Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refusing to homeschool

333 replies

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 17:41

Curious about this...

How many parents have simply decided that they're not doing homeschooling? Either because they're wfh and can't balance that with homeschooling or because it's too much for their kids and making them miserable?

If you're not homeschooling, (i) are you getting a hard time from the school?; and (ii) what are your kids doing instead?

YABU - we're homeschooling.

YANBU - we never started/we've given up.

OP posts:
Morph2lcfc · 21/01/2021 07:27

There’s been some posts about parents being threatened with ewo if children don’t engage with home learning. There’s a significant number of kids that won’t always engage in school either but if parents have got them into school then they’ve done their bit legally. Mine has asd and now he is in Specialist but back when he in mainstream some days he spent all day in the senco’s room and did no learning. If I’d been having to home school then there’s no way I’d have got him to do all the work set for the class and I don’t think it would be fair for school to penalise. I know people will say things don’t apply to sen kids but there was a time before mine was diagnosed and put on the sen register when he wouldn’t have been classed as sen just naughty. So guess what I’m trying to say that I don’t think it’s fair to penalise parents for not being able to do something that the school can’t do either in normal times.

Mines in school this time but last lockdown he wouldn’t engage in the work. School were relaxed, he did reading and we uploaded pics of us playing games like battleships, sports in the garden etc which they seemed to be happy with. This time for the kids not in school the home learning seems to have ramped up a gear so I can see why some people are struggling.

Lulu49 · 20/01/2021 22:58

I work in social care, we have over half our staff off due to covid related issues, either isolating or they actually have it. I saw my daughter for the first time today (Wednesday) since Saturday night except the 15 minutes in the morning when I wake her up for school. I’ve been starting at 7am and finishing at 10 pm. I finished at 2 today, did the food shop, picked her up from school and then slept as I was doing a night shift from 10pm through til 9am Thursday, I’ll sleep half of Thursday and Friday I have a cleaning job and am back at work 7 am Saturday and again Sunday. Last lockdown she stayed at home, I knew she wouldn’t engage and I was right, she was up all night and sleeping all day and I was at work similar to now. I’m a single parent. This time I have sent her to school as the provision is available for her because she will engage at school. It’s working thank goodness because there’s not a hope in hell of me being able to home school

kimmsutt · 20/01/2021 22:56

Trying not to get political, but surely what is missing here is the strength of messages to employers to allow staff to go on furlough if they need to (/can). There is still a furlough scheme for many but definitely not the pus as we had last year to ‘look after our families’. The call is ‘work from home and your kids will be next to you’ which is going to lead to domestic stress, confused kids and jobs half done. Arsehole government!

ReginaPhalangee · 20/01/2021 22:46

I'd like to clarify... all the way through this thread I've made it very clear that I fully empathise with everyone trying to juggle homeschooling. I'm doing it myself. Probably badly Confused

I have only passed on what I've been told. True or not, I'm really not trying to scaremonger. My first response which people have quoted was from a poster who said they weren't going to bother... not an anxious parent! Ever since then I've posted ideas and given advice and guidance.

I disagree with the notion that anyone should be penalised but not once did I mention any fines. I've no idea what may or may not happen. And from what I can gather, 'good enough' engagement is absolutely fine. Not every piece of learning needs to be handed in. Just to know parents are trying is absolutely fine in our book.

It's the parent who refuses point blank to engage and hangs up the phone when we call who will probably be chased up. And not by me! I've enough on my plate.

LeopardPrintKnickers · 20/01/2021 22:32

I’m trying so hard to keep the plates spinning but my God, this is so hard. All I seem to be hearing is friends who don’t work telling me they’re struggling or they’re giving up...

My kids are 10 and 8, but neither are able to work independently, they need my reassurance and often for me to give context, explain things and cheer them along the way. There are NO live lessons, just new files uploaded every day of what they should be learning which is great but also adds to the pressure as I’m scared of us falling behind. I’m also working all the hours God sends to keep our business going. As well as the home learning, I’m also struggling to balance a demanding, stressful job with the demands of 24/7 parenting - listening, talking, hugs, refereeing, dealing with upset and worry, cooking...

So many of us are fighting the toughest battle right now - hearing about those who can’t be arsed just makes my blood boil...

SquigglePigs · 20/01/2021 22:05

@Leonberger

Surely we are all working around this. The vast majority of people are still working and all in the same boat.

Just fit it in when you can surely. After work, before work, weekends...it does not need to be done 9-3.

I’ve seen so many parents in my child’s school moaning about working and having do homeschool. So are most of the country at the moment, nobody is having an easy time Hmm

It does depend on the school a bit. A friends school is issuing work for the day at 9am and instructing that it must be completed between 9am and 4.30pm and submitted to the school at 4.30. They say that "the children need a work life balance too so work should not be completed outside of these core hours".

For a lot of working parents that's impossible because as you say, it often fits better before work, after work or at the weekends.

Some schools are being fantastically supportive. Others seem to think parents have no commitments outside of doing whatever the school deems appropriate.

Almostslimjim · 20/01/2021 22:02

At my school refusing to homeschool is being classed as neglect.
Lack of daily engagement results in an absent mark and threats of the EWO have begun.

But it's a totally empty threat. Unless you've got other concerns to support your referral all the EWO is call me up, ask why we aren't engaging with the home learning and tell us we should try a bit more (if that). If the child usually has good attendance and you don't have other safeguarding concerns outside of lockdown they'll do the bare minimum.

MummyMayo1988 · 20/01/2021 21:03

YABU but I can see how parents would struggle. Some of the work my yr6 DS has goes right over my head. Luckily tho he's quite bright and gets on with it mostly himself with only a little helo from me.
My Yr 3 DS is a lot easier but I have a daily battle to get him motivated.
Weve been going our for a daily walk and I am trying my best.
This whole thing sucks on a whole new level of sucking. I hope it ends soon.

Silkiechickscat · 20/01/2021 20:56

Our school has just today stopped recording anyone not in a live lesson at the set live time as unauthorised absence. It was a ridiculous policy as a lot of kids don't have their own device, kids with SN, working parents etc.

oblada · 20/01/2021 20:45

@FancySomeChips

At my school refusing to homeschool is being classed as neglect. Lack of daily engagement results in an absent mark and threats of the EWO have begun.
What a ridiculous stance to take. Your school is being completely ridiculous. A bit like those policemen claiming they can issue fines to people for travelling to places to exercise. Absolutely bonkers.
Angrywife · 20/01/2021 20:17

@ReginaPhalangee

Interesting...what can you the school do about it if parents refuse to homeschool? Can you take them to court?

Potentially, yes. There are referral options. Of course nobody wants to have to go down this route at all and we want our families to engage, so we are throwing as much support out as we possibly can.

Given that the DFE have stated there must be no unauthorised absences and no enforcement during lock down - its ridiculous and completely wrong to say a parent could be fined for not home schooling.
PeachyPeachTrees · 20/01/2021 20:00

Even just 30 mins before work and 30 mins after work is better than nothing. Reading, TTRockstars, spelling app or BBC bitesize are things that need minimal imput from a parent.
I'm homeschooling 2 reluctant children and feel like jacking it in, but I'm going to keep going and do as much as I can while trying to balance work and a happy home life. It's worth the hard work now.

gallbladderpain · 20/01/2021 19:32

Surely you are only failing your own child ?
I don't get this mentality at all !
Been remote learning since March 2020 due to cev child.
In some jobs it absolutely would be impossible due to the parents job roll but also they aren't working 24 hours a day 7 days a week. We have friends who are in this situation they came homeschool during the weekdays because of work but they will cover a little bit each evening and over the weekend.
The 'we can't do that so we just won't do anything at all' I feel for kids who have parents with that mentality and suffer from a lack of resilience to even attempt to try and do what they can

Wotsitsarecheesy · 20/01/2021 19:31

"Have you ever had a child who is supposed to be doing live lessons refuse to get out of bed? Be violent towards you? Threaten to kill themselves? Cry and cry? Just lie on the floor with their head in their hands and refuse to respond to you?"

"We are trying very hard but Ds has ASD and is a school refuser. Refusing to do almost all work but we are still trying every single day. School have offered a vulnerable child place. Ds won't go because schools are closed it says so on the news every day."

This is our situation too. All of the above. DD in Y9, supposed to be choosing her options atm. ASD/anxiety/MH issues, school refuser, already on a part time timetable as she couldn't cope and refused to engage with full time school. She is attending some live lessons, sporadically (1-3 a day), but not doing any other work. She has always struggled to work from home - school and home are kept totally separate and she can't handle two being combined. Last lockdown she did no work at all from home, so this time 1-3 lessons a day is an improvement. But school have already reduced the number of subjects they will let her take at GCSE because she isn't fully engaging with home learning, and if she continues to refuse they may reduce her choice further. She is already having to choose between her favourite subject and her best subject for GCSE. She is just 14, extremely bright (grammar school) and doesn't appreciate the problems she is causing for herself long term. But the tantrums if I even try to discuss this with her are horrendous and mean she digs her heels in even further. Like a PP, school have offered her a place but she refuses to go because schools are closed and her siblings are at home.

I am finding homeschooling both impossible and distressing, seeing a bright future go to waste. I can't see how this can be improved until schools open again and I can get her back in. In the meantime this lockdown already means she won't be allowed to take all the subjects she wants at GCSE (they have reduced the number of subjects she is allowed to take). This will have consequenses for her sixth form and possible uni choices. If schools were open, she would be attending those lessons as she enjoys them. It is her anxiety about using Zoom and her refusal to work at home that is the problem.

Sorry this is so long. I have nowhere else I can vent!

LisaD76 · 20/01/2021 19:30

My dd is struggling with the home schooling, she is year 8 and can’t always get the file to load, she had one earlier on zoom where they had a worksheet that took ages to print as the bloody virus protection wouldn’t let us open it, then it was about a previous text they had been sent for another lesson, which we couldn’t find. She would rather be at school, but we are furloughed and would obviously rather her here and safe, besides I think the teachers are not faring any better.

Murphs1 · 20/01/2021 19:24

This is interesting as I am a key worker as is my husband. My ds goes to school 2 days a week and is doing much less of the set work at school than I do with him at home. For 2 days this week he hasn’t done any English or maths at school on google classroom, just the fun stuff. I think saying there will be consequences is a bit threatening actually and not helpful to parents trying their best.

Truelymadlydeeplysomeonesmum · 20/01/2021 19:15

@FancySomeChips

At my school refusing to homeschool is being classed as neglect. Lack of daily engagement results in an absent mark and threats of the EWO have begun.
I this is THREATS

They can threat all they like. At the end of the day some parents still won't engage.

The government have given guidance to local authorities. So legally no action can be taken in the pandemic. No successfully anyway.

Invisablewoman · 20/01/2021 19:11

Working and home-schooling is undoubtedly extremely hard. I work part-time in a very stressful role and my DP works full-time. We have a YR and Y5. We are both wfh and count ourselves VERY fortunate that we have understanding employers that have carers plans in place which means we have both dropped work hours to 2.5 days each so we split homeschooling 50/50.
There is very little downtime though and I'm often working after they've gone to bed to keep on top of things. If I've had to go into work (which had happened a few times we have to juggle and a lot of TV gets watched).

If we didn't have understanding employers it would have been night on impossible to support the children at home without taking leave.

sausagerole · 20/01/2021 19:11

I should add that my eldest did really well engaging with online learning by himself, it was only the middle one that I had to speak to the school about

RainbowBrite1 · 20/01/2021 19:10

Two children at home ones who's 3 and could be in nursery but I don't want to take the risk, she's asthmatic. My 2nd one is almost 7 and I'm trying my best to homeschool I'm not a key worker I'm a sahm so I'm very lucky to have the time but honestly I'm struggling she's struggling and my other little one wants my time too. School are not doing any live lessons for year 2 just lots of videos explaining how to do it but sadly we are now behind with work and the Constant notifications texts emails to say more work has been added is driving me round the bend. They are only responding to emails or messages during school times I think 10 till 4 which is absolutely fine with me but they send out text messages and emails telling you new work has been added and sometimes it can be 11.30 at night. They want 4 hours per day 😫

sausagerole · 20/01/2021 19:09

When I had all 3DC (Y4, Y1 and 6 month old baby) at home alone, I told the school that I might use the set work as a springboard for our activities but we wouldn't be submitting/completing all the work or even much of it. Both my older children have significant SEN and emotional stability and learning things via nature hunts/podcasts/crafting etc is the only learning they were able to access. I totally understand they've needed to close schools, but either my children are at home with me and I'll educate as I am able/see fit, or they are at school recieving an education via the state. I don't see how the LA can enforce state curriculum in a homeschooling environment - I understand they have a legal responsibility to provide the curriculum,but how can anyone legally enforce that I as a parent have to teach that in what is essentially a homeschooling context?? Sorry, not RTFT so this might have been discussed already.

drspouse · 20/01/2021 18:44

@FancySomeChips

At my school refusing to homeschool is being classed as neglect. Lack of daily engagement results in an absent mark and threats of the EWO have begun.
This despite the DfE saying no fines would be issued??
FancySomeChips · 20/01/2021 18:39

At my school refusing to homeschool is being classed as neglect.
Lack of daily engagement results in an absent mark and threats of the EWO have begun.

MazAds · 20/01/2021 18:37

@Whattodowithaminute

I have 2 DS engaging well with live lessons, I’m not making them do any extra even though it’s provided. Last lockdown one of them cried every single day, this time he’s happy. My youngest DS is only 4 and isn’t engaging well at all, we do little bits here and there but broadly he’s playing on his own lots of the day.
He’s still so young, he will still need lots of play to learn anyway, so I think what you’re doing is absolutely right. What a great example your other two are setting for him! Smile
Mammyloveswine · 20/01/2021 18:26

Parents refusing to homeschool their children will be classed as vulnerable and offered a place in school...however this depends on their being space to do so safely so should not be an "easy way out".

If you do not engage with home learning at all it is not good enough... teachers did not choose this and we understand things are tough, many of us are also juggling home learning at the same time as physically teaching in school, setting home learning, making welfare calls, dealing with funding issues, safeguarding..

We ask that you do your best...if that's an hour on a night with a sat morning set aside to focus on the key skills then that's great!

But please don't just refuse to do anything!