Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Jackie Weaver is a hero to feminism?

591 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 06/02/2021 22:28

Because I refuse to believe that those appalling men would have spoken to another man the way they attempted to shout her down. She handled herself so beautifully.

Frankly I think she deserves to be Dame Jackie Weaver for services to common sense!

OP posts:
Cadent · 07/02/2021 11:49

*world of

Roussette · 07/02/2021 11:49

Earrings Totally agree. Cancel culture is just a phrase bandied about when you haven't got a reasonable argument. Along with snowflake and woke.

Anyone can attend any parish council meeting. They are not private. And the behaviour of the men booted out honestly speaks for itself.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/02/2021 11:49

@wombat1a

THink she did brilliantly, however I doubt it would have matter if it had been a man or a woman in her position, those 'elected representatives' would have had a go at whoever.
This is probably true, however there was a significant misogynistic approach by Chairman Barry - he shouted down Jackie, initially & refused to allow Sue (who is also amazing) speak at all. (This was in meeting 1, the planning one that preceded meeting 2, and which he was removed from)
Cadent · 07/02/2021 11:48

Just watching this on YouTube. Works a difference between BBC coverage vs Sky News. BBC treating it like a joke and saying ‘everyone’s laughing’ but Sky News are actually asking Jackie questions like whether she things it was due to her sex that she was treated like that.

SecretSpAD · 07/02/2021 11:48

I think there's been such a reaction to her is because any woman who has ever had to work with men in this sort of environment, has been treated like this or seen another women treated like this.

Yes this. Reminds me of meetings with arrogant, misogynistic, narcissistic male consultants who think women should be there to do the admin and make them drinks. Twats all of them #jackieweaverforPM 😂😂

Arobase · 07/02/2021 11:47

As for online public shaming, if you behave badly in a recording that you know is going to be published, that's a risk you choose to take.

wombat1a · 07/02/2021 11:46

THink she did brilliantly, however I doubt it would have matter if it had been a man or a woman in her position, those 'elected representatives' would have had a go at whoever.

Arobase · 07/02/2021 11:46

@ConnectFortyFour

Correct me if I'm wrong but I'm assuming jackie was the only person being paid to do this job? Naturally then she is going to be of a higher calibre than the others?

The other thing being missed in all this is that online public shaming is also a form of bullying.

Not necessarily naturally. There are plenty of local councillors who are very experienced and sensible and are at least of equivalent calibre to the clerk. You might also think that the qualified solicitor should have known rather more about the law and how to conduct local public meetings.
EarringsandLipstick · 07/02/2021 11:45

online public shaming is also a form of bullying

Agreed. 'Cancel culture' and all that crap

No. This was a public meeting. Members of the public can attend the meetings, and did on this occasion too.

The meeting is recorded to be a public record.

That's not the same as exposing something that was initially assumed to be private. It was public to start with, and it had just been highlighted, that's all.

There's no 'cancel' bit either. All the officials are being asked to do is their job.

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 11:45

@Eleganz

Are you not in favour of democratic elections having a choice between candidates

Do you mean people in Cheshire are not free to choose their candidates already and are relying on a video to go viral for democracy to kick in? I'm not following

Arobase · 07/02/2021 11:42

[quote trulydelicious]@Eleganz

Can I interest madam in our range of tinfoil headwear

Arobase has just spelled it out, thankfully. There could be some ulterior motives to this.

I hope people are organising for some good opposition candidates when they come up for re-election. These tinpot dictators are going to hate it so much when they no longer have any power

Perhaps an orchestrated effort to kick these men out. Makes more sense now[/quote]
How on earth is that an ulterior motive, or something that is new to you?

Anyone is entitled to stand for election. As has been pointed out, JW sensibly used the publicity to extol the benefits of more people become involved in local government. Or do you think everyone should have kept quiet about this behaviour, meekly let them stand unopposed in May, and let them carry on failing to do the job they were elected for?

MilesJuppIsMyBitch · 07/02/2021 11:42

It's such lovely sunlight isn't it.

This type of behaviour isn't just confined to councillors either. My mum has witnessed similar on various arts/ theatre committees.

It's a gleeful watch, but also depressing.

viques · 07/02/2021 11:42

Eleganz, I realise that!

What amazes me is that - assuming they are aged 60 to 70 - they grew up in the sixties and seventies. They listened to Bowie, the Stones, Bob Marley, Ska, Motown, they saw the start of punk. They saw their contemporaries become hippies in LA, or wear mini skirts and kipper ties in Carnaby street. On tv they watched the Vietnam war, apartheid in South Africa and the growth of black political power in the US. They watched their sisters and female cousins assert their rights as women, they saw a woman elected as PM. They lived through the three day week and the miners strike. They lived through incredibly fast moving social upheavals that changed social aspiration and expectations. But their mindset and beliefs did not budge an inch to acknowledge or accommodate change.

Their attitudes and demeanour are exactly the same as the late Harold, who was born in the 1930s. So what does it take to make a dent in the armour of male privilege that refuses to evolve.

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 11:41

@Eleganz

Why have you brought 'The Right' into this? I haven't

EarringsandLipstick · 07/02/2021 11:41

Jackie, OTH handled herself and the resulting press with aplomb.

Absolutely. In her interview with BBC, she used the opportunity to ask for greater involvement in parish councils, including more diversity & more younger people. She's super.

picklemewalnuts · 07/02/2021 11:41

When people want to be disruptive, it's hard to manage it. I've been in a meeting that insisted a meeting be called to change the date of a planned meeting.

Unfortunately Jackie wasn't present to sort us out.

Arobase · 07/02/2021 11:40

So, shouty/bullying person 1 presses a button and kicks shouty person 2 and shouty person 3 from a Zoom meeting. This is what happened

Why are you misrepresenting the facts, @trulydelicious? We can all see for ourselves that at no point does Jackie Weaver become shouty or bullying.

Eleganz · 07/02/2021 11:39

[quote trulydelicious]@Eleganz

Can I interest madam in our range of tinfoil headwear

Arobase has just spelled it out, thankfully. There could be some ulterior motives to this.

I hope people are organising for some good opposition candidates when they come up for re-election. These tinpot dictators are going to hate it so much when they no longer have any power

Perhaps an orchestrated effort to kick these men out. Makes more sense now[/quote]
Really? That is what you take from that comment?

The state of the right in this country is laughable really.

This is all a big conspiracy by MSM to get rid of a few parish councillors in Cheshire? What? Confused

Talk about clutching at straws.

The point was that the behaviour of these men should be used to provide the electorate with a choice at the next elections. Are you not in favour of democratic elections having a choice between candidates?

NotMe321 · 07/02/2021 11:38

it's hard to believe a bunch of adults could behave so appallingly

Sadly not at all hard. Ironically, I received a copy email this weekend sent by a newish male member of a committee I'm on. It really was quite staggeringly rude, and reeks of "I know best, how dare you question me". What is particularly striking is that it's clearly not a one-off burst of temper, he's taken trouble to sit down and write out a long, offensive message and indeed to copy it to a range of people, and at no point has it occurred to him that, having got it out of his system, he really should just delete the email and start again.

WeLoseTheEdge · 07/02/2021 11:38

[quote trulydelicious]@LApprentiSorcier

A politics student who watches local council meetings as a pastime

That's what I mean. It's implausible. Something smells off here[/quote]
Not implausible at all. My DH recently watched a meeting of our local council (discussing a children’s playground). If you’re interested in local politics and (have a high boredom threshold) why not?

Roussette · 07/02/2021 11:37

Eleganz

Spot on! Whataboutery at it's finest!

The Vice Chairman is very objectionable, he was even nastily shouting at someone in the background where he was. Given he was sat with his Father, I presume it was his mother or wife he was being vile to. How anyone can defend this sort of behaviour, god alone knows Hmm

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 11:36

@DoctorHildegardLanstrom

I also don't understand why people are trying to defend the men on this

I'm not trying to defend the men. They were all bullies and shouty - not acceptable. But hailing this lady as a national feminist hero is too much

LApprentiSorcier · 07/02/2021 11:36

Perhaps an orchestrated effort to kick these men out. Makes more sense now

Whether that's true or not, the fact remains that it's only the men's behaviour that has made the video go viral. No one would have paid any attention to a civilised discussion about planning applications, or whatever.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/02/2021 11:36

@inappropriateraspberry

Ask Alexa 'Who is Jackie Weaver?' 😆
Oh my God!

Just did this - fantastic!!!

borntobequiet · 07/02/2021 11:36

I was put off local politics when younger by men like these, I was a little surprised that they still exist.
Jackie W has been doing a sterling job using the publicity generated by this incident to encourage more people to get involved in their parish councils to combat the influence of such people and get useful things done. I’m dubious of the motives of those criticising her. Perhaps they don’t want more people involved? I wonder why? One reason might be that the more people are discouraged from getting involved in entry-level politics, the less they understand, and the more power and influence accrue to those already in charge.

Swipe left for the next trending thread