Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Jackie Weaver is a hero to feminism?

591 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 06/02/2021 22:28

Because I refuse to believe that those appalling men would have spoken to another man the way they attempted to shout her down. She handled herself so beautifully.

Frankly I think she deserves to be Dame Jackie Weaver for services to common sense!

OP posts:
CrisisManagement · 07/02/2021 11:11

[quote WestendVBroadway]@CrisisManagement PP are saying the others would not have spoken to her like that if she were a man, true however if she were a man and the others were women I think you may all have a different opinion.[/quote]
Nope. But why are we even having this hypothetical conversation?

I don't understand why anyone would attempt to twist themselves in knots to defend these men. They behaved unprofessionally and appallingly. Jackie kept calm and managed to continue with the business at hand in the face of some pretty fucking unhinged behaviour.

In case no one has ever told you this, you do not need to tolerate anyone speaking to you like these men did. Ever. Not in the workplace and not in the home.

frumpety · 07/02/2021 11:09

@trulydelicious

I don't get it frankly.

And yet here you are, discussing it. Smile

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 07/02/2021 11:08

This is the article that Parker was talking about - lots of info in there! www.alderleyedge.com/news/article/21225/handforth-parish-council-are-not-fit-for-purpose

Dailyhandtowelwash · 07/02/2021 11:07

[quote WestendVBroadway]@CrisisManagement PP are saying the others would not have spoken to her like that if she were a man, true however if she were a man and the others were women I think you may all have a different opinion.[/quote]
But that didn’t happen, did it? And that isn’t what is happening in business/local politics/national politics/households everywhere. You get some bullying women in every sphere, but there is no widespread existence of overbearing, bullying, aggressive women dominating meetings and decisions.

Dailyhandtowelwash · 07/02/2021 11:05

It started going viral because it looks like a British comedy of manners. But now it’s sparking conversation about bullying and misogyny and local government corruption and representation - all amongst a population bored to tears by being locked in their houses for months. I don’t see any need for a conspiracy theory.

@Eleganz I’ve enjoyed your posts very much pointing out the facts behind it all. As a fellow (I assume) governance person I totally agree. JW was there, as a senior ALC person, to ensure that the meeting, which has been lawfully called, took place - she was the one ensuring that people were represented. She was there as the bastion of democracy! It was the Chair and his associates who were trying to disrupt it, and she excluded them before the meeting began, as none of them were prepared to recognise the legitimacy of it. Given that this was the second meeting in a row, I imagine she already knew that there was no value in reasoning, and as most of us have only seen an abridged version of events, we’re probably not best places to judge her efforts in any case.

Good clerking means ensuring that the council/committee/whatever gets its work done within the rules. The Speaker of the Commons for example is advised throughout every sitting by the Commons Clerks; they’re not just there to keep the minutes. When the Speaker chucks an MP out of the Chamber for breaking the rules, it’s often on the advice of the Clerk.

Roussette · 07/02/2021 11:04

But I struggle to understand how this is newsworthy

I presume you've had a humour bypass...
It was funny and horrifying all together.

And anyone doubting Jackie (GO JACKIE!) must think it's OK for nasty woman hating men to harangue and shout at women.

There is nothing strange whatsoever about it going viral. Surely those doubting it have seen the strangest things taking off and going viral for no reason whatsoever.

All hail to Jackie Weaver for using every single interview yesterday to talk about people joining parish councils and having a voice. And to say how the bullying and behaviour like this has to stop.

Anyone doubting this, needs to see the previous meetings (I have) and look into one of the male families on there. Bullies. Plain and simple.

This video needed to be seen. I know men like this. They just cannot stand a woman having the final word.

Eleganz · 07/02/2021 11:04

[quote trulydelicious]@Eleganz

them doing their usual lazy journalism of reactive reporting on things that go viral on social media to fill time and column inches

This is more like it. But I don't get why some here try to overengineer the incident and give her a 'national feminist hero' status[/quote]
Because that is their opinion of her actions.

Sadly there are committee and board meetings throughout the country that are dominated by rude, unprincipled and unprofessional men. That is why this has struck a chord.

Charlottie01 · 07/02/2021 11:02

I loved how calm, mature and confident she handled herself, as she said " Appalling behaviour !"
She didn't take it personally or to heart she stood her ground

WestendVBroadway · 07/02/2021 11:02

@CrisisManagement PP are saying the others would not have spoken to her like that if she were a man, true however if she were a man and the others were women I think you may all have a different opinion.

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 11:01

@Eleganz

them doing their usual lazy journalism of reactive reporting on things that go viral on social media to fill time and column inches

This is more like it. But I don't get why some here try to overengineer the incident and give her a 'national feminist hero' status

Seatime · 07/02/2021 10:59

Jackie Weaver for prime minister! She would sort out the Eaton mess.

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 10:58

@frumpety

It is a human interest story

Like a puppy jumping on Youtube that goes viral with 10M views you mean?

I don't get it frankly. Let alone the 'feminist hero' bit

Eleganz · 07/02/2021 10:58

[quote trulydelicious]@HenriettaHeffalump

Sorry, I thought it was all made up

I'm not saying it was all made up.

But I struggle to understand how this is newsworthy.

What is the media trying to achieve here?[/quote]
The media are reporting it because to has gone viral (I.e. it has been demonstrated to be of public interest). It went viral because of a politics student who looks at these videos pushing it out on Twitter and other platforms because it is hilarious.

You seem to be suggesting that the media proactively decided to make massive news out of a rancorous parish council meeting from Cheshire for some nefarious purposes and expect us to accept this is more plausible than them doing their usual lazy journalism of reactive reporting on things that go viral on social media to fill time and column inches on something other than brexit and Covid.

borntobequiet · 07/02/2021 10:57

[quote trulydelicious]@LApprentiSorcier

A politics student who watches local council meetings as a pastime

That's what I mean. It's implausible. Something smells off here[/quote]
A politics student who is actually interested in politics? Unheard of. Soon they’ll be expecting history students to be interested in history, physics students interested in physics, watch YouTube videos on these subjects, what is the world coming to...

frumpety · 07/02/2021 10:56

trulydelicious, the power of social media, so lots and lots of people see it, share it and discuss it, therefore it becomes newsworthy and the MSM takes it on. It is a human interest story.

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 10:55

@ScreamingBeans

If women behaved like this in a professional context

But many do, though. Or do you think it's just men who can be bullies?

ScreamingBeans · 07/02/2021 10:54

I think there's been such a reaction to her is because any woman who has ever had to work with men in this sort of environment, has been treated like this or seen another women treated like this.

If women behaved like this in a professional context, we'd be up on a disciplinary because it's unacceptable.

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 10:53

@LookMoreCloselier

I'm glad someone else thinks theres something a bit strange about this going viral

Yes, it's very odd

Graciebobcat · 07/02/2021 10:53

You never need to yell at someone in a Parish Council meeting. Very unprofessional.

CrisisManagement · 07/02/2021 10:53

I would love to know how Jackie found out this had gone viral. I mean, there she is, going about her life, when suddenly she finds out her conduct in a work meeting held a few weeks ago has made her a national treasure.

She'd be pinching herself.

TillyTopper · 07/02/2021 10:52

To be honest I don't think any of them covered themselves in glory.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/02/2021 10:51

[quote HenriettaHeffalump]Jackie Weaver the opera, for anyone who hasn't seen it:

[/quote] Thanks so much for this Henrietta

Brilliant! People are amazing!

HeronLanyon · 07/02/2021 10:51

Watch the previous meeting. Watch it and understand !

LookMoreCloselier · 07/02/2021 10:51

@trulydelicious I'm glad someone else thinks theres something a bit strange about this going viral!

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 10:50

Are we supposed to hate men? Aren't women sometimes bullies too? I don't get what's the moral of all this and why people believe she's a hero for kicking a couple of men out of a Zoom meeting.