Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children should be taught financial literacy?

111 replies

HeidiHaughton · 01/02/2021 18:52

All the threads from women in such precarious financial situations. Never seemed to occur to them the cost of not working. And the invariable refrain that it "didn't make sense to go back after maternity leave". Surely as a social good people should be educated about how finances work.

OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 02/02/2021 14:38

Have you asked many children who grew up in poverty if they would have preferred not to be born at all?

Most people don't see it, but I think this type of argument is illogical. It is an irrational emotional argument based on the false premise that never having existed is the same as discarding your (say) 18-year-old life.

Zenithbear · 02/02/2021 14:38

Yanbu.
The amount of financial abuse that is rife on here and in real life.
The amount of women who truly think they have made it because their partner earns enough for them to sah from the minute they have a child. They don't seem to care about their own pension, being financially independent or investing. Leave it to the menfolk.
The people moaning about still living in rented accommodation in their late 30s 40s and 50s predicting house price crashes that rarely happen, blaming landlords, estate agents, the government, the EU etc. Anyone but their own choices.
Lots of people don't understand budgeting, don't have savings, many haven't made a will. Yet have debts and huge mortgages.
So many posts asking if they can afford private school/to leave their dh/manage on £100k a year.
Supposedly professional intelligent people clueless about what to do with 1k,10k, 50k etc.
So many out of touch with reality about what is a good salary. Claiming they could not possibly manage on less than £10k a month. Or 2k each disposable income.

Iwonder08 · 02/02/2021 14:01

Financial literacy should be taught at school. Majority of parents in this country lack basic skills to teach their kids anything to do with finance.

StepOutOfLine · 02/02/2021 10:49

Our citizenship studies have a module about financial and economic literacy and competence. Obligatory for all from 14 onwards from this year. It's important.

(Not in the UK)

MaskingForIt · 02/02/2021 10:47

@thecatsthecats

Pretty much agree with everything you’ve said, both parents should set themselves up to be able to provide for their children, but in some cases taking out life insurance can help to bridge a gap in earnings/lifestyle aims in the main earner dies.

From talking to friends who would benefit from it though, none seem to actually have it.

christmasathomeagain · 02/02/2021 10:39

PHSE is teaching finances as I hear and help my daughter with these lessons. More than we got at school.

However, social financial education is maybe better placed at home but it depends how the parents see it. I think many people who are in poor financial positions do not see that they are in that position because of decisions they made (not everyone of course and I recognise not everyone has a choice over ever aspect of their lives).

Example, my mum messed around at school (despite having an educated mum as an example) so left with no qualifications. She got married at 17 and had me at 18. She was a sahm for a number of reasons but come 27, she was divorced with 3 children, no qualifications and very little work history/experience.

We were brought up on benefits with mum doing part time, low paid jobs. However, my mum recognised that much of our situation was caused by her own poor choices. She instilled in us that it was important to get an education, to work hard, to be established in your career/relationship before having children. My siblings and I are in very different situations than mum was and our children have different lives than we had. My siblings and I talk about how our children don't know how lucky they actually are. I hope my children learn from the example set at home rather than the example how how not to do things like we were.

HugeAckmansWife · 02/02/2021 10:17

I teach it to 6th form in PSHE. the difference between credit and debit cards, what being overdrawn means, looking at average cost of various things. I agree that there should be a strand of maths that is more related to real world scenarios.. Tradespeople need maths to work out volumes of paint, areas of flooring plus doing quotes, vat, etc. I also 100% agree that state schools could and should go on til 4pm with optional extra activities offered until 5.30 or 6. The private sector do this and what we can cover and offer is hugely increased. We get paid the same as state but do have longer hols.. This is much more useful time than the 2-3 hours every day wasted by most teens when their school ends at 2.45 or 3pm. It would take an enormous shift in the sector though and huge recruitment to allow each teacher to not suddenly be having an increase in teaching load.

thecatsthecats · 02/02/2021 10:13

@MaskingForIt

Also, I think girls are often cultured into not thinking about the practical monetary aspects of life.

I think this circles back to the starting question though, about SAHM (especially unmarried ones) not realising how precarious their situations are.

Plenty of women only seem to work as something to do until they have a baby, so they don’t need to pay attention to money because a man will deal with that for them. Unfortunately a lot of men then want a tight control on finances and the woman ends up screwed over, which is partly if her own making.

Not just in cases of SAHM, but also the tragedies of life. Widowhood, disability, etc, that can all happen to the earner/non earner.

My husband and I are both well aware of family tragedies. My mum's first husband was an alcoholic abuser who stole all their joint money. His dad died when he was four. My husband isn't an alcoholic abuser but he is still mortal. No job is 100% safe.

I find "all money is family money" posters insufferably smug, because the core of their belief is that they are protected by sharing everything.

The core of my marriage's finances is that each of us needs to be in a position to provide for this family before we have children and in the event of either of us dying. It's part of the reason I want a small family - I don't want more kids than I could cope with ALONE.

As such, we've worked our way to a position where either of us could take on the whole burden of the family finances, but we both independently thrive financially. It doesn't make us less of a team, it makes us more of one - we're far more easily able to snap our fingers and walk away than "all money is family money" couples, but we don't.

gurglebelly · 02/02/2021 09:12

@Dobedohdahdee

Absolutely agree. I’m amazed at some of my friends - intelligent, university educated, yet don’t have pensions.

In one case a friend’s old(ish) parents bought him a house outright, but his house is in their name (ie his parents).

And I don’t know anyone in real life who doesn’t work but the amount of threads you read on here where an unmarried woman is considering giving up work because her (D)P thinks she should...

Mind boggles

Argh the first bit of this always breaks my head - don't they realise that if the decide not to be in one where your employer matches your contribution they are giving away free money? I bet they wouldn't turn down a bonus! It's so short sighted 🤯
LolaButt · 02/02/2021 09:05

I’m really honest about finances with my children, as I’ve gone from being broke to having a decent amount of money.

I teach them about buying shares (GameStop has helped with this one), assessing risk, taxing yourself first when you get paid and putting money in savings, not blowing loads of money on a cool car which will only depreciate etc.

I figure if they only listen to 10 percent of it, it’s better than the info I got from my parents!

MaskingForIt · 02/02/2021 08:51

Also, I think girls are often cultured into not thinking about the practical monetary aspects of life.

I think this circles back to the starting question though, about SAHM (especially unmarried ones) not realising how precarious their situations are.

Plenty of women only seem to work as something to do until they have a baby, so they don’t need to pay attention to money because a man will deal with that for them. Unfortunately a lot of men then want a tight control on finances and the woman ends up screwed over, which is partly if her own making.

RomeoLikedCapuletGirls · 02/02/2021 08:19

I agree. My mum is very thrifty but when I was young the finances of my family were very much hidden from me and there was a general idea that I wouldn’t need to learn it.

Also, I think girls are often cultured into not thinking about the practical monetary aspects of life.

Bouncebacker · 02/02/2021 08:14

I agree - I also think careers advice which encourages young people to consider that they may want flexibility in their work to care for children will contribute to a more equal sharing of caring responsibilities

Graciebobcat · 02/02/2021 08:08

I agree it should be on the school curriculum (I thought it was in PSHE?) But it doesn't matter how you "learn to budget", the point is that millions of people are underpaid and don't have enough money. A more important focus is having a more equal society. Divisions have become completely exposed and exacerbated in the pandemic.

Mudmudingloriousmud · 02/02/2021 08:01

Magenta, my argument.... Hmm is that there is are a cohort of teens, some of whom are extremely vulnerable, wasting hours of their ⌚ each week, being forced by the system to go over maths concepts they do not understand and will never need.
Many come from very difficult backgrounds.

I have feel we should be using this time to arm them with useful information instead of forcing them to try and grasp algebra and triangles. Confused

Ideally all dc should leave school with a good grasp of the basics but more so those in bottom sets maths groups age 15 who are unlikely to catch up and no aptitude in maths nor interest in it.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/02/2021 07:59

Honeylulu you've hit on an important point there.

By the time a lot of this feels relevant, people are often in their twenties and long beyond the reach of formal education. You can teach a 14 year old about credit cards but they are going to think it's boring & irrelevant and probably won't remember it.

honeylulu · 02/02/2021 07:55

I both agree and disagree. I am quite slow with maths and just couldn't be bothered with it at school. It was difficult and boring. I couldn't see what it had to do with my life.

Obviously once in the world of work, mortgages, pensions etc I realised I did need it and it's useful. Maybe if the lessons were more focused on HOW you would use maths that would have been better. I do recall one set of learning on proportionality where we looked at the front pages of newspapers and calculated how much % the photos took up on tabloids as opposed to broad sheets. I was really interested in that.

On the other hand we had several sessions in the 6th form on life skills and only when I was having a clear out many years later i realised we had been taught about mortgages and credit cards etc but I hadn't recalled any of it. I had a mortgage by then and it had been a real shock to me how much I'd pay in interest over the term. In the 6th form though it must have gone in one ear and out if the other whilst I daydreamed about my boyfriend.

The only life skills sessions I do remember were about learning to drive and getting your own car. I suppose because when I was 16-17 it was potentially imminent.

CyranosBestie · 02/02/2021 07:44

I'm going to ignore the tone and reasoning of the OP....however I think it would be great if children were taught about finances, budgeting, managing money in schools, in the same way they could be taught about applying for jobs, writing cvs, interview skills etc.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/02/2021 07:37

Social media does not help. In this country it's very easy to see what other people have (material possessions, holidays etc) but not so easy to see what they earn. I think a lot of people on lower incomes underestimate what other people earn, and therefore get misguided impression of what is affordable on a low income. Social media gives people the idea that they should be affording expensive brands, days out, masses of food choice, brand new things for children, when actually on a low income you can likely afford none of those things.

4redSocks · 01/02/2021 23:23

@Grenlei you need to look deeper than that. People are unaware imagine coming from a family who robs Peter to pay Paul it’s the normal it’s your surroundings. It’s a bit like denial you don’t always realise your in denial.

There’s a lot of threads about food parcels from schools/vouchers. I’m shocked by some comments and I do wonder if budgeting has gone out of the window!

Obviously this isn’t always the case some people are just naturally money savvy and I am one of those nobody taught me that skill. My mother is a spender so it certainly wasn’t her.

MagentaDoesNotExist · 01/02/2021 23:17

@Mudmudingloriousmud

magenta why is it patronising?. It's my opinion and I'm working with these teens and my own maths is extremely poor so I can totally empathise with their situation and whilst I had already reasonably stable life in that I had two parents who adored need, yes we faced many issues over housing and budgeting and massive problems.. So I have lived it, seen it and see how these poor dc are wasting their time . I have can't get my head around anyone thinking dc who struggle with maths are going to be better off persevering with triangles and algebra when they are entirely clueless when it comes to simple basic budgets?

Confused

With respect, you've contradicted your own argument there. You say you have a loving family and your maths is poor. I had a terrible family and my maths is just fine. I'm not aware of any study demonstrating causation between the two and from my persoective it's pretty obvious that most people who struggle with money don't do so because they can't add and subtract. Since you say this is your professional area, could you please post the research that shows I'm wrong and that a lack of grasp of basic maths causes these problems?
Grenlei · 01/02/2021 23:05

I completely agree this stuff is essential. That said, the information is readily available, anyone who has a smartphone or other internet enables device can educate themselves on the financial basics. It's often will rather than skill. Some people don't care, or don't care enough, and they probably wouldn't have cared as kids either.

I have several friends who have spent years in debt because they don't understand how storecards or high interest rate loans work. I know others who are in a very precarious financial position protected only by the fact they are (for now) in a happy long term relationship. If that was to end, they would be screwed.

I don't know what the answer is, but there has to be something that can be done to stop the cycle of people mismanaging their money, encumbering themselves with (unmanageable) debt, or ending up in a relationship based on financial inequality which they are either trapped in, or up shit creek without.

Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 23:05

Funnily enough there is also a thread about the retirement at 50 on million and posters have said people come into money and blow it.

People with very good income who don't know basics will struggle! They do!

Mudmudingloriousmud · 01/02/2021 23:03

magenta why is it patronising?.
It's my opinion and I'm working with these teens and my own maths is extremely poor so I can totally empathise with their situation and whilst I had already reasonably stable life in that I had two parents who adored need, yes we faced many issues over housing and budgeting and massive problems..
So I have lived it, seen it and see how these poor dc are wasting their time
. I have can't get my head around anyone thinking dc who struggle with maths are going to be better off persevering with triangles and algebra when they are entirely clueless when it comes to simple basic budgets?

Confused
spaceghetto · 01/02/2021 22:52

I disagree! I'm a sahm but am well aware of the financial situation i'm in. I know it's not robust by any means but my mum worked full time and I felt very disconnected from her when I was growing up. I didn't want that for my children. When dh and I started to think about children, we downsized our house, got a smaller mortgages and cut our expenditures. As twee as this sounds, filling my children's pre school lives with lovely experiences (for us all!) has been completely worth it. Plus, if you're careful with money, holidays and fun days out are still possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread