Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children should be taught financial literacy?

111 replies

HeidiHaughton · 01/02/2021 18:52

All the threads from women in such precarious financial situations. Never seemed to occur to them the cost of not working. And the invariable refrain that it "didn't make sense to go back after maternity leave". Surely as a social good people should be educated about how finances work.

OP posts:
Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 21:48

Magenta, are you a passionate maths teacher?

Maths is a tricky subject and many dc are visual learners who get lost because we can't do bespoke teaching in our school.

You say dc won't engage with free eduction and that's not the fault of the school? You sound defensive?

Who said it was the fault of school? Actually I do think it is because school cannot be flexible enough but with large classes maybe they can't but I often wonder what a small bit of thinking out the box would do.

As a society we shouldn't be leaving a 15 year old to flounder and waste time in maths lessons.
We should make sure they can do basic adding, subtracting... Times tables and basic fractions.

Then we should teach them budgeting.. On food shop sites, role play Saturday jobs, wages, as I said before empower them.

Phineyj · 01/02/2021 21:46

I'm on the fence. Schools can and do include a fair bit of this, although it's left up to the school how much. But virtually all maths courses include this stuff as examples in the textbook, plus there is PHSE, business studies, Economics, Young Enterprise and a plethora of competitions and resources (Barclays used to do good ones). But only a minority of students ever seem to be interested - I think it's one of those things that's hard to imagine needing till you do.

Plus as a teacher, most of my colleagues are woefully ignorant about financial matters!

MagentaDoesNotExist · 01/02/2021 21:46

@corythatwas

I understand debt and interest and all the rest, thank you very much. Unfortunately I also understood that however much my working was an investment in my pension, it wasn't always an investment we could afford at a time when the cost for childcare + travel to work came to more than my earnings (this was in the days before any subsidised nursery hours etc).
I think this is the thing. The vast majorit of people IMO who struggle to budget/ manage their money do so because they don't earn enough of it. That is a societal, structural problem.

I suppose there's an argument that making the unfairness of it clearer might create the political momentum to change it, but that's not the same as saying it's a problem because people don't "get it". I think pretty much every adult understands that more money going out than coming in leads to misery (and most children, per Oliver Twist etc!)

I believe most people who struggle to budget do so because the cost of living compared to their reasonably achievable salaries is too high, or because they are struggling with other issues like addictions, compulsive behaviour etc.

Not judging this before people jump on me - I believe this as I've experienced some of these things myself! And people should get support to help them in those circumstances, in that way our society is extremely rubbish. I'm just not sure that not being able to add and subtract is the problem in most cases.

00deed1988 · 01/02/2021 21:43

YANBU.

I grew up being told it was rude to discuss money. I remember asking my stepdad how much he earned as I was genuinely curious and being shouted at for being so rude. The rest of my family were on benefits/disability/state pension and renting council houses so I was clueless. When I 1st got a job I blew every last penny...for years. I didn't even realise you had to pay for water until I had my own flat!

My husband on the other hand was brought up by people who educated him on money and saved into pensions and paid a mortgage. He is much better with money that me. Only in the last 2 years in my early 30s now I have started saving towards a house deposit, sorted my credit rating and got several pensions and insurance.

I have sat down with my kids, showed them how much money we earn and asked them how much they think we pay for things and showed them on little slips so they understand what bills have to be paid and the value of money. They are still young and will teach them properly when they are older. Of course the parents should do it but some parents just aren't capable as they haven't got a clue themselves!

HerringGull · 01/02/2021 21:42

@Ohalrightthen you think people shouldn't have children in this country if they are likely to grow up in poverty? Have you asked many children who grew up in poverty if they would have preferred not to be born at all?

I grew up poor (comparatively). We couldn't afford to heat more than one room properly (we wore more clothes instead), we didn't go on school trips, got about 5% of the pocket money of our peers from normal earning families, and our clothes were mostly hand-me-downs. But we always ate food. Our earnings as a family were well below the poverty line, so technically I am a child who grew up in poverty (I would describe it as poor instead, as many people are much worse off).

I had an extremely happy childhood and grew into an adult with a sound understanding of money. I argue that a poor childhood can increase your chance of being able to manage money well, IF your parents help you learn. Would I rather not have been born? Errr... no.

Ch3rish · 01/02/2021 21:41

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

Would be very hard to teach without risking it becoming financial advice.
No it wouldn't, teaching about bank accounts, credit cards, budgeting, borrowing money etc has got nothing to do with financial advice.

I can't believe anyone thinks that anything approaching a regulated activity would be included

corythatwas · 01/02/2021 21:39

I understand debt and interest and all the rest, thank you very much. Unfortunately I also understood that however much my working was an investment in my pension, it wasn't always an investment we could afford at a time when the cost for childcare + travel to work came to more than my earnings (this was in the days before any subsidised nursery hours etc).

MagentaDoesNotExist · 01/02/2021 21:39

@Mudmudingloriousmud

Magenta, I couldn't disagree more.

No maths is very relatable, I'm talking about teens not primary age.

By 15 if a child isn't understanding basic maths they are not going to and forcing them to waste hours of their life staring at stuff they cannot understand, is not helpful to them at all.

We really do need to arm them with the basics of budgets... Employee rights.. Nmw etc...

There are a lot of dc who get to 15 and can barely to the 3 times table. They are the very ones who need some financial sense... Put in a real life way... I mean you even give them an ocado shop to do for 4 weeks with x amount.. Rent x amount... Real life.

That's basic addition and subtraction that is the focus for much of primary school. The issue isn't the curriculum, it's people not engaging with the free education provided, which is very sad. But I don't think that is the fault of schools.
MagentaDoesNotExist · 01/02/2021 21:37

@Womencanlift

To the pp that said what should get dropped from the curriculum I do think mortgages, how to budget, how income tax works etc. is more of an educational benefit than different types of triangles, all the sin/cos/tan stuff and lots of other things I have never used since I left my last maths class 20 years ago
I remember about people moaning about learning trigonometry when I was at school and saying it was pointless when it's actually so, so useful.

But regardless a tiny amount of time is spent on that compared to basic addition and subtraction (all you need for budgeting) and multiplication and percentages (all that you need to understand mortgages, credit card interest, etc). The curriculum already covers all of this. People not listening or being interested in learning it may be more of an issue.

PaperMonster · 01/02/2021 21:36

Years ago I used to teach a personal finance module on BTECs - was a bit of an eye opener.

Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 21:36

Magenta, I couldn't disagree more.

No maths is very relatable, I'm talking about teens not primary age.

By 15 if a child isn't understanding basic maths they are not going to and forcing them to waste hours of their life staring at stuff they cannot understand, is not helpful to them at all.

We really do need to arm them with the basics of budgets... Employee rights.. Nmw etc...

There are a lot of dc who get to 15 and can barely to the 3 times table. They are the very ones who need some financial sense... Put in a real life way... I mean you even give them an ocado shop to do for 4 weeks with x amount.. Rent x amount... Real life.

smoothchange · 01/02/2021 21:33

Parents need to start teaching their children about real life things.

Not all parents can't. They don't all possess the knowledge to do so. This is why teaching this in school would be hugely beneficial to the country as a whole. Let people know and understand both opportunity and consequence.

Katjolo · 01/02/2021 21:33

It's on the PSHE curriculum.

Womencanlift · 01/02/2021 21:32

To the pp that said what should get dropped from the curriculum I do think mortgages, how to budget, how income tax works etc. is more of an educational benefit than different types of triangles, all the sin/cos/tan stuff and lots of other things I have never used since I left my last maths class 20 years ago

Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 21:32

How would it be hard to teach?

MagentaDoesNotExist · 01/02/2021 21:32

@Mudmudingloriousmud

Yes, yes and yes again.

Imagine how we would empower our dc if instead of triangles, they learned about stocks and shares, compound interest, 🏦 loans.. Food shop budgeting!
Credit cards.. Money manege meant, ways of saving and budgeting!

It's all very well saying parents should do it, yes in a ideal world they should but I work with students who come from extremely difficult backgrounds, multiple children living across other family members because the parents are into their 2nd family or 3rd new family.
Students with a parent with drugs issues, some in Foster care with parents who don't want to know them.
These students already face enough challenges and it pains me to see them slogging over algebra, when I know soon they will be young adults and possibly begin families of their own and they can't budget.

We need all dc to learn basic money management... It would turn society around to empower them with knowledge about over drafts, loans, rent.. Owning.. Food budgets.

But understanding fundamental maths and algebra is exactly how you understand compound interest, annuities or mortgages, investments etc. Budgets are the basic level of maths taught at primary school before any algebra, just simple addition and subtraction. Surely mathematical literacy is the key? The practical applications flow naturally and are understandable as a result of learning the theoretical concepts that school mathematics focuses on.
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 01/02/2021 21:28

@HeidiHaughton

All the threads from women in such precarious financial situations. Never seemed to occur to them the cost of not working. And the invariable refrain that it "didn't make sense to go back after maternity leave". Surely as a social good people should be educated about how finances work.
What makes you think that not even one of those women know the cost of it and either don't care,consider it worthy or simply don't have a better option right then?

Do you seriously believe that if we had "better education " no women would be SAHMs?

That circumstances, opportunities, life choices never come into play and it's all about educating people?

willFOURbagsbeenough · 01/02/2021 21:27

Martin Lewis has actually achieved this. He got it onto the curriculum in England a few years ago and has now gotten it for Wales, NI and Scotland.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 01/02/2021 21:24

Would be very hard to teach without risking it becoming financial advice.

Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 21:23

I feel very strongly about it and I will be writing to Boris about it.

Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 21:21

Yes, yes and yes again.

Imagine how we would empower our dc if instead of triangles, they learned about stocks and shares, compound interest, 🏦 loans.. Food shop budgeting!
Credit cards.. Money manege meant, ways of saving and budgeting!

It's all very well saying parents should do it, yes in a ideal world they should but I work with students who come from extremely difficult backgrounds, multiple children living across other family members because the parents are into their 2nd family or 3rd new family.
Students with a parent with drugs issues, some in Foster care with parents who don't want to know them.
These students already face enough challenges and it pains me to see them slogging over algebra, when I know soon they will be young adults and possibly begin families of their own and they can't budget.

We need all dc to learn basic money management... It would turn society around to empower them with knowledge about over drafts, loans, rent.. Owning.. Food budgets.

Polyxena · 01/02/2021 20:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Brighterthansunflowers · 01/02/2021 20:44

The thing is you can’t teach it in school in any meaningful way. It would just be a couple of PHSE lessons. The best way to teach it is parents to teach and model it in an ongoing age appropriate way.

But tbh I think in many cases it’s not that people don’t know the “right” choices it’s that they feel they don’t have choices (childcare costs more than they earn for example). You can tell people it pays in the long term all you like but if people can’t absorb the extra short term cost then they just can’t.

TaraR2020 · 01/02/2021 20:37

Absolutely, everything from basic payslips and tax to investing ought to be taught. As well as how to do a tax return.

Iggly · 01/02/2021 19:13

We choose to have a welfare system to benefit the rich
^ this

Swipe left for the next trending thread