Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest. Have you sent your kids to school when they could have stayed at home?

557 replies

Witchcraftandhokum · 19/01/2021 17:02

I left my job in education before Christmas mostly because of the governments appalling response to Covid in schools and anti-teacher sentiment generally so I haven't really got a vested interest. But I'm curious, after speaking to my ex-colleagues and friends who work in other schools there seems to be a dramatic take-up on the offer of places for vulnerable students and children of Key-workers compared to the last lockdown.

The numbers in my old school during the last lockdown made it hardly worth opening the school, this time they're at capacity and are having to bring extra staff in at a risk to themselves. In my friend's child's class there are 21 out of 32 currently attending.

What's going on?

OP posts:
Minecraftmadness · 19/01/2021 20:52

Both mine are in.
DH and I are key workers although I actually work from home 3-4 days a week.
My eldest in secondary has an EHCP and is doing 3 days a week mostly for his sanity.
My youngest yr 5 could go in for just 2 days a week but the school is only offering full time so she has to go in all week (can’t really leave her home alone the days I’m in work). I’m a bit gutted about it to be honest as she has been doing really well at home.
KS1 in our school is rammed (KS2 a bit less) and there seem to be a lot of parents who could manage without schooling but the head is overly generous with places. Don’t know of any cases of misuse in particular though as don’t know enough about what all the parents do but I’m pretty sure 100+ out of 250 kids don’t need to be there!

mufffintopandheels · 19/01/2021 20:52

The situation is very different now to last spring.

More businesses open. Less businesses opting to furlough. More serious financial situations. Key worker list bigger. Employers less tolerant.

Not everyone is in a position to stay at home and and juggle work, learning, babies, cooking, cleaning etc etc etc. Some people might be on back to back phone calls. Or have very detailed jobs that can't have any distractions. How are they supposed to fit it all in?

A lot of people on here sound very self righteous about "doing the right thing" and keeping kids at home. Yes that's all well good if you are able to. To others, doing the right thing means having to send their kids to school so they can keep hold of their job and earn money to put food on the table, heat the house, and keep a roof over their kids head.

Not everyone's situation is the same and what is a breeze for one person could be an impossible unworkable nightmare for someone else.

lilsquish · 19/01/2021 20:51

Im not a teacher but have a number of friends who are. Numbers attending this time are way higher than the last time. (eg 10 kids in hub which was 4 schools combined, to now 20 in hub for one school only!)

i would be allowed a place for mine (nursery) but haven't as trying to do the right thing and sort childcare with OH and MIL around my shifts. However seeing the daily photos and updates with everything they are doing at nursery are making me mad as im seeing what my DC is missing out on. Sad

Dentistlakes · 19/01/2021 20:47

People who are bending the rules for their own selfish benefit know they are and do so with that fact on their conscience. When a teacher becomes ill or a child takes COVID home to a vulnerable parent, then they will have to live with the fact that they contributed to that without having to. Schools and teachers are being put in an impossible position.

Cloud1220 · 19/01/2021 20:44

I know of many employers whose staff were at home in the last lockdown, this time around have them in the office because they’ve made the office ‘Covid safe’. They’re less flexible with childcare. Not using furlough. So the employees have little choice if they want to be able to do/keep their jobs than to send their children in!

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 19/01/2021 20:42

DH and I are both key workers working from home. 2/3 of our kids are at home, the little one is in school. I suppose that technically he could be at home, but he'd be getting no education whatsoever.

Je551ca · 19/01/2021 20:41

@Iknowwhatudidlastsummer

Pretty much every child needs to be at school

and every working parent needs them to be at school

and every parent, working or not, needs some space and a bit of free time from the kids.

Again, what happens if we ALL claim our places?

Then many will end up on a waiting list and be disappointed. But if someone is offered a place and all of those needs are met, others should not judge. My child goes to school three days a week. It is best for him and me in many ways. Yes he could stay home but it wouldn’t be what’s best for our family. If everyone makes the same decision, do what’s best for your own family, and the result is that his place is no longer available, I will deal with it. All any of us can do is what we feel is right for our own. And that makes us good parents despite the judgment of others
giggly · 19/01/2021 20:41

Slip of the finger, as I was about to say as a nurse I’d love to leave my job because I am unhappy with my pay and conditions and that’s even before the impact of COVID on both myself and my colleagues. Funny that the teachers are up in arms now!

Dentistlakes · 19/01/2021 20:40

@Iknowwhatudidlastsummer

Pretty much every child needs to be at school

and every working parent needs them to be at school

and every parent, working or not, needs some space and a bit of free time from the kids.

Again, what happens if we ALL claim our places?

Exactly. All these special cases who think their need is more than everyone else’s.

Key worker/vulnerable child provision is for those who have no choice. Not a ‘nice to have’ option. If you are sending your kids in when you really don’t have to then you are part of the problem.

Iknowwhatudidlastsummer · 19/01/2021 20:39

The CF can only abuse the system thanks to parents who do not... instead of insulting them, at least accept them. If everybody who could vaguely pretend for a spot was using it, either the school would basically reopen (with the constant schools temporary closures for lack of staff, and entire year groups repeatedly sent in isolation)

or the rules would have to get much stricter and most of the CF would lose their spot.

Hope4theBestPlan4theWorst · 19/01/2021 20:39

I'm sure I read somewhere that the "keyworker" list had increased from the first lockdown
Not sure how or why as what was essential then is essential now

However there are people in very difficult situations

I know someone who works Monday to Friday at a clothing retailer 10-2 term time only and because they are open to click and collect she's expected to work and she's a single parent.....

She contacted the school who've given her a place because she literally has no option but to be honest people can Order online for home delivery - I'm sure clothing retailers do not need to physically be open as such or at least not requiring all staff

Dentistlakes · 19/01/2021 20:38

No, I haven’t and wouldn’t. Technically we probably could, but as I work from home (always have), I couldn’t drop my kids off each morning with a clear conscience. It’s a complete nightmare and I’m having to work silly hours to keep up, but it matters more to me that I do the right thing.

People who take the piss will be remembered by those around them and rightly so.

giggly · 19/01/2021 20:38

@Witchcraftandhokum for a start YABU to ask the question if you are in such a fortunate position to leave employment simply because you were unhappy. If only that option was ava
Therefore

Iknowwhatudidlastsummer · 19/01/2021 20:37

Pretty much every child needs to be at school

and every working parent needs them to be at school

and every parent, working or not, needs some space and a bit of free time from the kids.

Again, what happens if we ALL claim our places?

Wontdothisagain · 19/01/2021 20:36

Oh yay, another one of these threads.

Some of you really are incapable of thinking outside of your own tiny, sad, pathetic little worlds aren't you?

There are many, many people whose jobs are on the governments key worker list who last time will have themselves or their partner been on furlough, or who were wfh and now aren't, or who were able to use family last time and now can't, because they themselves are back at work, or have run out of goodwill. There will also be people who kept vulnerable or children with additional needs home and now can't. There will be people who have lost jobs and have taken on other roles.

This situation has now been going on for almost a year, families will be desperately trying to stay afloat, keep their incomes, salvage what's left of their mental health.

I know on mumsnet we as parent should all give up our jobs, live in a tent and eat leaves to keep everyone safe. In reality, nobody is going to do that.

So bore off.

Je551ca · 19/01/2021 20:35

Depends what you mean by “need” to

m0therofdragons · 19/01/2021 20:34

First time we actually had very free cases so although dh and I are critical workers, dh juggled homeschooling. We also thought dc might die and couldn’t live with the guilt. This time there’s actually cases and we’re using the escalation plans we never needed in the first wave so work is busier and dh’s role less predictable as to whether he’s be able to care for dc. Dh is also unwell and on a course of treatment so looking at our new position with the risk of dc dying very low we’ve reassessed - like every other critical worker I know.

I do ensure we follow all the rules to protect teachers as much as possible. So far no pupils have tested positive but 6 teachers from the staff room sharing food. That’s not my dc fault but highlights an issue that the school’s risk assessment is more picking up.

Iknowwhatudidlastsummer · 19/01/2021 20:34

[quote Goatscheesewithhoney]@Iknowwhatudidlastsummer - LOADS of key workers jobs are similar to mine, honestly, it must be a lovely, sheltered world to be in where you believe that kind of work is unusual Sad[/quote]
fine, but LOADS of "key worker" jobs are similar to mine. At a push, i could claim a key worker place. It would be a push and I would be a CF. Many parents are as far from critical worker as I am and taking places they don't have a right to.

If we all do that, what's the point of closing the schools at all?

It's just a bit of a problem when critical workers end up being sent home because of the abuse.

sleepyhead1980 · 19/01/2021 20:34

I'm the other way round - put them in last lockdown but keeping them home now. Mainly due to the fact that informal childcare is permitted this time when it wasn't last time. And also I updated our processes at work to allow remote work when we didn't have those in place previously

Tentacles14 · 19/01/2021 20:33

So yes DD is going in when I could have her at home. But everyone will have their reasons.
Not sure I understand those working in schools to be saying they’d prefer to be at home home schooling their child. Would they not be teaching remotely during normal hours - we are still expected to do our job in normal hours. My DD has to fit around my job not the reverse sadly.

Skatastic · 19/01/2021 20:32

Nope and I am a keyworker but I am managing DS10 at home. Just.

Spied · 19/01/2021 20:32

My dc are in school. I am support staff in another school.
Dropping my dc at school on a morning feels like the walk of shame.

Tentacles14 · 19/01/2021 20:31

My DD is in - she does not have an echp but has a diagnosis that makes remote learning harder to connect with. Our school has chosen to only send support staff in, with teachers teaching remotely from home. It’s an independent school so I think that is driven by the aim to deliver the same to all - as support staff have the same risks of catching it as teachers would do if they were in. I could have my DD at home (DH is a key worker, I am not but work full time). But I cannot do my job full time and keep my sanity with home schooling my DD and the fees remain at full price. My work have offered reducing hours but we cannot afford the pay cut (DH got zero financial help from the chancellor as he earned over 50k). My work will not flexi furlough as the gov publish names of those who do so. But I can’t afford to bear the burden of the cut alone - we used our savings to survive in the last lockdown. So in she goes.

Society’s complete acceptance of the fact some sectors of society have had zero help for a year (including new self employed and those earning £50,001) bring consequences. So many furloughed that we knew were not worked up about the inequality of treatment. Yet that inequality of treatment is now driving my need to send my DD in. Every decision (including not to protest or say something is unfair) has a consequence I guess.

TakeMe2Insanity · 19/01/2021 20:30

DH works in an institution which the government describes his work as a key worker. His work gave him a letter at the start of the first lockdown stating he was, as such our child could get a place at school. DH has been wfh since January 2020! So that’s a year. No we have not taken up the place as we don’t believe it is safe, however it has been easier for us to do so as I don’t work. I do believe it is harder for some parents as both parents are working.

Goatscheesewithhoney · 19/01/2021 20:27

@Iknowwhatudidlastsummer - LOADS of key workers jobs are similar to mine, honestly, it must be a lovely, sheltered world to be in where you believe that kind of work is unusual Sad