Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refusing to homeschool

333 replies

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 17:41

Curious about this...

How many parents have simply decided that they're not doing homeschooling? Either because they're wfh and can't balance that with homeschooling or because it's too much for their kids and making them miserable?

If you're not homeschooling, (i) are you getting a hard time from the school?; and (ii) what are your kids doing instead?

YABU - we're homeschooling.

YANBU - we never started/we've given up.

OP posts:
nostaples · 19/01/2021 20:41

FGS, no school or police officer in the country is going to take legal action because a parent is not homeschooling. Everyone would recognise that as stupid and entirely counterproductive. Schools will support and cajole, where possible. They are absolutely not going to punish families who are already struggling in a variety of ways.

Ineverpromisedyouarosegarden · 19/01/2021 20:41

We are trying very hard but Ds has ASD and is a school refuser. Refusing to do almost all work but we are still trying every single day. School have offered a vulnerable child place. Ds won't go because schools are closed it says so on the news every day.

I am frontline worker so working out of the house 8-7. Dh is working from home but also frontline so lots of meetings, confidential calls etc.

Dd year 11 is doing most of hers and trying to one to one Ds.

None of this is acceptable really. Massive impact on Ds. Dd's mental health really suffering as she is really putting her self under strain trying to help Ds. My work is incredibly stressful and Dh is stressed too.

I hate it all. Older Dd and Ds are also working from home on their university courses too. Wifi is hit and miss today.

On top of all that older Ds is in private uni accommodation where the landlord won't allow any allowance for students living at home and he is still paying rent.

Allispretty · 19/01/2021 20:40

Well it's just an absolute shit show really isn't it! We did a full school day today and within that time I'd say 1:30 hours was the only learning because it was a combination of needing a break, throwing around his pencil, getting angry/frustrated, crying because I ended up shouting. I feel like an utter failure because then following all this and a quick walk he spends more time on his Xbox than he's probably learning.

I don't believe there's consequences for not completing work or if is then it's some schools and I think that's pretty shitty indeed given the circumstances. I'm lucky at the moment I'm furlough however I start a new job in 2 weeks I'm in the office for 5 days and DP is wfh ft. On paper we are both classed as key workers, ds won't have a laptop to work on in 2 weeks (currently using my work one) I was told tough there's no spaces and nothing else. No phone call or assurance/support on what I could do in terms of making home learning easier.

I've resigned myself to the fact ds will complete what he can on the worksheets with a little bit of input from DP when he can, then we're going to have to switch the week around and make weekends school days...it's the only option I have a feeling by March I'll be rock bottom due to stress of learning a new role + attempting school work.

Lancrelady80 · 19/01/2021 20:39

As long as people are trying their best, and doing what they can when and how they can, and keeping schools in the loop, then fair enough.

But just shrugging it off isn't going to be brushed aside.

Expectations on schools and from schools are different this time.

Do something educational as well as you can as often as you can and let the school know. Else they have no option but to go down the same route they would if someone simply wasn't sending their child to school. Schools are understanding and realistic about things, but you have to engage with them even if it's to say that you simply can't engage with home learning in the way it's being provided.

tootiredtospeak · 19/01/2021 20:39

Quoting the law doesn't mean it's going to happen and in the same way the police cannot enforce people sticking to the rules as they dont have enough police officers. Schools do not have enough staff to monitor and police this plus the DFE would not pursue this currently. I do not agree with people just choosing not to try but it really irritates me to see them being bullied if they are struggling by your inference they are committing a crime.

Awalkintime · 19/01/2021 20:39

Je551ca
I am also not paid to do more than 1 job but I am currently doing many, just in the same way you are expected to but we're having to deal with it and get on with it so in much the same fashion, we all have to get on and do as best as we can.

Teachers are also working parents!!!

You're finding it tough, teachers are finding it tough. We are all in the same boat having to juggle different roles right now.

Katjolo · 19/01/2021 20:38

Read everyday and dedicate some time for maths/ daily writing. Rest of the time could be spent doing independent arts, crafts and going for a walk or playing in the garden (if you have one).

supersonicginandtonic · 19/01/2021 20:38

@AbitSceptical I feel you. Please don't make other people make you feel bad. Especially the ones telling you their children have no other option.
Please put your child's mental health first and do speak to the school.
This time last year my DD was confident, outgoing and had many friends. The shit show of the last year has completely changed her. We've had times where she's become nocturnal, we've had periods of self-harming, we've had all sorts.
Through it all the school have been amazing. I'm in daily contact with the pastoral lead.
We are currently working back up towards a full svjool day. DD logs on first thing and this week is doing 2 lessons per day, last week it was 1. These are lessons she chooses herself. We're also ensuring she gets out for a short walk every day and she's involved in the cooking of tea.
She has a movie night with her dad at the weekend.
We are going to build up to a full day gradually and then hopefully start doing short times in school. They have always said that her mental health is the most important and there will be time to catch up. I recommend you speak to school.

Almostslimjim · 19/01/2021 20:38

And we've told school that due to work commitments DC won't be on the live lessons and they're fine with that. Live lesson 1 is at the same time as DHs work allocation meeting (which he leads). Live lesson 2 is his lunch break, where he has to cook for the 3 of them and eat and get DC2 down for her nap. DC1 won't sit at the live lesson unless we are with him.

dingdang · 19/01/2021 20:35

Let's stop bashing each other. The whole point here is that it is impossible to work from home and supervise home learning. I work full time, lone parent, and I do an hour with my year one daughter in the morning and an hour during lunch and a walk in the afternoon. The rest of the time is telly, colouring in or FaceTime with Granny for an hour. I wake early to work and work after she goes to bed. I'm exhausted and it's only week three!

randomer · 19/01/2021 20:34

I would suggest keep reading and number alive and moving along.Anything else is a bonus.

Almostslimjim · 19/01/2021 20:34

I’m a primary teacher and the last lockdown did nothing to affect the children’s attainment or progress. In fact I think it did a lot of them good being with their parents so much.

Yes, last lockdown we did no formal school work (not compulsory school age then) and DC1s teacher said he'd come on "leaps and bounds". I think it was just more time at home and less time having to put effort in to behaving to pre-school standards/ following instructions. He just thrived.

Sweettea1 · 19/01/2021 20:33

Ds high school i make sure he does all his main lessons but things like art drama music I don't force he should be picking his opticians this year an will drop them anyway so what's the point in arguing over them now. Dd5 does what's set not all in 1 go but over the week so might do some maths after tea she prefers todo it later when I've more time to help so aslong as its all done before the next week its fine. School have not mentioned anything about what happens if not done but there is alot more children attending school this time round maybe thats why.

Lancrelady80 · 19/01/2021 20:33

Section 444(1) and (1A) of the Act create offences relating to the failure of parents to secure regular attendance at school of a registered pupil...It remains a parent’s duty to ensure that their child of compulsory school age receives a suitable education in whatever way they can under section 7 of the Act and state-funded schools are required to provide remote education to pupils who are not attending in certain circumstances by virtue of the Coronavirus Act 2020 Provision of Remote Education (England) Temporary Continuity Direction 2020 made on 30th September 20203.

Sections 444A and 444B of the Act make provision for the issuance of
penalty notices where there is reason to believe a person has committed
an offence under section 444.

Je551ca · 19/01/2021 20:33

I applaud your honesty and realism Smile

DeepFakeQueen · 19/01/2021 20:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Itsnotlikethiswithotherpeople · 19/01/2021 20:32

@ReginaPhalangee

No personal judgment from me at all because I know how hard it is but as a professional, I should tell you that failure to engage with remote learning is not an option. Learning remains statutory even at home so anybody not engaging will find there are consequences. We just had a full staff meeting about exactly this issue.
I think there is a lot of confusion in schools about the legal situation. It is school's responsibility to offer virtual learning but there is no mechanism to fine parents for non attendance at a virtual class, from a legal point of view.

During the period of the 7th January - 6th February 2021, s. 444 of the Education Act (1996) has been disapplied (source: assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/.../Education...).
This means that you cannot be fined for not sending a child who is registered at a school, to that school, during this time.

You continue to have a responsibility educate your child (technically it is always your responsibility, you discharge that by sending to school ordinarily unless a home educator) but that does not need to be by engaging with screen based schooling if that isn't proving suitable, for whatever reason. You could educate your child predominately at the weekend and evenings when you aren't working (for example) and never 'attend' a live lesson. You can also select work you think is more suitable if the work is too hard or too easy.

Now you may very well choose to help your child do school set virtual learning for all kinds of good reasons but it's not a legal requirement.

Je551ca · 19/01/2021 20:32

[quote SonicTheSorryRabbit]@Ebee19. But putting your job at risk because you're too busy with homeschooling and too tired to concentrate is also poor parenting.[/quote]
Yes. This. Having parents on the verge of a breakdown is far more damaging than missing school. The whole situation is hard enough for kids to deal with, they don’t need their home life ruined as well.

tootiredtospeak · 19/01/2021 20:31

This is nonsense or you must be referring to secondary. All of the primary schools in our area are not offering any live lessons nothing interactive at all. It is simply a suggestion weekly of what topics you might wish to cover and a request that you upload a couple of pics to class dojo. In no way is this monitored and there could not be any repercussions. The teachers dont have any ide who is doing what. I am working at home and am managing to do a few hours a day split between schools suggestions bitsize and other practical stuff like baking ect. We haven't uploaded anything. I simply dont have time and no one has checked up on my child. I am online with parents from all our locals schools and they are all the same.
There will be children they check up on but simply not sending staged photos of your child working isn't going to land any of us in trouble. There is no tangible way of monitoring correctly what is being done.

Je551ca · 19/01/2021 20:29

@Awalkintime

Je551ca lots of teachers are parents and are doing exactly that.

There are kids that struggle to engage in school too you know.

Doesn’t mean they are doing a good job at the home school part. I imagine many are doing what all working parents are having to do and putting their job first. Not other people’s kids, their job. Teachers are paid to teach for 7 hours a day. I am paid to do something else for 7 hours a day. I cannot do both myself the same as teachers cannot pick up my work so that I can teach.
MabelMoo23 · 19/01/2021 20:29

I’m feel slightly ashamed of my homeschooling efforts, my 5 year old is a nightmare to get engaged, she just throws herself around screeching that she’s bored and starts playing up so we aren’t getting anywhere near enough done, although we are doing something every day and the school are providing home learning and to be fair it’s good. It’s me struggling to get my 5 year old (reception) engaged and try and care for my 3 year old as well

I know I need to do better, but short of losing my shit, she simply isn’t bothered

FreshFreesias · 19/01/2021 20:28

How can parents who work full time possibly be blamed because they can’t educate their kids on top of this?

AyrshireAmbler49 · 19/01/2021 20:26

I’m a primary teacher and the last lockdown did nothing to affect the children’s attainment or progress. In fact I think it did a lot of them good being with their parents so much.
If I had a primary aged child and I had to wfh, I’d be doing the bare minimum.

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 20:24

@Ebee19. But putting your job at risk because you're too busy with homeschooling and too tired to concentrate is also poor parenting.

OP posts: