Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children should be taught financial literacy?

111 replies

HeidiHaughton · 01/02/2021 18:52

All the threads from women in such precarious financial situations. Never seemed to occur to them the cost of not working. And the invariable refrain that it "didn't make sense to go back after maternity leave". Surely as a social good people should be educated about how finances work.

OP posts:
smoothchange · 01/02/2021 22:49

It’s not hard to work out finances and if you can afford x, y and z both now and in the future if things change.

It's not hard for you

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 01/02/2021 22:45

I don’t think it should fall to schools, they have enough to cover as it is and it’s just one more thing some parents will opt out of doing for their children if someone else does it.

It’s not hard to work out finances and if you can afford x, y and z both now and in the future if things change.

It’s not just the finances though, it’s about them knowing they can’t have everything they want so needing to make wise choices than plough ahead regardless.

lavenderlou · 01/02/2021 22:44

Financial education is in the curriculum - there is statutory guidance relating to it from the DfE. It is usually taught as part of PSHE (the official subject title is now Personal, Social, Health and Economic education) although PSHE as a subject is actually non-statutory so the financial education part could be taught elsewhere.

In reality, it's a small part of an already overloaded curriculum. Schools aren't judged on it as they are on subjects with exam results (and all the pressure of league tables/Ofsted that goes with that) so in all likelihood kids will get a few lessons per year focused on this aspect.

saffire · 01/02/2021 22:38

Yes. And they should be taught at school- many parents have no idea how to handle money correctly.

Martin Lewis has produced some resources for schools, I believe they are free.

QueenofLouisiana · 01/02/2021 22:32

It is on the curriculum and we do teach it- also mentioned in lessons on negative numbers (how the bank doesn’t actually give you money when you run out- you’ll pay more back!). However, we also teach esafety and I still find my 10 year old pupils putting photos and full names on Facebook for all to see.

SpaceRaiders · 01/02/2021 22:32

I agree. My parents weren’t the most helpful in filling the gaps either, I definitely believe that financial education should be made an equal playing field for every child. And not just for those who have financially literate parents, who are able to support and fill in the gaps. PP instead of asking what should be dropped. Perhaps increasing the school day would be an idea. Many countries manage 8-4pm senior schooling, I’m not sure why the state sector here can’t.

willFOURbagsbeenough · 01/02/2021 22:21

And BTW Martin Lewis financial education textbooks for schools is downloadable for free so any parent who wants to teach their DC financial education at home can.

smoothchange · 01/02/2021 22:19

ok give an example of how to teach about credit cards without sound positive or negative

Why would it need to be presented as positive or negative? Surely just the facts, which would outline both the positive and negative points of using credit cards.

MagentaDoesNotExist · 01/02/2021 22:15

@Mudmudingloriousmud

Umm well its a variety of factors, if your parents are at war or you don't really have a stable family, and you go to school unsettled you won't get dc to learn much but.. Visual learners need more than a colourful TV program?. I mean physical, tactile learning, multi sensory lessons.. Attacking the learning in different ways.

So many dc are from no stable family at all.. One night stands.. As I said earlier.. No actual parent who wants them because they are on to families way down the line?.

Many dc will not understand the more complicated maths, they understand the basics but they will go no further and above all, no maths teaching has context or meaning for them at all. It's random and remote.

However, 15,16 year olds who may have Saturday jobs or want to drive, buy their own clothes.. become independent... Maybe more open to learning about this... Life skills.

I'm telling you now, starring at triangles isn't going to arm them with the financial skills they need.

Ok that's your opinion. I've lived much of that. Unwanted child, independent since 16, struggled with money a lot and lived in poverty for years struggling every month for rent and food or keeping my electricity on. I find your post a bit patronising to be honest.
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/02/2021 22:15

Yanbu and they are taught in my house!

4 year old has toy shopping till and money. I set up tiny pots with priced up things he can buy (5 raisins, a sticker, 5 cheerios etc) and we talk about how 10p wont buy everything Grin

MagentaDoesNotExist · 01/02/2021 22:13

@4redSocks

* I believe most people who struggle to budget do so because the cost of living compared to their reasonably achievable salaries is too high, or because they are struggling with other issues like addictions, compulsive behaviour etc. * *@MagentaDoesNotExist* this is the whole point of money management. Weather your budget is greater than the persons next door it doesn’t matter. Everybody has a budget even some celebs will need to budget to some extent.

Budgeting is not just a thing that exists for low amounts of money.

Yes, I said exactly that. More money out than in equals misery, it's even taught in children's stories. We all know that. I don't think that for most adults who fall into financial difficulty, the issue is that they do not understand this concept. That's my point. 99% do. Their financial troubles sre caused by other factors.
Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 22:09

Look at the lottery winners who blow it in a year.

Some basic financial savvy they would never blow it all!!

Infact.. Arming the dc I know with basic savvy.. Encouraging them t to save open up sipp and isa.. They may end up ahead of wealthier peers who have no financial savvy.
It's not hard!!

Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 22:06

Umm well its a variety of factors, if your parents are at war or you don't really have a stable family, and you go to school unsettled you won't get dc to learn much but.. Visual learners need more than a colourful TV program?. I mean physical, tactile learning, multi sensory lessons.. Attacking the learning in different ways.

So many dc are from no stable family at all.. One night stands.. As I said earlier.. No actual parent who wants them because they are on to families way down the line?.

Many dc will not understand the more complicated maths, they understand the basics but they will go no further and above all, no maths teaching has context or meaning for them at all. It's random and remote.

However, 15,16 year olds who may have Saturday jobs or want to drive, buy their own clothes.. become independent... Maybe more open to learning about this... Life skills.

I'm telling you now, starring at triangles isn't going to arm them with the financial skills they need.

MixedUpFiles · 01/02/2021 22:06

This definitely happens in some families. I don’t know if it’s an economic class issue or just particular people. I remember my parents taking me with to help buy a new car. They showed me all the details of the negotiation, the cost, the financing. Funnily enough, last night at dinner I was discussing with DH making some adjustments to my pension contributions. I made sure to have that conversation at dinner so it would happen in front of dd and she could ask questions.

I do think it becomes tricky to do at school because many of the things that are the “right”way to do things are simply not feasible for some families.

4redSocks · 01/02/2021 22:06
  • I believe most people who struggle to budget do so because the cost of living compared to their reasonably achievable salaries is too high, or because they are struggling with other issues like addictions, compulsive behaviour etc.

@MagentaDoesNotExist this is the whole point of money management. Weather your budget is greater than the persons next door it doesn’t matter. Everybody has a budget even some celebs will need to budget to some extent.

Budgeting is not just a thing that exists for low amounts of money.

thecatsthecats · 01/02/2021 22:04

Not only that, but we actually need children for society to work.

That's a bit of a short sighted view of it. We need more children to service the current population levels, yes. But that will only end in an arms race of producing children to educate them to service the needs of other, much richer, human beings.

Far better to face facts than neither the environment nor the increasing mechanisation of the service industry can sustain current population levels and accept that no one deserves children.

And if that sounds harsh, it's approximately a thousand times less harsh than the consequences of uncontrolled population growth. The earlier the measures occur - education being the principal measure - the better.

Ch3rish · 01/02/2021 22:00

ok give an example of how to teach about credit cards without sound positive or negative

I don't understand what you mean, explaining how a credit card works is neutral and factual, why would it need to be positive or negative?

WeAllHaveWings · 01/02/2021 21:59

Ds has done a personal finance module in school and they get told about this in pse, but really this is something for parents to teach their kids.

Role play Saturday jobs? That is an employers job when they employ a young person.

Schools have enough to do without taking on parents and employers jobs too.

4redSocks · 01/02/2021 21:58

@00deed1988 I think it’s an excellent idea to sit down with teens especially and explain what you have coming in! So they have an understanding of how expensive things are.

MagentaDoesNotExist · 01/02/2021 21:57

@Mudmudingloriousmud

Magenta, are you a passionate maths teacher?

Maths is a tricky subject and many dc are visual learners who get lost because we can't do bespoke teaching in our school.

You say dc won't engage with free eduction and that's not the fault of the school? You sound defensive?

Who said it was the fault of school? Actually I do think it is because school cannot be flexible enough but with large classes maybe they can't but I often wonder what a small bit of thinking out the box would do.

As a society we shouldn't be leaving a 15 year old to flounder and waste time in maths lessons.
We should make sure they can do basic adding, subtracting... Times tables and basic fractions.

Then we should teach them budgeting.. On food shop sites, role play Saturday jobs, wages, as I said before empower them.

I am neither a teacher nor a mathematician, so certainly no reason to be defensive on the subject. Sorry if it seemed like that, I was just expressing a view. I am passionate about children having equal life chances and am just questioning whether this is really the underlying issue here - the school curriculum - or other factors.

I agree that large classes in schools are hugely detrimental in general, education needs funding much better and perhaps pressure for that will come from the pandemic.

As to floundering, nobody should be left to flounder. No child should be leaving primary school without being able to add and subtract so I understand why secondaries aren't focusing on that primarily. There are ways to teach things to different children with different learning styles, like Numberblocks on iPlayer, that's been brilliant for helping my visually focused pre-school DC understand how numbers work. I do think the UK education system is pretty appalling really. I'm just not convinced by the arguments in the thread about how it needs to change, but I'm interested to read other people's views about it.

Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 21:56

Would you warn them about the loan sharks, credit card fees.. Show them if they borrowed x how much they would pay off.. That factual. You would then also show them where and when cc are helpful and how to use them safely.

Also cc judgments.. I accidentally defaulted on an overdraft.. It was on my record for years and years.

Arming them with information..

4redSocks · 01/02/2021 21:54

@PotteringAlong

I agree they should be taught by their parents, but I assume you mean at school. The question then becomes what do you want to get rid of out of the curriculum to add it in. There are not an infinite number of hours in the day to allow every life skill you might ever need to be taught in the classroom.
Trouble is that’s assuming the child's parent has good money management. I think it should be taught in school generally.
Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 21:53

Magenta I know people who earn lots and can't budget it for all areas of society really and some v wealthy carful people who budget too much!!

I know v wealthy people who think having a stock and share investment is literally buying and selling shares at the right moment.. To make a fast buck!!

There is a lot of misunderstanding out there and dc should be drilled in the food budgeting, rent, clothes before they hit 16..

nearlynermal · 01/02/2021 21:53

God yes: compound interest!

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 01/02/2021 21:52

No it wouldn't, teaching about bank accounts, credit cards, budgeting, borrowing money etc has got nothing to do with financial advice ok give an example of how to teach about credit cards without sound positive or negative

I do think mortgages a basic overview would be helpful!

Swipe left for the next trending thread