Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Weight loss

41 replies

Lovesacake · 29/01/2021 10:08

Hi,

NC for this thread. So I shall start with a not so stealthy boast...I have finally, after a VERY long period of dieting, reached a healthy BMI (it was 36 when diet began). I’m glad to be here after losing 4 stone but also nervous as I have lost large amounts of weight before and then put it all back on.

So AIBU to ask for any tips/advice from those of you who have lost weight and actually kept it off? How does that work?? I am mid 40’s so don’t have the metabolism I once had. I really want this time to be the time I actually maintain a healthy weight!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JessieLongleg · 23/12/2021 09:38

Don't diet and just make changes to you overall food intake you can keep up. I have health problems and losing weight slowly without a diet and I never put back on for no reason.

NinjaCake · 23/12/2021 09:29

This reply has been deleted

This post has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

KerryLacy · 16/05/2021 02:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 13/04/2021 13:56

@StayingHere

Oh this is old. Weirdly it came up on my active threads just now.
Has it? Omg finally I know how zombies get resurrected!
HostessTrolley · 13/04/2021 13:43

Aaah zombie thread...

HostessTrolley · 13/04/2021 13:41

@SummaLuvin so it’s ok for there to be threads here that shame and disparage people for being overweight and condemn them as being lazy, greedy, and a burden on society, but its not ok for people to post here for help and support to lose weight or maintain their loss?

Ok...Hmm

StayingHere · 13/04/2021 13:41

Oh this is old. Weirdly it came up on my active threads just now.

StayingHere · 13/04/2021 13:38

I've maintained a 3 stone loss for well over a year now.
I strictly weekly weigh and I have a target weight range. If I am towards the top I will cut back for a bit. Its much easier than trying to lose loads of weight that's for sure

PurpleDaisies · 29/01/2021 17:28

Congratulations on a fantastic loss.

I weigh weekly and I’ve got a number in my head that if I hit I make sure I really focus on diet and exercise until I’m back at my happy number. I tend to ignore period weeks which are always up a bit. Weighing daily doesn’t work for me.

I find exercise really helpful in maintaining and also changing the shape of my body so even if I’m not getting lighter, I look better. Lockdown has been good for me because some of my favourite classes have give online so I feel less self conscious about not being very good. Les mills is brilliant-I love the barre and sh bam dance based classes but there are lots of others too.

In terms of food, I still weigh carbs but everything else I just do by eye. I try and focus on eating really well 80% of the time and don’t worry about the rest. You could try relaxing your window while upping some exercise and seeing what happens.

Lovesacake · 29/01/2021 17:20

@alittleprivacy omg if I tried dancing on a trampoline I would be weeing all over the place 😂 but could definitely try a hula hoop.
@Iremembertheelderlykoreanlady that sounds like quite extreme intermittent fasting to me, but I’m no expert. With intermittent fasting you have an 8 hour window for eating so unless it was one huge meal you ate over the course of 8 hours 😂 I’m not sure it would count. But as I say I’m no expert!

OP posts:
Iremembertheelderlykoreanlady · 29/01/2021 13:50

*I'm

Iremembertheelderlykoreanlady · 29/01/2021 13:50

Question - if I only eat 1 meal a day and calorie count does that mean in intermittent fasting?

alittleprivacy · 29/01/2021 13:11

@Lovesacake

Oh good points about exercise. The only exercise I really love is dancing but the trouble is I’m terrible at it! So have never stuck with dance classes as I always feel like such a plum. But again lockdown has been helpful in that I’ve just been dancing my socks off in the privacy of my home and so there’s no reason I couldn’t keep that up as I really do enjoy it so much.
There you go then. Just dance like a teenager in front of your mirror or take 45 minutes to clean the kitchen after breakfast because you are bopping. If you want to up it a notch you could consider getting a hula hoop or an exercise trampoline and dancing with/on it. You could do one of the many, many dance workouts on youtube (I struggle with that though, as I need to dance to 'my music' or I won't want to keep doing it.) And when this is over, consider a dance class.
Hazelnutlatteplease · 29/01/2021 11:09

Yy to weighing every now and then. Having a bit of leeway to take into account stressful periods or menstrual cycle, but having a weight above which you must do something about. So above that weight I tighten back up the diet.

Weighing carbohydrates and high calorie foods. I have a little set of electronic scales that sit on the kitchen top.

Yy to MyFitness pal. It is awesome for maintenance as well as weight loss

YourWurstNightmare · 29/01/2021 11:02

I maintained for over 5 years (before Covid knocked me sideways) and what worked for me was healthy meals during the week and then weekends off. If there was an event during the week, I'd skip a weekend day off.

picklemewalnuts · 29/01/2021 10:59

Intermittent fasting 4 days a week would work, then?

I'm 2 stone down from a BMI of over 40. I've done it before, and put the weight back on over 2 years. I found it hard to deal with family having treats and junk that I couldn't have. This time I seem more at peace with that, so I'm optimistic I'll do ok.

I'd suggest maintenance weigh ins, and the moment weight creeps up by more than 4lb start logging your food and upping the fasting until it's down again. It should get easier every time.
Also, at your new weight, maintain or build up your exercise. Increase your muscle. You may then be able to eat more without putting on weight. And measure your waist, bust, hips and thighs occasionally. You may find that trims as you become more muscular, even if your weight goes up slightly.

I'm planning to lose 2 more stone then pause for a few months, to get used to the new weight and establish/reinforce a new normal before reducing again.

Lovesacake · 29/01/2021 10:51

YES to intermittent fasting! That’s what I’ve been doing during the diet, but was sort of hoping to relax it a bit when maintaining as I really miss brunch and my ‘eating window’ doesn’t open till 1.

OP posts:
Lovesacake · 29/01/2021 10:50

Oh good points about exercise. The only exercise I really love is dancing but the trouble is I’m terrible at it! So have never stuck with dance classes as I always feel like such a plum. But again lockdown has been helpful in that I’ve just been dancing my socks off in the privacy of my home and so there’s no reason I couldn’t keep that up as I really do enjoy it so much.

OP posts:
FitzsimmonsMarvel · 29/01/2021 10:47

I think intermittent fasting and cutting out snacks is great. Not the crazy hours one but I fast from 7pm-10am then I have 3 meals a day and no snacks. If I want chocolate etc I’ll have it straight after my dinner so there are decent periods of time where I’m not eating. It helps with weight loss and maintenance as you aren’t eating for large periods of time each day.

TardisThroughTime · 29/01/2021 10:45

Christ @SummaLuvin who died and made you boss of this public forum where we can post wherever (and seemingly according to you whatever) we like?

Thedogshow · 29/01/2021 10:44

I think that for maintaining weight loss exercise is great, because you feel good about yourself and it gives you a daily sense of achievement.

And keeping tabs on your weight regularly & remember how good you feel now having lost the weight.

Fressia123 · 29/01/2021 10:39

I have no advice but I did notice that after losing 4st myself, my new weight without looking after my weight and after having a baby, was still lower than when I was 15. I'm running again and I think that's the key to lower weight for me.

alittleprivacy · 29/01/2021 10:35

Make a big lifestyle change. I lost weight when my DS was a year old as I'd gotten heavier post-pregnancy. After about 18 months I'd started to put it back on and by the time he was 5, my BMI had entered the obese range but I didn't realise it at all at the time. I was 39 by then and made a serious effort to lose the weight again as I had this idea in my head that if I turned 40 so overweight, that would be it for life. (And while my 40th birthday itself was arbitrary, your weight and metabolism heading towards menopause isn't.)

I was a healthy weight when I turned 40 but I absolutely knew that the odds were that I'd put the weight back on as soon as I let my guard down. It was a little worrying but luckily for me, a few weeks after my birthday by complete chance I found my 'sport' and after 6 months became very fit within a year, I was genuinely athletically fit. I don't really have to worry about what I eat anymore but the truth is I seriously crave a healthy diet because my focus is on how my body feel and performs. Do I like the aesthetics of being slim and having a well toned body, yes, very much so. But that's just a bonus to how my body makes me feel and all the amazing things it lets me do now.

I doubt I would ever have kept up a diet just to stay a healthy weight. But I fully believe I will do what it takes to stay as athletic, strong and flexible as I am as I age. So find your thing. Something you have always dreamed of doing in some corner of your mind and start doing it. When your body's abilities make you happy, you will want to take care of it.

VapeVamp12 · 29/01/2021 10:34

I personally wouldn't recommend daily weighing like others have said. It can really affect your mentality for the day. Say if you've been eating healthy and exercising and you weigh yourself and it says you've put on two pounds - you could lose motivation, feel guilty, have a blip, etc.

I think weighing every few days or once a week plus taking measurements is a good way.

I only say this because if I have had an amazing week and the scales don't match what I think, I can fall off the wagon for 2 days and completely stuff it up!

Lovesacake · 29/01/2021 10:33

Thank you for all the supportive comments 😊. It all sounds so logical and easy when written down, but I definitely have a pattern of working hard to lose weight and then slowly but surely piling it back on because I relax too much. You’re all right though, looking back I have always started avoiding the scales when I knew I was getting bigger and then ‘suddenly’ I’ve put it all back on. I think it will be a challenge to maintain when life goes back to normal as I’ve found it much easier to control my food intake when there’s no socialising or eating out!

OP posts: