Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a CMS one

91 replies

2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 13:04

Received my annual review from CMS today. Fantastic need!

Payments have been put down to £5 per week for 3 children, down from £25! This is after the csa have already quashed it debt of £15,000.

Why are they allowed to just walk away from the responsibility of providing for their children? Why are they allowed to continue to have more kids, leaving the ones they already have in utter poverty?

Why are they allowed to cook the books when they a self employed? He's driving around in a brand new car, always dressed in the latest clothes, holidays etc.. total dick.

Now I'll have to start working more double shifts to make up the shortfall, meaning my kids suffer even more.

Just ranting, I'm sure I'll get over it

OP posts:
Idratherberude · 19/01/2021 15:25

You're a better woman than I. I'd have shouted at him in front of the kids, or maybe murdered him for some real satisfaction.

2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 15:22

If he's skint, he's skint. Fair enough, I can't take what he doesn't have but the fact is I know he's not skint.

£25 a week, that's all I ask

OP posts:
HoppingOnSteppingStones · 19/01/2021 15:19

Apply for a variation. Get as much info as you can on his business.

It infuriates me when exes do that
My ex tried. When ds started seniors I asked for it to be raised as hadn't changed for 10 yrs. He offered 10 a month... Or told me to go to cms and fuck myself.
I went to cms.. It went up by 170 a month.
And each Yr it has risen because of his earnings
He also has just gone self employed. So I shall see what next year brings non the renewal.

Dhs ex was the opposite. He offered her x amount. She said no wanted it to be legal. And insisted on it being cms and only that figure.
Which was half of what he offered.
He then transferred her money for uniform. Dance class and various other things on tip and she transfers it back. Every time.
But then says to their dd. I struggle on the bit your dad gives me, which is why I work FT!
We didn't discuss with his DD. As she's only 8 but when she's old enough I'm sure she'll realise. She just likes to paint dh in a bad way. It's annoying but we know he does right. Even before he brought her uniform and shoes. Sent it back. Then 6 months later she returned it. Still with tags on and said it now didn't fit! It did when we brought it. It hadnt been bloody worn but then was too late to exchange or return.

2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 15:07

@PumpkinWitch I am sorry, it's rubbish isn't it? I don't think they grasp that it's the kids that suffer the most.

OP posts:
2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 15:06

@GlitterToast my exdp doesn't have any set days, sometimes he can see them once a week, other times he can go for weeks without seeing them. He FaceTimes them every day without fail though.

OP posts:
2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 15:05

@dontdisturbmenow I have no idea about his business to be honest. I know that he has been working throughout lockdown.

His car is bought, he told me so himself.

I'm not expecting loads, the £25 per week was a struggle but we managed

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 19/01/2021 14:42

@Coseynightin

Id wager more NRP would pay more if they knew the money was being spent on the children instead of being thrown into the RP household pot.

50/50 should be the default and then this does not happen.

I bet when together though also you benefited from his self employed status.

I'd wager you are either a bitter NRP or a bitter second wife. Either way, you're talking bullshit.

Most men I know don't even want 50/50 because they can't possibly work and have the children half the week too. Even though women manage it.

PumpkinWitch · 19/01/2021 14:41

[quote 2020canfuckitself]@Dogscanteatonions my ex is a self employed tradesmen. He's minted! But everything is in his girlfriends name, he's not daft is he Confused[/quote]
I hope his girlfriend leaves him and takes all his assets with her. 🤣

I don’t get any child support from my ex so I feel your pain.

unmarkedbythat · 19/01/2021 14:39

Id wager more NRP would pay more if they knew the money was being spent on the children instead of being thrown into the RP household pot.

What, the household that the children are a part of? Daft.

dontdisturbmenow · 19/01/2021 14:36

He's minted! But everything is in his girlfriends name, he's not daft is he confused
He is daft to put everything in the name if a girlfriend who could walk away tomorrow with it all.

Are you sure his business hasn't suffered significantly? The car could just be in lease and be hers.

My ex be we paid a penny in maintenance. Very frustrating at the time but ultimately, the kids became young adults and saw him for who he is.

GlitterToast · 19/01/2021 14:35

The CMS are a joke both ways.

My partner has his son 60% of the time. He pays for all is his son's clothes, hobbies, school trips, everything, Yet according to the CMS, my partner owes his ex money? It's bonkers!

omg35 · 19/01/2021 14:25

I'm sorry lovely. Keep claiming the £5. It's a pittance and insulting but he has to pay something. Also write to your MP. It's very unlikely they can do anything but you never know

Icanflyhigh · 19/01/2021 14:18

@coseynightin you need to get over yourself and learn about the real world love.
I never fail to be astounded by some of the shite I read on here.

Schoolhouse123 · 19/01/2021 14:17

I feel for you (unfortunately due to how this government chooses to run the cms system you are not alone).
I've found the best way to deal with it for me is have a wallow, sort out my practical finances and get on with it because otherwise it'll only make myself ill.
My ex has not payed cms since dc1 was 18 months (now 16). He gave up his job (after years of moving jobs constantly /taking cash in hand), went on to have several dc and for the last few years has been working in a supermarket. Cms wrote off the past debts. Ex has not had contact either and crosses the road when he sees dc.
I try to concentrate on the fact that dc are brilliant human beings whom have a better work ethic and morals than ex has and ex will never be able to hold his head up.
Keep positive and know your doing your best.

Icanflyhigh · 19/01/2021 14:16

@2020canfuckitself I am in a similar position to you.
ExH is self-employed, nothing in his name, clever bastard that he thinks he is, and he pays the absolute bare minimum he can get away with.

As the DC get older they are realising this and the only saving grace is that they now know what the situation is and how far their sperm donor will go to see them not provided for by him.

They also know that I will bend over backwards with DP to make sure that they have everything they need, so although it doesn't make it any easier on me financially, they know he is shirking his responsibility to them.

2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 14:04

@cheeseismydownfall I completely agree. When he lived here we had just a normal life. Kids had what they needed and bills were paid. Then I ended things and he became bitter.

I don't want his money for me, I just want my kids to have a decent quality of life that's all. I'm now panicking about how I'm going to afford my council tax this month because I'm down £80 per month

OP posts:
2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 14:01

@Collaborate I've pestered the CMS for months about this. They're useless!

OP posts:
SpaceRaiders · 19/01/2021 13:58

The most frustrating thing about CMS is that the onus is on the RP to prove that the NRP is earning more than they say they are. Which is virtually impossible, unless you’re able to afford a private financial investigator. And even then you’d probably only get an extra few pounds a month.

The way I’ve dealt with it is ignoring it. Yes, he should be paying more. He’s self employed and most certainly fiddles his books. Yes, it’s not fair and dc deserve far more support from him both financially and emotionally. But what I’ve found he’s been more willing to support dc, when he’s seen that I manage very well without him and we actually don’t need his money. Dc don’t go without and I’ve made huge sacrifices to make sure that will never happen. If he pays great. If he doesn’t that’s fine too. I will out earn him within 4 years, best form of revenge imo!

Collaborate · 19/01/2021 13:57

If he's diverting his income to the girlfriend and you have evidence of that you must apply to CMS for a variation. It's one of the grounds.

cheeseismydownfall · 19/01/2021 13:51

It is absolutely disgraceful. I cannot understand how any man (or woman) could look themselves in the mirror for providing five fucking quid a week for their three children. I think there are two separate issues that urgently need to be addressed:

  1. the apparent ease with which a parent can use their self employed status to minimise their CMS payments

  2. the idea that a NRP with low/no employment can just shrug their shoulders and say they can't afford to pay. The resident parent has no fucking choice but to do everything, anything to feed, clothe and house their children. They don't get to opt out just because it is hard.

It should be a national fucking scandal. But because the majority of those disadvantaged are women and children, it is just allowed to happen.

safariboot · 19/01/2021 13:39

It's fraud by the father and should be treated as such. If the government can have people to snoop on alleged benefits cheats, they should be able to have people to snoop on child support cheats. Lifestyle incompatible with declared income should prompt a serious investigation.

I wouldn't have much faith in the American approach though. The system there is a reincarnation of the debtors prisons of Victorian England. It's the can't pay, far more than the won't pay, who get jailed without any lawyer to defend them.

Soubriquet · 19/01/2021 13:32

@Coseynightin

Id wager more NRP would pay more if they knew the money was being spent on the children instead of being thrown into the RP household pot.

50/50 should be the default and then this does not happen.

I bet when together though also you benefited from his self employed status.

I’m sorry! I didn’t realise kids didn’t need a warm home or food in the bellies

Electric for their computers/televisions

Money is more than just want they want. It’s things they need like a home!

2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 13:31

My household pot is just rent, utilities and food. That's about it. I don't go anywhere, not been on holiday for years. All my money goes on my home and my children.

Everything goes into one pot.

OP posts:
2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 13:29

@Coseynightin when we were together he had a normal job, I worked full time then too. He only became a tradesmen after we split so pipe down.

OP posts:
OrigamiParrot · 19/01/2021 13:29

@Coseynightin

Id wager more NRP would pay more if they knew the money was being spent on the children instead of being thrown into the RP household pot.

50/50 should be the default and then this does not happen.

I bet when together though also you benefited from his self employed status.

I have no idea what you’re getting at here - the money goes into the household pot that funds the children’s home and lives. Which is the whole point Hmm

Sorry OP - it’s absolutely rubbish.