Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refusing to homeschool

333 replies

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 17:41

Curious about this...

How many parents have simply decided that they're not doing homeschooling? Either because they're wfh and can't balance that with homeschooling or because it's too much for their kids and making them miserable?

If you're not homeschooling, (i) are you getting a hard time from the school?; and (ii) what are your kids doing instead?

YABU - we're homeschooling.

YANBU - we never started/we've given up.

OP posts:
SansaSnark · 19/01/2021 19:47

The expectations from schools were put in place because parents demanded them, and the DfE responded.

I think it's fine to give up- do what you have to, to survive, but don't expect your child's teachers to do extra to catch them up when schools return, and certainly don't expect any catch up in the holidays.

ReginaPhalangee · 19/01/2021 19:46

NannyOgg please ask your school if they could supply you with some tech. We have done this for many and we have more on order now. And our community are donating to our school.

Frazzled2207 · 19/01/2021 19:46

@arethereanyleftatall

Yabu. But my dc are y5 & y7 so just get on with it with zero input from me.
really?? mine are 5 and 7 and do nothing without full on input from me,
Lemons1571 · 19/01/2021 19:46

WFH covers a huge spectrum of different working patterns, hours, demands and roles though. Trying to homeschool and WFH is completely different for a parent with a full time professional office role who’s salary is needed to pay the mortgage, than a parent who does 2 hours per week on a hobby business and any earnings are extras for a few bonus luxuries.

I can’t see any of these cases going to court. The very first question by a judge would be to the school “did you do everything in your power to get engagement including offering a school place as a vulnerable child?”. Otherwise the courts will be overrun by about 4 million court cases where children missed a few zooms and didn’t submit twinkl sheets on 13th and 27th January. The court backlog is bad enough as it is!

PlantMam · 19/01/2021 19:46

We abandoned ship in the summer because it was all worksheets and whenever my dd asked for help I was completely incapable of giving understandable direction and instead spiralled into increasingly complicated descriptions, resulting in her regularly bursting into tears!

This time she has three live online sessions so has plenty of opportunity to get proper instruction from a qualified teacher, so no crying.

I miss the freedom of setting our own timetable (it’s hard to fit dog walking into daylight hours!) but it’s much better.

I feel for anyone trying to cope with less input from school, it was an absolute nightmare for us last time.

MNnicknameforCVthreads · 19/01/2021 19:45

Whilst ultimately some sort of education is in the best interests of the child I am inclined to agree with this:

“ Lots of schools basically abandoned kids in the first lockdown (despite some heroic work by individual teachers). They can fuck right off with threats of legal action now.”

m0therofdragons · 19/01/2021 19:45

@Murmurur the higher achieving year 5s might but the low confidence below average ones (1/3 to 1/2 the class) will find it harder. Dtds put up a wall with maths. At school they’re currently getting top greater depth level but somehow that disappears without a teacher giving reassurance and my word is worth very little. This is after Saturday’s homework as in my previous post, dtds are in school (and I’m incredibly grateful they can be). Dd1 is year 8 and online learning at home but she can be left for a couple of hours (I’m not happy doing that with dtds)

ReginaPhalangee · 19/01/2021 19:44

And many of us in my school are juggling our own children who are either in school (primary mostly) or remote learning, such as my secondary age son who is 13 and has to stay home alone every single day - for the first time in his life - whilst I go in and teach others. So I get it!!! I really do.

sonypony · 19/01/2021 19:44

Some of you say do it as and when but we have been told that our schools 3 meetings are compulsory 8:30, 11:00 and 1

They can say what they like but doesn’t make it true. You are not legally obliged to do those.

blue25 · 19/01/2021 19:43

Why would you just give up? This could be going on for months.

queenofarles · 19/01/2021 19:43

Have you ever had a child who is supposed to be doing live lessons refuse to get out of bed? Be violent towards you? yes

Just lie on the floor with their head in their hands and refuse to respond to you? yes.

It’s not easy and it’s so stressful to all my 3dcs, but there is just no other option , they know it needs to be done, not to mention just how exhausted and burnt out I am!

Just this morning my eldest 14yr decided to nap at 10,30 which resulted in him missing two lessons and the school messaging me to inform of that.

PerpendicularVincent · 19/01/2021 19:43

DC has some SN and has a busy schedule of online lessons. DH and I also have full time jobs with calls throughout the day.

It's really tough, but we can't just not do any schoolwork with him.

We take it in turns to sit with him when he has lessons, and if we all have calls at the same time then we sit outside his room so that we get some privacy and can be there if he needs us.

Homework is done sitting at the table with us, either at lunchtimes or after work, or if it's something straightforward, whilst we're working.

I've cried this week with tiredness, but there is no other option - we just have to get on with it.

I saw someone on an FB group last week saying that they'd given up on online learning and instead had decided to teach their son life skills like being a good partner Hmm. It just sounded like they couldn't be bothered with lessons tbh, which is so unfair to their child.

MH1111 · 19/01/2021 19:42

Schools should not have closed, many are over half full anyway.
All we have done is shunted lots of problems onto other areas of society. The mental health consequences are considerable.

Nanny0gg · 19/01/2021 19:42

@Awalkintime

So they're simultaneously teaching online lessons and teaching lessons in the classroom?

Yes lots of us are.

Good job you're qualified teachers able to differentiate then.

How about parents doing a totally different job, which requires them to be online at all times, with children of very different ability who can't/won't work on their own.

Oh, and not enough tech to go round.

ReginaPhalangee · 19/01/2021 19:41

But is it the same lesson? The problem many parents have is that they can't both be on a work call in one room and supervising live lessons in another room. Since it's impossible to be in two places at once.

Not necessarily... but my role requires me to do both. Yes it's an impossible situation and pretty exhausting. My lessons are adapted for home learners, the children in my classroom have the same objectives but obviously we have the resources to support. We try to provide this for home use but we fully understand the difficulties.

To the PP who said we could 'fuck right off' ConfusedBiscuitNo school wants to take anybody to court, I can promise that. We pride ourselves at my school on the family-feel relationships with our parents and children. We have to prove our children are engaging with the learning. They're enrolled on our register so we have no choice. If a parent doesn't show they are engaging we have no choice but to try to engage them. It's not our decision.

Ohalrightthen · 19/01/2021 19:41

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

You can't just decide that compulsory education isn't working for your family, it is a legal requirement and, more importantly, to not persevere is to do your children a huge disservice

It is a legal obligation to provide your child with a suitable education. It is not a legal obligation to engage with a school to do so.

So parents do need to homeschool children, but they are under no obligation whatsoever to use materials sent by the school or to report back to the school. Lots of schools basically abandoned kids in the first lockdown (despite some heroic work by individual teachers). They can fuck right off with threats of legal action now.

They can only do that if they deregister the child and forfeit the school place. You cannot remain registered with a school and not engage with their education attempts.
alfieum · 19/01/2021 19:40

Working in a demanding role with confidentiality and safeguarding issues. However not classed as a key worker. I am supervising my SEN year 1, ignoring my speech delayed two year old who I am watching deteriorate. Is all the work getting done? No.

TonMoulin · 19/01/2021 19:39

I've spoken to a few parents some of who have said they are giving up. It's not that they don't want to homeschool as such but the expectation from schools are too much.

Parents are told to teach their dcs about adjectives etc... when they have no idea what it is. One of them told me about the work set for her nursery child that involved reading a story and then making some complex craft with the child and sending a photo. Very good if you are in class and know how to do that stuff. Not so good when you have no art stuff and can't buy any.
I know there is no way I could have taught my dcs the phonics (Im not british and cant pronouce those sounds properly)
etc....

It often feels that the teachers are basically hoping that a parent will replace them and will do all the teaching for them. Whih a lot of parets cant do.

So they give up. Who would blame them?

Murmurur · 19/01/2021 19:38

I think you should talk specifically to other parents of infant school children. Most (but not all) Y5/Y6s will manage something with a laptop and parent helping out when they can, but 5 year olds are a different kettle of fish. It's so easy for people to judge and say "try harder" but they have walked zero miles in your shoes.

AbitSceptical · 19/01/2021 19:32

@queenofarles

I just feel unless the child has SN, then there is absolutely no way they can’t sit and join Live lessons, they were attending up till a few weeks ago so it’s not something completely new to them, they are familiar with the teachers and subjects.

DD1 attends her lessons and unfinished work we complete later in the day.

Have you ever had a child who is supposed to be doing live lessons refuse to get out of bed? Be violent towards you? Threaten to kill themselves? Cry and cry? Just lie on the floor with their head in their hands and refuse to respond to you?

No? Lucky you. Try and be a bit less judgmental. And grateful you have a DD who does do the work.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 19/01/2021 19:32

You can't just decide that compulsory education isn't working for your family, it is a legal requirement and, more importantly, to not persevere is to do your children a huge disservice

It is a legal obligation to provide your child with a suitable education. It is not a legal obligation to engage with a school to do so.

So parents do need to homeschool children, but they are under no obligation whatsoever to use materials sent by the school or to report back to the school. Lots of schools basically abandoned kids in the first lockdown (despite some heroic work by individual teachers). They can fuck right off with threats of legal action now.

TracyBeakerSoYeah · 19/01/2021 19:31

It's quite ironic that pre Covid if anyone on MNet asked if it was a good idea to WFH & not put their baby/child in nursery/pre school on those working from home days, the consensus was a big fat no.
Posters would say it's not professional as how can you get your work done from home if you are having to supervise a child.

Obviously we need to do what we need to do during this pandemic but it just seems that all the reasons why it's not a good idea to WFH & school or care for children at the same time has been forgotten.
Luckily my DC are older & are getting on with their work this time round as the school is now organised & doing virtual classrooms/online learning.
Plus we have the luxury of quiet spaces to learn & all the technology needed. Not all kids are lucky in that respect.
Last year it was hopeless as there was no online learning at all just worksheets emailed out.
School found the many children got bored with the lack of teacher/class interaction.

It really annoys me when posters say home learning & WFH is a piss of piss & berates anyone who is struggling.
I have it easy but I can see that other people do not.
It really annoys me that there are some posters on MN threads that are not intelligent or empathetic enough to realise that life isn't uniform & people's experiences wildly differ.

Silkiechickscat · 19/01/2021 19:31

At the moment I've one with SN who needs full-time 1 to 1 to do from home and 1 year 10 trying to do GCSEs from home. I've had to not work since March to try and give the SN one an education but I can't survive with no income indefinitely and we don't qualify for help from school or for income as was newly self-employed.

He just screams, cries, whines, kicks , refuses and we have no school place and almost no savings and its not sustainable. School finally promised him a place from Tuesday but then withdrew it Monday night. So we are back to surviving with no money and no help from anyone but we will have to get more income soon. It's pointless me logging on pretending to be him. I was doing that but what is the point? It just hides the problem.

PandemicPalava · 19/01/2021 19:28

Some of you say do it as and when but we have been told that our schools 3 meetings are compulsory 8:30, 11:00 and 1. The teachers need an email if a child cannot attend. This is working well for us as I am at home and my work is craft so I can just about make my orders and deal with enquiries while supervising dd (10) but if I had a more taxing job I think we would really struggle. I didn't realise the situation was so strict about following what the school sends

Hankunamatata · 19/01/2021 19:26

Last lockdown we scrapped doing homeschooling with most of stuff from school. We did maths sheet, english sheet, read together and watch educational tv programme. Kept things ticking over without too much stress.