Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest. Have you sent your kids to school when they could have stayed at home?

557 replies

Witchcraftandhokum · 19/01/2021 17:02

I left my job in education before Christmas mostly because of the governments appalling response to Covid in schools and anti-teacher sentiment generally so I haven't really got a vested interest. But I'm curious, after speaking to my ex-colleagues and friends who work in other schools there seems to be a dramatic take-up on the offer of places for vulnerable students and children of Key-workers compared to the last lockdown.

The numbers in my old school during the last lockdown made it hardly worth opening the school, this time they're at capacity and are having to bring extra staff in at a risk to themselves. In my friend's child's class there are 21 out of 32 currently attending.

What's going on?

OP posts:
Teacherontherun · 19/01/2021 23:22

Ridiculous but I have because I am a teacher. We have to do our full timetable of live lessons plus a lunchtime tutorial, so no way I can also supervise my own kids. Makes me so mad that by looking after other kids, my kids have to either be left unsupervised and unable to work or go to school

Noneedtocry · 19/01/2021 23:16

@GibbertyFlibbet

It absolutely does my head in though that this has boiled down to a set up where some people get to choose “what is best for me and my family” based on what their job is.

KW provision should be to enable someone to do their job because they would not be able to work without it. That’s it.

This thread gives me comfort that we’re not the only KW keeping DC home despite the costs to us all.

Of course there are families where there’s no choice but for children to be in school, for lots of the reasons highlighted on this thread. And that’s fine, and that’s why it’s right that schools have to be open.

But there are lots of others, including plenty I know in real life in situations more or less identical to ours, who are sending kids in because they can. They then get to do their work in peace and within reasonable hours, not having to homeschool or make sure kids get exercise and human contact, having weekends and evenings for family time and housework and who then on top of all those massive benefits want me to agree that they’re doing the right thing because the juggle which is grinding me and my family into the ground somehow wasn’t an option for them.

This absolutely...

Anyone who replies to this with: I could keep my kids at home but...
They would get a worse education
They would sit in front if screens for 10 hours
I wouldn't have time to get my work done
They wouldn't get to see their friends
They would be isolated and depressed

This is exactly what everyone without the KW places is dealing with and every CF taking the piss is just prolonging it for everyone who is doing the right thing.

trilbydoll · 19/01/2021 23:05

@GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas my DH works 6am-10am and then 2pm onwards and homeschools in the middle, if that cheers you up at all.

I am sick of reading about how the burden of all this falls disproportionately on women but no-one ever says it's because useless men allow that to happen.

I work for an aerospace company, I think I'm critical if you are very generous with the definition. But I'd be so embarrassed to ask for a school place, they know full well I'm a part time accountant Grin

FlyingPandas · 19/01/2021 22:58

@Greenygrape of course it’s never 100% cut and dried. I’m just saying that fundamentally as a society we are conditioned to do what we feel is best for us as an individual - and as a family. And so in a large, large number of cases, that transpires to doing what is going to make our lives easier as an individual or family, whatever that may be.

Including, in many cases, taking up a school keyworker place when only one parent is a keyworker but the other works from home (or is a SAHM, or whatever). It’s selfish. But no more selfish than anything else, as you say.

Arguably, of course, the ‘selfish’ definition also includes those who ate out to help out and those who went to the playground and those who went Christmas shopping and those who had parties and those who just had granny over on Christmas Day because they couldn’t bear the idea of her being on her own and you could go on and on and on forever.

We are human beings, we are all fundamentally selfish. The entirety of society is selfish. Which is why there are so many kids in schools now, and why lockdown will never work properly, and why there are so many people breaking rules in a thousand tiny ways all over the place: we all want to take care of number one before we think about everyone else.

Justgorgeous · 19/01/2021 22:58

My son is Year 11 and has an EHCP and yes he’s in, it’s a secondary school with 20 kids in at the moment.

Dontjudgetoofast · 19/01/2021 22:57

My child is in school while I am at work because his Dad has completely unravelled after losing his job in lockdown. I am sure everyone is judging us, because on the surface there is a parent at home, but the simple fact is that his Dad gets really angry about everything from Boris Johnson to the way they do long division, and can’t cope with even accessing the online learning apps without having a shouty meltdown.

I can happily go to work though, knowing my child is safe at school with kind rational normal adults who will encourage him to engage with the curriculum, rather than swearing about the government and turning off Google classroom to watch conspiracy videos on YouTube. You might think I am ‘taking advantage’ or careless of the covid risk but, having weighed everything up, I know I would be letting my child down if I left him at home.

I am beyond grateful that the school gave my child a place, without even having to explain all this to them.

ThisMammaCat · 19/01/2021 22:57

Our kids are at home. Granted, 2 are home schooled anyway, but I hated every second of having to send my oldest in after the first lockdown, but we had to (on pains of a fine). I'm glad the school is closed again. My oldest, for that time, was the only risk factor in our family- we work from home, get food deliveries, or shop local with social distancing, and having to send him in REALLY got to me, especially as my partner is clinically vulnerable. I'm dreading the inevitable point where we are once again ordered by that psycho government to send kids back to school before the danger has passed.

Greenygrape · 19/01/2021 22:42

@FlyingPandas it's not so simple though. There was never a covid case in our school. We've worked from home for a year, followed the rules and given up a lot. So to suggest sending our kids in for a keyworker place is a sign of how selfish we are is hurtful and untrue.

Likewise, my neighbour next door who has a cleaner, nanny and parent popping in or taking the kids away through the week and husband not working from home one day as a construction manager (surely there's some paperwork?!) Not to mention the lockdown parties..is less selfish because their daughter isn't in school.

ALL parents and children are giving up a great deal, whether in school or not. At the same time we're least likely to be in hospital, least likely to die and depending on which scientist you refer to young primary age children are least likely to spread the virus.

People were stuffing their faces with eat out to help out before playgrounds were unlocked. I don't think parents have been less selfish than everyone else.

FlyingPandas · 19/01/2021 22:30

I could have done but haven’t. I’m a KW but DH works from home. We just couldn’t justify it.

I’m amazed, though, at how many kids are in (both in my kids’ school and in the school where I work). I think it’s partly because so many parents and kids found lockdown learning so hard last time.

But also I think it is because, as a society, we’re just so conditioned to take care of ourselves and our families first and foremost.

So most people are going ‘yay, I can technically have a key worker space, it’ll make my child’s/my life easier, I’ll take it!’

And not ‘actually, I could technically have a key worker space, but the right thing to do for society overall is for me to keep DC at home.’

People seem to have, as a general rule, a mentality like @JackyReacher. The ‘I’m entitled to it so I’ll take it’ attitude. Arguably, no parent should be sending a child to school unless they are definitively vulnerable (SEN, ECHP etc) or if both parents are KW. But most people seem to just be thinking of themselves and their DC. Not the wider issue. You can see the responses all over MN - all sorts of excuses about why THEIR situation, THEIR family, THEIR child is different and therefore deserving - but very often their reasons boil down to ‘It makes our lives easier.’

AllTheWayFromLondonDAMN · 19/01/2021 22:26

Yes, for two days a week. We are both teachers and juggled it last time, but at quite a cost to our and their mental health. This time around both DH are in school one day a week and even though when the other is in, the other is at home we have sent our two in because we need the space to work and they need to be mixing with other kids. My youngest in particular missed six months last time (other one was in one of the year groups that went back for a couple of days a week) and really suffered.

That said I’m a governor at the school and therefore am privy to the numbers and an analysis of what kids are in when and why and we are only operating at just under 10% capacity so I don’t think our two going in two days is causing undue stress on the system. If we were at capacity or extra staff were having to be brought in I wouldn’t want them to be taking the spaces another family needed.... but I’m sure that I’ll be told I’m unreasonable by someone on here because me and DH are anything less than full-time doctors on a Covid ward.

Glitterinthegrey · 19/01/2021 22:26

DH and I are both critical workers. I'm a shift worker, he works office ish hours. He can't work from home, I can but my employer is rotating us back into the office, and if someone who's meant to be in goes sick, I can get called in at a moment's notice.

My youngest DD (10) is going to school but only the days that I work all day. I can't do my job and homeschool at the same time (safeguarding), and may physically not be here, so feel it's the best option for her. I do have an older DD but she's doing live lessons all day so couldn't watch her sister too.

I feel endlessly guilty about it though.

scrivette · 19/01/2021 22:22

Well the DC are in school full time (DH and I both keyworkers) but I work part time.

The school have asked that they attend full time due to continuity, however there are more pupils this time compared to last time so I wonder if that will change soon.

FuckOffBorisYouTwat · 19/01/2021 22:21

Sorry except when working longshifts

FuckOffBorisYouTwat · 19/01/2021 22:21

Both keyworkers (frontline NHS for the main) but keeping the teens off all the time and ten year old off if working long shifts

Titsywoo · 19/01/2021 22:19

@Mum45678

Yes. I sent both mine in for a few days a week. I'm a single parent, work full time and technically a key worker. I work in a demanding job that can be done from home but requires lots of concentration and focus.

I had them home for all of the last lockdown but I almost had a nervous breakdown trying to keep all the plates spinning. The eldest is on the SEN register and she has been referred for ADHD. I have to monitor everything she does or she will not do any work.

I am eternally grateful for the teachers and TAs who are supporting them in school. I refuse to feel guilty. I'm really tired of people judging others when you have no idea why they have or haven't sent their kids to school.

As much as I appreciate your position many of us are not "technically a key worker" and have full time jobs, kids with SEN and are near nervous breakdowns. We don't get the choice though so I think it is understandable when people get upset.
ShopoholicIn · 19/01/2021 22:18

Nope. But I know people who were upset that some others were, and finally have now started sending there kids to school.

LG1000 · 19/01/2021 22:16

Almost did, but so far haven't. I can be at home with kids, but husband and I could stretch the 'critical' criteria to request a place if necessary.

The remote learning provision was so poor during the last lock down, that it seemed a school place was the only option if we were to prevent our kids from wasting another 5 months. I made this point to the school when they complianed about the number of children in. Thankfully, they are making the effort to provide a little more than twinkl worksheets this time around.

I am sure this is a factor for many parents.

carolinesbaby · 19/01/2021 22:14

I don’t get it either, especially with the new strains. You’d expect numbers to be really low especially with the message to keep home.

It's because people need to earn a living.

Employers won't furlough key workers. So they have to work or not get paid.

ElfAndSafetyInspector · 19/01/2021 22:10

Be honest. Have you sent your kids to school when they could have stayed at home?

No, the exact opposite.

I kept her at home last lockdown when I could have sent her to school.

That was feasible (if extremely difficult) short term, but not feasible long term, so she is now taking the place to which she has been entitled throughout.

QueenofLouisiana · 19/01/2021 22:09

No. He’s at home. I’m online teaching, DH is online teaching. Our rota days in school don’t clash.

I’m teaching a child in school who’s sibling is at home. So that child is mixing with half a class, while the sibling is safely at home having time with mum! We’re expecting to have to open in half term, no doubt that child will be in then too.

MissMarpleDarling · 19/01/2021 22:08

I left mine home alone when I could have sent him in so I'd say YABU.

Treemama · 19/01/2021 22:07

Nope. Dh and I are both key workers but we work different hours so he stays at home homeschooling our dd and ds, plus minding our 1 year old and then I finish at 3.30pm and he goes to work soon after. I managed to get a day off during the week, plus 1 day working from home so I can help with homeschooling. It's a lot of juggling but safer for everyone.

Ohdofuckofdear · 19/01/2021 22:06

Sorry I should have added that our DD is autistic and disabled so she has been offered a place at school every day but we've not used it apart from the one day that is a family emergency.

Greenygrape · 19/01/2021 22:05

Well it depends. The kids could be at home but having them sit infront of the TV for 10 hours a day whilst we work isn't great.

Many of us were failed last year, we believed keeping the kids home would mean back in school quicker but it was 6 months and then unions still wanted schools closed. We saw the impact on ourselves, relationships, jobs and kids. We saw stay at home parents with a key worker partner send their kids because the criteria the school made up was rubbish. Once bitten twice shy, plus most parents are working.

Wibblewobble99 · 19/01/2021 22:05

Slightly different for us as DC is at nursery. In the last lockdown I worked from home all surveys were cancelled and looked after DC. It was a nightmare but we did it. husband continued to worm as normal as he’s a KW.

This time I am still working on site and have been told it’s ‘business as usual’. There are too many loopholes left by Boris’s announcement particularly relating to my work field in construction and they’re quite frankly being exploited. This time we have no choice but to send DC to nursery, putting the nursery staff at risk. Between my husband and I we probably see between 30-50 different people a week, be them colleagues, tenants, contractors etc. We take all the precautions we can but it’s never going to be foolproof. I’m hopping mad as you can probably tell!!!