Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Jackie Weaver is a hero to feminism?

591 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 06/02/2021 22:28

Because I refuse to believe that those appalling men would have spoken to another man the way they attempted to shout her down. She handled herself so beautifully.

Frankly I think she deserves to be Dame Jackie Weaver for services to common sense!

OP posts:
Roussette · 08/02/2021 11:01

Well, even the BBC are letting him explain his side of the story

I just hope that the irresponsible MSM journalism that allowed this story to run unchecked and caused these men to get mocked as far as USA and Australia are held accountable for it and think about what they do next time

Make your mind up Truly. Are the MSM behaving irresponsibly or not? You can't have it both ways.

I don't agree with anyone being mocked on national and international TV for getting frazzled, unsettled or shouting, no

Hahaha. Now that is funny. That's most of media reporting on people gone then. Do you actually read what's out there?

'Getting frazzled' my arse. Until you can accept that those horrible men behaved awfully, there is no hope for you.

Are you saying that it's OK to behave like this in a meeting? Obviously you are.

By the way, you cannot stop something going national or international. That's the nature of the beast. You are sounding remarkably ignorant naive, honest you are.

I tweeted a reply to something awful that Katie Hopkins said once on Twitter. Oh my god... it was unbelievable... thousands and thousands of likes and retweets in UK and US. I was delighted actually because what she said was so vile. Now tell me how I could have stopped that going 'international'?

Truly shall I tell you what makes me cross. Posters who purposely do not read all the research handed to you, the measured posts explaining the situation, the ignoring of certain questions. That is what you are doing. You are cherry picking little bits here and there to suit your agenda.

Marinaloves · 08/02/2021 10:19

Eh? They mocked themselves
No one is mocking them, they’re just watching a video of them making twats of themselves - they don’t need any help in the mocking department.

Seriously @trulydelicious

trulydelicious · 08/02/2021 10:03

@JaimeLeeCurtains

derailing

You think expressing a different point of view is derailing? Speaking of bullying!

dontdisturbmenow · 08/02/2021 10:01

Are you aware that women were excluded from the professions because they were female and therefore believed to be emotionally, mentally and physically incapable of this?
That still doesn't make her a feminist hero. I've been spoken like this at work too. I responded as I was trained to, adhering to the remit if my role and keeping my calm. Like she did. She did her job well from that perspective. End of.

Arobase · 08/02/2021 10:00

I don't agree with anyone being mocked on national and international TV for getting frazzled, unsettled or shouting, no. Do you?

Given that there was absolutely nothing that had happened that justified them getting like that (apart from the fact that they were incredulous that they couldn't get their own way and continue sabotaging the meeting), and that they knew the meeting was being recorded and would be published, I would say that if they couldn't exercise a basic degree of self-control they should have removed themselves. If you are going to behave appallingly, you have to take the consequences, whether it's the people who were at the meeting despising you or thousands of people elsewhere laughing at you.

HenriettaHeffalump · 08/02/2021 10:00

I take criticism wonderfully! But do not attempt to do a wide eyed act with me...mate Smile

JaimeLeeCurtains · 08/02/2021 10:00

It's probably best to let @MNHQ deal with the derailing and reports re the thread now?

trulydelicious · 08/02/2021 09:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Arobase · 08/02/2021 09:55

I don't believe there is any requirement of these Men to explain themselves.. the footage speaks for itself

It doesn't, that's the problem. Please read my post to hannayeah

The footage does speak for itself, because with absolutely no knowledge of the background anyone can see that Tolver and Brewerton were trying to stop the meeting from happening and that Weaver was doing her job and making it happen. She was also exercising considerable self-control in the face of what was, on any interpretation, appalling behaviour from them. Brewerton shouting incredibly rudely in the background at some unfortunate person out of camera range is perhaps the lowest point. I suppose that, yet again, asking this question is hopeless, but do you really think their behaviour was acceptable in any context, let alone a public meeting?

As I say, all of this is self evident. Additionally, virtually every report I have seen explains the basic background of why Jackie Weaver was there - i.e. because of complaints about the behaviour of certain councillors in Handforth and their attempts to prevent meetings being held, including unlawfully getting rid of the usual clerk. So the publicity that you complain about so virulently properly puts it all in context. Is that why you complain about the publicity so much - because it gives you no scope for exonerating your heroes?

HenriettaHeffalump · 08/02/2021 09:53

🥺🥺🥺🥺

Why is everyone so mean to the nice men? Ugh do one. My patience with your crap has reached its limit as you may be able to tell.

trulydelicious · 08/02/2021 09:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

trulydelicious · 08/02/2021 09:51

@Arobase

Does it ever occur to you for a moment that what caused these men to get mocked is their behaviour

I don't agree with anyone being mocked on national and international TV for getting frazzled, unsettled or shouting, no. Do you?

growinggreyer · 08/02/2021 09:50

@dontdisturbmenow

She dealt with it professionally and with confidence. No it doesn't make her a hero to feminism.
Are you aware that women were excluded from the professions because they were female and therefore believed to be emotionally, mentally and physically incapable of this? Women have had to fight for their place at the table and every woman who does this with grace under pressure is a hero to feminism.
HenriettaHeffalump · 08/02/2021 09:50

[quote trulydelicious]@HenriettaHeffalump

I've reported you as well

Why have you reported me? I'm genuine and I have explained what worries me here - or does everyone have to agree with you and if not they are a troll?[/quote]
It isn't that you disagree with me. Do not attempt to do a wide eyed act with me mate. You know exactly what you are doing...or you don't and then I feel sorry for you.

HenriettaHeffalump · 08/02/2021 09:49

@Arobase

Well, even the BBC are letting him explain his side of the story, so I don't know how it can be so clear to everyone who is in the wrong here

Because, for the reasons I set out above, it is perfectly clear that having been given that opportunity he is, shall we say, economising to a rather major extent with the facts. His own conduct demonstrates that. But, yet again, @trulydelicious, you choose to ignore posts you find inconvenient because you can't answer them.,

Yep! Behaving as a nasty troll who doesn't like women aren't they? Not saying that's what they are you understand, but the behaviour is similar to those who are like that, you know?
trulydelicious · 08/02/2021 09:48

@HenriettaHeffalump

I've reported you as well

Why have you reported me? I'm genuine and I have explained what worries me here - or does everyone have to agree with you and if not they are a troll?

Arobase · 08/02/2021 09:46

Well, even the BBC are letting him explain his side of the story, so I don't know how it can be so clear to everyone who is in the wrong here

Because, for the reasons I set out above, it is perfectly clear that having been given that opportunity he is, shall we say, economising to a rather major extent with the facts. His own conduct demonstrates that. But, yet again, @trulydelicious, you choose to ignore posts you find inconvenient because you can't answer them.,

dontdisturbmenow · 08/02/2021 09:43

She dealt with it professionally and with confidence. No it doesn't make her a hero to feminism.

Marinaloves · 08/02/2021 09:41

Wow thanks for the updates for all those people that can be bothered to read all the minutes etc
what is Tolver trying to hide?!
Why did they sack the clerk ?!

HenriettaHeffalump · 08/02/2021 09:41

[quote trulydelicious]@BlueThistles

I don't believe there is any requirement of these Men to explain themselves.. the footage speaks for itself

It doesn't, that's the problem. Please read my post to hannayeah[/quote]
Why on earth should anyone read your posts? You clearly aren't reading anyone else's. You have moaned on and on in this thread, completely ignoring the information which has been handed to you on a plate, responding with articles which contain minimal information and which most people have read and then some! I've reported you as well, as I cannot believe you are genuinely this thick headed.

borntobequiet · 08/02/2021 09:40

I also don't think that Jackie Weaver is a 'feminist hero' (this issue has nothing to do with misogyny - as you have explained) or that someone is automatically in the right just for staying calm and pushing a button.

Though I suspect the men in question are likely to be misogynists, I agree that they are probably non-discriminatory in their bullying behaviour and would bully men and women alike if so inclined.
However, Jackie can be termed a feminist hero - though I wouldn’t use the term myself, it’s a bit hackneyed - for, as a woman, standing up to bullying, out of control men- which they were. Their behaviour and language were downright frightening.
On the second point, no one has suggested that Jackie was “automatically in the right” for those reasons. People have gone to great lengths to explain the context and back story that explain why she was in the right. I’m puzzled as to why this seems to have escaped you.

Arobase · 08/02/2021 09:38

Watching the video, Mr. Tolver started to become frazzled when he was trying to establish some ground rules at the start of the meeting and no one was taking any notice. He is offering an explanation but everyone instantly believes what Ms. Weaver is saying, why?

He wasn't trying to establish ground rules; after all, they're perfectly well established and are presumably followed at every meeting. People were asking reasonable questions which he wasn't even bothering to answer. The reality is that he didn't want this meeting to be called, was really angry that he'd failed to prevent it, and was doing his best to sabotage it. Watch the other videos. He behaves like that all the time.

I just hope that the irresponsible MSM journalism that allowed this story to run unchecked and caused these men to get mocked as far as USA and Australia are held accountable for it and think about what they do next time

Does it ever occur to you for a moment that what caused these men to get mocked is their behaviour.? If not, why not? Why do you imagine all the other utterly boring council meetings where everyone behaves properly don't go viral?

trulydelicious · 08/02/2021 09:25

@BlueThistles

I don't believe there is any requirement of these Men to explain themselves.. the footage speaks for itself

It doesn't, that's the problem. Please read my post to hannayeah

trulydelicious · 08/02/2021 09:21

@hannayeah

Thank you for providing this detail. Obviously if there is anything unlawful going on, it should be sorted out and it appears that it will.

I still think it's irresponsible from mainstream media to make this 'a story' - do you think journalists have gone to the trouble to read all the meeting minutes- as you have- before publicly condemning and subjecting these men to endless mockery? I doubt it. And once the damage is done, there's no going back.

I also don't think that Jackie Weaver is a 'feminist hero' (this issue has nothing to do with misogyny - as you have explained) or that someone is automatically in the right just for staying calm and pushing a button.

My last two points is what actually shocks me about this thread/incident

Helendee · 08/02/2021 09:10

They were all awful in my opinion.