Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DaisiesandButtercups · 04/02/2021 09:32

It may be seen as an extreme point of view in these modern times when the feelings and opportunities of health care providers are regarded as more important than those of the patients but I actually think that men of any variety should be barred from working in maternity or gynaecology in any capacity.

I don’t think a woman should be in the position of needing to ask for same sex nurses, midwives or doctors in woman centred health care. To have to ask will be traumatic in itself for many women.

Whatisthisfuckery · 04/02/2021 09:29

’LexxaM

Indeed so but the issue of competing rights is important.
The right of males to identify as women v the rights of other groups who don’t wish to have males attend to them.
The Equality Act protects sex, gender reassignment, religious views.
Which is most important when they conflict? How to solve this problem?’

A woman’s body is not an equal opportunities space and women are not obliged to have a diversity and inclusion policy when it comes to their intimate care.

ancientgran · 04/02/2021 09:01

@Keeva2017 Thank you. It is weird because I didn't register what was happening at the time I feel horrified that the GP did it but it feels like it happened to someone else in a strangely detached way. It must have been traumatic in its own way as here I am over 55 years later thinking about it. I have mentioned it twice on MN but I've never said it to anyone in person.

Keeva2017 · 04/02/2021 01:58

@ancientgran what an awful experience for you. I’m sorry you went through that.

nothingcomestonothing · 03/02/2021 23:48

FFS! Nothing is 'assigned' at birth, it's not a fucking lottery! Just another example of how ideologically captured healthcare is in this country.

As several PP have said, my preference would be female sexed professional, then male sexed professional with chaperone, male born person performing their version of female never. I am not here to validate your identity, especially when I'm the patient and you're the care giver!

The entitlement just blows me away. Who was that trans GP boasting about how female Muslim patients didn't used to let him perform intimate exams, but now he's a she they do? Thinking about those women patients makes me so angry, their dignity and their religious and cultural beliefs overridden to validate the person supposedly there to care for them. I fucking hate it.

LexxaM · 03/02/2021 22:54

Indeed so but the issue of competing rights is important.
The right of males to identify as women v the rights of other groups who don’t wish to have males attend to them.
The Equality Act protects sex, gender reassignment, religious views.
Which is most important when they conflict? How to solve this problem?

pumpkinbump · 03/02/2021 22:12

@OhWhyNot

From your link pumpkinbump

Study suggests that transwomen exhibit a male pattern of criminality

mmm maybe because, and I know this will sound absurd, it’s becuase they are male ...

That'll be that funny little thing called evolution.
OhWhyNot · 03/02/2021 22:08

From your link pumpkinbump

Study suggests that transwomen exhibit a male pattern of criminality

mmm maybe because, and I know this will sound absurd, it’s becuase they are male ...

pumpkinbump · 03/02/2021 22:03

Paradiseland - fairplayforwomen.com/criminality/

OhWhyNot · 03/02/2021 21:59

At times I prefer to see a female hcp I don’t need to justify why

I work in mh with males at times they prefer to discuss certain issues with male hcp and they are encouraged to tell us (or if we are aware that they may want to we ask them often the answer is yes some men do not wish to speak about erectile dysfunction with a female hcp which is a side effect of a number of antipsychotics)

ParadiseIsland · 03/02/2021 21:57

@pumpkinbump

Regardless of whether a man has surgically 'transitioned', they can still abuse a woman in other ways. They are found to have the same capacity for violence/abuse as non trans males. So no, just because you can't be raped because the penis has been removed isn't good enough. Especially when a large majority opt to keep themselves intact.
Genuinely wondering

Are the studies done on TW and the level of rape/aggression etc... by separating TW who have had bottom surgery from those who haven’t/have barely made any changes (bar wearing a skirt)?

My understanding is that those studies looked at all TW who self identified as TW. In which case I’m not surprised the risk is the same.
I was expecting that results would be different for those who went all the way. Happy to be proven wrong if this is the case

Sexnotgender · 03/02/2021 21:56

@LexxaM

The issue for me is choice and the policy in the NHS at the moment is that any woman insisting on a female midwife or nurse for gynae and midwifery is judged to be a bigot and guilty of hate crime. Not sure how this applies to women whose religions who forbid it. Whose rights are paramount in that situation?
I agree but I don’t like bringing religion into it.

ANY woman should be able to request female only provision regardless of religion.

LexxaM · 03/02/2021 21:54

The issue for me is choice and the policy in the NHS at the moment is that any woman insisting on a female midwife or nurse for gynae and midwifery is judged to be a bigot and guilty of hate crime. Not sure how this applies to women whose religions who forbid it. Whose rights are paramount in that situation?

pumpkinbump · 03/02/2021 21:47

fairplayforwomen.com/penis/

Glenchase · 03/02/2021 21:46

Personally I’m happy to be treated by any sex HCPs as long as they’re professional. But I absolutely believe that women should have a choice and should be able to request a natal female HCP if they so wish. Ditto for men who should be able to request a natal male HCP.

pumpkinbump · 03/02/2021 21:44

Regardless of whether a man has surgically 'transitioned', they can still abuse a woman in other ways. They are found to have the same capacity for violence/abuse as non trans males. So no, just because you can't be raped because the penis has been removed isn't good enough. Especially when a large majority opt to keep themselves intact.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 03/02/2021 21:43

The overriding issue is consent. For those who consent to having males perform a medical procedure or examination that’s absolutely fine.

The problem comes with women who don’t consent being labelled bigots etc.

Completely agree. Hence the remainder of my post.

Whatisthisfuckery · 03/02/2021 21:40

YADNBU! How could it possibly be U to say people should have the right to request and recieve care from a person of the same sex? The notion is utterly mad.

What I do think is incredibly U however, is health care proffessionals lying about their sex, in order to perform intimate care on a woman.the alarm bells would be deafening me if that ever happened to me. I’d break the land speed record getting out of there. I couldn’t think of anything more overtly dodgy.

ParadiseIsland · 03/02/2021 21:39

Yes I would be worried that the safeguards in place for male HCP wouldnt be there for a transwoman ‘because she is a woman’.

Not a problem imo if said transwoman has had botttom surgery/hormones that make her unable to ejaculate.
Much more of an issue with people who are basically cross dressers.

Sexnotgender · 03/02/2021 21:39

I'm with you. I've been examined or treated by numerous male gynaecologists, my male ob gyn was wonderful, I was treated by male doctors in pregnancy and have also been cared for by male nurses. I don't have an issue (other women might, and they absolutely should have the right to state a preference).

The overriding issue is consent. For those who consent to having males perform a medical procedure or examination that’s absolutely fine.

The problem comes with women who don’t consent being labelled bigots etc.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 03/02/2021 21:32

I don’t necessarily have an issue with men in midwifery, there are many male consultants after all - my first was delivered by a woman consultant, assisted by a man. I wasn’t concerned.

But we have every right to demand safe space for ourselves at the most vulnerable parts of our lives.

I'm with you. I've been examined or treated by numerous male gynaecologists, my male ob gyn was wonderful, I was treated by male doctors in pregnancy and have also been cared for by male nurses. I don't have an issue (other women might, and they absolutely should have the right to state a preference).

However - and it's a big however - these men were always careful. Especially when performing intimate examinations they always had a chaperone present, and were very respectful of my status as a vulnerable female patient. Were a TW dr/nurse similarly fastidious - which any with an ounce of insight or sensitivity would be - I'd have no problem with that either.

The issue is that, according to TRA rhetoric, they wouldn't be. 'TWAW', therefore my body is expected to provide validation to that identity at the cost of my own privacy, dignity and possibly safety.

Big fat no.

My PAP tests have always been done by women, and oddly enough (perhaps because of precedent)? I would prefer that procedure to be carried out by a female. I wouldn't want a solitary male practitioner performing that test however he identified.

Women say 'No'. Men hear something else. It was ever thus.

Hannah1329 · 03/02/2021 21:29

@MissMarpleDarling

I could have had an alien helping me while in labour and wouldn't have cared.
So do you believe women who do care shouldn't have the choice?
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 03/02/2021 21:29

My three children were not assigned a sex at birth; their sexes were observed.

As for choice: it was hard enough to find any doctor prepared to say he'd attended a home delivery and sign the paperwork, without expecting him to be present as well; they were delivered by midwives. Who were female in each case.

Directionerforever · 03/02/2021 21:28

Has anyone tried tweeting @crouchendtiger - Andrea Sutcliffe who is the chief registrar for the NMC? She’s pretty responsive on social media.

pumpkinbump · 03/02/2021 21:27

"What is it about a trans female that you would object to?"

The clue is in the question. Trans female as opposed to female. You cannot become female. You stay male whatever you do to your body.