Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refusing to homeschool

333 replies

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 17:41

Curious about this...

How many parents have simply decided that they're not doing homeschooling? Either because they're wfh and can't balance that with homeschooling or because it's too much for their kids and making them miserable?

If you're not homeschooling, (i) are you getting a hard time from the school?; and (ii) what are your kids doing instead?

YABU - we're homeschooling.

YANBU - we never started/we've given up.

OP posts:
ReginaPhalangee · 19/01/2021 20:22

Aldisla thank you. And yes you're right. We have so many vulnerable families we are trying to support. I've spent my lunch breaks delivering food parcels to our most vulnerable. I'm a single mum, my childcare option (parents) is no longer available.

Please let's be kind to each other. This whole thing makes me so so upset.

Ebee19 · 19/01/2021 20:22

If you don’t home school you are putting your child at a disadvantage when they return and possibly the rest of their education which would impact their outcomes. So simply choosing not to is poor parenting - and frankly should have consequences.

For those who are trying to do a version of the syllabus which suits their child and situation - fair play.

Ideas for those struggling that I’ve heard work:
Online classes set by school
Online grandparent story hour etc
Doing maths with cooking or baking
BBC bite size and even movie afternoon - and you ask questions about it after :)
Reading
Now spring - plants and vegetable experiments

Also in primary schools a lot of time is art, play, drama, music, sport and so on - so don’t think anyone should feel guilty if an hour of play or something. Movies are also common for a class or so in secondary.

AldiIsla · 19/01/2021 20:21

Probably just took the kids in with them @DartmoorWilderness. Grin after all, no other alternatives.

lyd4165 · 19/01/2021 20:20

I’m finding the biggest obstacle to homeschooling for us is my school aged child’s younger siblings. My son is 5 and cannot be left for a second to get on with any work I give him without wandering off and requires constant direction and encouragement. Meanwhile I have a 2 year old and a baby screaming for my attention in the other room. I don’t feel safe leaving my two younger children unsupervised to help my son but likewise cannot possibly expect my 5 year old to be able to think straight with 2 teething, grumpy, bored siblings to contend with if we’re in the same room. I also work. I am tearing my hair out with stress and guilt everyday about his schoolwork, his happiness, my other children’s happiness. It’s beyond difficult.Confused

Arabella2020 · 19/01/2021 20:20

My child is online learning, finding it difficult to both of us doing long hours/different shifts, but if I don’t get that work uploaded by 3pm I get numerous phone calls, I’m finding it really overwhelming constantly explaining myself to them

DoubleFunMum · 19/01/2021 20:19

I must admit, I'm on the verge of giving up. Or at least taking a more 'liberal' approach. So far my kids (8 years old, twins) have done the school set work every day. But I'm 33 weeks pregnant, very hormonal, and the stress is taking its toll on all of us. We were all in tears today at one point or another. I am simply not equipped to 'teach' things to my children the way a professional is and they don't understand what I'm telling them - leading to frustration and upset. Last lockdown we did baking, gardening, STEM projects, art and this time the school's set work leaves me no time for anything else, even housework, let along fun stuff with the kids that they find engaging. I'm worried I'm ruining my relationship with my kids, which isn't ideal before a new baby arrives. And after today I think I need to prioritise my own mental health a bit more, not to mention avoid stress and possible premature labour! It's all a bit much!!

Elfinghecking · 19/01/2021 20:18

So if I just explain that my kid refuses to do online work or I don't want to homeschool I can send him in? That would make my life so much easier. And if he goes in the other one may as well.

DartmoorWilderness · 19/01/2021 20:18

@Helspopje

Well, at least if they try to phone home to speak with me, they won’t get me as I’ll be at work. Perhaps they shouldn’t have declined my keyworker place (NHS consultant).
🤔 Who was looking after your primary age DC while you were at the hospital?!
PandemicPalava · 19/01/2021 20:18

@sonypony 'in whatever way they can' so it doesn't have to be what the school sets? If we decide to cover the curriculum in our own way and can prove it, it looks like this would be fine.

changedmynamelol · 19/01/2021 20:17

My dc are doing online learning. Yabu.

Morph2lcfc · 19/01/2021 20:15

My child is attending school this time. He has asd so struggles doing school work at home anyway as in his mind school work is for school. I tried but as I was also working from home I was not prepared to spend the small amount of time I could spare with him screaming and shouting and getting distressed to get the smallest bit of work done. School were relaxed about it and he did do a lot of reading so there was some learning just not what the school set (primary). He was offered a place this time due to having an ehcp so he’s going in and happily does his work at school. It looks like the expectations from school for the ones that are at home has massively ramped up this time do not sure we’d cope if he was off this time

AldiIsla · 19/01/2021 20:15

@ReginaPhalangee our teachers are working their arses off. Most can see it.

People forget that there's children who live in dangerous homes, with illiterate parents, in unsecure housing and that schools are still working with them - the most in need. Alongside teaching online, teaching in class, marking, dealing with their own children and caring responsibilities.

You deserve medals. I've got two learning from home and the broadband isn't the only thing under some extra stress!

Our local LA is giving out food packs, they've designed them so theoretically even young children could feed themselves from them. Really brought home how vulnerable some children are. I think of that when I'm feeling the strain, my kids and I don't know what hardship is.

Awalkintime · 19/01/2021 20:14

Je551ca lots of teachers are parents and are doing exactly that.

There are kids that struggle to engage in school too you know.

Lancrelady80 · 19/01/2021 20:14

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

You can't just decide that compulsory education isn't working for your family, it is a legal requirement and, more importantly, to not persevere is to do your children a huge disservice

It is a legal obligation to provide your child with a suitable education. It is not a legal obligation to engage with a school to do so.

So parents do need to homeschool children, but they are under no obligation whatsoever to use materials sent by the school or to report back to the school. Lots of schools basically abandoned kids in the first lockdown (despite some heroic work by individual teachers). They can fuck right off with threats of legal action now.

  1. In lockdown 1, this was all brand new, totally unprecedented and a complete emergency. Noone had the foggiest what to do or what was going on. Schools had 2 days notice of closure. Many had no experience at all of remote teaching or the platforms to be used.

  2. Schools did NOT abandon the children. We were instructed by the DfE to suspend the curriculum and just provide childcare for keyworker and vulnerable children. Go back and listen to the speech. Many schools did above and beyond by providing work anyway. This was variable due to a bundle load of reasons including staff illness, time constraints, money and online access. Again, we were told just to provide childcare so stop whinging that it wasn't all consistently brilliant, schools and staff were just surviving in the face of adversity and doing the best they could. Many teaching professionals worked through holidays to look after key worker children so fuck off with your "schools basically abandoned children" rhetoric.

  3. Thos time round, schools are legally responsible for continuing to provide education for those at home. Anyone who doesn't want to engage is welcome to deregister their child in order to meet the "by other means" part of the Act. If not, expect the school to be acting on their legal obligations.

  4. Noone wants this. But if you want to pick a fight about it all being too hard (and it is, I taught from home whilst homeschooling my Y1 SEN child and 4 year old in Lockdown 1) then pick a fight with those who cried they weren't being given enough work in Lockdown 1. Consequently, government put a legal obligation on schools to provide 3/4/5 hours of work a day, depending on Key Stage, and to ensure children progress as if in school. They are the ones insisting on complete engagement or children being classed as vulnerable, with lack of engagement leading to fines, courts etc. Schools are threatening noone. (Although we would probably rethink that if put in a room with the twonk allegedly in charge of this ridiculous situation.

The government have no idea what it's like for any of us on the ground, either attempting to deliver in the classroom or trying to juggle full time jobs with homeschooling. It must be hell for shift workers and single parents.

If they'd listened to the teachers (or even bothered asking) a more nuanced approach would have been taken.

FanFckingTastic · 19/01/2021 20:14

I have 3 kids, one of which has complex SEN needs. I also have a full time job. My kids are all in different schools so the level of work and the amount of online participation that is required varies, but it's definitely much more than it was during the first lockdown and the schools really seem to be ramping up the pressure to have work completed and online lessons attended. My DD's primary school is the worst. She has various online lessons over various different platforms. She's required to wear uniform whenever she has a 'lesson' Most of her lessons require parental support (e.g. setting up the zoom call, printing off worksheets, photographing work and submitting via a parents email) Don't get me wrong it's lovely that the school are trying to keep the kids learning and I'm very grateful to her teachers, who are really trying their best. There is, however, an assumption that a parent is there to help all the time and that the relevant tech is available. I have to say as well that I'm not convinced that a zoom call of 30 small primary kids is anything more than organised chaos. We try and get as much work done as possible but I can't be all things to all people so I just do the best that I can. Sometimes DD attends the face to face sessions, but sometimes she doesn't and I refuse to feel guilty about this. It's not because I'm a feckless waste-of-space parent, it's because I'm trying to juggle the needs of her siblings, organizing a house and trying to get my own job done as well. Homeschooling is important, but so is keeping my job, and my sanity.

MrsSmith2021 · 19/01/2021 20:13

It is my job as a parent to ensure my children get a good education. The schools can’t provide that right now, so I am doing my best.

SomersetHamlyn · 19/01/2021 20:10

@Helspopje
Well, at least if they try to phone home to speak with me, they won’t get me as I’ll be at work. Perhaps they shouldn’t have declined my keyworker place (NHS consultant).

Where are your kids while you're at work?

MyGhastIsFlabbered · 19/01/2021 20:10

My youngest is being assessed for ADHD/ASD at the moment. Last year, pretty much every time I tried to get him to do any school work he screamed the place down, and would keep it up for hours. There were 2 other children here plus DP wfh. So I did the best I could to keep the peace. I'm NHS so they're in school this time around.

Je551ca · 19/01/2021 20:09

@Awalkintime

But what if I say to you, "Sorry, I'm working. I can't supervise DC and work at the same time.

What do you think teachers are doing in school? Working online and supervising children at the same time.

Is very different at home with partners. Kids push the boundaries more and as far as kids are concerned they can opt out because there are other things to do. If a working parent is on work zoom calls all day how can you make a child engage with school work
BeckyWithTheGoodHair5629456 · 19/01/2021 20:08

My daughter does not have to submit any work to be marked. Year 2. Is that normal?! We are doing the homeschooling, alongside me trying to hold down a professional job, to say it's a juggle is an understatement.

ReginaPhalangee · 19/01/2021 20:08

Thanks Sonic. It's tough for us all, there's a lot of teacher bashing around which does upset me because I'm working myself to the bone and my colleagues are too. I don't sleep at night, I am constantly worrying about how to make learning accessible to every child I teach.

I'm disappointed to read about schools which may not be giving the same offer but I can assure you that plenty of us are working harder than ever before, including the first lockdown.

VintageStitchers · 19/01/2021 20:07

I let DS 11 yrs choose which bits he wants to engage with.

There’s no online teaching so no zoom etc. and without any interaction with friends, I think it’s pretty depressing for him.

I doubt our school will do anything as they’ve repeatedly stated to do what you can but not to worry if you don’t complete any of the work.
That seems reasonable to me.

tatutata · 19/01/2021 20:05

My DS7 is working quite well, my DS5 just refuses point blank. I can't make him put pencil to paper.

AlwaysLatte · 19/01/2021 20:04

I can really see how difficult it is, but equally by looking at my two children's work it is possible for them to get it all done in 3-4 hours if they work at it, so you could do an hour before work and a couple of hours after - or one hour before, one after, then a couple of catch up sessions at the weekend. Some BBC bite size while you're working and give them rewards for completing some of the online maths etc apps you can get for tablet?

Helspopje · 19/01/2021 20:03

Well, at least if they try to phone home to speak with me, they won’t get me as I’ll be at work.
Perhaps they shouldn’t have declined my keyworker place (NHS consultant).