Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Wickstead · 03/02/2021 21:07

Apologies, @Purplepeonies, this is a fast moving thread so ignore my last (completely garbled!) post

titchy · 03/02/2021 21:06

@Purplepeonies

This is a genuine question here. There are so many people on here whose beliefs are so far removed from mine so genuinely want to understand.

What is it about a trans female that you would object to?

Can you really not understand that for example where a woman has been raped, asking her to strip from the waist down and lie on her back, legs akimbo, just might be a tiny bit triggering? Hmm

What about Muslim or Orthodox Jewish women?

Wickstead · 03/02/2021 21:06

@Sexnotgender and @JKRisagryff see dyne same question as me

Perhaps, @Purplepeonies you could address that?

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 03/02/2021 21:05

What is intimidating about a biological man? Is it his penis or his stereotypically male characteristics?

I have a diagnosis of ptsd. Since the trauma responsible, I get a very visceral reaction to Adam's apples. I've had over 2 years of therapy but it's made zero difference. A man delivered dc1 (my choice, they were willing to call in a female consultant) but I didn't want to wait. In my exhausted, dehydrated state seeing his Adam's apple through my legs triggered what turned out to be psychosis. It was horrendous, terrifying and took me a full year to recover completely.

Everyone should have a choice.

Osirus · 03/02/2021 21:05

@ListeningQuietly

If a midwife thinks that sex is assigned at birth

rather than coded into the chromosomes of every cell from the point of conception

I wonder what the standards of the Continuing Professional Development are

Oh come on, FFS!
GaraMedouar · 03/02/2021 21:05

I agree with Hannah1329’s last paragraph.

First I would choose a female, 2nd a male who knows they’re a male and thirdly a male who presents as a woman. Obviously if I was in a life and death situation beggars can’t be choosers. But let’s say I’m going for a smear - then I’d have the female nurse do it, may say yes to the male nurse if for example the female nurse was off sick so he was a stand in and asked if it was ok, if I thought oh what the hell i don’t want to have to rebook again and have the faff, but to be presented with a male nurse where you are supposed to pretend they’re female , and go along with the pretence and charade and not mention the elephant in the room , to validate them, nope from me. I would refuse .

For my kids’ births I only had female midwives. But one birth in hospital I was asked if a male junior doctor could come in at the end , and I was honestly quite happy with that, not a problem.
I knew he was training and needed experience (he was only observing).

Sexnotgender · 03/02/2021 21:04

@Purplepeonies

This is a genuine question here. There are so many people on here whose beliefs are so far removed from mine so genuinely want to understand.

What is it about a trans female that you would object to?

The fact they are male.
pumpkinbump · 03/02/2021 21:04

This is beyond a joke. Considering less than 5000 GRCs have been issued, a good majority of these must be self ID trans, which is ridiculous in a healthcare setting.

Purplepeonies · 03/02/2021 21:04

@JKRisagryff

PurplePeonies agree with SexnotGender, could you answer the question as to how you feel about removing this choice from other women who perhaps do care about who is doing intimate examinations on their body? What would you say to someone who does care and for whom it is a big deal?
Of course. Would like to clarify I do agree that there should be the choice.

I'm just conflicted because I also believe that trans women are women.

Moonmelodies · 03/02/2021 21:03

I wonder how someone with a traumatic experience of someone of another race would get on if they requested an HCP of a different race.

Wickstead · 03/02/2021 21:03

@Purplepeonies

I really couldn't give two fucks what genitals health care professionals have. If they are good at their job that's all I care about.
That’s great.

Do you think it’s ok if other women feel differently to you?

MissyB1 · 03/02/2021 21:02

Oh I do think everyone should have the right to request. But remember that doesn’t mean your request must be granted as sometimes it just won’t be possible. The right to request does not necessarily mean the right to have.

JKRisagryff · 03/02/2021 21:02

PurplePeonies agree with SexnotGender, could you answer the question as to how you feel about removing this choice from other women who perhaps do care about who is doing intimate examinations on their body? What would you say to someone who does care and for whom it is a big deal?

Aiaiaicorona · 03/02/2021 21:01

I don’t care about the gender of HCP’s either as long as they can do the job. Anything such as a breast exam and there’s always a chaperone anyway. I’ve had male gynaecologists as many are.

Also to point out that some are outraged that the NMC collect this data, please remember nurses are exposed to hazards such as radiation and some procedures require women of a child bearing age not being present/distanced. It is likely any nursing or midwifery staff working in such areas will have to declare their sex at birth to their manager if they are at risk of this.

Hannah1329 · 03/02/2021 21:01

@Purplepeonies

I really couldn't give two fucks what genitals health care professionals have. If they are good at their job that's all I care about.
Some people won't mind. I don't think that means people shouldn't be able to choose though. It's a matter of consent.
Purplepeonies · 03/02/2021 21:00

This is a genuine question here. There are so many people on here whose beliefs are so far removed from mine so genuinely want to understand.

What is it about a trans female that you would object to?

ancientgran · 03/02/2021 20:59

I was assaulted by a GP, horrible as he was my mother's GP when she was pregnant with me. She was sitting at his desk when he did it, he broke my hymen and I didn't even understand what happened. I was about 12, I suppose it always was at the back of my mind that something was wrong but it was years later that I suddenly realised what happened.

Hannah1329 · 03/02/2021 20:58

@ListeningQuietly

After having my kids IIRC both surgeons who did the stitches were blokes which was fine by me BUT If I'd requested female staff (for personal, societal or religious reasons) I'd be suing the NHS if they lied to me

and it IS lying to say that men are women

This is exactly how I feel too. It's the dishonesty and pretence I wouldn't like.
JKRisagryff · 03/02/2021 20:56

I agree it’s about choice. I personally don’t care who treats me as long as there is a chaperone for intimate examinations, I don’t have a preference of sex. But just because this is my point of view doesn’t mean I can decide that for other people. I know a lot of women who would be traumatised by having males conduct intimate examinations, some of whom have actually been sexually assaulted before by medical professionals. This is not a hypothetical debate for them, this is real trauma, being brushed aside.

katnyps · 03/02/2021 20:55

I don't want to offend here so take this as a genuinely open question...

What is intimidating about a biological man? Is it his penis or his stereotypically male characteristics?

Apologies if that is an offensive question!

ListeningQuietly · 03/02/2021 20:55

After having my kids IIRC both surgeons who did the stitches were blokes
which was fine by me
BUT
If I'd requested female staff
(for personal, societal or religious reasons)
I'd be suing the NHS if they lied to me

and it IS lying to say that men are women

ChattyLion · 03/02/2021 20:54

YANBU, obviously. Nobody requesting same- sex care in a sensitive situation is BU. Women should be able to have single sex care and same sex care providers.

Sexnotgender · 03/02/2021 20:54

@Purplepeonies

I really couldn't give two fucks what genitals health care professionals have. If they are good at their job that's all I care about.
Good for you. Do you think we should remove the choice from people who do mind?
Purplepeonies · 03/02/2021 20:53

I really couldn't give two fucks what genitals health care professionals have. If they are good at their job that's all I care about.

ancientgran · 03/02/2021 20:52

I've had male and female HCP when pregnant and I'm OK with either but people should have a choice. My mother was traumatised when she had a midwife who was a nun. She said it was embarrassing as the nun would never have had sex and obviously she knew my mother had. I wonder what they would have said if she asked for a midwife who'd had sex.