Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ancientgran · 04/02/2021 10:41

@DaisiesandButtercups

Ancientgran the clue is perhaps in your name and the fact that your GP is long retired.

Sadly things are less personal than they used to be and although there is much evidence that having a long term relationship with a known GP and midwife are beneficial this is the exception rather than the rule nowadays. Very few GPs have any involvement in maternity care now beyond an initial appointment to refer to a midwife.

Given that most of the midwives, obstetricians and gynaecologists that a woman will encounter will be unknown to her I propose that the majority of women who have suffered male violence and many who have not will be more comfortable with a female professional and that the number who would prefer an unknown male professional would be vanishingly small.

Of course women should have the right to request a different health care professional at any time without any need to justify it at all, this is basic consent.

So you agree that people shouldn't be barred because of their sex?

I think the vanishingly small also count.

Kitdeluca1 · 04/02/2021 10:40

In regards to the second is assigned at birth’ comment erm it’s true, medically and biologically speaking we are male or female.

I also wouldn’t of been comfortable with male midwives while I gave birth and it’s something that I expressed both times. Giving birth is something only a woman can do and I think the empathy and encouragement you receive from a midwife is something that comes from personal experience or knowing that one day she’ll feel it to. Might sound strange but no uterus no opinion comes to mind. Of course if there was only males available I would of been fine but preference would always be female.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 10:37

It is a shame that the Scottish government supported by many organisations including a rape shelter run by someone who lied about their sex to get the job (but has been allowed to stay even though physically and legally male and NOT a fan of many types of women) DON’T think that rape victims should have the right to request a female examiner to gather evidence of their rape.

It was only down to the enormous hard work of Johann Lamont that Scotgov were forced to change the law to allow women to at least request a female.

And it's worth remembering that the above trans individual plus other allies flounced from the SNP and defected to the Scottish Greens because the SNP voted for Johann's amendment to the law to change the word "gender" (ie gender identity and trans women are women so share a gender with female people) to "sex" (biological sex, MTF trans people are male and women are female so they don't share a sex). The Scottish Greens made up the no vote, luckily there aren't very many of them.

gaijinetal · 04/02/2021 10:34

@prisencolinensinainciusol2

I have just voted (YANBU) and noticed that, at the time of voting, a rather worrying 11% of respondents voted basically that women should not have the right to request same sex provision. Worrying, no?

The thing is, I've skimmed thru the thread and actual replies do not mirror that eleven percent.

So I'm guessing that the "eleven percenters" have no (or very poor) arguments to back up their hatred of women.

Would that be a fair assessment?

I've always presumed there's lots of accidental button selection too.

Hence you get threads with severe abuse etc and there'll always be 3 % or more saying yabu (to have a problem with the behaviour).

SinkGirl · 04/02/2021 10:33

@DaisiesandButtercups

It may be seen as an extreme point of view in these modern times when the feelings and opportunities of health care providers are regarded as more important than those of the patients but I actually think that men of any variety should be barred from working in maternity or gynaecology in any capacity.

I don’t think a woman should be in the position of needing to ask for same sex nurses, midwives or doctors in woman centred health care. To have to ask will be traumatic in itself for many women.

I utterly disagree with your first comment. I have seen several exceptional endometriosis specialists and only one is female. It would be a tragedy if the skills of the others couldn’t be used. None of them ever performed an internal examination of me though.

Absolutely women should have the right to choose, and should not be misled or put in a position to refuse care from someone insisting that something untrue is true.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 10:32

I'm not sure how they decided to assign her female, it was very difficult for the parents as various doctors were involved about which surgery would have the most satisfactory outcome.

Yes I can imagine.

DaisiesandButtercups · 04/02/2021 10:27

Ancientgran the clue is perhaps in your name and the fact that your GP is long retired.

Sadly things are less personal than they used to be and although there is much evidence that having a long term relationship with a known GP and midwife are beneficial this is the exception rather than the rule nowadays. Very few GPs have any involvement in maternity care now beyond an initial appointment to refer to a midwife.

Given that most of the midwives, obstetricians and gynaecologists that a woman will encounter will be unknown to her I propose that the majority of women who have suffered male violence and many who have not will be more comfortable with a female professional and that the number who would prefer an unknown male professional would be vanishingly small.

Of course women should have the right to request a different health care professional at any time without any need to justify it at all, this is basic consent.

ancientgran · 04/02/2021 10:23

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I think in rare cases it can be assigned. Someone I know (not well, friend of a friend) had a baby with ambiguous genitalia. I don't know all the details, as obviously it was a very private matter, but it was some weeks before it was agreed with the parents and doctors that the baby would be assigned as female and surgery carried out. She is an adult now and considering transitioning.

I imagine it is incredibly rare but I don't suppose it is a unique situation.

Yes that's what I was talking about in my last sentence. All humans are objectively male or female whether or not their sex is ambiguous to the observer. No one has both sets of working gametes. They will have developed further down one pathway than the other.

I'm not sure how they decided to assign her female, it was very difficult for the parents as various doctors were involved about which surgery would have the most satisfactory outcome.
gardenbird48 · 04/02/2021 10:16

It is a shame that the Scottish government supported by many organisations including a rape shelter run by someone who lied about their sex to get the job (but has been allowed to stay even though physically and legally male and NOT a fan of many types of women) DON’T think that rape victims should have the right to request a female examiner to gather evidence of their rape.

It was only down to the enormous hard work of Johann Lamont that Scotgov were forced to change the law to allow women to at least request a female.

I absolutely think women should have the right to choose. I hate smear tests at the best of times and would very likely not do it at all if I had to have a man (however he identified) touching me in that way. My teenage daughters should also have the right to choose.

ancientgran · 04/02/2021 10:15

@DaisiesandButtercups

Ancientgran I was not referring to general practice but no I don’t intend to say anyone doesn’t have the right to see his or her GP.

The majority of women are cared for by health care providers whom they have never met before when they give birth in hospital or attend hospital for gynaecological appointments.

But you did say they should be barred from working in maternity or gynae. My GP (long retired) was the doctor who looked after maternity patients at the surgery, they divided up various clinics. He was kind, caring, sympathetic and knew me well. I think barring someone like him isn't appropriate. I have seen female midwives who were very unsympathetic and abrupt and I would have preferred him hands down.

In my last pregnancy my Consultant was male and very understanding. I made a complaint about his Registrar who was very rude to me when I declined amnio which she insisted I should have due to my age. She even told me I didn't have the right to refuse. So sorry I don't think you can make a decision for all women.

Having said that I have had some fantastic midwives and the female GP I saw when I was bleeding and thought I was miscarrying was everything you could hope for in a very upsetting situation.

Martinisarebetterdirty · 04/02/2021 10:05

@PerfectPenquins

Of course it should be a choice. If you dont care what sex the HCP is then that's fine but some awareness that there are a multitude of reasons why others do wouldn't go amiss. Just because your happy to have a man do any intimate care doesn't mean everyone is. Same with other care sectors, my mother should have the right to have a biological female doing her washing and dressing.
Exactly this. It doesn’t matter if you are fine with a man or a trans woman, it matters for the women who are not ok with it and their rights are not yours to give away.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 10:05

I think in rare cases it can be assigned. Someone I know (not well, friend of a friend) had a baby with ambiguous genitalia. I don't know all the details, as obviously it was a very private matter, but it was some weeks before it was agreed with the parents and doctors that the baby would be assigned as female and surgery carried out. She is an adult now and considering transitioning.

I imagine it is incredibly rare but I don't suppose it is a unique situation.

Yes that's what I was talking about in my last sentence. All humans are objectively male or female whether or not their sex is ambiguous to the observer. No one has both sets of working gametes. They will have developed further down one pathway than the other.

DaisiesandButtercups · 04/02/2021 10:04

Ancientgran I was not referring to general practice but no I don’t intend to say anyone doesn’t have the right to see his or her GP.

The majority of women are cared for by health care providers whom they have never met before when they give birth in hospital or attend hospital for gynaecological appointments.

NotBadConsidering · 04/02/2021 10:02

Currently it’s 314 votes, 10% have voted YABU. That’s 30 people. 30 people who think women shouldn’t even be able to request this. But no one who has explained why. The fact that there are at least 30 registered users of Mumsnet who believe women shouldn’t even be able to make this request would explain a lot about how certain threads are monitored and reported.

ancientgran · 04/02/2021 10:00

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I may be missing the point - it has been known - but surely the tweet in the OP is correct, that sex is assigned at birth? In the sense that the baby is designated male or female based on visual inspection and that this is assigned to the baby's medical records? I know that a lot of people find out in advance now, but traditionally the boy/girl decision would only be settled at the birth.

What they mean is that the person's "gender", a word which is never clearly separated from biological sex by trans activists, is assigned at birth when actually they may be a different "gender" internally (again never clearly separated from biological sex enough that people fully understand what they mean). Sex is of course not "assigned" at birth, it is determined by the father's gamete that fertilised the ova. Even where it is ambiguous to the doctor, a person is objectively male or female.

I think in rare cases it can be assigned. Someone I know (not well, friend of a friend) had a baby with ambiguous genitalia. I don't know all the details, as obviously it was a very private matter, but it was some weeks before it was agreed with the parents and doctors that the baby would be assigned as female and surgery carried out. She is an adult now and considering transitioning.

I imagine it is incredibly rare but I don't suppose it is a unique situation.

prisencolinensinainciusol2 · 04/02/2021 09:58

Does anyone know what the sex divide is with gynaecologists?

The only thing that I know for sure is that any news item about a bad one I've seen - it's always been a male one.

Of course you'd expect that to be the case if 99% of gynaecologists were men...

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 09:56

blueinthesky Thanks I'm so glad you were allowed the choice when you needed it. I agree an emergency situation can be different.

ancientgran · 04/02/2021 09:54

@DaisiesandButtercups

It may be seen as an extreme point of view in these modern times when the feelings and opportunities of health care providers are regarded as more important than those of the patients but I actually think that men of any variety should be barred from working in maternity or gynaecology in any capacity.

I don’t think a woman should be in the position of needing to ask for same sex nurses, midwives or doctors in woman centred health care. To have to ask will be traumatic in itself for many women.

What if a woman prefers a male HCP in maternity or gynaecology. I had some issues after my first child, I had a home birth with 2nd and the person I could absolutely trust was my male GP. I had a lovely midwife but she changed jobs, I had a few weeks to meet and know my 2nd midwife and her husband had a heart attack the week before I gave birth. The midwife and her student were lovely but I didn't know them and they didn't know me. My GP was fantastic, he knew me and knew what to say to reassure me. I understand some women don't want to see a male HCP but I don't think you have the right to say I couldn't see my GP.
blueinthesky · 04/02/2021 09:54

Name change

YANBU

I accepted treatment from male HCP when I was in hospital having a major haemorrhage after being raped. It was an acute situation and i barely noticed what was going on around me (apart from many raised voices and panic).

I was offered a female surgeon and anaesthetist when I had my vaginal reconstruction and repair of vaginorectal fistula, but I figured that I would be under anaesthetic, there would be many people in the theatre team and I said I wanted the absolute best surgeon available irrespective of sex. As it happened, the gynae and colorectal surgeons i had were women.

I had a medium term catheter for a while and then moved to intermittent self catheterisation. When I was learning to do this with scarred and distorted anatomy I was always helped by a female nurse, which I requested. I would have refused this from a man, and would have taken the more invasive option of a long term suprapubic catheter instead.

Nowadays I’m happy to see either sex in clinic for check ups and for examination I can manage a man with a chaperone if needed. I would still prefer a woman, but after 4 years of therapy the fear has faded a little and I can manage in the hospital setting.

FWIW when I was initially discharged I had a HomeStart volunteer come to help me bath the kids because even seeing my own (then 5 year old) son naked provoked huge anxiety.

I was very lucky to have excellent support from healthcare and kids school where they were very gentle and listened to me at every step along the way and never forced me to do or accept anything I did not want - even when that meant delaying treatment or compromising on what I felt I could manage.

I am pragmatic enough to recognise that the more restrictions I placed on who I would allow to treat me, the more I might have to compromise in other ways - waiting time, travel to a different unit, operative skill etc. The important thing for me was that I was allowed to make those choices myself without pressure.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 09:53

I may be missing the point - it has been known - but surely the tweet in the OP is correct, that sex is assigned at birth? In the sense that the baby is designated male or female based on visual inspection and that this is assigned to the baby's medical records? I know that a lot of people find out in advance now, but traditionally the boy/girl decision would only be settled at the birth.

What they mean is that the person's "gender", a word which is never clearly separated from biological sex by trans activists, is assigned at birth when actually they may be a different "gender" internally (again never clearly separated from biological sex enough that people fully understand what they mean). Sex is of course not "assigned" at birth, it is determined by the father's gamete that fertilised the ova. Even where it is ambiguous to the doctor, a person is objectively male or female.

prisencolinensinainciusol2 · 04/02/2021 09:50

@TakeTheCuntOutOfScunthorpe

I may be missing the point - it has been known - but surely the tweet in the OP is correct, that sex is assigned at birth? In the sense that the baby is designated male or female based on visual inspection and that this is assigned to the baby's medical records? I know that a lot of people find out in advance now, but traditionally the boy/girl decision would only be settled at the birth.

Not assigned - recorded

That why it's called the baby's records

SquishySquirmy · 04/02/2021 09:49

YANBU.

Personally, I am happy to be treated by male doctors, nurses, midwives etc. But I know that other women aren't and they should have that right to say no.

Although, thinking about it more... I dont mind being treated by a male, but I want it to be my choice.

Any male that thinks they have the right to do so...I dont want them anywhere near me.

It's a good general rule for life: if a male thinks their right/desire to come near me is more important than what I want, then they are the very last person on this world I want near me.

prisencolinensinainciusol2 · 04/02/2021 09:46

I have just voted (YANBU) and noticed that, at the time of voting, a rather worrying 11% of respondents voted basically that women should not have the right to request same sex provision. Worrying, no?

The thing is, I've skimmed thru the thread and actual replies do not mirror that eleven percent.

So I'm guessing that the "eleven percenters" have no (or very poor) arguments to back up their hatred of women.

Would that be a fair assessment?

TakeTheCuntOutOfScunthorpe · 04/02/2021 09:41

I may be missing the point - it has been known - but surely the tweet in the OP is correct, that sex is assigned at birth? In the sense that the baby is designated male or female based on visual inspection and that this is assigned to the baby's medical records? I know that a lot of people find out in advance now, but traditionally the boy/girl decision would only be settled at the birth.

gardenbird48 · 04/02/2021 09:34

@Directionerforever

Has anyone tried tweeting *@crouchendtiger* - Andrea Sutcliffe who is the chief registrar for the NMC? She’s pretty responsive on social media.
Good thinking. I might ask her why the NMC report in discrimination didn’t include the protected characteristics of Sex or Maternity.

They included gender - (not legally defined and not the same as sex) and gender identity, (also not a protected characteristic or legally defined).

Do these people have problems with reading comprehension?? A worry considering their role.