Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Impatiens · 04/02/2021 17:33

but to be presented with a male nurse where you are supposed to pretend they’re female , and go along with the pretence and charade and not mention the elephant in the room , to validate them, nope from me. I would refuse.

Exactly. It's deception, and that's not right.

redpencil77 · 04/02/2021 17:31

@YouJustDoYou

After a horrible, traumatic experience at the hands of a male doctor and 5 male students during a vaginal exam when I was a teenager, I have always since then requested female nurses or doctors where possible. It's never been an issue at all........but now I'm wondering, would it be these days? :(
Do it
Impatiens · 04/02/2021 17:30

Yes anything that touches on the trans issue automatically becomes very inflammatory @katnyps. I agree, it would be great if everyone could be calmly reasonable about it but we're a long way past that.

The tone of some posts may sound objectionable but it's far far less insulting to me than the way the NHS, Midwifery Council quoted by the OP, and so many other organisations have just steamrollered their 'guidance' in without consultation, seemingly without any care for the safety, dignity, beliefs of the Women who'll be directly affected.

Quaagars · 04/02/2021 17:28

And I notice another one from Quagaars is a straw man ('you don't want trans women near you'). Honestly. hmm

Most some of us don't think TWAW. Get over it.

You kind of contradict yourself there.
Hmm face at me for saying you (general you) don''t want trans women near you, it's apparently a straw man?
Then in the next breath say Most of us don't think trans women are women. Get over it.
Not so much of a straw man then, is it? As you're basically agreeing with what I said, seeing as they're apparently not women, even if you do hide the word most behind the strike out feature.

redpencil77 · 04/02/2021 17:27

You ought to say it, you are the victim

redpencil77 · 04/02/2021 17:24

@GaraMedouar

I agree with Hannah1329’s last paragraph.

First I would choose a female, 2nd a male who knows they’re a male and thirdly a male who presents as a woman. Obviously if I was in a life and death situation beggars can’t be choosers. But let’s say I’m going for a smear - then I’d have the female nurse do it, may say yes to the male nurse if for example the female nurse was off sick so he was a stand in and asked if it was ok, if I thought oh what the hell i don’t want to have to rebook again and have the faff, but to be presented with a male nurse where you are supposed to pretend they’re female , and go along with the pretence and charade and not mention the elephant in the room , to validate them, nope from me. I would refuse .

For my kids’ births I only had female midwives. But one birth in hospital I was asked if a male junior doctor could come in at the end , and I was honestly quite happy with that, not a problem.
I knew he was training and needed experience (he was only observing).

I wouldnt go for the smear and make sure they knew why
katnyps · 04/02/2021 17:23

@Impatiens
I think we're on the same page? I'd like to have this discussion without the transphobic tone of some of the more extreme posts - as I think that undermines what is an important topic. It is an anonymous forum though so I should know what to expect

redpencil77 · 04/02/2021 17:19

@JKRisagryff

I don’t know how anyone can say otherwise.

Which is it to be, should a woman who requests a female medic be denied care? Or should she be forced into receiving care from a male-bodied person? This is basically what it comes down to when you’re removing the right to same-sex provision and calling anyone uncomfortable with it bigots. They probably have very good reasons for being distrustful/wary around males.

It would be very nice to be able to say let’s all be kind and get along and sweep all the pressing issues under the rug for now. These are the questions we need straight answers to. No one seems to want to answer these questions as they want to stay woke without having to say out loud, ‘We don’t care about re-traumatising victims of abuse. We don’t care what a woman’s boundaries are. We want women who feel uncomfortable/scared/suspicious around males to put their feelings aside. Males should be allowed to do intimate examinations on uncomfortable/scared/suspicious females to help them feel validated’

And fpr what? Woke virtue signalling
redpencil77 · 04/02/2021 17:17

[quote Glinner]The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662[/quote]
Not unreasonable AT ALL!

Wonder if her permission was sought for the letter - how does it stand with GDPR? I would be going down the legal route if I were Claire

Impatiens · 04/02/2021 17:16

@katnyps

Fair question! To be fair to MN I think some have been taken down but a couple of comments that stand out to me (I only made it up to page 4 rechecking) One post saying the scenario of being seen by a trans women would be "too sinister" and another stating "What I do think is incredibly U however, is health care proffessionals lying about their sex, in order to perform intimate care on a woman.the alarm bells would be deafening me if that ever happened to me. I’d break the land speed record getting out of there. I couldn’t think of anything more overtly dodgy"

Ok, other posters have answered this while I was away but I partly agree with you, the 'tone' isn't great and could be taken as 'transphobic'.

But there is an issue here that specifically relates to transwomen and to the the way the NHS implements their guidelines - that somehow it's unreasonable or phobic of Women not to accept a transwoman as being just like any other woman when we know they're not. It really concerns me.

Terriblewithmoney · 04/02/2021 16:53

@ArabellaScott

Also just want to note that there are currently HCPs identifying as 'female' who were born male. In case anyone thinks this is just hypothetical. One GP practises in London and noted in an interview how women patients would allow more intimate procedures than when said GP identified as a male.
'Noted' is a nice word for the barely concealed relish with which this person talked about this. Envy not envy
Terriblewithmoney · 04/02/2021 16:48

@Quaagars

I actually think that men of any variety should be barred from working in maternity or gynaecology in any capacity

Why?
If they're good at what they do?
I've had lots of lovely male doctors.
The only doctor I have actually gone out of my way to say "just not so and so doctor" when they asked if I had a preference when it came to booking an appointment was a female one who was absolutely awful.
Surely that's taking away choice from women too, who would prefer a male doctor, and I thought "we" (general we) were against taking choice away?

Bloody disingenuous nonsense this. The bastard child of NAMALT and choicey choicey lib fem arseholery with a soupcon of anecdata thrown in for good measure.

And I notice another one from Quagaars is a straw man ('you don't want trans women near you'). Honestly. Hmm

Do we just pick from a list of crap argument techniques and then construct something around whatever comes up?

Most some of us don't think TWAW. Get over it.

ArabellaScott · 04/02/2021 16:43

Also just want to note that there are currently HCPs identifying as 'female' who were born male. In case anyone thinks this is just hypothetical. One GP practises in London and noted in an interview how women patients would allow more intimate procedures than when said GP identified as a male.

ArabellaScott · 04/02/2021 16:40

I also believe that trans women are women

Thats fine, I don't believe it, though. You are welcome to belief in any faith, I am also welcome to not believe in it.

WendyTestaburger · 04/02/2021 16:37

Does anyone know if the Sussex board view, represented by the Claire D exams, is actually reflecting the wider NHS position?

The NHS position is to record gender ID instead of sex. So single sex wards are actually single gender ID wards. So Claire Dimyon, or any of the rest of us, are perfectly entitled to ask for a "female" HCP. It is just that the NHS understands "female" to be a gender ID and not a sex category.

We can all ask for a female HCP but there is no guarantee that we will not be seen by a person who self IDs as female. The NHS would not distinguish between a male bodied person who decided they were trans last week and got HR to update the system or a transexual who had genital surgery a decade ago. And tbh I don't know if I would either To be clear I am talking about the times I am going to be discussing or showing my breasts and or genitals. The majority of my life I am happy to co exist with transwomen, non binary people, and males with or without a gender ID

I don't believe finding this situation concerning is transphobic.

I think it would be more appropriate to be cross with the NHS for having a deceitful policy that is open to being abused. How difficult would it be to record sex AND gender ID? And let's be cross with the males who have treated females so badly that some of us suffer lifelong consequences.

cheeseismydownfall · 04/02/2021 16:31

I think the issue of transwomen providing intimate care to women is actually much, much more problematic than men providing this care.

It is at least straightforward for a woman, when presented with the prospect of having intimate care provided by a male, to say no, and to express their preference for a female. (I say "straightforward" and not "easy" because of course, this still isn't an easy thing for many women to say, especially vulnerable women).

But if that woman is put in the situation where a transwoman is providing intimate care, then suddenly the whole dynamic shifts away from what is best for the woman, and becomes about validating the transwoman and fear of saying or doing something that will get them in trouble. How the FUCK is a vulnerable woman supposed to say, "Hang on a minute, I'm sorry, but actually I want a female here, and you are pretty clearly a male?", when we are being told that it is hateful to 'misgender' someone?

I genuinely question the validity of the consent given by a woman in this situation. A woman who has consented to intimate care from a female has not consented to intimate care from a transwoman.

AngelicInnocent · 04/02/2021 16:31

I think overall, it's the idea of deception that most (not all) posters are unhappy about.

Personally, I don't care what sex my hcp is as long as I have the appropriate chaperone there if required. However, being told that asking for a chaperone is transphobic or bigoted because the male hcp identifies as female would be outrageous.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/02/2021 16:28

katnyps
"What I do think is incredibly U however, is health care proffessionals lying about their sex, in order to perform intimate care on a woman.the alarm bells would be deafening me if that ever happened to me. I’d break the land speed record getting out of there. I couldn’t think of anything more overtly dodgy"
I think both imply what I was referring to - would you interpret differently though?

The argument there might run, transgender and transsex are not the same thing, in the same way that gender and sex are not the same thing, so claiming that they are is surely untruth? And telling an untruth is telling a lie? And telling a lie which you know will get you access to vulnerable naked women is probably ever-so-slightly dodgy...

(For which read, dodgy if someone is discovered to be doing it.)

Sulkywoman · 04/02/2021 16:21

@unmarkedbythat. Why on earth shouldn’t women discuss what we want to discuss here? If you don’t want to, that’s fine but it looks like many do, so just don’t come on and whinge at us.

katnyps · 04/02/2021 16:19

@Impatiens
Fair question! To be fair to MN I think some have been taken down but a couple of comments that stand out to me (I only made it up to page 4 rechecking)
One post saying the scenario of being seen by a trans women would be "too sinister" and another stating "What I do think is incredibly U however, is health care proffessionals lying about their sex, in order to perform intimate care on a woman.the alarm bells would be deafening me if that ever happened to me. I’d break the land speed record getting out of there. I couldn’t think of anything more overtly dodgy"
I think both imply what I was referring to - would you interpret differently though?
There was also another post asking why any trans woman would opt to work in female-sexed healthcare at all - which essentially amounts to expecting trans people to self discriminate. No mention in that post of why men would choose to work in that area.

Sulkywoman · 04/02/2021 16:18

I recently had a breast exam. Found the person doing it was male and said I was surprised and didn’t really appreciate why the female radiographers were not there as usual. The treatment was very rough and pushy...worse than usual . I went through with it to see if my fears were justified or whether I was being unfair to him. I think he muttered something about equal opportunities. I am writing to the organisation about it. I trust my male doctor and am fairly robust but I did feel worried. No chaperone , probably due to Covid and no one else around. I think we should be given a choice to rebook if we are not comfortable. In an emergency it is more difficult, but I do not like the deception involved if a woman is told they are getting a woman and it’s actually a trans woman who turns up.

CoffeeTeaChocolate · 04/02/2021 16:05

I think it should be a choice for women. Especially when it comes to midwives doing the first at-home check a few days after birth.

I was visited by a male midwife (please note not trans, just a genuinely nice, male midwife) without having been asked if I was OK with that. I needed my stitches checked but felt so uncomfortable at the thought of having a man examine my stitches when I was alone with him in my home. I didn’t ask and didn’t get the help I needed. I was too embarrassed to even tell him that I wanted to be checked out by a female midwife.

With my next baby I had a female midwife. I had no issues asking her to check my stitches.

I am usually comfortable with male HCPs, no issues with male gynaecologists etc but I felt extremely vulnerable in the situation I was in and I don’t think it was fair that I wasn’t given the choice.

Impatiens · 04/02/2021 15:54

@katnyps However, I think this fairly reasonable argument gets damaged when people start name calling and giving the strong impression that they assume a significant proportion of trans people working in healthcare are doing this for some nefarious purpose - that, in my view, is transphobic.

I agree, it would be.

I know most people aren't saying that here but there are some pretty transphobic views being discussed here that I think need to be challenged.

Has anyone said that here? I haven't read the whole thread so that's a genuine question. What are the other 'transphobic' views being discussed?

I'm really concerned that any attempt to discuss the needs of Women in these and other areas is continually being derailed by unfounded accusations of 'transphobia'. Every time!

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/02/2021 15:49

Shouldn't it be the case anyway that someone embodying at least three protected characteristics (pregnancy and maternity, sex and religion or belief) should get a higher score in the "entitled" scale than someone embodying only one (gender reassignment) ?

Graphista · 04/02/2021 15:37

@unmarkedbythat clear from the title and op imo you didn't have to open or continue reading the thread if you have no interest in doing so, but I suspect it's more a case of you wanting threads discussing this issue - which affects ALL girls and women - to be "hidden away" - NO! This is important and should be in the general mn sections not just the feminism board

I'm also heartily sick of those of us defending the rights of girls and women - and especially traumatised girls and women - being accused of transphobia!

I have friends who are trans and they actually agree with a lot if not all of the elements of practices needed to protect and keep emotionally comfortable women who have good reasons to not want trans women in their sex protected spaces. Ime the majority of them "get it" it's a vocal minority that are arses about all this and they are as offended by them and their actions as we are, mainly as they feel it means trans people are gaining a reputation of being ignorant, dismissive and uncaring towards women and girls who do have concerns and fears. Frankly from discussions with those friends the people they know in real life who are arsey about trans rights they say were ALWAYS arseholes it's nothing to do with them being trans. This is just their latest bandwagon!