Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DOGS

108 replies

Getmeoutofhere2019 · 06/02/2021 00:04

At the beach with my 5 and 2yr old today. Sitting by the wavebreaks building sand castles. Too many dogs off leads coming over and invading our space. Trampling our area and getting in the children's face. Closely followed by an owner saying "oh its ok ... they are friendly " AIBU to be totally annoyed by this. I never know how to respond to the owner. NO Its not OK .... or just smile and nod.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StrangeToSee · 13/08/2021 10:11

What's the 'on purpose' for anyway. On purpose or not is irrelevant. If my dog is scared by a child's behaviour, whether on purpose or without realising they are frightening the dog, their parents should intervene

Of course there’s a difference. Kids can unintentionally scare a nervous dog by shrieking, running, kicking balls, riding scooters and all the other things kids do in parks. If your dog can’t cope with that he needs to be on a lead or taken to dog-only places. Parents shouldn’t have to stop their kids playing in the park just because your dog gets scared.

Obviously I tell my DC not to run up behind dogs (or people) but you can’t guarantee a runaway toddler won’t trot blindly into your dog or grab at their fur before the parents can react. Once again avoid family-friendly places if your dog is frightened by this. Don’t blame the parents!
When a toddler walks into my dog or a child pets him without permission the parents usually rush over to apologise. Then I tell them it’s ok, he loves kids but is a bit boisterous even on the lead and might pull them over by accident if they try to play tug of war or something.

grlwhowrites · 12/08/2021 15:22

I'm a dog owner and my dog is incredibly excitable so he's always on the lead but we have it too, big dogs come bounding over to us in the park and their owner is seemingly nowhere to be seen. Then the owner shows up and says the whole "oh, they're fine" line but that's not a guarantee, is it? If you're a dog owner, you should be responsible and keep them in sight at all times and if you do let them off the lead, it should be in safe, enclosed spaces. They should also have excellent recall so they return to you when you say their name.

Having said that, we also have it with over excited children who come running over to our dog and start grabbing at him (in their defence, he does look like a teddy bear that's come to life) which is a risky game. Now, I know my dog is friendly, adorable and sweet natured but he's still a dog, I can't guarantee he won't get pissed off and react to an overly tactile child one day. I'd encourage parents and dog owners to be responsible and respect that not everyone wants to be around a dog, and not every dog wants children near them.

Mreggsworth · 12/08/2021 14:40

I've had plenty kids pestering my dog, It has happened pretty much every day of the summer holidays, I don't mind and my dog loves a fuss, but it is a double standard.

I walk my dog daily in a busy park full of families and dog walkers, I would say I see an incident average once a year (dog on dog, never dog on human) which to me on the grand scale of things suggest that most dog owners are responsible. On the flip side the ammount of human on human incidents I have seen Hmm . Dogs really aren't a problem on this earth on the big scheme of things, just cant get my head around why people are so bothered by them. Cant help but feel there is an air of arrogance that 'how dare another species enjoy our world'.

Yes dogs shouldn't jump on people unwelcomed, no one is denying that, and no one is denying dogs should be trained and have recall. But we share this world with animals, and they arent perfect just like humans, and will have behaviours that inconvenience and annoy others, but that's just part of sharing the world with other species (and humans).

I literally know no one in real life who has these views mumsnet seems to have on dogs though, maybe I just live in a more relaxed and accommodating area

vivainsomnia · 12/08/2021 14:36

I’ve never experienced children pestering or scaring my dog on purpose. Nor do I know any parents who think that’s acceptable behaviour
ha ha, I actually wrote by post above before reading this one. Certainly proving my point! What's the 'on purpose' for anyway. On purpose or not is irrelevant. If my dog is scared by a child's behaviour, whether on purpose or without realising they are frightening the dog, their parents should intervene.

Occasionally a toddler will bump into my dog or grab at him
So it does happen!! Your dog might not care, mine does.

If you walk your dog in an area frequented by kids your dog needs to be fairly unflappable around kids
And he is! Absolutely fine walking and staying way away from them, which seems to be what most posters want, so all good. The problem is because he is especially cute, kids come to him and insist on petting him even when I tell them he doesn't want it. That's the issue.

If a dog bites a child out of fear, in a public place, the dog is likely to be seized and PTS regardless of what the child did to scare it
My dog would never bite. He won't even show teeth, he just runs away and hides. If a kid did something that could hurt him though and ignored my commands to stop, I definitely wouldn't care if my actions to free my dog hurt the kid. This is extreme behaviour though and thankfully, I don't foresee this ever happen.

If dog owners want a true relaxing off-lead experience for their dogs - they should go to a dog field - AND PAY
Absolutely not! If my park allows my dog to be off the lead, and my dog is behaving perfectly and not pestering anyone or any dog, I certainly will NOT go and take him somewhere else (which is miles away as opposed to 10 mns walk from my house) just because some kids can't act properly and their parents are too lazy or stupid to intervene.

vivainsomnia · 12/08/2021 14:23

@Missfelipe, @DarlingFell, When we mention kids harrassing dogs on MN, we are always making it up because it just never happen.

Ultimately, with these threads, it always results in the same outcome: Dog owners agree there are bad ones, but claim that they are not, and those parents who actually do acknowledge that kids can pester dogs claim that their never would always ask.

That's because bad dog owners and bad parents do remain a minority and those won't come here and admit that they allow bad behaviour. What gets to me are posters who have had bad experiences and conclude that all dog owners are bad, as it's been clearly written on this thread.

StrangeToSee · 12/08/2021 14:11

I know this is MN, posters mainly parents of little precious darlings, but that doesn't mean I should accept the behaviour of little brats whose parents think pestering a scared dog is acceptable

I’ve never experienced children pestering or scaring my dog on purpose. Nor do I know any parents who think that’s acceptable behaviour.

Occasionally a toddler will bump into my dog or grab at him (he doesn’t mind as he’s well socialised with children and very gentle even if they startle him). If you walk your dog in an area frequented by kids your dog needs to be fairly unflappable around kids. If a dog bites a child out of fear, in a public place, the dog is likely to be seized and PTS regardless of what the child did to scare it.

I don’t agree with dogs off lead in parks unless they have excellent recall and give other dogs and humans a wide berth (unless given permission to play). You always get out of control dogs in the wrong areas. Or people with kids too afraid to walk through the ‘dog’ bit to reach the non-dog area and playground. Plus people who either don’t read the signs or let the dog play in the kids area because they don’t care!

bunnybuggs · 12/08/2021 14:03

the problem seems to be that dog owners equate 'dogs allowed' beaches with 'dogs have total freedom' beaches - it is the same with parks. My local small park has a big sign saying dogs must be kept on a lead as it is used by the local primary school and nursery for play and sports - as well as by local residents for walking.
In fact, it is used mostly as an impromptu dog training off-lead free for all and it is a minefield of dog poo for small children.
If dog owners want a true relaxing off-lead experience for their dogs - they should go to a dog field - AND PAY - otherwise dog friendly beaches should be redesignated and fenced off (and owners should pay) and other beaches should allow dogs under control and on lead . Dogs do love to run free - but the owners must realise that comes at a cost.

RichTeaShite · 12/08/2021 13:46

“Being friendly and being under control are two different things”.

No dog should be off lead unless it can be recalled away from distractions.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 12/08/2021 13:07

YANBU, and I say this as the owner of a very nervous rescue dog who hates dogs in her face and will run off if she's scared.

DanielTigersMummy21 · 12/08/2021 13:02

Yanbu. I am considering Nordic walking poles to have something to whack them with if they don't back away from my toddler when I shoo them away. I had to get between my buggy and a doberman looking thing the other day on a woodland walk!

LST · 12/08/2021 12:34

@jasjas1973

Yes, there are irresponsible dog owners, yes it's been said over and over and over here. Do we need yet another thread on this topic?

Yes because its getting worse, R4 had a piece on it, the Dangerous Dogs Act, over 8000 admissions to hospitals (not AE) but stays in hospital due to dog attacks, many are kids who will be maimed for life.

We recently had a thread on hitting a dog and how its akin to hitting a child, so she should LTB, - i wonder if the lack of knowledge of new training techniques is responsible for so many dogs out of control?

imho the number of well trained dogs & responsible owners is far out weighed by the idiots and ignorant.

There def needs to be a far more rigorous appraisal of potential dog owners than there is currently, licence fee's would also pay for more dog wardens - Cornwall has two for the whole county.

I disagree. You just don't notice the good dogs and oweners
GuyFawkesDay · 12/08/2021 12:30

It's interesting because I follow a behaviourist who works with "death row dogs" which have killed pets or attacked humans. He is very clear about the huge amount of time, energy and commitment required particularly for larger mastiff type breeds etc. But not to underestimate the effort required for "fluffy" cockapoo types too.

Agree as well kids need to be taught how to coexist with dogs. I always got mine to ask owners before approaching and taught them how to approach dogs calmly etc. It's part and parcel of the things parents should do

jasjas1973 · 12/08/2021 12:20

Yes, there are irresponsible dog owners, yes it's been said over and over and over here. Do we need yet another thread on this topic?

Yes because its getting worse, R4 had a piece on it, the Dangerous Dogs Act, over 8000 admissions to hospitals (not AE) but stays in hospital due to dog attacks, many are kids who will be maimed for life.

We recently had a thread on hitting a dog and how its akin to hitting a child, so she should LTB, - i wonder if the lack of knowledge of new training techniques is responsible for so many dogs out of control?

imho the number of well trained dogs & responsible owners is far out weighed by the idiots and ignorant.

There def needs to be a far more rigorous appraisal of potential dog owners than there is currently, licence fee's would also pay for more dog wardens - Cornwall has two for the whole county.

Keety · 12/08/2021 12:20

I was called 'crazy' the other day because I firmly told an overexcited dog (he's friendly!) charging up to me to go away and turned my back on it.

Some (emphasis on 'some') dog owners just really can't understand why people don't love their dogs as much as they do. In my case it's partly because I was bitten by a dog a few years ago as I was crossing a railway bridge. My instinct since then is to move away from any dog not on a lead - friendly or not.

Missfelipe · 12/08/2021 12:14

@vivainsomnia

If a dog is known to hate or be nervous of kids I have no idea why you would walk it at a time and place popular with children Oh the irony and totally proving how totally biased posters here against dogs. threads after threads about kids being scared of dogs and how all owners, even of lovely gentle dogs should therefore be forbidden of public park.

When it's the dog that is frightened, it's still the dog that should go elsewhere.

When the dog approaches the kids, the owner is a terrible person, it's ok for the kid to kick the dog, owner is irresponsible.

Kid frighten the kid, the owner of the dog should keep the dog away.

How about parents practice what they preach and teach their kids not to come close, let alone chase small dogs? The park is open for BOTH dogs and kids. Half dogs need to be on the lead, the other half is a big open area where dogs and kids are free to play, respectfully, which my dog does.

I know this is MN, posters mainly parents of little precious darlings, but that doesn't mean I should accept the behaviour of little brats whose parents think pestering a scared dog is acceptable.

This.

We were recently sitting in a park with our dog on lead. She is not really fussed about children and doesn’t pay them any attention. A child came over to ask about her and at first was keeping a distance. She then without warning lunged and wrapped her arms around the dogs neck to ‘hug’ her, something that would never have happened to her before and we certainly don’t man handle her. Luckily all was fine but I was gobsmacked. Parents shouting ‘aww are you saying hi to the doggy’ 🧐🧐🧐

DarlingFell · 12/08/2021 12:09

@vivainsomnia

Just going to turn into yet another dog owner and dog bashing thread.. loads of posters will turn up saying dogs should never be off lead and never be allowed anywhere.. same every single time This indeed. I was talking to a dog owner yesterday in the park, where dogs are allowed of the lead, and where, inevitably there are a lot of kids at the moment. Suddenly, two kids came to my dog, who start to run away from them as she is scared, and they thought no better than to run after him. No parents around. I had to tell the kids to stop and they were scaring my dog. They left and the other dog owner said she had the same issue with kids coming to pet her dog. Hers will tolerate it but hates it, yet she says it happens all the time.

Should I start a thread on stupid irresponsible parents who think it's acceptable to let their kids scare my dog, and add that frankly, every parents are irresponsible idiots and kids should all be on lead?

Yes, there are irresponsible dog owners, yes it's been said over and over and over here. Do we need yet another thread on this topic?

Agree with all of this. I have two very cute dogs and kids just love to come up to them, right in their faces, follow them and chase them..... and the parents just stand there not saying a word.

Do I start a thread on these useless parents, though? No, because there are good and bad parents, just as there are good and bad dog owners. These threads are SO DULL and even more tedious is the poster who thought it was a good idea to resurrect a 6 month old thread to go over the same tired old issue Hmm

Streamingbannersofdawn · 12/08/2021 12:05

Were you on a "dogs allowed" beach? Only as a dog owner whose dog loves the water I can struggle to find a beach where dogs aren't banned. If people are ignoring the ban that is awful and it should be enforced. A lot of people don't attend formal training where dogs are taught recall properly and to ignore other people and other dogs when instructed.

I do however love a good fairly difficult to access dog friendly beach where I don't have to worry about children and picnics I must confess.

ItzANoFromMe · 12/08/2021 11:54

@Happymum12345

Most beaches that I know have specific areas for dogs. Could you go to a beach where dogs are not allowed?
I do this. But dog owners still come on the beach.
Happymum12345 · 12/08/2021 11:38

Most beaches that I know have specific areas for dogs. Could you go to a beach where dogs are not allowed?

vivainsomnia · 12/08/2021 11:27

If a dog is known to hate or be nervous of kids I have no idea why you would walk it at a time and place popular with children
Oh the irony and totally proving how totally biased posters here against dogs. threads after threads about kids being scared of dogs and how all owners, even of lovely gentle dogs should therefore be forbidden of public park.

When it's the dog that is frightened, it's still the dog that should go elsewhere.

When the dog approaches the kids, the owner is a terrible person, it's ok for the kid to kick the dog, owner is irresponsible.

Kid frighten the kid, the owner of the dog should keep the dog away.

How about parents practice what they preach and teach their kids not to come close, let alone chase small dogs? The park is open for BOTH dogs and kids. Half dogs need to be on the lead, the other half is a big open area where dogs and kids are free to play, respectfully, which my dog does.

I know this is MN, posters mainly parents of little precious darlings, but that doesn't mean I should accept the behaviour of little brats whose parents think pestering a scared dog is acceptable.

Forrestttheout · 12/08/2021 11:22

@StrangeToSee

Also most owners CAN recall they just don’t think they need to. When I’m with my dog-reactive dog (who is always on a short lead to stop him attacking dogs who run up to him) he can spot another dog from far away. If it gets too close he starts trying to lunge and barks at it aggressively (I hold him so unless the other dog is stupid enough to keep coming he can’t reach it). Funny how quickly the owners manage to recall or grab their dog when they think theirs is in danger!
I see this also, I have a big rescue who is very nervous about other dogs approaching him while he is on the lead (no problems off lead). His recall is not the best so in public areas he stays on lead. Its amazing how quickly people go from shouting they're friendly to quickly calling dogs back or running to fetch them when I shout back that's great but this guy isn't. In answer to the OP is not acceptable for owners to allow this and its just as annoying to other (responsible) dog owners as non dog owners because it gives us all a bad name and as in my example above can lead to dangerous situations for humans and dogs.
Candyapple49 · 12/08/2021 11:20

If a dog is known to hate or be nervous of kids I have no idea why you would walk it at a time and place popular with children .

Candyapple49 · 12/08/2021 11:19

@vivainsomnia

Just going to turn into yet another dog owner and dog bashing thread.. loads of posters will turn up saying dogs should never be off lead and never be allowed anywhere.. same every single time This indeed. I was talking to a dog owner yesterday in the park, where dogs are allowed of the lead, and where, inevitably there are a lot of kids at the moment. Suddenly, two kids came to my dog, who start to run away from them as she is scared, and they thought no better than to run after him. No parents around. I had to tell the kids to stop and they were scaring my dog. They left and the other dog owner said she had the same issue with kids coming to pet her dog. Hers will tolerate it but hates it, yet she says it happens all the time.

Should I start a thread on stupid irresponsible parents who think it's acceptable to let their kids scare my dog, and add that frankly, every parents are irresponsible idiots and kids should all be on lead?

Yes, there are irresponsible dog owners, yes it's been said over and over and over here. Do we need yet another thread on this topic?

I am a dog owner and I don’t think that dogs should be off the leads in parks where children play . In my mind these are “ designed for human “ places . Dogs on leads are fine , but remnants of poo in the middle of football pitches us not on . Areas such as natural woodland are better as parents are on the lookout for dangers , so to say .
Candyapple49 · 12/08/2021 11:15

I am a dog owner and totally agree with you .
I was also on the beach yesterday with ds 5 and a couple came with a huge what looked like a rottie cross off the lead . We were sitting and it bounded towards us and began snuffling in my bag . Not acceptable at all . I am not scared of dogs usually , but in that situation I was terrified that it could snap at my son and I would be totally powerless .

vivainsomnia · 12/08/2021 11:03

Just going to turn into yet another dog owner and dog bashing thread.. loads of posters will turn up saying dogs should never be off lead and never be allowed anywhere.. same every single time
This indeed. I was talking to a dog owner yesterday in the park, where dogs are allowed of the lead, and where, inevitably there are a lot of kids at the moment. Suddenly, two kids came to my dog, who start to run away from them as she is scared, and they thought no better than to run after him. No parents around. I had to tell the kids to stop and they were scaring my dog. They left and the other dog owner said she had the same issue with kids coming to pet her dog. Hers will tolerate it but hates it, yet she says it happens all the time.

Should I start a thread on stupid irresponsible parents who think it's acceptable to let their kids scare my dog, and add that frankly, every parents are irresponsible idiots and kids should all be on lead?

Yes, there are irresponsible dog owners, yes it's been said over and over and over here. Do we need yet another thread on this topic?