Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
mootymoo · 05/02/2021 12:07

I had a male midwife at one point, I was asked if I minded, which I didn't. He was excellent. It comes down to whether we think it's ok to insist on the sex/gender of medical practitioners, and in what circumstances? Is it just for a predefined list of procedures? Does this mean men can refuse a female gp for sensitive consultations?

I personally think medical professionals should be allocated on experience for the procedure required not their chromosomes, subsequent gender identity or choice of gendered clothing. My OB/GYN was male and the most experienced consultant in south London at the time, he treated my grandmother before me and remembered me years later - rejecting him for his registrar would have been rather foolish in my opinion!

There are not many male midwives, even fewer trans ones, so generally they can accommodate requests but should we have the right to demand same sex, no not in my opinion because it could have negative consequences to others

picklemewalnuts · 05/02/2021 11:53

I'm so shocked at that article Ereshkigalangcleg!

There are so many examples of why he shouldn't be a midwife- laughing at the woman who wanted to get her stomach back being the least of them.

I agree men should have the choice of every area of medical specialism just as women should. However some situations should not arise. Male midwives as part of a team, with women around and other people on the ward- not a problem. Women should still be able to specify female care without prejudice. Men in women's homes, alone- absolutely not.

I was accidentally booked in to see a male gp for my smear. I hadn't thought to specify because it had always been a nurse before. It didn't occur to me even in passing that a man would be doing my smear. And I didn't refuse or rebook.

It sickens me, actually, that these battles are still ongoing.
Men should be able to request care from a male.
If he is treated by a female HCP, he may feel a bit embarrassed or uncomfortable (although he's probably socialised to accept care from women and may well find it more comfortable than from a man). However, he also knows that very very few sex offenders are women. Odds suggest he's absolutely safe.

Women don't have that same security!

DaisiesandButtercups · 05/02/2021 11:35

Thank you @JoodyBlue! I have bookmarked the video to watch later.

DaisiesandButtercups · 05/02/2021 11:31

I want to quote @yetmorenamechanging from 08:18 for some reason I can’t.

The points are clearly made in that post.

I do question the motives of men who decide to be midwives, obstetricians and gynaecologists.

Yes they must know that a not insignificant number of women will be distressed when they walk into the room or their homes and that women will be inhibited in sharing information.

Doesn’t it display a degree of arrogance or lack of empathy in those men?

They certainly have a degree of access to women’s bodies which some other men might find enviable.

It must bolster their self esteem when women are amazed at how kind, gentle and lovely they are.

Does anyone doubt that there are enough “lovely” and highly skilled women who work in these professions and the possibility that we don’t need any new men joining these professions, we have enough capable and caring women.

It is interesting how when a profession is made up primarily of women the few men will rise to the highest paid posts and take charge in roles where they get to dictate policy.

When a man walks into a room of women there is an immediate change of atmosphere which is palpable. We are so socialised to placate and please, to defer to and respect male authority. Many women will immediately and unconsciously pay attention to the man and his needs be it out of primal fear or that socialisation to serve him.

In women’s health care it is women who should be centred. We could ask for this if we wanted it. Yes we should have the right to request a same sex health care professional but in maternity and gynaecology why should we have to? Imagine how much confidence it would give to women and girls to know that they wouldn’t be confronted with having to make that request.

ThornAmongstRoses · 05/02/2021 11:27

This isn’t meant to be goady, I’m genuinely curious - Is it the chromosomes that matter or whether they have a penis or not?

For me i would have a problem with any male person. And I would need it to be explained that the person was female if I had requested a female and a person arrived who appeared male. Then I would be ok. But other women draw the line differently.

So as long as they have the XX chromosomes then they are ok?

So if a man walked in, deep voice, facial hair, male physique and had a penis, you would be happy having him there as long as you understood he had XX female chromosomes?

So what is it that about the chromosomes that make someone ‘ok’ even if everything else about them is male?

I just find the whole concept really interesting.

I admit that if I were to have a smear for example and it was performed by a biological male who presented as a male I would feel a bit uncomfortable but I don’t really understand why? Even if there was a female chaperone there (say a practice nurse) so I knew the male doctor wasn’t going to harm me, I would still feel a bit uncomfortable. But as a previous poster said, they’re just genitals to medical staff and male professionals have probably seen 100’s of vaginas in their time depending on their career.

Someone has said something along the lines of they can’t believe male midwives are allowed.....but why is it ok for male obstetricians then? Or should that be a female only professional too? No males should be allowed to enter that field?

I had no idea that mammographers weren’t allowed to be males as another poster said?! Does that mean male GPs aren’t allowed to perform a breast examination if a woman presents with concerns about a lump she’s found?

The whole thing is so complex.

I 100% agree that women should have the freedom of choice to select personal cares, examinations and treatments etc from female staff - absolutely - but it’s such a complicated matter.

As I said though - I fully support a woman’s right to choose and she should be allowed the freedom to make that choice.

gardenbird48 · 05/02/2021 11:16

I am not 100% opposed to intimate care from men but in a non emergency setting when it's just me and the HCP in a room then yes, that person needs to female, to avoid the extra level of anxiety and fear that comes with a male HCP, however good they are

And most decent male hcps would offer or want a chaperone when treating a woman to ensure that everything is obviously ‘above board’ and to protect themselves from any possibility, however rare, of false accusations. The report by Nursing and Midwifery union said that male hcps are significantly more likely to be involved in sexual assault allegations. Sadly the majority of these will be guilty.

Any male (however they identify) too keen on being alone to do an intimate examination on a woman should be treated with caution.

parallax80 · 05/02/2021 11:08

I’m sorry but that statement is exactly what women experience in professions every day. Mechanics, plumbers, electricians.... the list for women meeting this reaction is far longer. And a female plumber isn’t wanting to check your pipes

And, ironically, medicine!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/02/2021 11:08

Re psychiatric wards, there was recently a webinar about ensuring sexual safety on mental health wards. One of the panel was an MTF nurse who was placed on a women's locked mental health ward.

This person in later conversations appeared to have little regard for the rights or feelings of the female patients who had no choice in the matter. Neither did any of the women on the webinar, and they all complained about the "transphobia" of people daring to speak up for these vulnerable women.

asIlayfrying · 05/02/2021 11:02

The problem is as others have said that to object to a transwoman is seen as bigotry. It's also easier for some than others to say 'transwomen are women.'

To me they aren't. They are transwomen - people who chose to live as women, who feel on some level they are women, but are to me male.

I will never not see that. I will never look at a transwoman and believe they are a woman in the same way I am. In a healthcare setting I would not be able to behave as if I was being treated by a female. I am not 100% opposed to intimate care from men but in a non emergency setting when it's just me and the HCP in a room then yes, that person needs to female, to avoid the extra level of anxiety and fear that comes with a male HCP, however good they are.

I cannot help my physical responses and don't want to suppress them as they are my protection and I rely on them and have from a young age.

It's a big - for me impossible - thing to ask, that people believe such a fundamental transformation from male to female can simply occur.

We know that male HCPs assault vulnerable women. Sometimes they get caught but mostly they are protected, though that is changing.

Therefore I would never accept care from a transwoman if I could get up and walk out, and that is not transphobic.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/02/2021 11:01

Grr, even the word 'bashful' gets my bloody up. The Grauniad and its equally ignorant readers can fuck the fuck off with that noise.

What I thought too!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/02/2021 11:00

This isn’t meant to be goady, I’m genuinely curious - Is it the chromosomes that matter or whether they have a penis or not?

For me i would have a problem with any male person. And I would need it to be explained that the person was female if I had requested a female and a person arrived who appeared male. Then I would be ok. But other women draw the line differently.

334bu · 05/02/2021 10:56

No just the fact that they are male.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/02/2021 10:56

He acknowledges that people think he's a doctor (perceived as higher status) without calling out the sexism back the other way.

Rockinmomma · 05/02/2021 10:55

I’m 50 now and have encountered a certain amount of sexism in my career. I’ve had 118 people – mostly women – refuse to be cared for by me. I have had other patients who were shocked to see a man; there was one who didn’t say anything, but the look of total shock on her face was very funny. Most people assume I’m a doctor when they see me. I have to be very aware of that. My gender is technically irrelevant, but there are underlying perceptions and unconscious attitudes
I’m sorry but that statement is exactly what women experience in professions every day. Mechanics, plumbers, electricians.... the list for women meeting this reaction is far longer. And a female plumber isn’t wanting to check your pipes WinkHmm

ThornAmongstRoses · 05/02/2021 10:48

So what happens if they bring in a post op transsexual who is biologically male with XY chromosomes yet looks like a woman and lives as a woman, and does not have a penis? Would that be ok? Even though she’s actually of the male sex?

For example it’s not the actually the chromosomes and biological sex that is the issue, it’s whether the person has a penis or not?

Or what if they were to send in a pre-op transexual who although still had female XX chromosomes he looked like a man and lived like a man (but without a penis), he had a deep voice and facial hair due to hormones etc, but because he had the female XX chromosomes he was assigned to you because technically he’s of the female sex which you asked for?

I’m just curious to where the line is drawn?

This isn’t meant to be goady, I’m genuinely curious - Is it the chromosomes that matter or whether they have a penis or not?

prisencolinensinainciusol2 · 05/02/2021 10:47

Word female obvs - very busy

prisencolinensinainciusol2 · 05/02/2021 10:47

I suppose we have to rely on them interpreting the female properly.

Check with Stonewalls first?

LangClegsInSpace · 05/02/2021 10:44

I don't think it's outrageous to be questioning why men are allowed to be midwives. They're not allowed to be NHS mammographers.

Breast screening involves having an X-ray (mammogram) at a special clinic or mobile breast screening unit. This is done by a female health practitioner called a mammographer.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/breast-cancer-screening/what-happens/

JoodyBlue · 05/02/2021 10:41

@DaisiesandButtercups astonishing interview here with Kate Coleman on this subject.

DaisiesandButtercups · 05/02/2021 10:28

There are now apparently “female” rapists I believe as crimes are reported on gender identity rather than sex.

The last thing we need in my opinion. Please let us hold on the objective fact and biological reality in law as in medicine.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 05/02/2021 10:21

Actually, I think we also need to say loud and clear that if there is such a thing as a female penis then there is also such a thing as female rape. And that female rape is just as bad and unacceptable as male rape.

But - as I'm sure is the point you're making - there is no such thing as a 'female penis' so the question is moot. In following your reasoning it's pretty much impossible to arrive at any other logical conclusion, but logic and even plain old reality are elusive in this debate. And unfortunately the emperors new clothes are still remaining stubbornly 'visible', and freedom isn't the freedom to say that 2+2=4.

It's like transubstantiation. You can point at something and declare to the hilt that it isn't really what it appears to be but something else. But it ain't corpus Christi. It's still a boring old wafer.

nothingcomestonothing · 05/02/2021 10:19

a male who identified as a woman came into the psychiatric ward where I was a patient... She was placed on the woman's wing but with a support worker permanently sat outside her door. It did make many of us feel a bit uncomfortable. The worst thing was after being on leave 'she' came back for a discharge meeting and was now identifying as a man.

I just wanted to highlight this important post from UndertheCedartree. Women in a psychiatric ward had their choice taken away from them, because the choice of a male was prioritised. And I say male, as they had decided to be one again, once not in a psychiatric ward. How is it ok for women in such a vulnerable position to be overridden in this way?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 05/02/2021 10:00

PP quoting this 'comment' from the Guardian.

Clearly some people will be bashful about exposing their genitals to a man, but to anyone with medical training the genitals are just another functional aspect of the body like any other, and there is no need for the taboo.

Fucking hell, I've just seen red mist. And that never happens to me.

What is it with these intrusive arseholes who think they have the right to decide other people's personal boundaries and bodily autonomy for them? Just who are these fuckers? And what do they stand to gain from it?

Like so many women on this site I too am a victim of sexual assault, sexually aggressive behaviour and rape (gang rape). Yes, my Ob Gyn was a truly wonderful bloke, and given he was also my infertility consultant I'll be indebted to him for the rest of my life. But I WILL decide that boundary. No one else. In many other circumstances I don't want some male I don't know or trust implicitly poking around in my nether regions. And I'm within my full rights to reject that.

They can get to fuck with these suggestions that women of a similar mind are guilty of 'sexism'. And I want to know: why the persistent pressure on women (and it is only women) to ignore their boundaries and not to listen to their own gut instincts? Why are some people relentlessly pushing at those boundaries and prodding at women? And what do they stand to gain from it? (I'm including some other women in this too BTW). Women are not bothering men: we are not constantly running about pushing and prodding at their boundaries and making perpetual demands on them. Why can't they just leave us alone?

Grr, even the word 'bashful' gets my bloody up. The Grauniad and its equally ignorant readers can fuck the fuck off with that noise.

ParadiseIsland · 05/02/2021 09:22

In a bid to make our society equal, we’ve made a lot of things gender neutral.
So everyone can be whatever they want or have whatever job they want for example. We all have the same rights (and should also have the same responsibilities).

The problem is that
1- by making everyone equal, we actually expect everyone to act like men. Being a man being the default position. And everything is ‘making things complicated’. In some ways, it’s a left over from attitudes we see in science for example (women are too complicated with their hormones. Men physiology is the ‘norm’). Also comes from the fact women have been finding hard to prove they are ‘as good as men’ and ‘the same’ (as just as able than)

2- we are deliberately ignoring the fact that actually men and women are different. They are raised differently, they have different experiences in life and therefore are NOT the same. It’s staring in our faces all day long but it’s also a good way then beat women with a stick by saying ‘we are the same therefore if you are uncomfortable/don’t progress at work/feel threaten, this is all YOUR fault as a person.’ Nothing to do with being a woman.
Obviously also applies to all the gyne stuff we’ve been talking about in this thread.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/02/2021 09:15

That's awful.