Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
gardenbird48 · 04/02/2021 13:03

Good post Graphista

And when we are considering this:

huge drop in patients going for smears and breast exams for starters.

It is not going to be helped by many cancer charities removing the word ‘woman’ from their publicity re female cancers (they don’t do the same for male cancers - I wonder why..).

As I mentioned previously I would be extremely unlikely to attend a smear if it wasn’t going to be with a female and would struggle with a breast examination.

I was referred to a male cancer specialist for a dodgy mole when I was pregnant. Despite it being on the top of my shoulder he made me fully undress and put on a gown and was very abrupt and dismissive. I felt so horrid and vulnerable in front of him that I probably wouldn’t do that again.

I would like the right to request a woman.

ancientgran · 04/02/2021 13:03

@NotBadConsidering The term “assigned” in relation to intersex/DSDs arose from the way these children were treated in the past. Their genitalia were looked at and it was decided by doctors how they could best “pass” as adults as they were or with some surgical intervention. So for example, a male with a severe micro penis could be “assigned” to be female because it would be “better” for them. A girl with clitoromegaly could be “assigned” as male etc. This decision was made on infants, it was decided what was best for them. Understandably this came under severe criticism. Adults who had this done to them felt their bodies weren’t right, and their autonomy on such decisions was taken from them. They have successfully, and righty in my view, campaigned for much less intervention unless absolutely necessary and for no “assigning” to happen in such circumstances. They have campaigned for hormone treatments and surgery to be delayed until adulthood where possible (if not essential to life beforehand)

This pretty much sums up the baby I was talking about, after days of tests and talking it was decided the baby was female and surgery happened to make her genitals conform. I think her sex was assigned. I'm glad if that isn't happening now as surgically changing their genitals is something I believe the individual should have some say in i.e. the final word. It seemed a pretty brutal surgery for a young baby when it was in no way life threatening.

IWillSqueakAgain · 04/02/2021 13:02

Lexxa the equalities act isn’t about what happens when two protected groups rights counter each other.

It protects our right to discriminate based on those protected. characteristics. So single sex is protected and we can use that to discriminate against any other protected group, which means single sex= single sex, not single sex plus those with grc.

A person with grc isn’t discriminating against women by using our spaces. So they can’t use that exception.

It isn’t a conflict of rights, our laws protect single sex excemptions. The law is on women’s side, despite the constant reframing of those who present it as ‘two protected groups conflicting’ or the many people/institutions deliberately misrepresenting it or ignoring it all together.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 13:02

He was pretty notorious on Twitter, you didn’t have to look far to come across one of his bizarre tweets

What was bizarre about them?

Datun · 04/02/2021 13:02

Of course wanting same sex, intimate health provision isn't unreasonable.

I'd like to know what the alternative is? Your request for a woman for your smear is accommodated, but it turns out not to be a woman, and you are not allowed to say anything? Or are considered wrong for saying something? Or unreasonable?

So you have to pretend they're a woman when you know they're not, during your smear? Or not have your smear because you don't believe in an ideology?

This is bonkers. No one should be forced into a position where they are having to refute an ideology while they are lying on their back for a smear, or going for a mammogram.

Manicpixiedreammollusc · 04/02/2021 12:55

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

"I don't mind who I see" and "what if you were about to die" obviously not counting as a valid explanation. Come on!

I can't for the life of me understand why women who don't mind being cared for by male practitioners (in most cases that would be me too) think they have the right to make that decision for every other woman as well.

Other women don't necessarily feel the same as me. I decide my own boundaries; I don't have a say in how others decide theirs. Other women's rights are not mine to give away.

Why are the 'let's all share and #BeKind' advocates seemingly incapable of comprehending this?

I also can't help but agree - I don't want to but I do - that there's something nefarious about a TW insisting on doing a job that required unfettered access to women's bodies - and screaming 'bigot' when they object - when there are a kazillion other occupations that demand no such insinuation. I've thought about whether I'd be more uncomfortable with a TW performing this kind of examination on me than a man. Unfortunately, although I'd prefer this not to be the case, it's true. And if it's true, that's the fault of the brand of vociferous, misogynistic activism that consistently aims rape threats and other pleasantries at women who don't play along with every word. Their fault. Not mine.

How unsurprising that since being banned from Twitter you’ve found your new home on Mumsnet.

Re this point directed at Glinner. And how unsurprising that you should have gone to all the trouble of stalking him from that site to this. It must have taken a considerable commitment in time and effort. Desperate or what?

Nope - just clicked on the thread and recognised the username. He was pretty notorious on Twitter, you didn’t have to look far to come across one of his bizarre tweets
rawalpindithelabrador · 04/02/2021 12:54

I'm just conflicted because I also believe that trans women are women

Please expound. Did they delete their Y chromosome and insert an X one? If I 'feel' like Bill Gates and identify as him, can I go round behaving as he does, including his access to money? No, I'd be sectioned for being delusion. It's not possible for me to be him. So explain how and why a male can 'feel' like and 'identify' as a female and actually be one?

Thewithesarehere · 04/02/2021 12:54

There is no way on earth I can be comfortable with a male-born person doing breast or vaginal assessment/smears. It’s horrible to accept that I should just go with it and that NHS is not obliged to let me know if a trans woman will be doing this assessment.
I find it mind boggling that we are even discussing this in the 21st century.

gardenbird48 · 04/02/2021 12:53

@dontdisturbmenow

Have any of the 40 ish voters who think that it is not OK for women to request a female HCP explained themselves yet? Because under the pressure the NHS finds itself to offer safe care and meet strict criteria, dealing with midwife and nurses shortage, struggling with staff sickness and working around them, adding that women could request a female only team, when ultimately the NHS can't (and of course shouldn't) refuse to train or recruit men is unrealistic.

Every time a male midwife is on a shift, there would need to be an additional female midwife just in case the male midwife has to be replaced. Add to this the ratio of trainee midwife, who need to be supervised on shift, the fact that we are talking 24/7 shifts, it becomes something impossible to promise and therefore demand unless in very exceptional circumstances.

We are talking about women having the right to request a same sex hcp.

This is not about demanding something that may be restricted due to available resources. I’m sure every woman understands that there may be operational reasons for not being able to grant their request and she could take that into account either by accepting a male in an emergency or by agreeing to wait until a female is available, but that the hospital would do all it could to facilitate her request.

That would be the patient’s choice. You seem to think that the patient shouldn’t even have a choice? Meaning that they are either forced to accept the male or have no treatment at all?

So women who can’t because of trauma or religious beliefs or any other reason are excluded from accessing treatment?

I hope I have misunderstood you.

Graphista · 04/02/2021 12:53

You know what I've just noticed? I think there's only ONE respondent is a currently practicing hcp. I find it very telling that the many hcps on mn very rarely post on threads critical of their practices and ideology, funny that.

Graphista · 04/02/2021 12:50

Anything such as a breast exam and there’s always a chaperone anyway except under proposed changes a transwoman will be legally regarded as a woman and you won’t be able to request a female chaperone “because why do you need 2 women in there”

But for people who mention chaperones - what if the GP is a male doctor, asks if you want a chaperone, and then the nurse chaperone who comes in is a transwoman? exactly

@purplepeonies I don’t actually believe you are genuine I think you’re being goady and offensive! Men - even ones presenting as women, are physically bigger, stronger and a potential threat to women in vulnerable situations like intimate medical exams. What is your true agenda? Why do you think it is right that true consent be removed from PATIENTS?!

Do you think it’s ok if other women feel differently to you?
I think it would be a mistake to assume this poster is a woman despite the “feminine” username

For people like myself (a survivor of csa) this is completely unacceptable. I have gynae isssues, I’m also reaching an age of needing more regular intimate exams as risk of certain conditions increases, plus family history and I absolutely do NOT want a man - however they may present - doing those intimate exams or even discussing such things. I have a female gp precisely BECAUSE I’ve had bad experiences with Male hcps. I will at a push speak to a Male gp about general health matters eg sore throat type thing but anything requiring an intimate exam or discussion of sex based medical issues I always ask for a woman. I would be livid if I were given a trans woman in that circumstance, it’s deceptive and doesn’t meet my needs or consent.

This is about consent and protection. Hcps really ought to know MUCH better and be advocating for patients rights to consensual treatment which is at the heart of good medical practice.

The problem comes with women who don’t consent being labelled bigots etc

@takethecuntoutofscunthorpe you are missing the point - sex is not “assigned” it’s “observed and recorded” as medical FACT - “assigned” means the hcp is making the decision as to the baby’s sex (not gender, sex) which is a total nonsense

As an ex hcp myself AND as a patient who’s experienced and witnessed awful medical misogyny even outside of this issue my concern is labelling patients bigots is the LEAST of it, my concern is this will very likely lead to women patients not being able to access screening and treatment.

I can well see this decision/attitude leading to a huge drop in patients going for smears and breast exams for starters.

This decision if followed through WILL lead to fatalities and that is ABSOLUTELY UNACCEPTABLE

I think this is particularly likely with women in certain religions/cultures who are already less likely to get screening, early diagnosis and treatment

It’s NOT just about “hurt feelings” or “perceptions” in the medical arena this ideology could well cost women their lives!

NiceLegsShameAboutTheFace · 04/02/2021 12:47

I'm just conflicted because I also believe that trans women are women

FFS Angry

NiceLegsShameAboutTheFace · 04/02/2021 12:43

*A male obstetrician saved my life and dc1's. I am glad he was there! A male nurse was on hand as well - also very happy to have him on the team.&

Fantastic. what about the women who aren't happy with it though? Do you agree that they have the right to ask for same sex medical provision?

prisencolinensinainciusol2 · 04/02/2021 12:34

Post of the day MarieV!

PrawnofthePatriarchy · 04/02/2021 12:31

DF was a GP obstetrician many years ago. He was much loved by so many women patients for his empathy and kindness. I've also had a wonderful male GP who I trusted completely. For those reasons I have no problem with male HCP.

But I totally support the right of any woman to insist on female HCP for intimate examinations.

I may be fine with male HCP but I would strongly object to receiving care from a male who identifies as a woman. To my mind it bespeaks a sinister and unhealthy attitude towards female bodies.

rawalpindithelabrador · 04/02/2021 12:29

I don't mind curry. So does that give me the right to tell my husband, 'Well, because I don't mind it, you have to not mind it and eat it, too'? The fuck it does. Women's rights are not yours to give away.

I wonder how many of these eager assistants who are 'fine' with even a trained monkey providing healthcare would be if they realised that any male who suddenly decides he is a woman just because he feels it is so will have unchaperoned access to female bodies and if you, the patient, have a problem with it you're a bigot who shouldn't be treated.

Is there any other delusion on the planet that is accorded this much leeway? Why the cognitive dissonance on this one?

If someone self-id'd as a 13-year-old when they're in fact 50, do you think that should mean they're entitled to date your own 13-year-old? Because that's exactly what's going on here, males are saying, 'Well, I'm a woman because I feel like it, therefore I should have unfettered access to female bodies (including those of children) or you're a bigot who shouldn't be treated'.

dontdisturbmenow · 04/02/2021 12:24

Have any of the 40 ish voters who think that it is not OK for women to request a female HCP explained themselves yet?
Because under the pressure the NHS finds itself to offer safe care and meet strict criteria, dealing with midwife and nurses shortage, struggling with staff sickness and working around them, adding that women could request a female only team, when ultimately the NHS can't (and of course shouldn't) refuse to train or recruit men is unrealistic.

Every time a male midwife is on a shift, there would need to be an additional female midwife just in case the male midwife has to be replaced. Add to this the ratio of trainee midwife, who need to be supervised on shift, the fact that we are talking 24/7 shifts, it becomes something impossible to promise and therefore demand unless in very exceptional circumstances.

gardenbird48 · 04/02/2021 12:06

@AngelicInnocent

I haven't voted.

Of course you are not being unreasonable to say that same sex provision should be a legitimate choice. You are being unreasonable to imply that the statement from the NMC means that the vast majority of nurses and midwives don't think that or that they believe sex is assigned and TWAW etc.

That is on a par with implying that any British person agrees with statements issued by the government.

A fair point. It might be useful for NMC members to point that out to the leadership who have spoken on their behalf to support self id in the latest GRA consultation.

Self id would guarantee that no woman gets any choice in the sex of their HCP (especially as more hospitals seem to be ignoring the single sex exemptions specified in the EA 2010 in any case)

ArabellaScott · 04/02/2021 12:01

YANBU, OP.

I suffered horribly from a misogynistic bully of an ob-gyn. I would now request female only care, and by female I mean women.

Typesofcatalogue · 04/02/2021 11:59

[quote pumpkinbump]fairplayforwomen.com/penis/[/quote]
The data is very old relating to when treatment and services for transsexuals was not good.

The same paper also shows an increase in violent crime in trans men (f2m) compared to women.

The later cohort did not and cannot be disaggregated. So you cannot draw any conclusion. It does not in any way show that transsexual women are a high risk to women.

Although given the wide umbrella of ‘trans’ that can include any cross dressing male and there’s no reason to think their risk is any different to any other men.

YANBU women should be able to request same sex provision. Anyone can request same sex provision and they do.

NotBadConsidering · 04/02/2021 11:52

XXY - Klinefelter Syndrome - is not an intersex condition. They are unequivocally male. Same with all of the chromosomal aneuploidies affecting X and Y. Those with XO are unequivocally women with Turner Syndrome. XXX, trisomy X are unequivocally women.

The term “assigned” in relation to intersex/DSDs arose from the way these children were treated in the past. Their genitalia were looked at and it was decided by doctors how they could best “pass” as adults as they were or with some surgical intervention. So for example, a male with a severe micro penis could be “assigned” to be female because it would be “better” for them. A girl with clitoromegaly could be “assigned” as male etc. This decision was made on infants, it was decided what was best for them. Understandably this came under severe criticism. Adults who had this done to them felt their bodies weren’t right, and their autonomy on such decisions was taken from them. They have successfully, and righty in my view, campaigned for much less intervention unless absolutely necessary and for no “assigning” to happen in such circumstances. They have campaigned for hormone treatments and surgery to be delayed until adulthood where possible (if not essential to life beforehand). This is the exact opposite of what trans activists are campaigning for for children; they want children to be treated as young as possible. This is why intersex advocates have asked to be left out of the debate.

However, nearly all intersex/DSDs are male or female, regardless of the appearance of the external genitalia. This can be determined within days of a baby being born with rapid FISH for chromosomes and an ultrasound to look for gonads, which are what determine a person’s sex.

Nearly every baby can have their sex accurately observed and recorded at birth. Those very rare babies with genuine ambiguity - much less that the 1% or “red hair” myth - can have their sex determined shortly after, and recorded. Even more rarely sex may not be revealed until much later, such as with Complete Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome.

So in answer to the OP, for a council representing midwives and nurses to state babies are “assigned” at birth is reprehensible. It’s anti-science. And worst of all, it’s not just them who are guilty. It’s actually been written into legislation in some places. We are living in a world where the same governments telling us all to listen to the science on things like Covid vaccines are also telling us doctors and midwives trot around birthing suites and maternity units with a sorting hat picking and choosing what sex to “assign” to babies on any given day.

It’s a bonkers world.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 11:48

How unsurprising that since being banned from Twitter you’ve found your new home on Mumsnet.

He was posting on MN well before he was banned from Twitter, actually.

EveEveander · 04/02/2021 11:47

@nothingcomestonothing

FFS! Nothing is 'assigned' at birth, it's not a fucking lottery! Just another example of how ideologically captured healthcare is in this country.

As several PP have said, my preference would be female sexed professional, then male sexed professional with chaperone, male born person performing their version of female never. I am not here to validate your identity, especially when I'm the patient and you're the care giver!

The entitlement just blows me away. Who was that trans GP boasting about how female Muslim patients didn't used to let him perform intimate exams, but now he's a she they do? Thinking about those women patients makes me so angry, their dignity and their religious and cultural beliefs overridden to validate the person supposedly there to care for them. I fucking hate it.

Absolutely agree
Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 11:47

BACP, who put out a guide to gender identity and relationships by a non binary person, that asserted that being a (stereotype of a) northern woman was masculine in character.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 04/02/2021 11:46

"I don't mind who I see" and "what if you were about to die" obviously not counting as a valid explanation. Come on!

I can't for the life of me understand why women who don't mind being cared for by male practitioners (in most cases that would be me too) think they have the right to make that decision for every other woman as well.

Other women don't necessarily feel the same as me. I decide my own boundaries; I don't have a say in how others decide theirs. Other women's rights are not mine to give away.

Why are the 'let's all share and #BeKind' advocates seemingly incapable of comprehending this?

I also can't help but agree - I don't want to but I do - that there's something nefarious about a TW insisting on doing a job that required unfettered access to women's bodies - and screaming 'bigot' when they object - when there are a kazillion other occupations that demand no such insinuation. I've thought about whether I'd be more uncomfortable with a TW performing this kind of examination on me than a man. Unfortunately, although I'd prefer this not to be the case, it's true. And if it's true, that's the fault of the brand of vociferous, misogynistic activism that consistently aims rape threats and other pleasantries at women who don't play along with every word. Their fault. Not mine.

How unsurprising that since being banned from Twitter you’ve found your new home on Mumsnet.

Re this point directed at Glinner. And how unsurprising that you should have gone to all the trouble of stalking him from that site to this. It must have taken a considerable commitment in time and effort. Desperate or what?