Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MissKhan1990 · 06/02/2021 11:13

Muslim here. Yes, if possible l would request a female doctor for religious reasons but it's also cultural. I've avoided as much as possible showing myself to any man. Now l'm married, its even more important to me.

If l requested a female doctor but one wasn't available then of course a male one would be fine as its about

Its more awkward for me if the doctor is from the same ethnic/ racial background as me. If its a white doctor then l'm usually less embarrassed.

Datun · 06/02/2021 11:04

It's essentially 'if you won't let a transwoman do it because you say they're male, then let's inflict someone male looking on you to teach you the lesson that you don't get to tell trans people you have bodily autonomy, that you are believe in sex, and have needs that gender identity denies'.

Yep.

We're not taking no for an answer. We are just going to keep giving you alternatives until we find one you cant wriggle out of.

Passing transwomen, transmen, predatory lesbians, genital inspections, genital obsessions...be kind.

IWillSqueakAgain · 06/02/2021 11:00

I’ve been thinking about male hcp.

There are many incidences I have been entirely comfortable with them. A particularly found memory is the very lovely anaesthesiologist who not only stood outside my room and asked my consent to enter before coming in when I was in labour, but also asked my consent repeatedly, unprompted, every time he needed to touch me, despite the fact I had to consent to the epidural procedure before he stared. He was also hugely sympathetic to my needle phobia and encouraged me to use gas and air while he placed the epi so I wouldn’t feel any of it. It was a stark contrast to the female midwife who put her hands on my stomach repeatedly without ever asking, and who acted like her explaining what she needed me to do for internals etc meant I had consented when she never asked for my consent ever.

I also am unusual for a woman abuse survivor in that I sought out a male trauma therapist. While my rapists were all male of course my mother was the one knowingly facilitating it, gas lighting me over it, and I needed to avoid seeing a woman because of the dynamic I had with her.

When I have a choice in the matter I’m good with male hcp on my terms.

When I went for covid vaccine there were tones of women around. Lots of open little booths. There would have been no need at all for me to fear if a man did it. There would have been no loss of privacy or dignity if a man did it. But I got to the front of the cue and was near a panic attack because of my needle phobia and when the woman hcp allocating which booth ask if I was ok I said I was phobic and wanted a woman to do it. There were loads of women doing the injections so it was no issue. It wouldn’t have mattered to me if a man was the hcp sitting in the booth taking the info, but equally a woman doing that while a man did the injection wouldn’t have changed my panic. The panic was strictly about the needle, yet I knew a woman doing it was more comfortable for me than a man, the same way when I get bp tested its always fine if a woman does it and goes through the roof when a man does, even if a woman is in the room at the time or if it’s one of the male gps who I am especially comfortable with. It’s just an innate bodily reaction to a man doing these things. And that remains the same if the man presents as a woman.

There would have been no safety, privacy or dignity reasons for me to have a woman doing my COVID vaccs, it was simply my comfort that meant I wanted it that way.

But why would women’s comfort not be a reason to do this wherever can be reasonably done? When did we become so obsolete?

MichelleofzeResistance · 06/02/2021 10:50

Oh and activists will also often follow this up with "Oh so if a transman comes in to do this intimate procedure you want a female hcp for, and has a beard and tattoos and looks fully male presenting, is that ok?"

At which point please note:

  • The goal is still to break down female boundaries and prevent female people being allowed to say no to male people

  • why would a transman who knows their female patient has asked for a female person want to walk in and pressure and upset this female further? How exactly as a hcp is this providing useful care?

  • the main aim of this is visualising punishing the female for daring to say no to a male person. It's essentially 'if you won't let a transwoman do it because you say they're male, then let's inflict someone male looking on you to teach you the lesson that you don't get to tell trans people you have bodily autonomy, that you are believe in sex, and have needs that gender identity denies'.

It's hardly patient centred or kind, is it? Not exactly intersectional transactivism: intersectionality really ought to be recognising that females have different identities and experiences and needs, and diversity and inclusion should be about meeting all needs. Not stamping on the inconvenient female people until they give in, surrender their sex based needs and obey your beliefs and cultures. That's not intersectionality, that's nearer to imperialism and gynephobia.

Datun · 06/02/2021 10:48

this is pressuring a female person to allow a male person to have access to and touch her body against her stated boundaries and consent, having placed her in a situation where she may now be afraid to say no, and experience anger and pressure to change her mind or be refused the treatment unless she accepts.

How are we living in a country where this is even being discussed as possible?

This.

And all to validate men.

IWillSqueakAgain · 06/02/2021 10:44

The twaw movement have had legs for decades.

MichelleofzeResistance · 06/02/2021 10:43

It has to be asked: what is the subjective difference for the female person who has requested a female hcp, between a man arriving to give health care and a transwoman arriving to give healthcare?

Why is the one not ok and the other ok, what is the difference in experience for the female patient that makes this ok?

Many activists would now try to convince you that you wouldn't know the transwoman was male, however this is by activism's own teaching extremely transphobic, as transwomen are not all fully transitioned and entirely female presenting, and 'passing' is not by any means a fair and kind requirement. The female patient has not requested someone with a feminine appearance: they are likely to be perfectly happy with an androgynous or masculine presenting female hcp.

And this described situation of 'you wouldn't be able to tell' comes again back to disrespect on the part of the male person, who has heard and understood the female person's request and boundary, and has disregarded it on the grounds that they will be able to deceive them.

The most likely outcome is that the female will certainly be able to tell, and will then be in the situation of being under pressure to go through with something they have not consented to, out of fear of what will happen if they say no to the male person. And let's take this down to the blunt truth of it, because dressing this up nicely does not help females: this is pressuring a female person to allow a male person to have access to and touch her body against her stated boundaries and consent, having placed her in a situation where she may now be afraid to say no, and experience anger and pressure to change her mind or be refused the treatment unless she accepts.

How are we living in a country where this is even being discussed as possible?

gardenbird48 · 06/02/2021 10:42

If the TWAW movement gains any legs and men can simply self identify as women without any medical certs etc, then this implies that a woman who requests same sex care could be assigned a pre op trans women who last week was a man named Terry but is this week a “woman” called Maureen. Sounds extreme but this could be reality.

Sadly chuckle this has got legs and it’s up and running. Last year I read a terrible account of an elderly lady being shouted at by her mtf hcp for ‘misgendering’.

Many hospitals have a policy where the wishes of a transgender person are explicitly prioritised over those of other patients (single sex wards etc) - even if those patients only identify as female part time!! Breaches of the single sex accommodation policy are strictly monitored EXCEPT where that breach is caused by placing a male bodied transgender person a a female ward. Staff are threatened with prosecution for discussing it.

We need to push back urgently before we pass the point of no return.

gardenbird48 · 06/02/2021 10:36

@SparklyShoesandTutus

It's a tiny number when you look at the number of the register 0.6%. On the whole there is a policy across the NHS that individuals can request sam see staff for intimate procedures and efforts are made to facilitate this. However it isn't always possible and where it isn't the option of a chaperone is usually offered. Often an unqualified individual that wouldn't be qualified to provide the procedure needed. When looking at childbirth it has been the case for most of history the midwives are female and doctors are male so both have are are involved in intimate procedures.
It is imperative that choice is maintained for women. If a woman requests a female hcp and is told there isn’t one available so she can either have a male with a chaperone or rebook the appointment for when a female is available - that is her choice. If she requests a female hcp and a non female person turns up presenting themselves as female the patient has had her choice removed. She can’t ask to rebook when a female is available because the hospital are presenting that hcp AS female. So she has to accept treatment by a male bodied person or nothing.

I mentioned earlier about Clare Dimeyon’s situation where she asked for a female hcp and her letter was circulated between departments as an example of unacceptable transphobic bigotry.

That just blows my mind. A healthcare setting taking a patient about to go through an unpleasant procedure (as well the fact that she was dealing with the stress and worry of a serious health issue) and doing that to them. Every person complicit in that action should have been disciplined for gross misconduct.

They are not the ‘caring profession!’

One thing I have noticed is that the mtf trans people tend to gravitate towards positions of power and influence that are either reserved for or direct affect women.

A number of influential Women’s Officer positions, a position on the policy advisory board for the Royal Obs/Gyn society (what on earth that person who has zero experience of living in a female body could contribute I have no idea) , co-chair of Women fit the Green Party, manager of a large women’s rape shelter in Scotland etc etc.

Actual women in positions so far removed from their area of expertise would be suffering a bad case of imposter syndrome. These people do not - I wonder why?

MichelleofzeResistance · 06/02/2021 10:35

I love her a lot, wonderful person, I’m happy to call her “she” etc but this does not change the fundamental facts that she was born male.

This is the nub of it. If you have asked for a female hcp there is a reason.

If a male person, at whatever stage of transition, arrives as your female hcp, however lovely they are, what is happening now is that you as the patient are under pressure to abandon your reason and to put demonstrating care and respect for the male person's self identity ahead of your own needs and feelings. In a situation where the hcp is now not demonstrating care and respect to you.

It has to be recognised: to some people sex matters, it cannot be disappeared at will, and to demand that a vulnerable female, quite possibly afraid, unwell, in pain, surrenders their own needs to demonstrate taking care of a male person who is demonstrating that they feel more important than the female person's needs, feelings, beliefs.....?

How is this not abusive and sex based discrimination? Male people are not intrinsically more important than female people, and female people do not have a sex based birth duty to always self sacrifice and take care of males. The whole point of this ideology is supposed to be that binary sex doesn't exist, and yet it's all rooted in this incredibly sexist, very binary sex class based thinking!

Chuckleknuckles · 06/02/2021 10:11

If the TWAW movement gains any legs and men can simply self identify as women without any medical certs etc, then this implies that a woman who requests same sex care could be assigned a pre op trans women who last week was a man named Terry but is this week a “woman” called Maureen. Sounds extreme but this could be reality.

By the way I have a trans relative, male to female, I love her a lot, wonderful person, I’m happy to call her “she” etc but this does not change the fundamental facts that she was born male. Realistically my relative if she were a nurse could be offered to the previous poster who requested same sex care as my relative is now theoretically a “woman”. And you’d probably be considered a bigot or transphobic if you complained.

MotherOfDottirs · 06/02/2021 09:50

The idea that midwives can’t talk about biological reality because of trendy concerns irrelevant to pregnant women is terrifying.

yetmorenamechanging · 06/02/2021 09:41

When looking at childbirth it has been the case for most of history the midwives are female and doctors are male so both have are are involved in intimate procedures.

Well across which period of history? Across human history as a whole and generally across cultures men haven't been involved in delivering babies. Men became involved when surgery started and midwives, together with their knowledge and expertise, were relegated under men's superior technical knowledge.

TimetohittheroadJack · 06/02/2021 09:33

male not make!

DaisiesandButtercups · 06/02/2021 09:32

Centuries of history of medicine when women were excluded entirely from the profession.

For how long have women had the opportunity to enter the medical profession?

The history of male led obstetrics and gynaecology is pretty horrific. Not a great deal of empathy or seeing women as actual human beings, nor even babies who were not thought to need any pain relief for painful procedures.

Men in midwifery was less of a thing when there was a greater risk of being burnt at the stake I imagine.

TimetohittheroadJack · 06/02/2021 09:32

sparklyshoesandtutus ok, so there's no female doctor available - fair enough, let's assume it's an urgent procedure that can't be rescheduled. The chaperone offered is a Transwomen, as according to the guidelines they are female. Which leaves the patient with a make doctor and a pretend female chaperone.

You're ok with this?

SparklyShoesandTutus · 06/02/2021 08:55

It's a tiny number when you look at the number of the register 0.6%. On the whole there is a policy across the NHS that individuals can request sam see staff for intimate procedures and efforts are made to facilitate this. However it isn't always possible and where it isn't the option of a chaperone is usually offered. Often an unqualified individual that wouldn't be qualified to provide the procedure needed. When looking at childbirth it has been the case for most of history the midwives are female and doctors are male so both have are are involved in intimate procedures.

TimetohittheroadJack · 06/02/2021 08:52

I have had 4 children, and my experiences have, in large, been positive. I was asked if it was ok to be examined by a male doctor, or if it was ok if a student was there, asked for consent before anything was done.

I was treated with respect, as the patient, as I should have been, given choices and my decision, at times in my life I was most vulnerable, were respected.

Had I been asked if it was ok for a trans women HCP to be involved, I probably would have said yes.
However, I would not have been ok with having to pretend that a TW was female. The obvious lie and deception would have put me on high alert and made me uncomfortable.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 06/02/2021 08:31

@picklemewalnuts

Miss Lucy, how many men take you up on that out of interest? Men have a harder choice there, I think.
Very few, but it's probably partly because most men who do want a male GP will have booked with one in the first place. The other big factor is that men do not feel sexually threatened by women, and are comparatively unlikely to have been abused or assaulted by a woman. Quite a few men specifically say they prefer to have a female GP for intimate examinations.
picklemewalnuts · 06/02/2021 08:20

Miss Lucy, how many men take you up on that out of interest? Men have a harder choice there, I think.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 06/02/2021 08:02

Does this mean men can refuse a female gp for sensitive consultations?

As a female GP, I always offer men the option of a male colleague for rectal or genital examinations.

The problem with trans HCPs of either birth sex is that the patient risks being called transphobic or gas-lit if they ask for an HCP of the other birth sex.

LadyWithLapdog · 06/02/2021 07:56

I think it’s a retrograde step. Choice goes both ways. Give women choice but allow everyone a profession if they’re qualified for it. Most people are decent in life and at work.

yetmorenamechanging · 06/02/2021 07:30

If overnight all the male obgyns and midwives disappeared and were replaced by women with exactly the same level of training and experience and bedside manner - because I'm assuming here women are equally as competent as men and vice versa - who would be negatively impacted?

I'd suggest that all the women who had a great experience with their male obgyns and midwives would still have great experiences.

BUT all the women who have difficulties with intimate procedures done by men would have a better experience.

So the answer to who would be negatively impacted, is the men who are doctors and midwives. I'm not sure why we need to focus on their professional goals over women's lived experiences?

I can see posters saying "women abuse too" and "I was sexually abused by a woman and I don't want a woman treating me".

To that I'd say I was also abused by a woman, although not sexually, and I do understand these women exist. However, we can't deny that the figures are extremely low. So low as to not really require that the entire women's health system is set up to accommodate this group. The NHS does have specialist centres for certain conditions though and I'd suggest a specialist centre could be set up for women who really can't deal with maternity care by women.

Lifeaintalwaysempty · 05/02/2021 23:55

@gardenbird48

it just strikes me that this is all going in the wrong direction.

Why are the powers that be deliberately making things worse for women? Reducing choice for women, reducing safeguarding, reducing the clarity of information around women's health issues specifically (not men's), reducing legal protections and reducing the freedom to speak out and question these problems.

The ideological capture in the NHS that has caused the topic of this thread must be reversed.

At the moment my daughters effectively have fewer rights than I did growing up. That is not ok. We can't allow this effective removal of rights to be converted into law. In some cases (Scotland, ROI) it is already too late but we have time to prevent any further progress and help the Scottish and Irish women reverse things.

So true. This is really depressing
Adulthumanfem · 05/02/2021 20:32

I had a male midwife. He was famous for being the first African and male midwife in my city. (Geneva Switzerland).
He was great but I still wish I had been asked about which sex I preferred for intimate care as I was quite taken aback when he lifted the cover and started examining what needed examining.
I also understand that for some women it would have been an unpleasant situation, for privacy and modesty reasons.