIsComingAlways · 08/02/2021 10:21

I think the conspiracy theorists that claim Sandy Hook was made up and troll parents of students that died saying they are all actors need locking up. Seriously sick or evil doing that.

catspider · 08/02/2021 10:19

Funny how when it's coming from the "right" it's a conspiracy theory to be mocked but when it's coming from the "left" it's absolutely true and must be believed beyond doubt.

Triffid1 · 08/02/2021 10:18

@LolaSmiles

It's depressing OP.

What's really depressing is that people seem to genuinely believe things like 'I'm called a conspiracy theorist just for asking a question and not thinking Boris is amazing'
It strikes me as a weird worldview to genuinely believe that nobody else (other than your chosen group of enlightened peers) asks questions, or criticises the government, or is a critical thinker.
The arrogance is astounding as they seem to sincerely believe that they're so much more intelligent and free thinking than everyone else on the planet.

Yes, this.

DH has a "friend" who pops up on his facebook post and his tone and attitude are so frustrating.

tormentil · 08/02/2021 10:16

@CuntAmongstThePigeons

I'm going to get told off for dragging this in, but.... I do think this thirst for non scientific ideas, for things which can't be proven but sound quite helpful being pushed into the mainstream affects this, and also that when you stop trusting mainstream sources for factual information it probably opens up the chance of you trusting non reliable sources for information.

For example, when the BBC is pushing unscientific ideas like being born in the wrong body. Gender not sex. It kind of makes me and I'm sure others think well if the BBC can't be trusted on this what else can't they be trusted on. It also means you look for other sources. I think people not trusting the mainstream press to tell the truth is dangerous.

If you scan the BBC with a critical eye on a daily basis it is possible to see that the BBC is not neutral. And when you have independent knowledge of a situation and see the same situation reported with an obvious and either inaccurate or exaggerated slant, then you can legitimately question anything else that the BBC have written.
Helmetbymidnight · 08/02/2021 10:16

I haven't heard of people say they are "anti-conspiracy theory" as such but I would assume it means they look at properly sourced evidence, sound facts and figures and verifiable analysis - rather than believing some dropped out philosophy student calling himself a medical doctor on Youtube.
I certainly wouldn't think its the idea that governments have never colluded to manipulate or deceive their "subjects"? or every single time it's been figured out?
Most thinking people DO know that Govts have and do behave atrociously - and that there are mysteries and unresolved stories - I mean, that's obvious.

lightand · 08/02/2021 10:12

@Helmetbymidnight.
The one minute clip is part of a presentation. Not sure if I could find the rest of the presentation or not. Up to other people to find the rest.
I couldnt say that the clip sounds like a joke, but up to others how they see it. But I think we can all see how some people might deduce things about him, and what he may want, from that clip.
I am surprised it was never taken down tbh. But presumably because not that many people took too much notice of it, back then? And now, it has been seen by countless numbers of people so no point?

Easy to see though, how rumours, whether true or not, start, and snowball, and dont go away.

LolaSmiles · 08/02/2021 10:10

DedlyMedally
My anti conspiracy theory comes from the fact that those clinging to conspiracy theories are unusually obsessed with the idea of them being more intelligent, more enlightened, more knowledgeable, more free thinking etc than everyone else on the planet (who are obviously government loving sheeple who believe the government would never do anything wrong).

Meanwhile in the real world there's actually a good range of views and debate across the spectrum, and a lot of questions, and a lot of critical thinking.

DedlyMedally · 08/02/2021 10:06

I don't really get the idea of being anti "conspiracy theory".
Is the idea that governments have never colluded to manipulate or deceive their "subjects"?
Or is it just the idea that they have, but every single time it's been figured out?

Helmetbymidnight · 08/02/2021 10:05

Yes, yes, yes, LolaSmiles. Exactly.

LolaSmiles · 08/02/2021 10:03

It's depressing OP.

What's really depressing is that people seem to genuinely believe things like 'I'm called a conspiracy theorist just for asking a question and not thinking Boris is amazing'
It strikes me as a weird worldview to genuinely believe that nobody else (other than your chosen group of enlightened peers) asks questions, or criticises the government, or is a critical thinker.
The arrogance is astounding as they seem to sincerely believe that they're so much more intelligent and free thinking than everyone else on the planet.

tormentil · 08/02/2021 09:59

@mymadpuppy

ChestnutStuffing All based on the idea "you'll have nothing and be happy" hmm like to see how they'd implement that.
Increase taxes, increase utility prices, withdraw services...
TakeTheCuntOutOfScunthorpe · 08/02/2021 09:55

I blame Tony Blair and Dubya.

Their governments were the point where spin and presentation became more important than facts. Before them, governments were dishonest scum, but everyone knew that. But Blair and Bush took things to a new level, where things were no longer true just because you could see or feel them, the "truth" was what they told you it was.

The media subsequently bought into this way of thinking too - if you can't beat 'em, join 'em. Watch CNN, Fox News, RT, Al Jazeera, France 24, BBC News - all biased in their own ways. All promoting opinion as fact, even when it is blatantly untrue.

It's no surprise that given our politicians lie to us and mainstream news providers lie to us - and lie so obviously - people seek truth elsewhere. Regardless of where you are on the political spectrum, I doubt you could watch an hour of CNN then an hour of RT and fully trust everything that was said on both as factual and impartial.

It's long been said that history was written by the winners. The present is written by those striving to be the winners - in a century people will look back on whatever version prevailed.

Helmetbymidnight · 08/02/2021 09:50

Jon Ronson gives an account of a young girl who lost a leg in the London bombings getting harassed by conspiracy theorists who thought the whole thing was a hoax and she was a MI5 operative. She eventually met with them and they still made her life hell. It's in his book The Psychopath Test. Something about this stuff makes people lose decency and empathy.

What about the people who claim Sandy Hook was fake. The hell they put the parents through is just off the scale.

Helmetbymidnight · 08/02/2021 09:49

I haven't seen it.

This is one minute clip about lowering CO2 where Bill Gates makes a joke about population figures and says that the potential exponential population growth the world is heading for might be held back with vaccines and reproductive health care.

And people have decided to try and convict him of spreading Covid and microchipping people on the basis of that?
A perfect illustration of how conspiracy theorists are absolute spanners.

dottiedodah · 08/02/2021 09:48

We have this exact thing! Our dear friends overseas are convinced we are being kept in the dark .No idea why so many people (including my Cousin who is a Doctor ) were /are in Hospital then! Rather awkward as I dont want to fall out ,but cannot agree !

LimitIsUp · 08/02/2021 09:44

None of my friends are posting this kind of nonsense (I am quite selective in the company I keep)

shouldreallynamechangemore · 08/02/2021 09:43

@Nomorepies

" Heartbroken" feels like slight overkill. People will always believe what they want to, you can't change it. Just choose to let it wash over you or associate with others.
It changes their behaviour, it affects how they relate to you, it changes your relationship. You lose the person they were. Just like a cult. It is heartbreaking.
ElephantsNest · 08/02/2021 09:43

@wonkylegs

I am related to a Covid denier anti vaccine anti mainstream medicine person. It has caused many many issues. I cannot cut off contact as we have shared responsibility for another relative and their beliefs have become a battle ground. I am told that I may believe that Covid exists but it's just my belief not a fact and that my beliefs are incorrect. For perspective and to understand why I am quite so upset I will just say now my DH is a senior dr who has been working on Covid wards. He has had colleagues become ill and die. These are facts not plucked from the news or the internet but from direct experience however according to my family member it's is just what I 'choose to believe'.
Sending empathy, that sounds so draining Flowers
shouldreallynamechangemore · 08/02/2021 09:40

@ElephantsNest

I encounter conspiracy people in real life, getting off social media is not an escape for some of us!

My loved one one was in hospital with COVID, three weeks of this on a ventilator and now I have had to arrange carers for them which they will need for the rest of their life. They will never live independently again because the virus caused life changing injuries to their heart and brain. It has been a stressful and upsetting time.

I had one so called friend tell me to my face (despite knowing all I had been through), that the virus was not real, and I’m being a sheep to wear a mask or bother with social distancing. It’s all a conspiracy apparently..

I am so sorry.

Jon Ronson gives an account of a young girl who lost a leg in the London bombings getting harassed by conspiracy theorists who thought the whole thing was a hoax and she was a MI5 operative. She eventually met with them and they still made her life hell. It's in his book The Psychopath Test. Something about this stuff makes people lose decency and empathy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread