Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?

461 replies

Glinner · 03/02/2021 19:55

The tweet below is astonishing for two reasons. First of all, as the poster points out, this is the NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL saying that one's sex is 'assigned' at birth. They said this out loud! As part of their evidence to the GRA enquiry!

But aside from that nonsense, what stood out for me was the number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates whose 'gender identity' does not match their sex. 4,484! That seems like a high number, does it not? I wonder how many of that number are fully intact males?

You might remember when Clare Dimyon requested a same-sex nurse to attend her during her mammogram, the NHS responded in the most extraordinary way--they took her name off the letter and published it in official literature as an example of a 'bigoted' request.

One thing for which we should be grateful to Eddie Izzard: Now we are under no doubt that in many cases 'trans' means, simply, 'crossdresser'. Are these 'trans' nurses, midwives and nursing assistants crossdressers? Are women within their rights to request that crossdressing men not be present during intimate exams and so on? If a woman makes this request, will she be committing a hate crime?

Here's the Clare Dimyon story

glinner.co.uk/interview-with-clare-dimyon-mbe/

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/patient-branded-transphobic-after-asking-for-female-medic-3jh3snddt

twitter.com/Sexnotgender_/status/1357034763039686662

AIBU to think that women should be able to request same-sex provision?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/02/2021 15:36

I can't help feeling that using about someone such words as "notorious" and "bizarre" tells me more about the person writing than about the person they are writing of.

Quaagars · 04/02/2021 15:33

Good post katynps - I agree, that's exactly what I mean, it's where the reasonable is getting mixed up with extreme/ and or bigoted views where the problem lies

FeckinCat · 04/02/2021 15:32

@Quaagars

I'd vote YANBU, as of course women should be able to choose to have a woman if they so prefer looking after them, but let's not be under any pretence going by the other threads and the comments on here, it's more like "I don't want to have to have trans women near me". Which is a whole other argument but worded "innocently" for anyone not seeing trans threads before.
Not at all.

I had a male MW during my second pregnancy. If he had told me that he was transgender and now preferred to be known by a female name/pronouns it would have made no difference to me.

If I had stated a preference for a MW who was the same sex as me and my male MW had insisted that he was now female, I would not have been happy. The relationship between a woman and her HCP must be based on a position of trust. If my HCP tries to make me believe something that is patently a lie, I would feel unable to trust them with my care/health.

100PercentMe · 04/02/2021 15:28

Not read beyond the OP but the recent Nursing and Midwifery council review about nursing staff experience of inequalities had none other than Stonewall listed in their list of advisors.
And had gender identity listed in amongst the protected characteristics. And kept referring to gender instead of sex in general.

katnyps · 04/02/2021 15:22

For what it's worth, and perhaps stating the obvious here, but this thread is suffering from what all discussions around controversial topics are at risk of getting into; well reasoned arguments getting mixed up with more extreme and (in my opinion) bigoted views. I actually agree that anyone should be allowed to ask for same-(biological) sex HCPs, and that it's wrong to be labelled a bigot in this respect. It doesn't mean you will be able to access the same care in the same timeframe (as Claire notes in her interview around her surgery taking three times as long) but I do think you should also have the option of a same-(biological) sex chaperone. I also think that most transgender HCPs would actually respect this request in the situation - any trans people able to corroborate that?
However, I think this fairly reasonable argument gets damaged when people start name calling and giving the strong impression that they assume a significant proportion of trans people working in healthcare are doing this for some nefarious purpose - that, in my view, is transphobic. I know most people aren't saying that here but there are some pretty transphobic views being discussed here that I think need to be challenged.
Does anyone know if the Sussex board view, represented by the Claire D exams, is actually reflecting the wider NHS position?

Impatiens · 04/02/2021 15:22

I just don't like the way from a lot (not all!) the hostility and outright "no" and prejudice towards trans people from some.

You are wrongly taking 'outright no' as prejudice - that's your issue, not other posters.

ErrolTheDragon · 04/02/2021 15:18

What has that got to do with transgender people?

It should have absolutely nothing to do with them.

Unfortunately, some individuals and some health organisations are prioritising the gender of the employee over the sex, and desire for same-sex treatment, of patients.

DARVO.Hmm

Personally I'm fine with male HCPs so a TW would be fine by me. But that's irrelevant to the needs of other women.

Quaagars · 04/02/2021 15:15

A transwoman who is open about being a transwoman is as welcome as most other male bodied person to be near me

That's not usually what I've seen in the comments before, as a lot do not usually want trans women to be able to turn up, and for one comment earlier on the thread said men should be banned altogether from gynaecology type professions (the one I quoted and asked why)

I do appreciate that there are women who would prefer a female doctor, and as I said we should always have the right to choose - I just don't like the way from a lot (not all!) the hostility and outright "no" and prejudice towards trans people from some.

DaisiesandButtercups · 04/02/2021 15:12

Quaagars

As I mentioned before, I understand that my opinion is not in keeping with current trends but I believe that a woman who has been traumatised by male violence trumps the woman who doesn’t really mind and had a really lovely male doctor or nurse once.

If any woman does not feel comfortable with any health care professional then she should have the right to request a different one without giving a reason.

WendyTestaburger · 04/02/2021 15:12

@unmarkedbythat

If posters could make clear in the thread titles that the thread is another one about trans issues that would be really helpful to those of us who would rather wade through cold sick than have to read yet another MN trans debate.
You don't think that current trans rights activism (and by that I do not mean all trans people) has affected women's ability to request single sex services?

Have you not read the example about Claire Dimyon?

Or do you not believe women should have the right to request single sex HCPs?

It's a fairly basic topic for a board frequented by so many mothers. Which part offends you?

WendyTestaburger · 04/02/2021 15:04

No quaagars

That's really disrespectful. How dare you try and frame women discussing their need to be seen by a woman as transphobia.

A transwoman who is open about being a transwoman is as welcome as most other male bodied person to be near me. ie Most of the time, as my friend, neighbour or colleague : just fine. On a few occasions where I am going to be alone or naked or otherwise vulnerable: no thank you.

If you have a problem, talk to the trans rights activists (who are not necessarily trans people) who got us into this mess. Not the women requesting occasionally to be allowed to exercise their rights.

ancientgran · 04/02/2021 15:04

@WendyTestaburger

Just noticing the ratio is hovering around 11% whilst the number of votes goes steadily up. So while that's still a small percentage it reflects an ever growing number of voters who believe women have no right to request a female HCP and yet somehow cannot find the words to express why, on this anonymous forum.
I haven't voted, I would have voted for people having the right to request a same sex or opposite sex HCP. It isn't that I'm against women being able to request same sex it is that I'd favour the broader policy so I felt neither answer applied to me. Don't know why people would vote against, I feel that requesting something is generally reasonable.
Quaagars · 04/02/2021 15:00

What has that got to do with transgender people?

Maybe ask all the people in the comments talking about transgender people?

Quaagars · 04/02/2021 14:58

I actually think that men of any variety should be barred from working in maternity or gynaecology in any capacity

Why?
If they're good at what they do?
I've had lots of lovely male doctors.
The only doctor I have actually gone out of my way to say "just not so and so doctor" when they asked if I had a preference when it came to booking an appointment was a female one who was absolutely awful.
Surely that's taking away choice from women too, who would prefer a male doctor, and I thought "we" (general we) were against taking choice away?

unmarkedbythat · 04/02/2021 14:57

If posters could make clear in the thread titles that the thread is another one about trans issues that would be really helpful to those of us who would rather wade through cold sick than have to read yet another MN trans debate.

Impatiens · 04/02/2021 14:56

@Quaagars

I'd vote YANBU, as of course women should be able to choose to have a woman if they so prefer looking after them, but let's not be under any pretence going by the other threads and the comments on here, it's more like "I don't want to have to have trans women near me". Which is a whole other argument but worded "innocently" for anyone not seeing trans threads before.
And this is exactly the attitude that has led to this inexcusable situation - where Women are made to feel it's 'transphobic' or 'bigoted' to request a FEMALE health-care professional or same-sex ward.

This poster does not understand and doesn't care about the needs of Women at their most vulnerable times - giving birth, undergoing treatment for serious illness, hospitalisation. It's an unforgivable manipulation of the truth.

gardenbird48 · 04/02/2021 14:55

@Quaagars

I'd vote YANBU, as of course women should be able to choose to have a woman if they so prefer looking after them, but let's not be under any pretence going by the other threads and the comments on here, it's more like "I don't want to have to have trans women near me". Which is a whole other argument but worded "innocently" for anyone not seeing trans threads before.
Quaag - did you notice that this is about choosing same sex provision? So I am female and I want to choose another female as opposed to a male hcp (and I support the converse for men obviously).

What has that got to do with transgender people?

katnyps · 04/02/2021 14:47

@Dutch1e
I'm sorry, you probably have had some bad experiences, but I think what you have said is sexist and offensive. YES I believe we should protect women, YES I acknowledge the statistics but I am strongly in the "not all men" camp I'm afraid.

Quaagars · 04/02/2021 14:47

I'd vote YANBU, as of course women should be able to choose to have a woman if they so prefer looking after them, but let's not be under any pretence going by the other threads and the comments on here, it's more like "I don't want to have to have trans women near me".
Which is a whole other argument but worded "innocently" for anyone not seeing trans threads before.

MerchedCymru · 04/02/2021 14:44

Good point garden - definitions are slippery these days. I take it you are in the Bristol area? Serious levels of misogyny in that neck of the woods, but prettily dressed in pastel blue and pink.

A number of our members have been at the receiving end of their masked protests - one against a public meeting to discuss 'Writing against the patriarchy' as I recall. Oh how we chuckled at the irony as we hurried past the threats and placards.

WendyTestaburger · 04/02/2021 14:40

Just noticing the ratio is hovering around 11% whilst the number of votes goes steadily up. So while that's still a small percentage it reflects an ever growing number of voters who believe women have no right to request a female HCP and yet somehow cannot find the words to express why, on this anonymous forum.

Graphista · 04/02/2021 14:38

So what do you expect HCP to say or do?

Advocate for patients! This is part of your professional duty!

How about upholding point ONE of the code for starters?!

https://www.nmc.org.uk/globalassets/sitedocuments/nmc-publications/nmc-code.pdf

1 Treat people as individuals and uphold their dignity
To achieve this, you must:
1.1 treat people with kindness, respect and compassion
1.2 make sure you deliver the fundamentals of care effectively
1.3 avoid making assumptions and recognise diversity and individual choice
1.4 make sure that any treatment, assistance or care for which you are responsible is delivered without undue delay
1.5 respect and uphold people’s human rights

This seems to have been completely disregarded!

Is it unreasonable for a man to ask for a male HCP to perform a prostrate exam? no definitely not unreasonable

Typesofcatalogue · 04/02/2021 14:33

flexible working which all workers can request but then shouting I fairness when they are told it's not possible.

Yea, but question sometimes is why is it not possible and why is it possible for some and ‘not possible’ for others.

gardenbird48 · 04/02/2021 14:31

@MerchedCymru

Here's a welcome response to the related issue of single-sex wards from Lewisham & Greenham NHS.

www.lewishamandgreenwich.nhs.uk/same-sex-accomodation/

If any of you are on here, Flowers.

That is potentially good news but I strongly advise you to check their policies on supporting transgender patients.

The same sex accommodation policy in our area is similar to above but what isn’t immediately apparent is that the Supporting Transgender Patients policy takes precedence and counts as female any male who wishes to identify as female, even on a part time basis. So they are not breaching the single sex accommodation policy, they just count males as female. And don’t record that as a breach - so no data.

The policy also explicitly states that if there is any conflict in needs between women and a transgender patient, the requirements of the transgender will always take precedence.

Interestingly, an influential member of the steering group that shapes policy for the whole region is a male bodied transgender person who also gives talks to menopausal women on hrt and has a blog where they make it very clear how they feel about many women. They were involved in the protests against (I think) a Fair Play For Women meeting in Bristol.

Terriblewithmoney · 04/02/2021 14:30

@dontdisturbmenow

We are talking about women having the right to request a same sex hcp No issue at all with a right to request, but sadly many confuse right to request and entitlement. Same with requesting flexible working which all workers can request but then shouting I fairness when they are told it's not possible.
Great. You'll be a YANBU vote then.
Swipe left for the next trending thread