Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Jackie Weaver is a hero to feminism?

591 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 06/02/2021 22:28

Because I refuse to believe that those appalling men would have spoken to another man the way they attempted to shout her down. She handled herself so beautifully.

Frankly I think she deserves to be Dame Jackie Weaver for services to common sense!

OP posts:
Arobase · 07/02/2021 09:09

But Jackie is only a clerk- whose role it is to take minutes- and she didn't have the authority to cut people out of the meeting, whatever anyone says

Not sure how it works, but could she have had authority beforehand from the people who called the meeting?

In any event, what she did was authorised after the event by the vote not to let the idiots back in.

notsosmoothie · 07/02/2021 09:09

she needed to have told the councillors beforehand that she was there in a support role only, tell them the boundaries of what she could and could not do in the actual meeting, and not overstep her role in the actual meeting

Did she? In order to not be yelled at, insulted and told to shut up?

I think not.

HenriettaHeffalump · 07/02/2021 09:02

"She is not the proper officer!!" say a small minority on Mumsnet 🤭. How embarrassing.

Jackie for PM! She is my hero. Those men were definitely trying to bully her. They are used to being in charge, (one actually kept yelling "I'm in charge" Blush), and become aggressive when they realised they were no longer in charge. Classic.

picklemewalnuts · 07/02/2021 09:01

I'd be in favour of all meetings being held by zoom in future. The ability to eject arseholes so effectively without needing to call the police is a major bonus. I've been subjected to some appalling chest beating behaviour in the past. And like Jackie Weaver, was accused of bullying on one occasion after having to stand up to it to allow the meeting to continue.

In the long run, it does the electorate no favours. Councils like this cannot get clerks to work for them, and then achieve nothing for the residents.

It is however not entirely an issue of sexism. They were as badly behaved to the previous, male, clerk. This is fairly sex neutral toxic entitlement, bullying everyone who doesn't agree with them.

Re the 'not attending a meeting because one hasn't been called' issue...

If a Cllr doesn't attend for 6 months, AND THE COUNCIL HASNT GIVEN THEM DISPENSATION, they automatically lose their seat.

In this case, a Cllr hadn't attended for five months, then Covid happened meaning the sixth month meeting didn't happen. So that is quite an odd situation to decide on, and could easily be strongly debated.

However this council didn't seem to be holding any virtual meetings. I'm not sure whether business was being done without full scrutiny by councillors and electorate- email decisions- or whether business wasn't being done. They would have been warned they 'must' get meetings organised.

Whenwillow · 07/02/2021 08:57

I think she was fabulous. Just a calm 'nope'.
Jackie for PM!

lightand · 07/02/2021 08:55

[quote rwalker]@AStudyinPink
But isn’t the role of the clerk to ensure the business of the council is conducted properly? How is screaming at people in any way ‘proper’? How can a meeting happen like that?

I fully get your point but when your in charge even if people are being arseholes you mange and defuse the situation not make it worse.

When dealing with conflict the first thing you do is listen let them get there point across then deal .
I'm not defending them but some of the things she did was just pouring petrol on the fire .[/quote]
I agree.

It wasnt a blueprint in how to conduct meetings at all

A nice bit of theatre for the general public to see, but she needed to have told the councillors beforehand that she was there in a support role only, tell them the boundaries of what she could and could not do in the actual meeting, and not overstep her role in the actual meeting.

speaksofty · 07/02/2021 08:53

Men were hideously behaved, good for her for kicking him out!

augustusglupe · 07/02/2021 08:45

I've watched it a few times, it's hilarious and also brilliant the way she stays so calm.
READ THEM AND UNDERSTAND THEM bloke looks so pathetic the way he keeps bobbing into view...I'M IN CHARGE Grin
I'm sure he's a joy to live with...

HenriettaHeffalump · 07/02/2021 08:45

[quote lotusbell]@HenriettaHeffalump, glad someone else thought that, made me chuckle. However this guy was really quite vicious in his tone of voice.[/quote]
What the Withnail and I thing?

Yes, that rancid little shit, Aled, sounded like a rabid dog when he went off. I really hope there are some repercussions. Anyone defending these people...seriously Hmm?

I stand with Jackie Weaver aka Britney Spears.

lotusbell · 07/02/2021 08:41

@HenriettaHeffalump, glad someone else thought that, made me chuckle. However this guy was really quite vicious in his tone of voice.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 07/02/2021 08:38

The man on Alex’s iPad needs some anger management lessons. If this wasn’t on zoom then Jackie would have been in some village hall with these nasty men. Aled is a nasty piece of work.

Eleganz · 07/02/2021 08:38

Should add that the action of the new chair to continue to exclude the disruptive individuals is totally in line with the standing orders that were so forcefully demanded to be read and understood.

Eleganz · 07/02/2021 08:37

It is interesting that there are some reactionaries who think the big story here is a council officer ejecting elected councillors from a meeting. The important point to remember is that given neither the council's chair or vice-chair actually formally started the meeting and instead behaved like disruptive dickheads, it was, legally, at that point just a bunch of people of zoom. Once they were ejected a new chair was formally elected for the meeting and they meeting was formally opened. That chair agreed that the disruptive individuals not be allowed into the formal meeting unless they gave assurances that they would behave, which they didn't.

Jackie did exactly the right thing in order to ensure that the business of the committee could be conducted in an orderly fashion. Which is far more important for democracy than allowing a small group of councillors to continue to hold the whole council to ransom and prevent it from doing any business.

HeronLanyon · 07/02/2021 08:31

Good work parker 👍

Parker231 · 07/02/2021 08:29

Extract from a local newspaper article.

I have subsequently submitted a Freedom of Information request to Cheshire East council, which has been accepted and the response is due by 17th February 2021.

I have received confirmation today that an investigation into the conduct and behaviour of Handforth Parish Council is being carried out by Cheshire East Council's Committee for Standards. The investigation started in July 2020 and is expected to be completed in the next 3 to 4 weeks.

Apparently, three councillors, Brian Tolver, Aled Brewerton and Barry Burkhill tried to suspend the clerk Ashley Comiskey Dawson at an employment committee meeting held on November 4th last year. However, he was reinstated at a meeting in January as this was a decision which could only be made by the full Parish Council.

Jackie Weaver is the Chief Officer of the Cheshire Association of Local Council and she had been asked to step in and support Handforth Parish Council in light of the complaints and investigation into them.

HeronLanyon · 07/02/2021 08:28
This is the prequel meeting (or sequel using stars wars terminology). They go straight from this meeting into the infamous meeting.
HeronLanyon · 07/02/2021 08:24

Yes the planning sub committee meeting (which immediately precedes the infamous meeting) is on you tube. Will see if I can find the link.

DinkyDaisy · 07/02/2021 08:22

Is there a video of the meeting just before the viral one?
The one Brian Tolver refers to right at the beginning?
Seems there is, but I can't find it! Watched January...

MyKingdomForACaramel · 07/02/2021 08:19

The last paragraph of this report tells me exactly what type of people they are. “I suggest you keep very quiet as we are lawyers”. Hmm
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/jackie-weaver-handforth-parish-council-latest-b1798444.html?amp

rwalker · 07/02/2021 08:16

@AStudyinPink
I don’t think so. Those men were hostile from the off and disrupting the legitimate business of the meeting. I would need to see the whole context to know whether they had reason to be angry, but their conduct was a disgrace.

I 100% agree with you about the 2 men ,but talking over people, interrupting people ,not letting them get there point across (no matter how wrong) and being defensive will not deescalate conflict.

It was her role to deescalate it I honestly don't think she made any attempt to do that.

CaveMum · 07/02/2021 08:09

There’s a parody Twitter account which is, amongst dropping hints that various council members are major crime lords, putting up suggestions for who should play who in the Netflix version of the meeting Wink

Handle is @TheJackieWeaver

skodadoda · 07/02/2021 08:08

@CrisisManagement

The next meeting:

Jackie takes a back seat and barely features. Not quite as fun as the first and they seem to have the technology sorted a bit more now. They still all have their cameras scarily close to the top half of their heads though.

I have a theory that Cyn and Sue don't like each other...

For those who can manage to sit through this, it shows very clearly what has been going on in the parish council.
AStudyinPink · 07/02/2021 08:00
  • When dealing with conflict the first thing you do is listen let them get there point across then deal . I'm not defending them but some of the things she did was just pouring petrol on the fire .*

I don’t think so. Those men were hostile from the off and disrupting the legitimate business of the meeting. I would need to see the whole context to know whether they had reason to be angry, but their conduct was a disgrace.

rwalker · 07/02/2021 07:51

@AStudyinPink
But isn’t the role of the clerk to ensure the business of the council is conducted properly? How is screaming at people in any way ‘proper’? How can a meeting happen like that?

I fully get your point but when your in charge even if people are being arseholes you mange and defuse the situation not make it worse.

When dealing with conflict the first thing you do is listen let them get there point across then deal .
I'm not defending them but some of the things she did was just pouring petrol on the fire .

WizardOfAus · 07/02/2021 07:51

Unbelievably, Sarah Vine in the Daily Mail has the best description of Jackie and the idiots she had to deal with.

Women such as Jackie are the sanity and the backbone of this country. They may not be as glamorous or as well groomed as the ones who sit on boards or bear fancy titles or hold the ears of Ministers. But in some ways that makes them all the more impressive. Because they do what they do not out of ambition or desire for recognition (just as well, really, since rarely is any forthcoming), but out of a genuine sense of moral duty.

Make no mistake: it’s not the Brian Tolvers or Aled Brewertons of this world who get things done. They’re not the ones who get the lock fixed on the disabled toilets in the Town Hall, or who make sure Mrs Featherington gets a lift to her hospital appointment. Oh no, such petty irrelevancies are not for them. They’re far too busy wafting around on an over-inflated balloon of their own pomposity, reminding everyone how important and in-charge they are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread