Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
NotBadConsidering · 05/02/2021 09:14

So a severely disabled, non verbal child who can’t advocate for themselves at all has their safeguarding and dignity entirely disregarded because the school has decided to ignore the law that is designed to support that child’s need for same sex care

And this has happened to someone I know. A woman found out her severely intellectually impaired teenage daughter was having her nappies changed by a male, despite being told the gender of the person was “female”. No one respected the girl’s right or her mother’s right in this instance.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/02/2021 09:14

One of the comments on the Guardian article I just posted:

It's also disappointing that some women chose not to be cared for by you. It's a side of sexism that we rarely hear about - surely in this day and age we should accept that anyone can do any job regardless of their gender. Clearly some people will be bashful about exposing their genitals to a man, but to anyone with medical training the genitals are just another functional aspect of the body like any other, and there is no need for the taboo.

ParadiseIsland · 05/02/2021 09:13

Because they are women now, didn’t you know?
So they can’t possibly sexually assault at or rape a child because only MEN rape....

Actually, I think we also need to say loud and clear that if there is such a thing as a female penis then there is also such a thing as female rape. And that female rape is just as bad and unacceptable as male rape.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/02/2021 09:11

Here's a male midwife who thinks women's distress at not being able to object when uncomfortable is funny, and that he is the victim of "sexism" by women who didn't want him to treat them:

I’m 50 now and have encountered a certain amount of sexism in my career. I’ve had 118 people – mostly women – refuse to be cared for by me. I have had other patients who were shocked to see a man; there was one who didn’t say anything, but the look of total shock on her face was very funny. Most people assume I’m a doctor when they see me. I have to be very aware of that. My gender is technically irrelevant, but there are underlying perceptions and unconscious attitudes.

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2019/may/09/tutor-not-job-man-roofer-male-midwife-nhs

gardenbird48 · 05/02/2021 09:08

I read recently about a lady whose disabled child was in a special school. She was very upset because the school has introduced a policy of allowing staff to self declare their ‘gender’ which would be recorded instead of their sex.

This meant that the parent could no longer specify a same sex carer to perform any intimate care for the child.

So a severely disabled, non verbal child who can’t advocate for themselves at all has their safeguarding and dignity entirely disregarded because the school has decided to ignore the law that is designed to support that child’s need for same sex care.

We know that sexual assaults on vulnerable children happen. We know that predatory males will put in a lot of effort to access victims - why try and make it easier?

ParadiseIsland · 05/02/2021 09:07

I don’t think the issue is with men choosing a career as a MW. The issue imo is much deeper.
I think most people, men or women, believe that being professional is what matters and the sex of the HCP doesn’t matter. Of course, being professional is essential. But I suspect there has been very few studies looking at the effect of the sex of the HCP on the care WOMEN receive. I also suspect that even when there is an obvious issue (eg @Dinosauratemydaffodils), the answer is never ‘this happens because the HCP was a male’. These types of occurence are classified under ‘previous MH issues’.
The fact that some trauma has been reactivated by the presence of a male HCP is ignored. Because well.... women’s feeling are often discounted as not important (or nit as important as...).. I really think that, in dinosaur case, said HCP reacted that way. He has done everything right, was kind, professional etc... so how could he be the reason for all her struggles?

Link to that is the fact that acknowledging that also means acknowledging the fact that sex matters. In that we are in a society where one sex is living under the regular fear if the other. Of course, on a day to bay basis, it doesn’t show. But I d8nt think many people, men or women, actually know what are the stats of the REAL level of rape and sexual assaults and general body harm sustain by women. Because they don’t report it. (Or maybe can’t report it... see how the system is set up). Nor are the studies showing how men would readily rape a woman if they know they wouldn’t get caught (or actually have no idea that what they did is was rape).
We go back to minimising ‘women over react/cry for wolf/are too emotional etc...’

prisencolinensinainciusol2 · 05/02/2021 09:06

Of course it is Leeds which is where the wonderful Managed area of prostitution in Holbeck is unquestioned by the Labour Party...

Ah, Holbeck. The one place in Leeds where they do know what a woman is.

CoffeeTeaChocolate · 05/02/2021 08:58

I disagree with the view that men’s choices in terms of professions should be limited. But there should be a choice to have an alternative HCP

There are some amazing male obstetricians. I had a high risk pregnancy and was seeing obstetricians in a clinic bi-weekly. I never felt in any way bad when a male obstetrician picked up my file.

Have you heard of professor Nikolaides? His work in fetal medicine is absolutely pioneering (he invented early methods for NT screening, screening for risks of premature birth and how to save the babies in twin-to-twin transfusion). He has a passion to help pregnant women and their children and he is a very kind man.

I think everyone should be allowed to choose their careers, men and women and follow their interests. That is the way we can have amazing, caring professionals.

However, there needs to be a choice for women and men women to be treated by HCPs of the sex they prefer. Some women may want their midwife or obstetrician to be female. Some men may want the person to do a prostrate exam to be male.

I cannot believe that some people are trying to take that choice away. And to accuse people of various things when they try to execute that choice is horrific. Why would you try to close down a discussion about choice with alluding to nasty undercurrents in thinking?

I find this frightening.

WouldBeGood · 05/02/2021 08:47

I’ll think on it.

Like many my views are shaped partly by personal experience and I’ve been traumatised by treatment by women both in life and in medical care. But I see the issue and the views of others and will give it proper thought.

I do agree with the right to choose.

yetmorenamechanging · 05/02/2021 08:25

To add: they become gentle and understanding BUT that doesn't mean they're not causing women distress.

Btw it doesn't at all mean all male medics are abusers, not at all. That's again centering them. It's not about them, it's about all women's experiences!

yetmorenamechanging · 05/02/2021 08:18

[quote WouldBeGood]@Kettledodger I think I just wanted to make the point that I don’t think men should be prevented from doing these jobs. I did say there should be a choice.[/quote]

Why should a man have a right to do a job that will cause some of the client base - exclusively women - discomfort? It's not like he can switch to specialising on men. It's totally guaranteed that there will be some women throughout his career who he will make very uncomfortable and they won't be able to say, due to past sexual trauma. This is guaranteed.

So, why does he have a right to enter that profession? Why does his personal interest in a specific part of human biology and function override every woman's right to not be triggered by having a man they don't know touching and seeing their genitals. And quite honestly, why would he even want to when it's put like that? Why is the focus on him and his rights and interested and wants and not on the well-being of all women?

I think it's usually not put like that and these men, if they're the nice ones, don't think about it at the beginning of their careers, but they get it later on and become super gentle and understanding.

There's a sponsored/sticky thread from the MoJ saying that 1 in 8 women are sexually assaulted at some point in their lives. That's an awful lot of women. That basically means on an average single day, every single ob/gyn in the country is seeing a patient who has been sexually assaulted. It's not just one or two women on a Mumsnet thread!

Glinner · 05/02/2021 08:06

"All those saying that they have male nurses etc it's not the point. The right to choose is the cornerstone of the feminist movement. Our choice is being taken away...therefore I see this as a step backwards and that should worry ALL women."

The people who pretend not to understand this point, you have to wonder about their motives.

OP posts:
WouldBeGood · 05/02/2021 08:00

@Kettledodger I think I just wanted to make the point that I don’t think men should be prevented from doing these jobs. I did say there should be a choice.

Kettledodger · 05/02/2021 01:48

All those saying that they have male nurses etc it's not the point. The right to choose is the cornerstone of the feminist movement. Our choice is being taken away...therefore I see this as a step backwards and that should worry ALL women.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 05/02/2021 01:34

As one of my children was delivered by a male It's really not something I can get worked up about. The person delivering would be a medical professional would they not?

Lucky you. A male delivered dc1. He was professional, kind and gentle. He also triggered my pre existing ptsd. Dc1 went to nicu and I had a psychotic break. I don't remember the first six months of my son's life. I tried to kill myself when he was 36 hours old.

Dc2 (after 2 years of intensive therapy on the NHS) was delivered by an amazing team of women.

Both Doctors were professional and kind but their sex made a huge difference to me and my family.

Impatiens · 05/02/2021 01:23

Is that all anyone requires from a doctor/nurse/midwife etc, that they be a professional? Surely that's the bare minimum? We need skill, empathy, trustworthiness.

Tvci5 · 05/02/2021 00:57

As one of my children was delivered by a male It's really not something I can get worked up about. The person delivering would be a medical professional would they not?

Quaagars · 05/02/2021 00:13

Actually Quaagars, despite only a brief acquaintance I've already got into the habit of mostly scrolling past your posts in the certain knowledge there'll be nothing useful or new there.

Fair enough, but commenting on something you clearly haven't read (like you've just admitted) just for a dig smacks a bit echo chamber like.

bellropes · 05/02/2021 00:10

I was seriously sexually assaulted by male medics on two different occasions. I don't go for smear tests or mammograms because I can't face being undressed and things done to me. If I did turn up and a man was doing those tests I wouldn't be able to cope, so I don't bother with either.

Impatiens · 05/02/2021 00:05

Actually Quaagars, despite only a brief acquaintance I've already got into the habit of mostly scrolling past your posts in the certain knowledge there'll be nothing useful or new there.

Quaagars · 04/02/2021 23:59

Regular as clockwork and just as predictable

If you scroll up a little bit you'll see I already addressed that.

Impatiens · 04/02/2021 23:56

And make your mind up Quagaars. Is it transphobia you're uncovering here or misandry? Or is it just that whenever women say anything about womens rights on AIBU or FWR you need to pop up with righteous ire arguing that you're really terribly reasonable but actually the horrible prejudice must be exposed?

Regular as clockwork and just as predictable.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 23:48

also people don't want trans women around them because "they're male."

Well, yes they are. Not sure why you put it in quotes as if it's disputed?

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 04/02/2021 23:44

it's kind of both because you get those insinuating that males must be doing midwifery type roles because of some perv reason, and also people don't want trans women around them because "they're male."

And are you asking why?

I personally don't want Adam's apples and their owners anywhere near me when I'm vulnerable. That's not because I think they are all sick perverts but because they trigger my ptsd (to the point of psychosis when a man delivered dc1).

I question men in midwifery/rape counselling centres not because I think they're perverts but because I don't understand choosing a caring profession knowing that potentially a large percentage of your patients might be uncomfortable and/or traumatised by you. I've worked with vulnerable people and their needs came first. I understood why the woman who had her 4th child taken off her didn't want pregnant me anywhere near her...People with Adam's apples should understand why I don't want them near me. If they lack that empathy then they are in the wrong job.

radicalnotion · 04/02/2021 23:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.