Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask at what age you put your child in nursery?

333 replies

chuckb4ss · 05/02/2021 18:08

Was it part time or full time, and did you feel it was beneficial for your child?

I've read that research shows babies should be with their primary caregiver for the first few years in order to create a secure, healthy attachment, but I simply cannot last that long!

OP posts:
Ileflottante · 06/02/2021 15:33

[quote Mrgrinch]@Eastie77 Thank you, it is only my opinion after all. I think people on here do an excellent job of thinking that their culture is the only one that matters and all others are wrong.[/quote]
No one minded you having an opinion, what I personally minded was that it was dripping judgement and in particular you deciding that I didn’t care when I put my kid in childcare.

Strongerthanilook · 06/02/2021 14:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheJerkStore · 06/02/2021 14:44

[quote Eastie77]@TheJerkStore if that is the case then I think women who feel guilty need to grow a thicker skin and stop fixating on other people's opinions.

As mentioned, my DC went to a childminder when they were a year old. I've read countless comments on MN about the perils of this kind of childcare and other comments about leaving a child in any kind of childcare when they are under 3. I've never given any of these comments a second thought as I've always felt confident in my choice. This actually reminds me that a neighbour once told me she felt 'so sorry and sad' for my DC when she saw the CM dropping them home in the evening as they were clearly exhausted. She asked me if I felt working FT and gaining money at the expense of missing their childhood was worth itGrin

I actually think it's quite infantilising to suggest women are so impressionable and lacking in agency that many are wracked with guilt or ruin their careers because of the opinions of random people (on the internet or IRL). Personally I think most of us are unconcerned with other people's views and so if MrGrinch thinks it's sad to see young children in childcare...well, I just can't get too exercised about that. [/quote]
I'm a university academic and women's career development is my specific specialism. I've interviewed lots and lots of women over the years and discussed this very topic.
Next time I shall be sure to make it clear that those feelings are nothing to do with deep rooted inequalities and societal expectations and that women should just grow a thicker skin!!
Excellent

Meanwhile, as we witness decades worth of women's progress in the labour market crash and burn within a matter of months we can tell ourselves that people's outdated views on men and women's roles in society, the home and the workplace have no bearing on this and a thicker skin is all that's required.

Parker231 · 06/02/2021 14:39

@itshappened - totally agree. Nurseries are good - we visited loads before deciding on the right one for DT’s. A nanny would have been cheaper but we wanted the benefits of a nursery.
Using a nursery does not harm babies and was a positive decision for DH, DT’s and I. There is nothing wrong with continuing with your career. I didn’t have any guilt as I knew we had made the right decision for our family. I would have hated staying at home as my friends were at work, no family in the U.K. and friends who had babies at a similar time were also returning to work.

slitheringsnakes · 06/02/2021 14:16

We were lucky with our nursery. The (small) baby room was led by a middle-aged woman who had decades of experience. They were extremely well looked after.

slitheringsnakes · 06/02/2021 14:14

3 months for DC1 and 4 months for DC2. They were both very happy there. 3 days a week.

itshappened · 06/02/2021 14:12

I can't believe how judgemental some of the comments on here are. Nurseries are not all the same... at the one my children attend, each carer has a maximum of 2 children until they are over 2. There is no chance my children were left crying and alone... they adore the staff there, even those who work in other rooms and especially the lady who makes the food! I may not spend all day with them, but I do know if my children are happy or not. My eldest has friends to play with all day, is learning to count and write letters, and can't wait to show me all their drawings/ paintings etc at the end of the day. Whilst my now 1 year old has so much fun rolling around in paint and making a mess. The staff love telling me all the stories of him laughing and dancing to music. The photos they share with me are hilarious. And the best thing? there are no screens and they get plenty of fresh air playing outside.

Having to work full time does not make me a bad mother, and I was of course emotional sending them both to nursery when they were so little. But they were not sad at all to be left there and it means the time we do have together at weekends is very special for all of us.

Neolara · 06/02/2021 14:12

When they were 3.

Eastie77 · 06/02/2021 14:09

@TheJerkStore if that is the case then I think women who feel guilty need to grow a thicker skin and stop fixating on other people's opinions.

As mentioned, my DC went to a childminder when they were a year old. I've read countless comments on MN about the perils of this kind of childcare and other comments about leaving a child in any kind of childcare when they are under 3. I've never given any of these comments a second thought as I've always felt confident in my choice. This actually reminds me that a neighbour once told me she felt 'so sorry and sad' for my DC when she saw the CM dropping them home in the evening as they were clearly exhausted. She asked me if I felt working FT and gaining money at the expense of missing their childhood was worth itGrin

I actually think it's quite infantilising to suggest women are so impressionable and lacking in agency that many are wracked with guilt or ruin their careers because of the opinions of random people (on the internet or IRL). Personally I think most of us are unconcerned with other people's views and so if MrGrinch thinks it's sad to see young children in childcare...well, I just can't get too exercised about that.

VienneseWhirligig · 06/02/2021 13:54

3 months, when my mat leave ended. I had to start mat leave at 6 months pregnant for health reasons.

HavelockVetinari · 06/02/2021 13:31

But I do wonder if you're seeing what you want to see when you say nursery isn't working well for children under 18 months?

@SarahAndQuack I really don't think so - as I said, DS went to nursery at 12 months. It would be easy to say how he loved going and was as happy as if he were at home (and I'd want that to be true), but whilst he didn't cry or cling, I still think he'd have much preferred staying with me or DH. We needed to work, to pay our mortgage (and because we both enjoy our careers).

On balance I think it was the right thing to do as a family, but I'm not going to lie to myself and pretend it was all for DS' benefit or that he wouldn't have preferred to stay at home.

Mrgrinch · 06/02/2021 13:21

Wow @strawberriesontheNeva that is seriously horrific!! Breaks my heart, those poor babies being mistreated.

Well done @Nonamesavail I can imagine it was soul destroying.

Was anything done about it in either case? I'd have had to warn the parents on my way out.

TheJerkStore · 06/02/2021 13:20

@strawberriesontheNeva

I've worked in nurseries with big baby rooms . Babies left sitting in bouncy chairs when crying. Picked up only to be fed/ changed. Vomiting/ diarrhoea bugs rampant in winter ( both staff and babies affected) constant snotty noses all year round . Miserable underpaid staff who cannot afford to eat, cannot share lunch with the children , even though huge amounts of left overs. Staff work hard and are treated like crap by management and parents , unless there's a show around and have to act happy. If staff are miserable then they won't care for children the best. I wouldn't subject my dc to that . I think the ratio of 1:3 is bad for a baby room ( I think ideally it should be 1:2)
You do know not all nurseries are like this though....

There are some excellent providers out there.

Nonamesavail · 06/02/2021 13:17

@strawberriesontheNeva

I've worked in nurseries with big baby rooms . Babies left sitting in bouncy chairs when crying. Picked up only to be fed/ changed. Vomiting/ diarrhoea bugs rampant in winter ( both staff and babies affected) constant snotty noses all year round . Miserable underpaid staff who cannot afford to eat, cannot share lunch with the children , even though huge amounts of left overs. Staff work hard and are treated like crap by management and parents , unless there's a show around and have to act happy. If staff are miserable then they won't care for children the best. I wouldn't subject my dc to that . I think the ratio of 1:3 is bad for a baby room ( I think ideally it should be 1:2)
I left as staff because of this.
strawberriesontheNeva · 06/02/2021 13:16

I've worked in nurseries with big baby rooms . Babies left sitting in bouncy chairs when crying. Picked up only to be fed/ changed.
Vomiting/ diarrhoea bugs rampant in winter ( both staff and babies affected) constant snotty noses all year round . Miserable underpaid staff who cannot afford to eat, cannot share lunch with the children , even though huge amounts of left overs.
Staff work hard and are treated like crap by management and parents , unless there's a show around and have to act happy. If staff are miserable then they won't care for children the best.
I wouldn't subject my dc to that . I think the ratio of 1:3 is bad for a baby room ( I think ideally it should be 1:2)

Mrgrinch · 06/02/2021 13:08

@Eastie77 Thank you, it is only my opinion after all. I think people on here do an excellent job of thinking that their culture is the only one that matters and all others are wrong.

TheJerkStore · 06/02/2021 13:08

@Mrgrinch is entitled to their opinion. Personally I don't agree with it although I understand why some people from some cultures would find the thought of a baby in childcare 5 days a week from morning to evening odd or upsetting. We are looking at this through a Western lens, "...in the US/France it's normal to leave a child in childcare at 4 months.." but whether we like it or not, in many countries around the world it would be considered shocking and tantamount to child abuse to do that.

I don't have an issue with people having differing opinions on childcare. Of course that's okay. However, it becomes a problem when that turns into women being judged for choosing to work.
It's always women that are told they should be feeling guilty for using childcare like it's only for their benefit and men have the right to work without having to consider childcare options or feeling any kind of guilt.
That's when I have a problem with it because it's attitudes like that which is contributing to the fact that it's women's careers that are being disproportionately impacted during the pandemic and why we're seeing women take on the bulk of childcare and homeschooling responsibilities even when they are working and gave a partner at home.

Eastie77 · 06/02/2021 12:50

@Mrgrinch is entitled to their opinion. Personally I don't agree with it although I understand why some people from some cultures would find the thought of a baby in childcare 5 days a week from morning to evening odd or upsetting. We are looking at this through a Western lens, "...in the US/France it's normal to leave a child in childcare at 4 months.." but whether we like it or not, in many countries around the world it would be considered shocking and tantamount to child abuse to do that.

My DC were with a childminder until they started pre-school nursery when they were 3. It was my preferred choice because I didn't think nursery was the right fit for them at 12 months old when I went back to work. When I mentioned this on another childcare thread I was accused of nursery-bashingConfused I don't think there's anything wrong with nurseries at all. My mum sent me to to one and I turned out greatGrin
I simply made a choice based on what was right for my own children. To each their own. These kinds of threads always become very emotive because people (mothers) feel judged whatever childcare or stay at home option they make. Honestly, just do whatever is right for you and your child.

Lelophants · 06/02/2021 12:32

@ShirleyPhallus

I think a lot of people on this thread who say that babies don’t need anyone else except their parents until 18mo have the luxury of older children who weren’t born during covid. My DD is now 10 months and during that time has only ever seen other children and babies from afar. Even her cousins she’s never met up close because her entire life has been in lockdown or restricted. She is absolutely missing out on interaction with other babies. My husband and I can tell she’s bored with spending every day with us and not being able to do much.

So babies might only need to be at home with their parents until 18mo, but that’s assuming that their parents will be socialising them with family / friends / baby group / neighbours etc etc. For those babies born during covid they have had none of that.

My DD will start 2 days of nursery a week when she turns 1 and I’m bloody excited for her. I know she’ll do well and will really enjoy the socialisation aspect of just being around other people. I’m not going to feel guilty for that one bit.

Mine is the same, but they don't need to socialise with other babies until they are 2 minimum. They really do just need to socialise with their main caregiver.
kersh33 · 06/02/2021 12:25

@pitterpatterrain

kersh33 100% - childcare is so culturally shaped, and people can’t see it if they don’t have work colleagues / friends / family that gives them a different perspective

Even within the UK I imagine you have very different attitudes, depending on work type / social circles etc

It's interesting isn't @pitterpatterrain ? Here it really is the norm and no one bats an eyelid. There's certainly no judgement about sending your child to childcare. In fact a lot of people, including my paediatrician, told me how it's better to get babies in childcare before separation anxiety kicks in at 7/8 months. That way they're used to having other people care for them.

Just a very different perspective from back in the UK where there does seem to much more guilt about putting children in nursery.

Butterfly44 · 06/02/2021 11:11

First child part time 3 days from 6 months; full time once got to age 3. Second child 4 days from 6 months to a year then full time. First was anxious to start and it was hard settling in but got there eventually. Very clingy to me and I would feel devastated leaving, but the staff would say as soon as I had left the crying stopped. Going back to work after maternity leave is always hard and takes time to adjust. Second child was a dream, don't know what happened. Other babies would be crying and mine would be chilled like what's the big deal. Staff all wanted to be his keyworker. 😂 Completely different experiences with both of them. But they went to fab nurseries, had a brilliant time learning and forming friendships; and it definitely gave them a great start in life. No regrets.

BettyOBarley · 06/02/2021 11:06

DD started nursery at 3yrs and it was horrendous, she screamed the place down for weeks and she changed from being quite outgoing and forward to really shy (still like that now at 7).

DS started nursery at 13 months and is much more confident and outgoing.

Obviously nursery could have had nothing to do with it and it's just personality types, but I genuinely think keeping DD out until she was 3 did her no favours.

BumbleBeegu · 06/02/2021 11:03

@speakout

I didn't. Only a pre school year at 4- part time ( reception equivalent) Far too busy having fun and learning to want to use nursery.
🤣 Wow 😯
DenisetheMenace · 06/02/2021 10:56

2 1/2 first child, 3 second, both 3 mornings a week. Didn’t need to but they were each ready to begin socialising.

BumbleBeegu · 06/02/2021 10:55

7 months...because I had no choice other than to return to work as a single parent.