Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised at how everyone knows everyone in small towns?

105 replies

thissemicharmedlife · 28/01/2021 12:11

Well obviously I am BU because it’s such a given, but has anybody found this aspect a bit of a culture shock when moving from a bigger city to a smaller town?

I grew up in a biggish city then moved to a lovely market town about 12 miles away (population about 30,000) at 20. However me and DP continued working in our home city for the first few years so never really got to know anyone locally. Anyway since having a child (so experiencing baby groups, nursery and school start) as well as getting a part-time job locally it’s really hit me how everybody knows everybody. There is no separation at all, if you mention where you work to your neighbours then they inevitably know or are related to half of your colleagues. If one of the school mums adds you on Facebook then they are mutual friends with everyone else you know in the town. You can’t go round Sainsbury’s without seeing a dozen people you know. I kind of miss before when I was anonymous.

I do wonder what it will be like longterm for my children to grow up and go to school here. If you’ve grown up in a small town did it feel a bit claustrophobic to know everybody? I used to bus to secondary school in a different area of my city and my parents didn’t know anyone else’s parents at my school. I would bet there’s at most one degree of separation between everyone round here.

OP posts:
whoamongstus · 28/01/2021 13:24

It's why I left my hometown!

Live in a city now, beautifully anonymous haha. I know my neighbours who are very nice, but I never bump into anyone I know in Tesco and I much prefer it.

Bythemillpond · 28/01/2021 13:24

I grew up in a small town on the outskirts of a city where everyone knew everyone else.
It was claustrophobic. I couldn’t wait to leave. I moved to London and the one concern my family had was that I wouldn’t know anyone. I love the freedom of being anonymous

Abitodd · 28/01/2021 13:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at OP's request.

HerringGull · 28/01/2021 13:20

I grew up and still live in a village - a reasonably big village though. It's not that I meet people who know people I know, it's more that I actually know almost everyone in the village. This is a bit different to the situation you're in obviously! But I love it.
When your dog takes itself for a sneaky walk people phone and say 'I've just seen your dog going past the house'. You go rescue your dog before it gets run over. The same applies to your toddler/ancient mum with dementia etc.
If there's a problem like vandalism (pretty rare) the culprit is inevitably found out, because someone will know who it was, and soon everyone will! They don't do it again...
When you have a loss, you tell two people and within a few days everyone knows. You don't have to explain over and over about how your loved one died.
I could go on. Obviously some of this doesn't apply in a town, but the point is that a smaller place is a community which cares about you, not a big city where sometimes even your immediate neighbours don't want to speak to you. I stayed in a city briefly and while it had many benefits, the anonymity was awful for me. I had close friends, but other them literally nobody cared if I lived or died - what a horrible feeling!
Hope that helps!

Sceptre86 · 28/01/2021 13:20

I moved from Manchester to a small town in Scotland. Everyone knew everyone and it was the kind of place where everyone would say hello and stop to coo over my baby. I hated it at first and then started to enjoy it somewhat. I have since moved to a bigger town in Scotland and there is a mix of people who have lived here for 3 generations and others who are new to the area having moved when the new housing is built. I do like it here but I prefer living in a big city (I am an introvert, getting stopped for a chat when I am trying to do the school run or get to work on time is annoying). That is probably more to do with my personality though.

Clymene · 28/01/2021 13:19

I lived in London before moving to a small town. I love it! I feel like I live in Albert Square Grin

lyralalala · 28/01/2021 13:18

In general though it’s brilliant. The support network is invaluable.

lyralalala · 28/01/2021 13:17

I think how claustrophobic it is depends on the type of gossiper your parent is.

My cousin hated our small village, but that’s because my Aunt told everybody everything. So, my teenage cousin knew that Mary in the shop, Phyllis in the library and Jean in the post office knew about her period problems/getting in trouble/failing a test at school and she hated it. She also did something very silly at 15 and because my aunt told everyone it was never forgotten.

Whereas my Nana wasn’t a gossiper and even with her friends had limits on details shared. That meant I had an easier time.

The only downside was when I got bullied it was hard to get it taken seriously because “that’s Mary’s boy, she’s lovely”. And she was, but her son was a nasty, violent, dickhead.

sleepfortheweek · 28/01/2021 13:17

I live in a town of around 5,000 people. There's a couple neighbouring villages but the next town (which is actually smaller than ours 🤣) is an hour away - and the nearest city is 3 hours away.

I moved here 10 years ago from a larger (but not huge) town. It still blows my mind when I hear locals making connections between people.

I love it though, everyone says hi, and there's a massive community feel.

However, people can be very judgmental about certain family names - if that makes sense.

TedMullins · 28/01/2021 13:16

I grew up in a small town and didn’t like it. I moved to a city for uni at 18, then to a bigger city, then on to London. I wouldn’t go back to where I grew up - for me it was less knowing everyone and more the abject boredom I had as a child and teenager. My parents almost bought in London before I was born but chose the town instead - I always tell them I wish I’d grown up in London! I found more like minded people in cities, in my experience town locals don’t have very broad horizons or open minds

bridgetreilly · 28/01/2021 13:16

I do wonder what it will be like longterm for my children to grow up and go to school here.

It will be brilliant for them. Why wouldn't it?

M0rT · 28/01/2021 13:13

I grew up in a small suburb of a city, and there were a lot of connections. But it very much depends on how much of a "joiner" you are.
I can go to the shops there sometimes and not see anyone I know but my brothers can't because they played on local sports teams.
YY to teenage behaviour monitoring, my BM would say "a little birdie told me" you were doing XYZ...very inhibiting Grin

AudTheDeepAndCrispAndEven · 28/01/2021 13:11

I moved around for work for years and was single and it was very easy to have good connection with colleagues but not really know anyone locally.. It's only since moving somewhere permanently and having kids that I've realised how interconnected people in a community can be. My DM moved here a few years ago and I had to warn her to be very careful who she discussed with whom as everyone is related or connected in some way!

Strokethefurrywall · 28/01/2021 13:09

I live in an island of 60,000 and there's about 2 degrees of separation here.

Because many are expats there is a strong sense of community and we're all each other's surrogate families.

This lends itself very well when someone suffers a trauma or tragedy. Everyone comes together to support each other and it's wonderful.

By boys were born here and will be here until they leave for university in the next decade, and I wonder if they'll appreciate the anonymity or feel bewildered by it.

That being said, even when we fly to Miami for shopping weekends, we will still inevitably bump into acquaintances from here, so we don't really escape!

pumpkinsoups · 28/01/2021 13:09

I live in a small town with no secondary school and only two primary schools. Absolutely everybody knows everybody. People marry and divorce and the old and new partners went to school together or are the BIL/SIL of the old partner. It's not a place where you can gossip without getting lynched as you'll be talking to their cousin and not know it.

thissemicharmedlife · 28/01/2021 13:02

My home city wasn’t particularly massive compared to others, and there would often still be ‘connections’ here and there and knowing friends of friends at places, but you could easily go to the supermarket without it being certain you would be served by someone you knew and it was easier to separate and ‘compartmentalise’ aspects of your life if that makes sense- school life and friends, my Saturday job, my extended family, my house and street and neighbours all nicely separate from each other. If something wasn’t great at school or there was any drama you felt like you could leave it behind when you weren’t there.

OP posts:
emmetgirl · 28/01/2021 12:58

community

emmetgirl · 28/01/2021 12:57

I moved from a part of the country where I could be pretty anonymous as it's so densely populated to a small coastal town. It took me a couple of years to get used to the fact that wherever I go here I see someone I know. It made me really uncomfortable but I think that was because it was so alien to me.
I've been here over 3 years now and own a well known business in the town and am now quite enjoying the more commute feel but it's taken some time to get to this stage.

Parkandride · 28/01/2021 12:54

I think it depends how much you integrate, where I grew up if you were involved in the rugby club and young farmers then everyone knew everything.
Personally I like anonymity!

BlackDogBlues · 28/01/2021 12:49

@Frannyhy

I also find that everyone has shagged every one else.
I live on an island. Moved here 20 years ago. 80k population. They all seem to have shagged each other.

The first thing anyone does is try and work out what connection you have.

I love going away and being anonymous. Then again keep bumping into the buggers when away as well..

Friends from here find it weird going into a pub away and not knowing people.

Bakedpotatoandgin · 28/01/2021 12:45

My town has a population of about 7000, although probably a lot more now bc that was at the last census and there's been a lot of new builds since then. Everyone knows everyone, most of them are related. My family is spread across the UK/ Europe so the concept of having all your family in the same place feels weird to me. As a kid I always felt like an outsider bc I couldn't call anyone auntie etc (either by blood or as friends of parents), our family friends were also outsiders. I probably won't stay here. Having said that, it does seem to be a good environment for the kids of many generations now, they grow up with their cousins almost like siblings.

Frannyhy · 28/01/2021 12:44

I also find that everyone has shagged every one else.

RebeccaBristol · 28/01/2021 12:41

I had a similar set up at secondary school where I travelled a long way. I hated it socially as was really difficult to hang out with my friends who all lived close to school. We picked a similar size town to you. My kids are primary age and one of the reasons I picked it was so as teenagers they will be easily able to see friends. I have lived in London and another city before and much prefer this personally fir family life. Feels much more like living in a community

AgeLikeWine · 28/01/2021 12:37

I grew up in a small town, with a population of about 15k. There was one secondary school, which everybody in the town and the surrounding villages went to. That’s why everybody knows everybody else in small towns.

ImAllOut · 28/01/2021 12:37

I recently started working about 40 miles away from my area and in the first week I discovered that the only other person from my area who worked there knew my dad from the business he runs!

Swipe left for the next trending thread