Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refusing to homeschool

333 replies

SonicTheSorryRabbit · 19/01/2021 17:41

Curious about this...

How many parents have simply decided that they're not doing homeschooling? Either because they're wfh and can't balance that with homeschooling or because it's too much for their kids and making them miserable?

If you're not homeschooling, (i) are you getting a hard time from the school?; and (ii) what are your kids doing instead?

YABU - we're homeschooling.

YANBU - we never started/we've given up.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
researchinglockdown · 19/10/2021 09:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Gwenhines · 23/01/2021 11:13

I'm about to give up on online lessons too. I've invested in workbooks and we are going to follow our own path with maths, English, and reading.

The 2x30 min live lessons and 2+ hours of work that inevitably take longer can get out of our lives. DD is only 6 and the negativity it brings into our home is no longer welcome. I given it a really good go, 2 weeks pre Christmas and again since beginning of Jan.
Im sick of spending 12-14 hours tied to my desk working my full time job and DDs school work. The extra 4-6 hours at that desk is being redistributed to get us out of the house and enjoying family time, we'll curl up with a book of our choice, I'll sit at the table supporting her go thru workbooks at her own pace, we will take a local map and she can plan is a walk then lead it, we will bake, and watch films etc.

DDs teacher puts a lot into the work, but it's in no way a substitute for being in school and taught like DDs friends are reporting back. Two teachers per year, one in school doing full lessons with kids face to face, with TA support. One at home doing online lessons with a TA watching while drinking cups of tea looking bored to tears, and then it's down to me and DD to suffer trying to get the work done, too much of it is along the lines of "write some sentences that....", which really means we battle for an hour while I try to get DD to do her own sentences then I give in and just tell her what to write. No thanks.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 23/01/2021 01:29

Why has anyone been ‘thrown under a bus ‘ why this phrase ?
It’s a pandemic
It’s chaos
I’m a single parent working FT
And not massively homeschooling my kids either
It is what it is - terrible for everyone
Some are lonely , some are unemployed some are bereaved
Some are working night shifts in ICU

All this thrown under the bus shit really annoys me
Just crack on

CayrolBaaaskin · 23/01/2021 01:12

I agree op. It’s tough to do very little with dds. I have to work full time and they need constant supervision. It’s all I can do to keep it together.

supersplodge · 23/01/2021 00:28

Havent RTFT so apologies if I'm repeating what PPs have said. Last lockdown was a nightmare as I had to print off all the set work and stand over the two DCs (early secondary) and explain / nag from dawn to dusk. After half an hour they'd beg to have a break, it was so hard to keep them on task..

This time they have online lessons and I borrowed a laptop from school, they have one each and we are lucky enough to have two rooms with tables so they log on for their first lesson and then follow their normal timetable. Lessons are partly F2F and then some set work so they aren't staring at screens all day (ditto the poor teachers) and PE etc is set tasks. I do have to support a bit and help printing things occasionally, but they know what they have to do so I'm not the bad guy! Soooo much better.

It's not ideal but academically miles better than last time.

Greenygrape · 21/01/2021 19:57

@Casschops we've got to that point. Hard to explain to the teacher that I didn't have time to look at the portal for all the home learning, but I did have time to spend the week making a Papier mache stone age axe with the kids. But for me one activity is me doing something without the kids and the other is me doing something with the kids. Only 24 hours in the day and only really 12 the kids are awake for.

Last year we put school work first and the only people it benefited were the school. I'm not teacher bashing but the reality was when I was downloading or uploading something they didn't have to think about my kids at all. My kids hated it, they didn't learn anything it was almost all revision.

So this time putting kids wellbeing, work and my husband and me first. Feel much happier, the kids are fine. I can be mum and not a poor imitation of a teacher

SallyB392 · 21/01/2021 19:09

They have to use a special code when you don't engage during lock downs, and overall attendance statistics shouldn't be affected. Children's statistics are based on 'available school sessions'. That said I don't know about Wales, Scotland & Ireland.

Casschops · 21/01/2021 18:19

The education system says that they are not childcare providers. Parents can equally argue that they aren't teachers. We were marked as non attending when school closed due to COVID month before Christmas.I told them in advance that online lessons weren't suitable. The teachers did their best. We went sledging.

SallyB392 · 21/01/2021 17:17

It is not compulsory to engage with schools. The law is very clear. Until 6th February 2021, schools must provide opportunities for remote learning. However you as parents are not required to send y our child to school or to engage with your child's school and the school can not use the usual non attendance legislation.

Legally you must ensure that your child(ren) receives an education to meet their needs and abilities, however you choose. Schools can't insist on your de-registering whilst schools are not open to all children.

1
Coronavirus Act 2020 Disapplication of Section 444(1) and (1A) of the
Education Act 1996 (England) Notice 2021
The Secretary of State for Education, in exercise of the powers conferred by section
38(1) of, and paragraph 5 of Schedule 17 to, the Coronavirus Act 20201
, issues the
following notice.
Disapplication of section 444(1) and (1A) of the Education Act 1996

  1. The Secretary of State for Education by this notice disapplies in relation to
England section 444(1) and (1A) of the Education Act 19962 (the Act) during the period specified in this notice.
  1. The Secretary of State for Education considers the issuing of this notice is an
appropriate and proportionate action in all the circumstances relating to the incidence or transmission of coronavirus for the following reasons: (a) An increase in the rates and means of transmission of coronavirus make it necessary to take further measures to reduce transmission. On 4th January 2021 the Prime Minister announced a national lockdown in England to begin on 5th January 2021. In light of the level and seriousness of risk and having considered advice and information from the Scientific Advisory Group on Emergencies, the Chief Medical Officer, the Joint Biosecurity Committee and Public Health England, the Secretary of State has decided that it is appropriate for most pupils to temporarily cease to attend school. The purpose of this measure is to reduce rates of transmission by reducing the number of contacts among pupils and between pupils and staff at school, and between pupils and others while travelling to and from school and while at home and in the community. (b) Section 444(1) and (1A) of the Act create offences relating to the failure of parents to secure regular attendance at school of a registered pupil. It is therefore appropriate and proportionate to temporarily disapply section 444(1) and (1A) so that pupils will not be required to attend school. It remains a parent’s duty to ensure that their child of compulsory school age receives a suitable education in whatever way they can under section 7 of the Act and state-funded schools are required to provide remote education to pupils who are not attending in certain circumstances by virtue of the Coronavirus Act 2020 Provision of Remote Education (England) Temporary Continuity Direction 2020 made on 30th September 20203 . 1 2020 c. 7. 2 1996 c. 56. 3 Published in the Gazette and online at www.thegazette.co.uk/notice/3642261
thelongwayhome · 21/01/2021 17:11

Honestly we feel really out in the cold with no idea what we are doing. Minimal communication with the school, minimal support, no live lessons. They do a live assembly once a week, asked all the children to show their pets and went through every single child even the ones who just had stuffed animals, and skipped over my child and our (real live) cat, despite her raising her hand in the call once she realised the teacher had gone past her in the register. She was already having confidence issues from being ignored in school, now she's out of it it's still happening and she's feeling very isolated. It's just me and her at home, and I'm trying to write my dissertation and finish take home exams and assignments for the final year of my undergrad and wondering if it'd be better for my child if I dropped out.
School wouldn't even know if she wasn't doing any work.

MarchingOnTogether · 21/01/2021 15:40

Yabu to not bother at all. The standard 9-3 might not work for everyone but we can all find some time to make some effort.
I have one in secondary doing lessons in real time, its hard work, he needs my help a lot!
Then one in primary who can do her work whenever, so if she needs my undivided attention she gets that after 3pm or over the weekend.
During school hours she reads, does times tables practice, plays educational games and watches tv shows related to her school topics. She also likes making up stories and doing crafts.
Her actual school work doesn't always get done but we make sure we touch on everything even if she doesn't find time to do all the written work.

WatchWatch · 21/01/2021 15:23

@MrsNWT

I'm not sure maybe I'm a sheep but do we have any other option rather than homeschooling?

School won't take them. I want them to keep being educated.

Do you mean just forgetting about schooling them?

I think OP was more thinking is there anyone not doing the work set by school.

We aren't but mine are lower primary so I don't feel it is as necessary. We are doing some education, but not the stuff from school.

MrsNWT · 21/01/2021 15:19

I'm not sure maybe I'm a sheep but do we have any other option rather than homeschooling?

School won't take them. I want them to keep being educated.

Do you mean just forgetting about schooling them?

52andblue · 21/01/2021 14:15

@Dutch1e
It IS immensely stressful.
I have a Y9 and a Y11. Both have ASD & Dyslexia.
both were doing badly and having a bad time at school.
I had hoped that HE would be a better option
but they need the structure of School - home is home and school is school to them, plus the Y11 is frantic about 'sticking to the curriculum' in his exam year. BUT...
All school are doing is sending reams of work. No online lessons at all. So it's new material, no explainations, maybe a link to a Youtube vid at best, tough luck if you don't understand. Emails coming through between 7am and 10pm (automated) with lists of 'work outstanding' - maybe 12 per day on average. He cannot cope at all.

WatchWatch · 21/01/2021 13:11

People can ask to be furloughed if they can't work from home and home school.

Can ask, can be refused. It isn't a right. I don't know anyone being furloughed currently, despite having requested it.

wildchild554 · 21/01/2021 12:53

@bemusedmoose how does that effect people that are self employed? I know if I don't work as I am self employed I can't pay the bills.

Dutch1e · 21/01/2021 12:46

@ancientgran I did think last March that they needed to get some home school experts involved because as you say 1 to 1 is very different to a classroom situation.

This would have been so sensible. It still could be, I hope that kind of consultation happens.

Wearethechampionsmyfriend · 21/01/2021 11:46

I work in a school and apparently there are lots of students not engaging at home so they are coming into their YR bubble thick and fast, especially the younger ones. Don't worry though the teachers are protected and at home, its the support staff that are in supporting them in school ! Obviously we're immune to any variant of covid !

ancientgran · 21/01/2021 11:06

Dutch1e I home schooled mine for 5 years and I understand what you are saying. I think the problem is that people are generally more familiar with the school system and they want to replicate it.

I did think last March that they needed to get some home school experts involved because as you say 1 to 1 is very different to a classroom situation.

Dutch1e · 21/01/2021 10:39

We're non-Covid homeschoolers and I cannot fathom how Covid-homeschoolers are managing this.

From the outside it looks immensely stressful trying to replicate a 9-3 (or whatever hours) school environment at home, with no field trips or other kids to play with.

Fwiw I have a 9 year old and we've just recently started a slightly more structured approach to learning; e.g. sitting down to work on foundational maths exercises or reading as a formal part of our day rather than in a haphazard way. This structured learning is finished in about 45 - 60 minutes, sometimes spread over 2 or 3 sessions of 20 minutes each. He is either at or above the expected requirements for his age, and he's not especially bright, it just doesn't take that long when it's one-to-one.

While I fully appreciate that we're enormously privileged to be able to go with the mood of the day I honestly cannot understand why schools, parents, and kids are being forced into distance learning that seems to achieve nothing but pain.

peachdribble · 21/01/2021 09:30

It is making us all a bit miserable! I’d rather home-school by taking child out formally if this carries on much longer- just making sure he understands the concepts of things and some days submitting the bare minimum to reduce the list each day- our teachers understand that the dynamic can be very different with parents or away from the school environment

Casschops · 21/01/2021 09:24

The government and school are expecting parents to work and provide education. This wouldn't work in my house as it is to small. Im not an education provider this is a skilled professional job im a mum and a full time Occupational Therapist. I don't have the type of child who is self sufficient enough to do the work. He needs constant support due his pretty shitty start in life. Luckily he is in school. The last thing parents need right now is added pressure of court proceedings.

Nothing7 · 21/01/2021 09:09

Hey thanks for this, we’re both very reluctant to go down this last given that the hcps actually need my support and at the moment the last thing I want to do is leave them any more under pressure. Additionally where my husband works, the staff that were furloughed were sadly made redundant - not because they requested furlough - the downturn in business as a result of covid was the reason , but it’s in our minds very much so that being on furlough you can become forgotten. Neither myself or my husband can afford to be made redundant.

bemusedmoose · 21/01/2021 08:58

People can ask to be furloughed if they can't work from home and home school. Whatever job you do - if teaching your kids is stopping you from doing your job you are entitled to be put on furlough. It was on Steph's packed lunch yesterday and the official guidelines say teaching your children is reason to be furlough if it seriously impacts your ability to do your job.

Nothing7 · 21/01/2021 08:34

I haven’t read the full thread sorry but I got as far as the consequences side from the government...
I am doing what I can, this might be putting them on the online sessions but I haven’t done all of the work with the children as to be honest my mental health and capacity has not been great because of trying to balance the pressures of my job with yr 1 and 4 primary age children at home full time. I work for a medical nutrition & equipment company and I directly work with heads of service dietetics in the NHS - and last week involved trying to help alleviate some of the challenges they are facing by additional supply of feeding pumps plus I have regular calls with the trusts so in the current situation they are high priority. I have a key worker letter but my kids school want both parents to have status. Hubby works out of the home and cannot change this as he works in manufacturing.
I have been honest with the school and explained that I can only do so much. They understand the situation and have said that the kids feeling happy and safe is more important and not to put pressure on myself.

For the government to suggest there will be consequences is pretty awful, we are not super human. There are a lot of parents out there who work full time and actually the 2 days off they need to recharge and spend quality time with their children.