Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think calling the samaritans makes you feel worse

279 replies

Fuckinlonely · 30/01/2021 20:18

I've seen it suggested to call the samaritans if you are struggling on here a lot. Aibu to think that the people who suggest this have never done it? I phoned and was asked what was wrong. I explained loneliness was making me depressed. She then proceeded to ask if I had a partner (no), close relationship with my family (no), friends willing to meet up (no). I asked her to stop making me feel worse. She then suggested going for a walk or going online. I explained that those ideas had actually occurred to me over the previous 10 months. She said I can call back anytime. What the actual fuck do people get out of this?!

OP posts:
Mif4 · 30/01/2021 21:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

user13752257 · 30/01/2021 20:55

Those posters saying variations of "you have to be ready to help yourself / change your mindset or nothing anyone does can help you" ... That actually is not a universal solution to all mental distress. In some cases it is true, in others it is not valid.

I know the NHS heavily pushes that ideology via CBT because it's cheap and easily mass produced with little training, but some issues are more complex and can't be rectified that way no matter how hard a person tries or how open they are.

It's not fair or right to clobber people over the head by effectively telling them their distress is their own fault and isn't resolving because they haven't tried hard enough.

It's not correct and it's cruel.

Chalkcheese · 30/01/2021 20:55

I have had good and bad experiences. I think when you are feeling very down and depressed sometimes there is nothing anyone can say that will help. But of course not all of them are going to be your kind of person. They are not trained counsellors or anything, they are just there for somebody to talk to when you need to. I find talking online much more helpful, or to somebody who will make me laugh or let me rant about politics or something.

StillWeRise · 30/01/2021 20:53

@Rummikub

I’ve found them hit and miss. One man tried to meet me when I was feeling my most vulnerable.
please, you must report this, seriously wrong in so many ways
Carouselfish · 30/01/2021 20:53

I emailed with them rather than phone. Maybe that would suit you more as less confrontational.

ThisIsNotSocialDistancing · 30/01/2021 20:52

I had a crap experience the one and only time I called them. It was about 10 years ago. I was very distressed about a problem with my child, and about a close friend who had just been given a terminal diagnosis. The woman on the phone sounded irritated, and told me I should make an appointment with the GP 'to get something to help [me] calm down'. I was mortified. Would never call them again, or suggest anyone else does.

Rummikub · 30/01/2021 20:52

@trackside

Some are good some are not. One spoke to me for an hour and really helped but once they just said 'we can't hear you, are you by a train track? Go somewhere quieter and call us back' and ended the call.
That’s shocking :(
MorgaineLeFay · 30/01/2021 20:52

Call CALM! Brill webchat and helpline 5pm till midnight every night.

randomer · 30/01/2021 20:51

@katy123, what were you hoping to gain from that franky ridiculous comment?

Fuckinlonely · 30/01/2021 20:51

My phone said it was going to charge me so I panicked and cancelled the text to shout so I dont have a review other than dont recommend it to a teenager who doesn't pay their own phone bill just in case!

OP posts:
Gingaaarghpussy · 30/01/2021 20:51

I rang the samaritans once, because I was trying not to self harm. I was majorly distracted because the chap I spoke to had the most annoying voice I'd ever heard.
So it was and wasn't a positive experience.

Rummikub · 30/01/2021 20:50

@Keepingthingsinteresting

It was around 8 or so years ago now I think. Doubt there’d be records of it now.

I did used to volunteer on a night line at uni. In training we were told to only ever reflect back. Perhaps that’s what Samaritans do too. Even though I had that experience I still valued it overall (I think?)

Bagelsandbrie · 30/01/2021 20:49

I’ve phoned a couple of times and never found them helpful. I’m glad others have. I always felt I might as well just sit and write down my thoughts or go through them in my head. It just seemed a bit repetitive too - like “what’s bothering you...” “oh I can see xxxx is bothering you... what do you think you can do about xxxx” and repeating back what I’d said to them.

randomer · 30/01/2021 20:49

What a load of nonsense OP. Loads of people are massively struggling and lonely.
I was talking to a friend today who has a very very busy family and professional life. She was surprised to hear I hadn't spoken to anybody for days.
People lose sight of others so easily.

Scrunchcake · 30/01/2021 20:48

I've definitely said to people on here and irl to call the samaritans but I've never had to call them and thinking now I've been a bit naive - didn't realise they'd be so hit and miss. Sorry you're having a crap time, op.

I've seen the Shout text service recommended on here but again have no first-hand experience of it. Might be worth checking out though?

trackside · 30/01/2021 20:46

Some are good some are not. One spoke to me for an hour and really helped but once they just said 'we can't hear you, are you by a train track? Go somewhere quieter and call us back' and ended the call.

Fuckinlonely · 30/01/2021 20:46

I'm not going to talk more about my upset because as a pp so charmingly pointed out "They can hardly send a new best friend by special delivery - so what can you expect them to say?"! We will keep it to a discussion of the samaritans but thank you for offering x

OP posts:
randomer · 30/01/2021 20:45

Whatsup Fuckin?
Is it longterm or Covid related or longterm and Covid has heightened it?

Keepingthingsinteresting · 30/01/2021 20:45

@Rummikub please, please report that. That should not have happened and there are systems in place to deal with it. If you can remember when you called please inform the samaritans central office.

Fuckinlonely · 30/01/2021 20:44

Imightcry I am so so sorry to hear that. Big hugs right back to you xx

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 30/01/2021 20:43

Unfortunately with all these things they at the mercy of human error, there can also be a bad combination of personalities with the caller or helper which can make rapport building difficult and on top of that the caller really needs to be at a certain point in their struggle where they are open and the conversation is helpful.

I still don’t think it’s a bad suggestion to advise someone to call when they aren’t in a position or don’t want to seek help from anyone around them.

Sorry you had a bad experience though.

Rummikub · 30/01/2021 20:43

Agree with pp I think mn is much better to find support

randomer · 30/01/2021 20:43

They are well meaning volunteers, thats all.

Sorry to hear you feel so rubbish OP. Do you have any MH services in your area?

Fuckinlonely · 30/01/2021 20:42

Has anyone got any reviews of CALM? Are they nice?

OP posts:
IMightCry · 30/01/2021 20:41

You're not wrong. Flowers 7 years ago I called them. The person sounded so flat on the other end. I wanted to hear a friendly voice, talk about what had happened. I put down the phone and took an over dose instead. The pain I was feeling was too much.

Big hugs. Please talk on here if you feel you can. Also I'm happy for you to DM if you need a listening ear. Flowers