Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Jackie Weaver is a hero to feminism?

591 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 06/02/2021 22:28

Because I refuse to believe that those appalling men would have spoken to another man the way they attempted to shout her down. She handled herself so beautifully.

Frankly I think she deserves to be Dame Jackie Weaver for services to common sense!

OP posts:
BlueThistles · 07/02/2021 12:52

it's rather galling to see these men get away with this behaviour over and over ....

they simply deny responsibility and events... and remain in situ to bully and control forever more... the sadness it that nothing ever changes 🌺

frumpety · 07/02/2021 12:48

@trulydelicious I hardly think a spot of high drama at a PC meeting going viral is going to topple the Government ?

JackieWeaverIsTheAuthority · 07/02/2021 12:41

@rwalker

I think she was as bad as them but just more clever. She couldn't of done more to inflame the situation if she tried. She just lit the fuse turned up the heat and let it explode. It was her way or no way, talked over people, Wouldn't let them finish and kicked anyone out who didn't agree with her . If a man would of behaved like that he'd be called a bulling wanker.

She confused control of zoom with control of meeting .

😂😂😂

She did the complete opposite.

stablefeet · 07/02/2021 12:38

@CutePixie

I thought the men and Jackie were childish, but the men were significantly more so. Jackie and the Chairman could’ve resolved their issues before the meeting. Formed a professional relationship. Still, I thought the meeting was hilarious!
The fact that Jackie was brought in at all hints that a lot had gone on before this meeting. We don't know if she tried to broker some sort of agreement with the chair in advance of the meeting. All we have is that video, where it was clear that some on the council are more concerned with their petty agendas than actually being a functioning committee.
frumpety · 07/02/2021 12:36

@KizzyKat91

Often less people apply than there are positions, so people get co-opted into the roles. This is why you end up with groups of power hungry retirees giving roles to other like-minded power hungry retirees...

For balance not all PC's are made up of power hungry retirees, but you are correct about the rest Smile

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 12:24

I was confused for a moment, I thought it was like one of these Youtube videos about a puppy who is taught where to poop for the first time, getting 20M clicks

trulydelicious · 07/02/2021 12:23

@Eleganz and @Arobase

Thank you for clarifying this for me.

So the Opposition (most likely) instigated the viralisation of a video and then worked with their MSM cronies to spin the story and encourage people to come forward to contribute to topple the government

Arobase · 07/02/2021 12:18

Perhaps an orchestrated effort to kick these men out. Makes more sense now

Any contested election is an orchestrated attempt either to kick out current representatives or stop new ones from coming in. What is so sinister about that?

As for seeing dark plots in something going viral - surely anyone who has any knowledge of social media knows that literally anything can go viral? Certainly the behaviour on these videos is so poor that it isn't in the least surprising that information spread quickly once a few people had seen them and retweeted/shared, that's literally why it's described as "viral".

VPNine · 07/02/2021 12:11

@frumpety

It's for the electorate to decide who represents them at meetings. Not Jackie Weaver.

I wonder how many people actually voted for the Parish Councillors, I imagine there would be a publicly available record ? Here, you just put your name forward, if there are the same number of people who want the role as there are roles available then they all get a position, if they all meet the strict eligibility criteria.
If there are more people than positions available, then someone may give way to allow another person to take on the role, I know I would if the opportunity presented itself, but we struggle at the best of times to fill the seats.

I have not RTFT, still back on page 9 with little hope of catching up, but frumppety is spot on. The "electorate" should be ashamed about who is representing them here and they are lucky to have someone like Jackie to step in and sort this lot out. We have someone complaining about our PC, that they should all resign because they do not represent the views of the electorate. But do they step forward to take vacant seats? Hell no.
Dailyhandtowelwash · 07/02/2021 12:09

@viques

Eleganz, I realise that!

What amazes me is that - assuming they are aged 60 to 70 - they grew up in the sixties and seventies. They listened to Bowie, the Stones, Bob Marley, Ska, Motown, they saw the start of punk. They saw their contemporaries become hippies in LA, or wear mini skirts and kipper ties in Carnaby street. On tv they watched the Vietnam war, apartheid in South Africa and the growth of black political power in the US. They watched their sisters and female cousins assert their rights as women, they saw a woman elected as PM. They lived through the three day week and the miners strike. They lived through incredibly fast moving social upheavals that changed social aspiration and expectations. But their mindset and beliefs did not budge an inch to acknowledge or accommodate change.

Their attitudes and demeanour are exactly the same as the late Harold, who was born in the 1930s. So what does it take to make a dent in the armour of male privilege that refuses to evolve.

This is so true. Recently someone I know from a parish group, when the issue of BLM came up, told me he really couldn’t understand why the term ‘negro’ was considered offensive as it was just the spanish for black and therefore descriptive. I started to explain the historical connotations and resonance of the word and then stopped, because he was a young man during the civil rights movement and frankly if he hadn’t absorbed it then, what was the point of me talking to him about it? It happened before I was born FFS.
KizzyKat91 · 07/02/2021 12:07

People release that most parish councillors are uncontested and so are technically unelected, right? Usually only 1 person stands for the position and so they are automatically given the role. Parish councils actively try to avoid more than 1 person applying for each available role due to the costs of holding a proper election.

Often less people apply than there are positions, so people get co-opted into the roles. This is why you end up with groups of power hungry retirees giving roles to other like-minded power hungry retirees...

The system can’t in anyway be described as democratic! theconversation.com/local-elections-disaster-for-local-democracy-as-hundreds-of-seats-go-uncontested-115874

frumpety · 07/02/2021 12:05

@CutePixie I think that would have been difficult to do as the Chair and Vice Chair were adamant that the meeting was illegal and so should not have been proceeding at all.

Peregrina · 07/02/2021 12:03

What amazes me is that - assuming they are aged 60 to 70 - they grew up in the sixties and seventies.

Cllr Tolver looks as though he's in his 80s to me, so would have been growing up in the War years. One of the others was a young man in his 30s.

Dailyhandtowelwash · 07/02/2021 12:03

@trulydelicious I’ve spent a lot of time in meetings, political and professional. There are female bullies out there, but it would be risible to suggest that they influence decision making and culture in every sphere the way male bullying does. To suggest otherwise would indicate someone who hasn’t had particularly wide experience of those structures. It’s not whataboutery remotely worth pursuing.

CutePixie · 07/02/2021 12:01

I thought the men and Jackie were childish, but the men were significantly more so. Jackie and the Chairman could’ve resolved their issues before the meeting. Formed a professional relationship. Still, I thought the meeting was hilarious!

LApprentiSorcier · 07/02/2021 11:57

@viques

Eleganz, I realise that!

What amazes me is that - assuming they are aged 60 to 70 - they grew up in the sixties and seventies. They listened to Bowie, the Stones, Bob Marley, Ska, Motown, they saw the start of punk. They saw their contemporaries become hippies in LA, or wear mini skirts and kipper ties in Carnaby street. On tv they watched the Vietnam war, apartheid in South Africa and the growth of black political power in the US. They watched their sisters and female cousins assert their rights as women, they saw a woman elected as PM. They lived through the three day week and the miners strike. They lived through incredibly fast moving social upheavals that changed social aspiration and expectations. But their mindset and beliefs did not budge an inch to acknowledge or accommodate change.

Their attitudes and demeanour are exactly the same as the late Harold, who was born in the 1930s. So what does it take to make a dent in the armour of male privilege that refuses to evolve.

It's a mistake to assume that everyone embraces the zeitgeist of the era in which they grew up. Sometimes this can be a good thing - we need some people who don't jump on the bandwagon.

In this case, there are clearly appalling attitudes in play, but I think 'how can Bob Marley not have influenced them? (etc.)' isn't really relevant in looking at why they are the way they are. It's something much more deep-seated.

As a comparison, look at the way racism persists even with the huge focus on BLM at the moment - in fact, to racists, BLM is more 'ammunition' than an encouragement to change.

Similarly, a person with the kind of outdated attitudes we saw in the video might well have been angered by the things you describe in your post, and have held even more firmly to their mindset as a result.

frumpety · 07/02/2021 11:56

Perhaps an orchestrated effort to kick these men out. Makes more sense now

What with voting and stuff, perish the thought !

If the inquiry ( which began in July 2020 ) into the complaints finds nothing amiss, then they will be free to succumb to the democratic process of elections in May. Unless there is a vote of no confidence before that time ? Can they do that ? the other councillors that is ?

I suppose you could be right, there is a slim chance we have been caught up in some dark plot to oust the Chair and Vice chair, but you then have to ask why does such a plot exist ? And then you could rewatch the videos for your answer.

Arobase · 07/02/2021 11:55

[quote Piglet89]@Arobase I am a real, practising lawyer and I would never so much as chuckle at an alumnus of Giggleswick School, like Aled.[/quote]
Me too, but I did think it was quite funny when he claimed legal advice privilege for a piece of supposed legal advice that he had just read out. And when he threatened a Non-Molestation Order which he would never get in a million years.

Doublefaced · 07/02/2021 11:54

The ‘Chairman’ reminds me of my ex FIL. And the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree with regards his son.

Arobase · 07/02/2021 11:53

[quote trulydelicious]@Eleganz

Why have you brought 'The Right' into this? I haven't[/quote]
It is not insignificant that the people disapproving of JW are those who habitually pop up on various threads espousing a right wing point of view. Just as it's not insignificant that the most rabid and misogynist BTL comments on news reports are on websites like the Mail's.

Piglet89 · 07/02/2021 11:53

@Arobase I am a real, practising lawyer and I would never so much as chuckle at an alumnus of Giggleswick School, like Aled.

Cadent · 07/02/2021 11:52

@EarringsandLipstick

BBC treating it like a joke and saying ‘everyone’s laughing’

I agree Cadent BBC had a shocking approach to the story, as if it were hilarious. Didn't touch on the abusive misogyny at play.

Exactly Earrings. I didn’t find the video hilarious at all, the misogyny was disturbing. And it was 2 other women who stuck up for Jackie.
pinkearedcow · 07/02/2021 11:51

@viques to be fair, lots of people are small minded and petty regardless of age or sex - you only have to look at some of the posters on MN! These men probably hated hippies and thought punk marked the end of civilisation.

Cadent · 07/02/2021 11:50

@wombat1a

THink she did brilliantly, however I doubt it would have matter if it had been a man or a woman in her position, those 'elected representatives' would have had a go at whoever.
But Jackie Weaver herself says her sex played a part in why she was treated like that.
EarringsandLipstick · 07/02/2021 11:50

BBC treating it like a joke and saying ‘everyone’s laughing’

I agree Cadent BBC had a shocking approach to the story, as if it were hilarious. Didn't touch on the abusive misogyny at play.

Swipe left for the next trending thread