Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask at what age you put your child in nursery?

333 replies

chuckb4ss · 05/02/2021 18:08

Was it part time or full time, and did you feel it was beneficial for your child?

I've read that research shows babies should be with their primary caregiver for the first few years in order to create a secure, healthy attachment, but I simply cannot last that long!

OP posts:
TheMoth · 06/02/2021 10:54

I find it really sad that women are expected to feel guilty at using childcare for babies, whilst men aren't.

But we all keep biting mrgrinch's line, so we're making someone happy.

pitterpatterrain · 06/02/2021 10:32

kersh33 100% - childcare is so culturally shaped, and people can’t see it if they don’t have work colleagues / friends / family that gives them a different perspective

Even within the UK I imagine you have very different attitudes, depending on work type / social circles etc

TheJerkStore · 06/02/2021 10:26

TheJerkStore apparently we women are allowed to work, but only whilst wearing a hair shirt and flagellating ourselves as the tears of existential guilt over our awful abandonment of our children to The Dungeon Of Childcare aka nursery flow down our cheeks.

It's ridiculous

DSs nursery was wonderful and he still talks about it now!

FFS.

I have several friends who became SAHMs only to find their lives overturned when their husbands fucked off with a younger, sexier, child-free new woman. I feel zero guilt over always having worked and looking at my DDs it's abundantly clear that they have not been damaged at all by going to nursery.

This is always a worry

unmarkedbythat · 06/02/2021 10:12

It's a bit odd to say your non-verbal child of 6-15 months "absolutely loved it" - how on earth would you know that?!

You may struggle to interpret the communication of non verbal babies but some parents are really quite good at it.

kersh33 · 06/02/2021 10:12

I find this conversation interesting as I'm English but had my DD in France where I still live. Here paid maternity leave is 12 weeks pp and most women go back to work then and babies are put into either a crèche or more frequently with a childminder.

I found it a bit surprising and scary to start off with. But I went back to work when DD was 4 months (I used up leave to extend for a month) and DD goes full time 9-6 to the childminders. It's worked really well and DD loves it there - but my main point is that it's very usual for young babies in France to go into childcare settings and the country isn't full of insecure, damaged adults. So I think you're fine.

unmarkedbythat · 06/02/2021 10:09

Ds1 was 10 months when I went back to work. 4 days a week. It was fine, he was at the same nursery until he went to school aged 4 and he definitely formed strong bonds with staff and peers.

Ds2 I went back to work when he was 9 months but we used a combination of family and nursery, he was usually with family tbh. But he started school based nursery aged 3 and really thrived there.

Ds3 went to a cm 4 days a week from 9.5 months and that became 5 days a week very soon after when I got a different job. He genuinely loves his cm. She is family to him.

The judgemental rubbish about childcare and how children need SAHPs is really quite boring and I'm uninterested in listening to those who want to spout it; their opinions are irrelevant to me and my family.

pointythings · 06/02/2021 10:01

@TheJerkStore

but not caring is just unbelievable.

Why do you assume parents (sorry mothers 🙄) don't care? It's not so black and white.

TheJerkStore apparently we women are allowed to work, but only whilst wearing a hair shirt and flagellating ourselves as the tears of existential guilt over our awful abandonment of our children to The Dungeon Of Childcare aka nursery flow down our cheeks.

FFS.

I have several friends who became SAHMs only to find their lives overturned when their husbands fucked off with a younger, sexier, child-free new woman. I feel zero guilt over always having worked and looking at my DDs it's abundantly clear that they have not been damaged at all by going to nursery.

ShirleyPhallus · 06/02/2021 10:01

I think a lot of people on this thread who say that babies don’t need anyone else except their parents until 18mo have the luxury of older children who weren’t born during covid. My DD is now 10 months and during that time has only ever seen other children and babies from afar. Even her cousins she’s never met up close because her entire life has been in lockdown or restricted. She is absolutely missing out on interaction with other babies. My husband and I can tell she’s bored with spending every day with us and not being able to do much.

So babies might only need to be at home with their parents until 18mo, but that’s assuming that their parents will be socialising them with family / friends / baby group / neighbours etc etc. For those babies born during covid they have had none of that.

My DD will start 2 days of nursery a week when she turns 1 and I’m bloody excited for her. I know she’ll do well and will really enjoy the socialisation aspect of just being around other people. I’m not going to feel guilty for that one bit.

Ileflottante · 06/02/2021 10:01

@Mrgrinch you’re saying I didn’t care when I put my four month old in nursery? That’s interesting. Where did you read that then?

hanahspanah · 06/02/2021 09:53

18 months for half a day a week and built up to 3 full days slowly. He's 3.5 now and will be starting school in September. My youngest will be starting at 18 months for half a day too, she's just turned one.

TheJerkStore · 06/02/2021 09:50

but not caring is just unbelievable.

Why do you assume parents (sorry mothers 🙄) don't care? It's not so black and white.

TheJerkStore · 06/02/2021 09:48

DS started nursery at 10 months and was there until he started school.
We walk past the nursery on the way to school and he speaks so fondly of his 'first' school and the staff always call out to him and stop for a chat.

Living in a small village has meant he made friends with children who live locally and now they're at school together.

He thrived there and we have zero regrets about sending him. I can't speak highly enough of the nursery and the staff.

If you look Into the research you'll see that the quality of the childcare provider is key. Good quality childcare is beneficial. Also, look at who produced the research as there is a lots of dodgy 'research' out there that has a clear agenda and opinion on the role of women in society.

Mrgrinch · 06/02/2021 09:40

[quote Ileflottante]@Mrgrinch because you’ve laid all blame and guilt at the door of mothers. Do you not think fathers are involved?

I’m guessing you and @TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY (Bat Shit Shirley) don’t have to work?

Some women want to return to work, some women have to return to work. I went back to work/study when my child was four months old. I’m quite secure in that. But some women have had to return to work so their children can eat and have a roof over their heads and your archaic backward judgement is entirely unhelpful and yes, not kind.

I won’t tell you what I really think of you, I was being kind.[/quote]
To be honest I'm not interested in what you think of me, not in the slightest.

Anyone who feels nothing about leaving their child at four months old is clearly worlds away from me. Leaving them because it's necessary but also wishing you could be with them is one thing, but not caring is just unbelievable.

MindyStClaire · 06/02/2021 09:38

It's a bit odd to say your non-verbal child of 6-15 months "absolutely loved it" - how on earth would you know that?! Because they didn't cry at drop-off? Or seemed ok?

Because despite using nursery, I have a bond with my children and know them well? Could you not tell when your nine month olds were happy, sad, uncomfortable etc?

It annoys me that I was encouraged to work hard all through school, do my best in exams, get into a good university and do well there, get a good graduate job and work towards my professional qualification. And then in my 30s when I was starting to reap the benefits of that (born financially and in terms of enjoying a fulfilling career), all of a sudden it was "oh... You're going back full-time?".

Ileflottante · 06/02/2021 09:20

@Mrgrinch because you’ve laid all blame and guilt at the door of mothers. Do you not think fathers are involved?

I’m guessing you and @TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY (Bat Shit Shirley) don’t have to work?

Some women want to return to work, some women have to return to work. I went back to work/study when my child was four months old. I’m quite secure in that. But some women have had to return to work so their children can eat and have a roof over their heads and your archaic backward judgement is entirely unhelpful and yes, not kind.

I won’t tell you what I really think of you, I was being kind.

Parker231 · 06/02/2021 09:15

@Mrgrinch - what about being without their fathers? Do they not count in your theories? My DT’s had an equally strong relationship with both DH and I. I would be worried if they didn’t as DH was jointly involved with them - fed them, got up in the night to settle them, bathed them, bought their clothes, selected their nursery and schools etc.

Baconking · 06/02/2021 08:50

9 months - 4 days a week.

They loved it

EvilSylvanianRabbit · 06/02/2021 08:47

I know my 9 month old ‘loved it’ Hmm as he was smily and happy at drop off, the nursery would send photos of him happily cruising around and playing with the toys, and he liked the company of other babies. What else was I to think, that he hated it? Confused he went there (in a variety of attendance patterns) until he started school and now at 6 he still has fond memories of it and says ‘there’s my nursery!’ if we drive past.

Mrgrinch · 06/02/2021 08:41

[quote Ileflottante]@Mrgrinch you’re not very kind.[/quote]
Because I said it makes me sad for tiny babies to be without their mother for half of their time? Okay then.

Ileflottante · 06/02/2021 08:11

@Mrgrinch you’re not very kind.

Afishcalledwonderful · 06/02/2021 07:45

My DS went to nursery for one day a week to begin with, at 12 months. We increased it to two days when he was 3 because he loved going there and seeing all his friends.

coffeeandgin26 · 06/02/2021 07:29

I didnt. I waited until
They started part time school nursery at 3.

I loved having them at home. I'm self employed so didn't need to

ememem84 · 06/02/2021 07:28

9m with ds and 6m with dd. Had to go back to work both times.

itshappened · 06/02/2021 07:28

Mine both went full time, so 5 days 8am-5:30pm at 7/8 months old, and loved it. Neither cried in the settling in period and the eldest will start school in September and in normal times they have a better social life than I do. Nursery for us has worked brilliantly and allowed me to work full time with no concerns about their happiness or development.

HazelWong · 06/02/2021 07:27

12/13 months for ours.

My older one is very social and really enjoyed it from the start. The nursery manager said to me "to be honest most of the little ones would rather be at home but he genuinely really loves it here". Some days he cried when we picked him up and kept pointing to go back.

My younger one is more ambivalent about it, honestly he probably would be happier at home until he's older.

But for us it's not just about the kids, it's also about our happiness. Neither of us are cut out to be SAHP so we both work part time to keep the nursery days down to 3 a week and that feels like a good balance.