Love reusable san pro. Love my menstrual cup. Could never get on with cloth nappies. Wanted to love them, tried with both DC1 and 2 (10 years apart as well) - hate them.
Can't stand the having to do a separate wash - I want to chuck them in with my normal wash like I do for san pro. But they get really stinky because of the volume of wee they absorb, so you end up having to do special washes in the end anyway. Also don't like them hanging around fermenting while waiting to have enough for a full load of just nappies.
Don't like having to be organised enough to be on top of the washing, I sometimes am, but often am not. We also don't have a tumble drier, so in order to replenish the nappy stocks if you're down to the last one involves finding all the nappies, putting a wash on (maybe taking the current wash out and hanging it up, if there's one already in), waiting for it to finish, hanging it up, waiting for it to dry until you have a clean, usable nappy. This kind of string of tasks is quite hard for me as I have ADHD. Whereas we have disposable nappies in packs, so it's easy to see when we're running low, and just add some to the supermarket shop or amazon delivery. I buy own brand nappies and they work fine and aren't expensive. If we do end up down to the last one or two, no worries, because there's normally a couple kicking around in the nappy bag or under a sofa cushion or in the car that can keep us going for a day or two. Or I can even go to the shop with DS in the last nappy, which is immediate and doesn't require me to remember or gather energy later to finish something I've started. Much less tricky for me.
Hate the bulk of them. I don't want to buy special overpriced clothes. I like getting clothes in second hand bundles and at bargain prices without having to worry about whether they're cut for a massive bum. It does look cute in a sleepsuit, but it also looks really uncomfortable, especially for tiny babies who can only lie around with their bum suspended on this massive bulk of nappy. I know some are worse than others for this, but I've never found anything as slim as a disposable and I just think they allow the DC to move easier.
I also don't find they last as long as a disposable and I find people who think they do change disposables way more frequently than I do. We tend to do one nappy overnight, change first thing in the morning, change at nap time and then of course if there are any poos change immediately. So go through 2 or 3 nappies per daytime, I find they are absolutely fine after 4-6 hours. If you leave a reusable one on that long it ends up soaking and uncomfortable and probably leaking. It's enough trying to persuade/wrestle a busy toddler to change once a day let alone every 3 hours!
Also don't like dealing with poo - so much less disgusting to be able to wrap the whole load of awfulness, wipes and everything up into a little ball and dispose of it ASAP. Even for a wee nappy, gathering up the wipes inside the nappy is convenient.
I do really like the patterns and the softness and (when I can get the washing right) nice laundry smell. Also lack of guilt about creating waste. But it just isn't enough to outweigh the downsides for me.