Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SnackSizeRaisin · 04/02/2021 20:59

I would like to know how many women here who would have let a strange male midwife check their stitches when they were completely alone with him in their homes.

I was offered a male midwife and ended up enrolling with a different midwifery service because I felt uncomfortable with the idea. (Didn't know if it might be frowned upon to request a woman midwife!) It's not that I mind male doctors or feel uneasy , it's more that being pregnant, giving birth and the recovery might require a lot of possibly trivial but intimate issues and I would be uncomfortable discussing with a man (especially as men can't possibly understand about what it's like - even a woman who hasn't had children can still relate to what a lot of the issues are). So whilst I wouldn't mind a man being at the birth or suturing my nether regions, I would not want them trying to give breastfeeding advice or discussing the after effects of a bad tear. As to the idea of a man making home visits after the birth... well that just seems like it will upset a lot of vulnerable women who probably won't dare to say anything. I wonder about the motives of a man who becomes a midwife. Surely they can't do a very good job because most women will feel too awkward.
This seems one area where women need care from other women. The rights of transwomen should be secondary. What genuine transwoman would want to be a midwife, knowing that it will upset women?

Sulkywoman · 04/02/2021 20:58

Omg. Alex Sobel is my Mp. I have been writing to him for years and I even voted for him in the wrong belief he was listening . I am not surprised that he has not written back to me for ages. Of course it is Leeds which is where the wonderful Managed area of prostitution in Holbeck is unquestioned by the Labour Party. Shit shit shit.

WendyTestaburger · 04/02/2021 20:38

@IWillSqueakAgain

Please stop using the term trans issue.

This isn’t a trans issue it’s a women’s rights one. It always has been always will be. Even if they make self id law it will still be an issue relating to those of us who were born female exclusively (we just won’t be free to say that...)

Yes you are right.

It is certainly not women who wanted trans people to be anything to do with this issue. The fact that they are is solely due to the successful lobbying by people (not necessarily trans people) who push a very specific form of trans activism that demands that we believe that people can change sex because they say so.

So first women are screwed by our misogynist society where rape is practically legal.

Secondly screwed by our patriarchal healthcare systems, which ignore our symptoms and use the male body as default.

Thirdly screwed by the aforementioned lobby groups insisting organisations such as NHS behave as if TWAW, thus over riding our rights to single sex care.

Fourthly (is that a word?) screwed all over again when we object by being branded "transphobic".

And we've no one to vote for who gives a shit.

THANKS GUYS

Impatiens · 04/02/2021 20:30

That person is an MP??

Terriblewithmoney · 04/02/2021 20:25

Thanks for pointing me in the direction of Alex's twitter feed Glinner. Alex is a monumental arsehole isn't he? And one who clearly doesn't understand his own manifesto, bless him.

Nice ratios there though Grin

Thewithesarehere · 04/02/2021 20:24

[quote Glinner]This is extraordinary grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/just-a-flat-no[/quote]
Yeah the sheer level of stupidity is astounding.

Glinner · 04/02/2021 20:05

This is extraordinary grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/just-a-flat-no

OP posts:
YouSetTheTone · 04/02/2021 20:00

Women are biologically hardwired to feel uncomfortable in the situation described by @CoffeeTeaChocolate. Our instincts are primed to alert us to possible danger when in the presence of strange male. Not because we’re irrational rude people. Not because we’re being ‘unkind’. But because men are physically superior and until we can do a risk assessment we’re meant to be alert to that.
I think that being forced to constantly override this in order to be polite or inclusive is unfair and as usual puts men in an even stronger position in society.

Datun · 04/02/2021 19:06

CoffeeTeaChocolate
I don’t think it necessarily is about trans people and I am actually quite offended if we cannot discuss this.

It's not. I agree.

But it's the expectation that certain men are beyond question.

But, of course, it's any man. And I too, would feel horribly uncomfortable having a man in my home wanting to intimately examine me when I was expecting a woman.

I mean, it's completely normal, ffs!!!

None of this should even be up for question. And no cohort within the male sex, gets a pass based on something they say.

CoffeeTeaChocolate · 04/02/2021 19:05

Thank you terriblewithmoney. I felt like I was going mad. He was lovely, very good with my baby and seemed to know his profession, but he was the one doing home visits to all women who just had a baby in my area.

Post natal care is so much about pelvic floor, stitches, bleeding and it is so hard to discuss with a strange man in your home. If just felt weird and way too intimate. With my second child he was apparently on holiday and I had a female midwife. I cannot explain how much better I felt with that.

There should be a choice. And there should be a debate on this. And however lovely this man is, he should only do home visits to women who consent.

Dutch1e · 04/02/2021 19:05

@katnyps I am also offended by the fact that men are statistically dangerous to women.

Terriblewithmoney · 04/02/2021 19:00

@CoffeeTeaChocolate

I don’t think it necessarily is about trans people and I am actually quite offended if we cannot discuss this.

I was visited in my home when I was alone with my baby by a male midwife. Not trans, a male presenting male.

I felt unable to ask him to check my stitches (which hurt a lot), very uncomfortable to discuss it with him. His advice to me for a bad back after labour was to carry down my pram three floors and take a long walk.

I don’t think it was acceptable that I wasn’t even informed that a male midwife would be coming. I would have loved a choice.

I would like to know how many women here who would have let a strange male midwife check their stitches when they were completely alone with him in their homes.

Hospital settings are completely different.

I think that's awful. And I'm sorry but I do question the motives - or at the very least the judgement - of a man choosing to work in this tole. Two posters on here saying they were put in this situation and felt unable to ask for proper medical care - that's unacceptable.
CoffeeTeaChocolate · 04/02/2021 18:57

I don’t think it necessarily is about trans people and I am actually quite offended if we cannot discuss this.

I was visited in my home when I was alone with my baby by a male midwife. Not trans, a male presenting male.

I felt unable to ask him to check my stitches (which hurt a lot), very uncomfortable to discuss it with him. His advice to me for a bad back after labour was to carry down my pram three floors and take a long walk.

I don’t think it was acceptable that I wasn’t even informed that a male midwife would be coming. I would have loved a choice.

I would like to know how many women here who would have let a strange male midwife check their stitches when they were completely alone with him in their homes.

Hospital settings are completely different.

IWillSqueakAgain · 04/02/2021 18:53

Please stop using the term trans issue.

This isn’t a trans issue it’s a women’s rights one. It always has been always will be. Even if they make self id law it will still be an issue relating to those of us who were born female exclusively (we just won’t be free to say that...)

Quaagars · 04/02/2021 18:48

So while that's still a small percentage it reflects an ever growing number of voters who believe women have no right to request a female HCP and yet somehow cannot find the words to express why, on this anonymous forum.

Or more likely and has been said on the thread that of course people don't have problems with women being able to request other women, it's the way it's been worded to confuscate the issue that it's really about trans people.
So there'll be some voting YABU for this.
Not because they don't think women should have a choice, that they're not comfortable with the transphobic issue that underlies reasonable concerns.

Thewithesarehere · 04/02/2021 18:44

@ArabellaScott

I also believe that trans women are women

Thats fine, I don't believe it, though. You are welcome to belief in any faith, I am also welcome to not believe in it.

Aptly put.
prisencolinensinainciusol2 · 04/02/2021 18:39

@WendyTestaburger

Just noticing the ratio is hovering around 11% whilst the number of votes goes steadily up. So while that's still a small percentage it reflects an ever growing number of voters who believe women have no right to request a female HCP and yet somehow cannot find the words to express why, on this anonymous forum.

It's that #nodebate thing. I'd not heard of it until I came to Mumsnet.

YouSetTheTone · 04/02/2021 18:34

I have a problem with being forced to accept intimate/ Medical care from an individual who insists their rights trump mine.
I’m not saying this individual doesn’t have a right to work in that role but I am saying that if I am uncomfortable with them performing that role on me then I’m entitled to say so without being called a bigot or to accept their care or nothing.

If I walk into a room with a medical professional I want our rights to be equal. I want to be able to say I respect you as a person but seeing as sex is a protected characteristic I’d like to request that I have a professional of the same sex as me if I deem it necessary.
If that person insisted on making me go against this wish because it would hurt their feelings I want to know why their feelings are more important than mine in this situation. And I want my feelings to be protected legally.

LangClegsInSpace · 04/02/2021 18:28

what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not?

I don't think it's that high a number. The text in the image says it's 0.6%. I seem to remember the BBC proudly announcing that 3% of their workforce was trans. Now that's high and goes some way to explaining a few things IMO.

YANBU about any of the rest of it.

LangClegsInSpace · 04/02/2021 18:20

@LexxaM

Indeed so but the issue of competing rights is important. The right of males to identify as women v the rights of other groups who don’t wish to have males attend to them. The Equality Act protects sex, gender reassignment, religious views. Which is most important when they conflict? How to solve this problem?
You use the occupational requirement general exception in Schedule 9, Part 1.

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/schedule/9/part/1/crossheading/general

Explanatory notes here:

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/notes/division/3/16/26/1/1

Skysblue · 04/02/2021 17:56

I learned recently (support group) that the majority of women suffering a disease who have a certain medical treatment will not discuss the sexual side effects of that treatment with male doctors/nurses, only with female staff. Everyone in the support group said they felt too embarrassed and uncomfortable raising their sexual problems with men. Everyone in the group who’d had that specific treatment was experiencing sexual problems as a side effect. The few lucky enough to see a female doctor had reported the side effects and were getting treatment adjustments, but the majority hadn’t reported the issue to their medical provider because of a lack of a female practitioner.

I mention this because there are women right now not reporting significant medical side effects to their medical providers because they are being seen by men. Irrespective of any trans/gender stuff, the people saying ‘what’s the problem with male doctors’ are very naive.

Apologies for the lack of detail am trying to stay anonymous 😬

Datun · 04/02/2021 17:45

@katnyps

Fair question! To be fair to MN I think some have been taken down but a couple of comments that stand out to me (I only made it up to page 4 rechecking) One post saying the scenario of being seen by a trans women would be "too sinister" and another stating "What I do think is incredibly U however, is health care proffessionals lying about their sex, in order to perform intimate care on a woman.the alarm bells would be deafening me if that ever happened to me. I’d break the land speed record getting out of there. I couldn’t think of anything more overtly dodgy"

You might want to take that up with Stonewall, in that case. They have included transvestism and cross dressing in the cohort of transwomen. An awful lot of these problems stem from that.

They have said it's perfectly legitimate to include sexually motivated male individuals in this cohort.

It's not fair to pretend they haven't, nor expect women to not acknowledge that.

Impatiens · 04/02/2021 17:42

seeing as they're apparently not women

There's no 'apparently' about it. Stop derailing the thread, this is a crucially important discussion.

Terriblewithmoney · 04/02/2021 17:34

@Quaagars

And I notice another one from Quagaars is a straw man ('you don't want trans women near you'). Honestly. hmm

Most some of us don't think TWAW. Get over it.

You kind of contradict yourself there.
Hmm face at me for saying you (general you) don''t want trans women near you, it's apparently a straw man?
Then in the next breath say Most of us don't think trans women are women. Get over it.
Not so much of a straw man then, is it? As you're basically agreeing with what I said, seeing as they're apparently not women, even if you do hide the word most behind the strike out feature.

No. I am fine with transwomen near me.

I do not believe they are women.

THOSE. ARE. DIFFERENT. THINGS.

PurBal · 04/02/2021 17:33

I actually don't mind male care despite the fact I was sexually assaulted by a male GP. Totally up to the individual.