Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refusing to homeschool

333 replies

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 17:41

Curious about this...

How many parents have simply decided that they're not doing homeschooling? Either because they're wfh and can't balance that with homeschooling or because it's too much for their kids and making them miserable?

If you're not homeschooling, (i) are you getting a hard time from the school?; and (ii) what are your kids doing instead?

YABU - we're homeschooling.

YANBU - we never started/we've given up.

OP posts:
pinkpixie83 · 20/01/2021 07:29

I've given up and have had to accept that 2 of my 3 will fall behind, but hopefully the teachers will know how to manage that on their return.
I'm a single parent working from home, my job is vital to my company but not a key worker. My high school daughter is logging on and doing her best, so she's a little behind but not enough the school have contacted me.
My 2 primary boys however, have one laptop between them, all they are being sent is links to white rose maths and worksheets, then worksheets for everything else. Along with a YouTube link for an assembly and a teacher reading a story per day. Thats it. I can't get them to engage, and couldn't for example get the YouTube links to work on any other device than my laptop as that's where the email with the links was.
School have called every week and I've told them the truth, they said they will try and help... but nothing. One of the boys has adhd but no echp so they know how challenging he can be. He has also repeatedly had extra support from their thrive team, however we haven't heard from them at all. They also know how difficult going back to school will be for him, as he got a short term exclusion in September because he couldn't understand all the covid rules. I honestly have no idea what I'm meant to do.

Porridgeoat · 20/01/2021 06:55

The title doesn't say teachers refusing. My point is, it is unreasonable to refuse to do any work with your child when teachers are in the same boat with juggling and managing a few different jobs and they are not giving up.

^^

All the teachers I know are working kid free in school or working from home with partners to look after kids. I’m sure this isn’t always the case. However their role is to educate kids. The teachers at my kids school seem to assume we have lots of free time to follow a curriculum

Porridgeoat · 20/01/2021 06:46

However I see educational value in children learning other skills. Planning walks using maps, planning a meal and cooking it, photographing and playing with images, creating cards for family, dam building. Play that stems from boredom.

haggistramp · 20/01/2021 06:45

I'm not doing any homeschooling. Dd is asd and refuses to do any schoolwork at home. She works fine at school and enjoyed school before lockdown. What would take a normal child 15 mins take my dd 3 hours of meltdowns and tears and we both end up frazzled by the end of it. I dont have the time to do that when I'm also working ft from home. Dd has been refused place at school as school doesn't think she'd cope at school with all the changes. Wtf am I supposed do? I feel that asd children have just been hung out to dry.

Hadenough80 · 20/01/2021 06:44

I can not fault my childrens school, my two younger children are in reception and yr 1.
My yr 1 child has sen and his whole life as he knew it before Christmas has been turned upside down.
He is struggling really bad and has resulted in meltdown after meltdown.
The school has been very supportive and has given me work that he is more likely to do (interests based).
They have told me not to put pressure on myself and to do what we can do.
Most schools will work with parents and find ways to make it easier.
So if your struggling please contact the school.
Don't feel like you and your child/children have to suffer in silence.

Porridgeoat · 20/01/2021 06:40

Sadly due to covid both DH and my hours have hiked up to 55 and 65 per week. We have enough time to feed the kids, put them to bed and watch a daily film or do a short walk with them and that’s it. The walk or film is usually my only time off housework and working.

Awalkintime · 20/01/2021 05:17

Jolie12345
The title doesn't say teachers refusing. My point is, it is unreasonable to refuse to do any work with your child when teachers are in the same boat with juggling and managing a few different jobs and they are not giving up.

NoseinBook3 · 20/01/2021 03:18

We keep getting work sent back. Both working home full time with a reception aged child and a year two child.

Work comes back because the handwriting isn’t up to usual standard, or because one math question out of twenty was wrong.

My child doesn’t want to engage with the work. It’s a struggle getting them to do anything. It’s further demoralising to keep being told it isn’t good enough for both us and our child.

PlantMam · 20/01/2021 01:20

@Rainallnight

I find the scaremongering on this thread extremely unhelpful to families like mine, with an adopted DD who is freaking out about being abandoned by school and not engaging with any work.
My DD missed a year of school due to serious illness (missed year 2, was in year 3 when lockdown began and is now in year 4) and she felt very similarly last time. She cried and cried and I was completely inadequate at teaching her (I said earlier in the thread that I overcomplicate my explanations and it just overwhelms her further). After a few weeks she refused to engage with anything school related at all.

This time they have 3 live hours a day and it’s much easier/better. She can see the other home learning kids on zoom and ask for (appropriate, expert!) help when she needs it.

I really sympathise with what you are going through - I wish I could offer some practical solutions but obviously everything is so varied from school to school - still, wanted to let you know that you are not alone. Home learning is a very mixed bag and really doesn’t work well for some kids.
If I were in your shoes and could get a school place I would totally take it -if you can’t get one I hope school are at least being understanding about it.

Hope you find a way forward (me and DD ceremoniously dumped all the unfinished summer term worksheets in the recycling bin, humming ‘Taps’, which helped enormously!)

CrackersDontMatter · 20/01/2021 00:32

There's lots of assumptions on this thread that all schools are doing live lessons. My yr2 DS is getting a full day's work set every day and no live lessons at all. Parents working from home would really struggle as much of it needs to be supported/directed.

Osirus · 20/01/2021 00:23

@tootiredtospeak

This is nonsense or you must be referring to secondary. All of the primary schools in our area are not offering any live lessons nothing interactive at all. It is simply a suggestion weekly of what topics you might wish to cover and a request that you upload a couple of pics to class dojo. In no way is this monitored and there could not be any repercussions. The teachers dont have any ide who is doing what. I am working at home and am managing to do a few hours a day split between schools suggestions bitsize and other practical stuff like baking ect. We haven't uploaded anything. I simply dont have time and no one has checked up on my child. I am online with parents from all our locals schools and they are all the same. There will be children they check up on but simply not sending staged photos of your child working isn't going to land any of us in trouble. There is no tangible way of monitoring correctly what is being done.
My daughter is in year R. We have at least one live lesson a day.

I upload every piece of work she physically does - or photos of her doing work, like experiments. I get a response to EVERY piece of work uploaded or emailed, without exception. Her teachers are incredible; they’ve worked incredibly hard. I’m working part time and, most days, still covering the lessons into the evening to get everything finished.

The teachers know exactly who is doing what - your local school sound, quite frankly, a bit shit.

BlackeyedSusan · 20/01/2021 00:09

@Dogsaresomucheasier that is how dc is allowed in school. (and sen) it is a good thing. except dc is not in school for 9 days or so now... I am so pleased dc could go in. But we were working with school before and sending in anything I managed to get dc to do remotely educational.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 19/01/2021 23:50

Some days I do
Some days I literally can’t ! There must be other 10 hour shift single parents like me ?

Edgeoftheledge · 19/01/2021 23:47

This thread has got to me. So stupid that any action should/would be taken against families in these circumstances. Angry

My Ds’s school has been great.

HauntedPencil · 19/01/2021 22:55

Sorry I should have read through! If that's not even true what a thing to scare people with - I should hope it gets removed.

HauntedPencil · 19/01/2021 22:53

It's absolutely INSANE that there would be W consequence over home learning.

Surely that's only if a school lolsace was offered and not taken up too? And other issues?

Teacupsandtoast · 19/01/2021 22:47

Also realising we are 10 pages in and this point will have been made...

Allispretty · 19/01/2021 22:46

@Rainallnight

I find the scaremongering on this thread extremely unhelpful to families like mine, with an adopted DD who is freaking out about being abandoned by school and not engaging with any work.
Exactly! This was my point earlier to @ReginaPhalangee who as a teacher I feel should know better than to make such a statement on a thread clearly full of anxious parents whose Mh is on the brink at the moment trying to parent/homeschool and work!

I don't believe any of it and I know for certain ds school won't be following up if little work is done they already said at the start do what you can

Teacupsandtoast · 19/01/2021 22:45

@FoxyTheFox

So parents can get a school place for their DC simply by refusing to do any homeschooling?

Escalation process is that school will phone home and speak to the parent(s) and child to discuss what the issues are and why they're doing no/little/substandard work. If its something that can be resolved then they'll work to resolve it, if it can't be resolved then the child will be offered a place in school and school will recommend that the place is used.

If this is the case, watch everyone refuse to home school to get their 'vulnerable' child in to school.....
PaquitaVariation · 19/01/2021 22:42

[quote 2021isthenew2020]@sonypony is correct in that currently the law puts the requirement onto schools to provide remote learning, but there is no legal obilgation for parents to engage with it, as long as they are providing "a suitable education in whatever way they can". Penalty notices for attendance (including remotely) have been disapplied, so no parent will be fined for this.

@ReginaPhalangee is incorrect, and has been given incorrect info by her SMT/LA.[/quote]
All of this. The legal duty at present is for schools to provide remote education but there is no legal duty on parents to provide access to that, just that they provide education in some way.

2021isthenew2020 · 19/01/2021 22:40

@oblada

Thanks! Found it - so 'in whatever way they can' - so if parents are both working and unable to engage with homeschooling they just can't. End up story. There is no bloody chance of any successful prosecution on the basis of those wordings, especially given the current context. No chance in hell. I'd even question the validity of this amendment to section 444 and the associated reading of section 7. As parents we are perfectly entitled to delegate education duties to schools. The Education Act 1996 never planned for the situation that we are currently in and parents cannot be suddenly given duties they didn't have before. Anyway, to threaten legal action is pointless and scaremongering.
It also states that legislation that allows for penalty notices against parents has been suspended

"relieving the burden on local authorities with respect
to investigation and decision making under sections 444A and 444B,
freeing up resources to meet the other needs that arise as a result of the
incidence or transmission of coronavirus."

Ie. they won't be investigating or prosecuting parents because they are busy with Covid stuff.

mrdobalinamrbobdobalina · 19/01/2021 22:36

@FoxyTheFox

So parents can get a school place for their DC simply by refusing to do any homeschooling?

Escalation process is that school will phone home and speak to the parent(s) and child to discuss what the issues are and why they're doing no/little/substandard work. If its something that can be resolved then they'll work to resolve it, if it can't be resolved then the child will be offered a place in school and school will recommend that the place is used.

My eldest DC is really struggling. DH is helping as much as he can be it's a frustrating and difficult process for both of them. I'm a keyworker working out of the home. I've never asked for a KW space because DC can be looked after by DH at home. But right now, I would love the school to suggest DS attends because it would be the best thing for everyone Sad
oblada · 19/01/2021 22:34

Thanks! Found it - so 'in whatever way they can' - so if parents are both working and unable to engage with homeschooling they just can't. End up story. There is no bloody chance of any successful prosecution on the basis of those wordings, especially given the current context. No chance in hell. I'd even question the validity of this amendment to section 444 and the associated reading of section 7. As parents we are perfectly entitled to delegate education duties to schools. The Education Act 1996 never planned for the situation that we are currently in and parents cannot be suddenly given duties they didn't have before. Anyway, to threaten legal action is pointless and scaremongering.

Rainallnight · 19/01/2021 22:33

I find the scaremongering on this thread extremely unhelpful to families like mine, with an adopted DD who is freaking out about being abandoned by school and not engaging with any work.

likeafishneedsabike · 19/01/2021 22:33

I’m not sure if we are failing or not then. DC is Year 4. No live or audio/video recorded lessons from school - just class PowerPoints uploaded. Or a comprehension work sheet. Daily zoom to explain PowerPoints, which is something. However, we have opted out on the basis that the learning is not fit for purpose. For example, a lot of the PowerPoints do not provide answers for the Maths questions because in school the teacher would write them on the board. DH is teaching DS two hours or so using Maths and English workbooks and Bitesize. Having read this thread, I feel a bit guilty now.