Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Dutch1e · 04/02/2021 14:28

I'm still incredulous at this

What is intimidating about a biological man? Is it his penis or his stereotypically male characteristics?

What's intimidating is that men as a social class are fucking dangerous and every single one of them is a threat by default until proven otherwise.

Take a quick peek at the rapes, beatings, abuse and harassment that we know of and ask yourself why we should stay in the water reminding ourselves that Not All Sharks Are Like That in order to validate the shark.

AlfonsoTheSensible · 04/02/2021 14:14

Right now, I am not fussed about the sex of who carries out an intimate examination.

But I want the right to refuse to have an intimate examination carried out by someone who makes me uncomfortable, for whatever reason. To date, this has not been an issue but I want to be able to make that choice if I have to.

And I want women to be able to make that choice without being labelled 'bigoted' or 'transphobic'.

dontdisturbmenow · 04/02/2021 14:04

We are talking about women having the right to request a same sex hcp
No issue at all with a right to request, but sadly many confuse right to request and entitlement. Same with requesting flexible working which all workers can request but then shouting I fairness when they are told it's not possible.

Terriblewithmoney · 04/02/2021 14:03

@gardenbird48

But I have always been able to e.g. ask to see a female GP. So what changed? I am fine with the NHS ring fencing jobs for females too if the demand for males in these roles is so low. I see no need for male midwives to be recruited and trained unless they can be effectively deployed without this kind of issue arising.

How long have you got? Basically there has been a very stealthy push within the NHS (and every public body) to change policy to enable people to self identify as whichever ‘gender’ they prefer. This allows male bodied transgender people to choose to be placed on women’s wards (even if they only id as female part time). This results in a hospital taking a letter from a patient requesting a same sex hcp and posting it in training material as an example of unacceptable ‘transphobia’.

This results in female staff having to change uniform in the same space as a male identifying as a female and being banned from objection under threat of their job.

This results in one hospital trust making a safeguarding provision to mitigate the risks of a male sex offender being placed on a female ward by saying that he ‘may’ be prescribed anti-libidinous drugs.

This results in frontline nursing staff being banned from discussing with female patients why there is a person with a male body in the bed next to them in breach of the single sex accommodation policy (except that breaches for that particular reason are inexplicably not recorded)

They also are replacing protected characteristics in their equality policies (or missing them out altogether). So Sex usually gets dropped and the NMC (Nursing and Midwifery Council) has dropped Pregnancy and Maternity in its latest review of discrimination in its staff. They have introduced two new pcs - gender (legally undefined) and gender identity (also not in the Ea 2010 and legally undefined) and are in grave risk of action against them as they are not complying with the law.

There is a major effort by some very influential organisations to remove single sections exemptions from the Equality Act 2010 and the resulting safeguards and protections.

Women are fighting back.

Sorry - 'What's changed?' was sort of rhetorical in that I know what has changed - people started pretending they believed TWAW - but actually not rhetorical because nothing has actually changed except that a pp wants me to believe that it's far far too complex to provide women to do fanjo work and Aneurin Bevan will be cross with me if I request one Grin
poorbuthappy · 04/02/2021 14:03

@Datun - absolutely.
If it's wrong for women to request and get then it's also wrong for men to request and get.

Still waiting for all the cancer charities / health boards etc to update their literature to remove the word man....it's odd how that's not transphobic isn't it?

Biscuitsanddoombar · 04/02/2021 14:03

Of course not poor why would it be?

I know my DH who is very shy and hates being touched generally would hate to have a prostate exam from a woman.

Sexnotgender · 04/02/2021 14:02

@poorbuthappy

Is it unreasonable for a man to ask for a male HCP to perform a prostrate exam?
No of course not. I’m not sure anyone has suggested it is.
MerchedCymru · 04/02/2021 14:02

Here's a welcome response to the related issue of single-sex wards from Lewisham & Greenham NHS.

www.lewishamandgreenwich.nhs.uk/same-sex-accomodation/

If any of you are on here, Flowers.

Datun · 04/02/2021 14:00

@poorbuthappy

Is it unreasonable for a man to ask for a male HCP to perform a prostrate exam?
No, not at all. But I wonder how he'd feel if an obvious woman showed up, and he wasn't allowed to mention it.
poorbuthappy · 04/02/2021 13:58

Is it unreasonable for a man to ask for a male HCP to perform a prostrate exam?

JoodyBlue · 04/02/2021 13:50

@Purplepeonies RE: I'm just conflicted because I also believe that trans women are women.

Women are the class of human with the anatomy that produce, carry, birth and feed babies, even if the ability or desire to do that is not present - yet it is the common denomination of woman. If you are using a four word mantra as your education, I think that is where your conflict is arising.

FeckinCat · 04/02/2021 13:49

Women should absolutely be able to request same sex provision and without having to disclose their reason(s) for that preference.

gardenbird48 · 04/02/2021 13:49

But I have always been able to e.g. ask to see a female GP. So what changed? I am fine with the NHS ring fencing jobs for females too if the demand for males in these roles is so low. I see no need for male midwives to be recruited and trained unless they can be effectively deployed without this kind of issue arising.

How long have you got? Basically there has been a very stealthy push within the NHS (and every public body) to change policy to enable people to self identify as whichever ‘gender’ they prefer. This allows male bodied transgender people to choose to be placed on women’s wards (even if they only id as female part time). This results in a hospital taking a letter from a patient requesting a same sex hcp and posting it in training material as an example of unacceptable ‘transphobia’.

This results in female staff having to change uniform in the same space as a male identifying as a female and being banned from objection under threat of their job.

This results in one hospital trust making a safeguarding provision to mitigate the risks of a male sex offender being placed on a female ward by saying that he ‘may’ be prescribed anti-libidinous drugs.

This results in frontline nursing staff being banned from discussing with female patients why there is a person with a male body in the bed next to them in breach of the single sex accommodation policy (except that breaches for that particular reason are inexplicably not recorded)

They also are replacing protected characteristics in their equality policies (or missing them out altogether). So Sex usually gets dropped and the NMC (Nursing and Midwifery Council) has dropped Pregnancy and Maternity in its latest review of discrimination in its staff. They have introduced two new pcs - gender (legally undefined) and gender identity (also not in the Ea 2010 and legally undefined) and are in grave risk of action against them as they are not complying with the law.

There is a major effort by some very influential organisations to remove single sections exemptions from the Equality Act 2010 and the resulting safeguards and protections.

Women are fighting back.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 04/02/2021 13:45

Nope - just clicked on the thread and recognised the username.

Of course you did.

SummerBlondey · 04/02/2021 13:43

In a life or death situation, I think I'd just be grateful to anyone equipped to save me, BUT....I always request a female nurse for my smear, I've never had any problems with this request.

ParadiseIsland · 04/02/2021 13:41

I am a HCP.
I dint agree with the idea that a woman has to accept a TW as a HCP ‘because they are women too’.

However, you also work within in certain structure. There isn’t a lot of leeway in the nhs for example. So what do you expect HCP to say or do?

Directionerforever · 04/02/2021 13:40

I don’t think it’s that unusual that many HCP’s don’t feel able to speak out or identify publicly as an HCP who is gender critical when this is the message that their regulatory body are aligning themselves with.

Graphista · 04/02/2021 13:24

It is not going to be helped by many cancer charities removing the word ‘woman’ from their publicity re female cancers

Totally agree, such actions are a Fucking disgrace and frankly an insult to the women they claim to represent

Medical misogyny is already and has for many years made the treatment of women far more difficult and ineffective than it should be. This latest development will make things worse not better. This is NOT progress

ListeningQuietly · 04/02/2021 13:23

ancientgran
20 plus years ago Chromosome testing was not easily available
now it is

In the 70's we called men competing in women's sports CHEATS
East German shot put etc
now we are supposed to admire them

It has never been easier to check and record the sex of an individual

It is scary that certain individuals get their affirmation
by infringing the rights
of the other sex

Terriblewithmoney · 04/02/2021 13:16

@dontdisturbmenow

Have any of the 40 ish voters who think that it is not OK for women to request a female HCP explained themselves yet? Because under the pressure the NHS finds itself to offer safe care and meet strict criteria, dealing with midwife and nurses shortage, struggling with staff sickness and working around them, adding that women could request a female only team, when ultimately the NHS can't (and of course shouldn't) refuse to train or recruit men is unrealistic.

Every time a male midwife is on a shift, there would need to be an additional female midwife just in case the male midwife has to be replaced. Add to this the ratio of trainee midwife, who need to be supervised on shift, the fact that we are talking 24/7 shifts, it becomes something impossible to promise and therefore demand unless in very exceptional circumstances.

But I have always been able to e.g. ask to see a female GP. So what changed? I am fine with the NHS ring fencing jobs for females too if the demand for males in these roles is so low. I see no need for male midwives to be recruited and trained unless they can be effectively deployed without this kind of issue arising.
Idratherberude · 04/02/2021 13:15

"I'm just conflicted because I also believe that trans women are women."

That's fascinating @Purplepeonies! Can you tell us more? Do you have any idea what sex anyone is, before they tell you? Do you know how babies are made and which parent gestated you?
Do you know which sex you are and how to access appropriate healthcare for the body parts you have? And if you think you know, how are you sure?

jeaux90 · 04/02/2021 13:14

YANBU the only time I've had a man perform any intimate services was because he was an absolute specialist but was always chaperoned.

It made me feel hugely uncomfortable none the less.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 13:12

Which is most important when they conflict?

Right of the patient to dignity in their care. Every single time.

WendyTestaburger · 04/02/2021 13:11

Manicpixiedreammollusc

Care to actually join in with the thread?

I'm really interested to hear more ideas why it's unreasonable for women to request female HCPs. The closest to an actual answer was re the staffing of a maternity unit. When I voted I was thinking of the question in general - for all intimate procedures like smears and breast exams - as well as births.

But re births, surely if it was best practice to allow the choice for a female, with the understanding that an emergency is an emergency, then the hospital would just have to make sure the ratio of male to female midwives on staff was appropriate?

It's not unfeasible, to take into account the needs of the many women who have experienced sexual assault by males and also religious women. And also other women who feel the need to be around women in this most extreme and vulnerable and uniquely female of experiences.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/02/2021 13:07

Although given the wide umbrella of ‘trans’ that can include any cross dressing male and there’s no reason to think their risk is any different to any other men.

Exactly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread