Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refusing to homeschool

333 replies

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 17:41

Curious about this...

How many parents have simply decided that they're not doing homeschooling? Either because they're wfh and can't balance that with homeschooling or because it's too much for their kids and making them miserable?

If you're not homeschooling, (i) are you getting a hard time from the school?; and (ii) what are your kids doing instead?

YABU - we're homeschooling.

YANBU - we never started/we've given up.

OP posts:
napody · 19/01/2021 21:17

@KylieKangaroo

My 4 year old isn't interested so I'm not going to force her. Plus I'm working from home anyway so it's impossible really! I can't take another 3 months of this though it's really got to me today!
Haven't RTFT but pre compulsory school age it shouldn't be an issue. Hope you get through it okay, I think a lot of people are feeling it this week.
nostaples · 19/01/2021 21:16

'Just ensure you have evidence of the things you are doing.'

You don't need 'evidence'.

If schools are asking for students' work to mark, then fine.

As parents you do not need to prove what you are doing.

Some appalling advice on this thread and if any of it's really coming from teachers themselves then they are misguided or downright wrong and much more of a hindrance than a help.

disneydreaming · 19/01/2021 21:16

YABU imo to just outright refuse. I think most families would be able to support their children to at least get some work done throughout the day even if they can't manage it all and most schools will be understanding as long as they can see there is some effort from families to engage in work.
I am a lone parent working predominantly from home although there are days I physically need to be in work and on those days I am lucky enough to qualify for a key worker space. I am fortunate that my DC (6,11) are both fairly good at working independently. The eldest helps the younger one when needed if I am in a meeting or on a call.
We occasionally have to complete work in the evening or sometimes into the weekend if I'm particularly busy and they need more help but between us we manage.

Daphnise · 19/01/2021 21:14

Whenever I see a self appointed authority figure claiming something "Is not an option" I know that not only is it an option, but many people will be doing it. And no one can take any action about it.

Teachers never seem to learn that adults are not their pupils.

Itsnotlikethiswithotherpeople · 19/01/2021 21:12

Again, you cannot be fined if you are home educating but ignoring school set work. There is a big difference between doing nothing of educational value with your children at any time in the week (which would still be illegal) and home educating them but not doing school set work (perfectly legal). You don't have to deregister to do this while schools are closed. It can be done at the weekend with small amounts in the evening in ways that are suitable for their age and development. Almost all home educators do not sit their 5 year old down for three hours in front of a screen or worksheets to learn. You can't be fined if you do this. Just ensure you have evidence of the things you are doing.

Please don't sit and do maths sheets with your young child at 7pm after work or with a baby in tow crying - miserable for everyone. It's neither legally required nor likely to be particularly educationally helpful. Go for a walk, collect some leaves, get hoops and put them in categories. Make up a maths game with a deck of cards. Laugh a bit. Your school may or may not be supportive. But you are making good choices to provide for your family, or care for younger siblings or heck just care for your own mental health! Whilst you're working, let them play or watch Disney in your eyeline. Then enjoy your time together. DO NOT feel guilty and don't be guilted into making yourselves miserable because the D of E has never met a child.

nostaples · 19/01/2021 21:10

The stupidity on this thread is annoying me now.

There has been no legal action because of parents not home schooling their kids, whatever that even means, during lockdown.

There will be no legal action because of parents not home schooling their kids, whatever that even means, during lockdown.

If you honestly don't understand why some parents are finding it impossible to supervise home learning (parents are not their children's teachers, after all unless they are, which is different) then you seriously need to open your eyes to what a lot people are experiencing at the moment. Perhaps watch the news. Or do a bit more listening.

You might, for example, be a teacher yourself and be trying to teach up to 100 kids a day. This is what I am doing. My own kids are old enough to get on with stuff, or not, but I thank God daily that they are not v little because they would definitely be in front of DVDs all day in that scenario even though I am a good mum who has taken a very great interest in my children's education. I simply could not get my students through A Level and GCSE or anything really whilst dealing with my own kids if they were little.

drspouse · 19/01/2021 21:07

We didn't do DD work from school in the first lockdown because it wasn't at all appropriate and they weren't answering requests for more targeted work. I got a roasting on here for "not wanting to educate my own child" (we were happy to teach her, just not find every resource she needed!).
Now the work from school is pretty much OK for her we are using it. She's actually in part time but we just managed to get out of them what she's been doing on her days on so we don't duplicate!

2021isthenew2020 · 19/01/2021 21:06

@sonypony is correct in that currently the law puts the requirement onto schools to provide remote learning, but there is no legal obilgation for parents to engage with it, as long as they are providing "a suitable education in whatever way they can". Penalty notices for attendance (including remotely) have been disapplied, so no parent will be fined for this.

@ReginaPhalangee is incorrect, and has been given incorrect info by her SMT/LA.

DrMadelineMaxwell · 19/01/2021 21:05

If you are working from home you can use the time you would have once lost due to commuting to do some reading or maths.

Spend the time you'd have spent listening to your child read after they'd been in school and supporting them to do their homework to pick up some of the most important bits of schooling.
And accept that if you've had to be flexible in terms of fitting in any school work in the week, that you should probably do some at the weekend instead. If the child is on free time all week they can do some work at the weekend.

YANBU to find fitting home learning in difficult.
YABU and doing your child a disservice to not fit anything in at all.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 19/01/2021 21:04

@Lancrelady80

Section 444(1) and (1A) of the Act create offences relating to the failure of parents to secure regular attendance at school of a registered pupil...It remains a parent’s duty to ensure that their child of compulsory school age receives a suitable education in whatever way they can under section 7 of the Act and state-funded schools are required to provide remote education to pupils who are not attending in certain circumstances by virtue of the Coronavirus Act 2020 Provision of Remote Education (England) Temporary Continuity Direction 2020 made on 30th September 20203.

Sections 444A and 444B of the Act make provision for the issuance of
penalty notices where there is reason to believe a person has committed
an offence under section 444.

You cannot commit an offence by failing to send a child to school when it is a government requirement to keep children at home - any more than you can commit an offence by failing to send a child to school during school holidays.

Schools are extrapolating and assuming that, because parents are normally required by law to send registered pupils to school, parents must therefore be required by law to engage in the substituted home schooling. There is no legal basis for that assumption. It's simply wrong.

AndAPartridgeInABearTree · 19/01/2021 21:00

This may be controversial but I see refusing to homeschool in the same category as refusing to ensure your child turns up to school on time every day. There's fines for unauthorised absence for a reason and if schools can get these kids back in school they should.

Diverseopinions · 19/01/2021 21:00

It's got the makings of an interesting newspaper article.

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 21:00

The Law states
It's the parents responsibility to ensure their children receive an education, be that school or otherwise.
School isn't available then the parents are the otherwise
HTH

Parents have many responsibilities, of which education is only one. They have the responsibility to feed and clothe their children as well. Which one should they prioritise?

OP posts:
Awalkintime · 19/01/2021 20:59

Jolie12345
But we're not refusing and there was nothing to imply we are wanting to.

BooksAreNotEssentialInWales · 19/01/2021 20:55

@SansaSnark

The expectations from schools were put in place because parents demanded them, and the DfE responded.

I think it's fine to give up- do what you have to, to survive, but don't expect your child's teachers to do extra to catch them up when schools return, and certainly don't expect any catch up in the holidays.

Of course they'll help them catch up. There's loads of reports that home learning doesn't work for many pupils, especially primary.
nostaples · 19/01/2021 20:55

@GypsyLee in this particular case during a global pandemic where parents are just trying to keep it together (as are teachers who, the majority of whom are also parents) nobody is going to enforce that particular law.

Any headteacher who is being heavy handed about this to the extent of threatening or enlisting legal action is very lacking in good sense or compassion.

Legal action would not be helpful even for feckless parents who are just being deliberately arsey and lazy (and no, I really don't think there are many who fall into this category) and would certainly not be helpful for parents who are struggling but trying.

There haven't been any cases of legal action under lockdown so this really is scare mongering and unhelpful.

Do your best, communicate with the school. That's it.

I am a teacher and senior leader and parent.

Allispretty · 19/01/2021 20:53

@ReginaPhalangee

Allispretty not down to me, I wouldn't want to do this whatsoever. It's what I've been told by SMT and they've been told by County.
Thanks for clarifying, the issue I take with this however is there are lots of parents on here at absolute breaking point attempting home learning whilst working ft. These consequences I'm assuming is for parents that literally just can't be arsed and refuse to engage with the school on their reasons why?
Jolie12345 · 19/01/2021 20:52

@GypsyLee

The Law states It's the parents responsibility to ensure their children receive an education, be that school or otherwise. School isn't available then the parents are the otherwise HTH

I'm glad schools will identify those that are being failed at home.
It's the case with H.edders.
They can be ordered back to school if the EWO believes the children education is being neglected

Nope. Not buying that. We ensure they receive an education by enrolling them in school. When schools close due to a pandemic we do not become the otherwise. That is clearly intended as a choice in normal circumstances. The government can’t have it both ways; Take legal action in normal times so that we ensure kids are in school and build our lives around that (we can’t even take them out of school for holidays); and in current times force schools to close and expect parents to pick up education.

In most cases the legal rubbish being quoted wouldn’t stand up. The laws are not designed for pandemics.

ReginaPhalangee · 19/01/2021 20:50

Allispretty not down to me, I wouldn't want to do this whatsoever. It's what I've been told by SMT and they've been told by County.

carolinesbaby · 19/01/2021 20:49

*Who are these parents who work for 16 hours a day, 7 days a week?

If you can't support your children's learning during the typical 9-3 M-F, do it at other times. Both of my children require significant one to one support with learning, so we take any and all opportunity to do it - they were each doing work at the weekend and in the evenings at times as a result.*

So when I have worked from 8.30-5 (on a scheduled diary which cannot be done outside of those hours due to the need for safeguarding referrals etc), then cooked and eaten tea and cleared up, you're suggesting I then sit 6 year old DS down and try to make him work through his school day at 7pm?

Are you serious?

Jolie12345 · 19/01/2021 20:48

@Awalkintime

Je551ca I am also not paid to do more than 1 job but I am currently doing many, just in the same way you are expected to but we're having to deal with it and get on with it so in much the same fashion, we all have to get on and do as best as we can.

Teachers are also working parents!!!

You're finding it tough, teachers are finding it tough. We are all in the same boat having to juggle different roles right now.

We agree on that. My point is, if refusing to home school is a result of not being able to do it all then that’s acceptable in my opinion. And that teachers may well do the same and id support them
GypsyLee · 19/01/2021 20:46

The Law states
It's the parents responsibility to ensure their children receive an education, be that school or otherwise.
School isn't available then the parents are the otherwise
HTH

I'm glad schools will identify those that are being failed at home.
It's the case with H.edders.
They can be ordered back to school if the EWO believes the children education is being neglected

StacySoloman · 19/01/2021 20:45

@Wisteria1979

I feel hugely let down by school to be honest. We get the bare min of online (less than an hour a day) and a whole heap of stuff they want printed / completed / uploaded. We have very little availability in the day and yes of course we do some at the weekend but it won’t be enough. The school is not providing what they are required to do and just push it back out. - sorry but they need to take some accountability back for the schooling. That’s their job. I have mine.
An hour of live stuff plus work to do sounds like lots to me?

What more do you think school are required to do?

Allispretty · 19/01/2021 20:45

@nostaples

FGS, no school or police officer in the country is going to take legal action because a parent is not homeschooling. Everyone would recognise that as stupid and entirely counterproductive. Schools will support and cajole, where possible. They are absolutely not going to punish families who are already struggling in a variety of ways.
Not according to @ReginaPhalangee as per pp...there will be consequences apparently Confused....reading that very saying makes me feel like I'm back in seniors!
Pootle40 · 19/01/2021 20:43

@ReginaPhalangee

No personal judgment from me at all because I know how hard it is but as a professional, I should tell you that failure to engage with remote learning is not an option. Learning remains statutory even at home so anybody not engaging will find there are consequences. We just had a full staff meeting about exactly this issue.
I don't think so.