Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest. Have you sent your kids to school when they could have stayed at home?

557 replies

Witchcraftandhokum · 19/01/2021 17:02

I left my job in education before Christmas mostly because of the governments appalling response to Covid in schools and anti-teacher sentiment generally so I haven't really got a vested interest. But I'm curious, after speaking to my ex-colleagues and friends who work in other schools there seems to be a dramatic take-up on the offer of places for vulnerable students and children of Key-workers compared to the last lockdown.

The numbers in my old school during the last lockdown made it hardly worth opening the school, this time they're at capacity and are having to bring extra staff in at a risk to themselves. In my friend's child's class there are 21 out of 32 currently attending.

What's going on?

OP posts:
Snaketime · 19/01/2021 21:23

Yes. I am a key worker, but my husband is furloughed. My DD is currently in the process of being diagnosed with ADHD, she doesn't do well with remote learning and I emailed the school and told them that and explained about the home situation and they told me she could go to school and they would see her in the morning, so I sent her.

Jolie12345 · 19/01/2021 21:22

@ZenNudist

I have.

I haven't really. I'm not allowed. If I was allowed id have mine in like a shot.

Grin
Useruseruserusee · 19/01/2021 21:21

No. We are two key workers here and our children are at home.

DH only works three days a week but teaches live from home all day. I work full time but can complete some of work at the evening and weekends so I have shifted my working pattern.

We live in an area that was at the top of the list for infection rates over Christmas.

Boulshired · 19/01/2021 21:19

The last time furlough seemed a great idea this time furlough for many is seen as volunteering for redundancy. 90% of the furlough workers never came back in DPs firm. People this time want to keep their jobs and many are scared that any lack of performance will put them closer to the door. Even private firms who are doing well are making the most of streamlining their staff. I can see many in the private sector having to make different decisions this time. When it’s over people will not care who is being repossessed or evicted as they never do.

ZenNudist · 19/01/2021 21:17

I have.

I haven't really. I'm not allowed. If I was allowed id have mine in like a shot.

CurlyS · 19/01/2021 21:17

I'm sure people on here would say we are being unreasonable in our situation.

Both of my step children's parents work outside of the home, key worker. I'm at home, I'm not working but I'm days from giving birth so they are in school based on their parents meeting the criteria for a space 🤷

GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas · 19/01/2021 21:16

Would love to hear from anyone who has forced their employer to give furlough on basis of childcare needs (which I understand is something you can request)

OwlBeThere · 19/01/2021 21:15

2 of my children could have stayed home but are in school on the recommendation of their teachers, I didn’t ask.

Jolie12345 · 19/01/2021 21:14

If the government weren’t being so forceful about the mandatory work then there would be less kids in school. But that’s a whole other thread. Literally

Tentacles14 · 19/01/2021 21:10

Sorry that should say not allowing me to access flexi furlough

Angel2702 · 19/01/2021 21:10

No my son has EHCP and they are pressuring him to go in but we are keeping him home as long as possible.

Tentacles14 · 19/01/2021 21:09

I am not sure why ‘doing the right thing’ is exclusively an obligation on working parents though.
The government did not ‘do the right thing’ when they carved my DH out from getting any financial support.
My employers are not ‘doing the right thing’ by allowing me to access flexi furlough (but will reduce my hours so I bear the financial hit).
My DD’s school governors are not ‘doing the right thing’ by charging full fees for a service that is not the same.
But I am expected to, despite it being to the detriment of my family. When all of the above will not as it will bring detriment to mine.
The burden is not being shared equally here. And sadly since the first lockdown it’s too great a burden for me alone.

Jolie12345 · 19/01/2021 21:08

@Dentistlakes

It doesn’t matter how careful you are out of school. Each child attending increases the risk. Not just the risk to teachers, but to genuine key workers who need to be working and not ill. Honestly, why do people think that schools have been closed to what should be the majority of children? Lots of working parents are homeschooling under huge stress. Yes, people should do the right thing, but I suspect lots won’t because they simply don’t care. It’s not about doing what’s best for you. It’s about doing what’s best for everyone.
It’s not that people don’t care. That’s a huge assumption. I care deeply, I want this to be over. As many have said you won’t know individual circumstances and reasons for accepting school places. You may think you do and that’s fine. I don’t care what people think of me. Genuinely fair play for those of you doing it all but for those that can’t take the help that’s offered.
QAplomb · 19/01/2021 21:07

Yes.

Dentistlakes · 19/01/2021 21:05

@TheDailyCarbunkle

How very dare anyone expect their children to go to school! The utter cheek of it! Next they'll be expecting jobs and food. Bloody ridiculous.

All children should be hiding at home, with no contact with other humans whatsoever. No child needs to leave their house. What is the world coming to when people expect a life beyond a basic existence for their child?? It's just plain grabby.

We all want our children in school. We should also all understand why that isn’t the case at the moment and why only those who really need to be there should be attending. Surely people have got it by now?
GibbertyFlibbet · 19/01/2021 21:04

It absolutely does my head in though that this has boiled down to a set up where some people get to choose “what is best for me and my family” based on what their job is.

KW provision should be to enable someone to do their job because they would not be able to work without it. That’s it.

This thread gives me comfort that we’re not the only KW keeping DC home despite the costs to us all.

Of course there are families where there’s no choice but for children to be in school, for lots of the reasons highlighted on this thread. And that’s fine, and that’s why it’s right that schools have to be open.

But there are lots of others, including plenty I know in real life in situations more or less identical to ours, who are sending kids in because they can. They then get to do their work in peace and within reasonable hours, not having to homeschool or make sure kids get exercise and human contact, having weekends and evenings for family time and housework and who then on top of all those massive benefits want me to agree that they’re doing the right thing because the juggle which is grinding me and my family into the ground somehow wasn’t an option for them.

Wontdothisagain · 19/01/2021 21:04

@BeanCalledPickle too bloody right, the truth is none of these nosey parkers on here know the truth about each persons circumstances.

They just adore having something to tut at and moan about, it makes them feel better about themselves, that they are more righteous.

Jolie12345 · 19/01/2021 21:04

[quote Thatusernamewastaken]@Je551ca
“ All any of us can do is what we feel is right for our own.”
Except maybe during, idk, a pandemic?[/quote]
Nope. I’m still looking after my own first I’m afraid. I’m not putting others at risk anymore that I need to. If everyone looked after their own and themselves it wouldn’t be spreading the way it is. Think about it

TheDailyCarbunkle · 19/01/2021 21:01

How very dare anyone expect their children to go to school! The utter cheek of it! Next they'll be expecting jobs and food. Bloody ridiculous.

All children should be hiding at home, with no contact with other humans whatsoever. No child needs to leave their house. What is the world coming to when people expect a life beyond a basic existence for their child?? It's just plain grabby.

Dentistlakes · 19/01/2021 21:01

It doesn’t matter how careful you are out of school. Each child attending increases the risk. Not just the risk to teachers, but to genuine key workers who need to be working and not ill. Honestly, why do people think that schools have been closed to what should be the majority of children? Lots of working parents are homeschooling under huge stress. Yes, people should do the right thing, but I suspect lots won’t because they simply don’t care. It’s not about doing what’s best for you. It’s about doing what’s best for everyone.

Thatusernamewastaken · 19/01/2021 21:00

@Je551ca
“ All any of us can do is what we feel is right for our own.”
Except maybe during, idk, a pandemic?

BeanCalledPickle · 19/01/2021 20:59

Mine, year one and year three, are at school. I am wfh in a central government Covid response role. DH also at home in non key role. I have no doubt whatsoever people think I’m taking the piss. What they don’t know is that the eldest has SN which mean that, when removed from routine, she becomes violent and aggressive to her sister placing her at risk. She can’t engage with home learning at all. The school actively encouraged me to send her. They extended the invitation to her sister as well. They have adopted a ceiling of 25pc per year and are not full.

My first point is that we simply do not know the circumstances of people with children at school. Because it is not our business. A fellow parent is having chemo, again not widely known, and an invitation was extended to her as well.

It is all well and good judging but ultimately the school has satisfied itself as to entitlement or vulnerability, exercised discretion if appropriate and that is that.

It’s not really the point but ultimately children will be back in school before the masses are vaccinated. They will never themselves be vaccinated. At some point we will unlock society and accept that people will get ill and die, much like we accept 10,000 flu deaths a year without outcry. So on that basis it will never truly be safe. Vaccines will not be 100pc effective. Not everyone will have a vaccine. I mention this not to somehow justify my decision to send them to school. I’m very comfortable with that. Rather to see it as context to any wider debate about the relative risks of school attendance going forward.

Wontdothisagain · 19/01/2021 20:59

Doing the right thing by whom exactly?

Also how far exactly do you take 'could have stayed at home'

I mean I'm on the KW lost, can't wfh, but I suppose I could insist that I take parental leave. I wouldn't get paid and I'd be letting down my employer at what is a crucial time.. I suppose I could leave my job and we could survive on Dhs salary until the pandemic is over.

To some on here I'm probably taking the piss.

Rosebel · 19/01/2021 20:56

Sometimes things change. Last time schools were mostly closed I kept my children at home because I was on maternity leave but this time I'm back at work (both of us are key workers) so they've gone to school.
I know it's not exactly what you asked but just suggesting one reason why some parents might have sent their children back.
Talking to a friend though she reckons lots of parents are sending in their children when they don't have to due to fear. Fear that the schools will be closed for months again and they can't work, or look after toddlers and home school for that long.

Jolie12345 · 19/01/2021 20:54

@Dentistlakes

People who are bending the rules for their own selfish benefit know they are and do so with that fact on their conscience. When a teacher becomes ill or a child takes COVID home to a vulnerable parent, then they will have to live with the fact that they contributed to that without having to. Schools and teachers are being put in an impossible position.
Sending a child to school doesn’t mean they aren’t being extremely careful outside of school.
Swipe left for the next trending thread