Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a CMS one

91 replies

2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 13:04

Received my annual review from CMS today. Fantastic need!

Payments have been put down to £5 per week for 3 children, down from £25! This is after the csa have already quashed it debt of £15,000.

Why are they allowed to just walk away from the responsibility of providing for their children? Why are they allowed to continue to have more kids, leaving the ones they already have in utter poverty?

Why are they allowed to cook the books when they a self employed? He's driving around in a brand new car, always dressed in the latest clothes, holidays etc.. total dick.

Now I'll have to start working more double shifts to make up the shortfall, meaning my kids suffer even more.

Just ranting, I'm sure I'll get over it

OP posts:
Givemeabreak88 · 19/01/2021 20:52

At least you got £25, I’ve only ever got £7 a week for my 4 kids from ex,
So £1.75 per child per week. And even then that was a fight to get

GeorgiaGirl52 · 19/01/2021 20:49

@safariboot

It's fraud by the father and should be treated as such. If the government can have people to snoop on alleged benefits cheats, they should be able to have people to snoop on child support cheats. Lifestyle incompatible with declared income should prompt a serious investigation.

I wouldn't have much faith in the American approach though. The system there is a reincarnation of the debtors prisons of Victorian England. It's the can't pay, far more than the won't pay, who get jailed without any lawyer to defend them.

I usually just let the insults about America go by - you are entitled to your opinion no matter how uninformed it might be. However -- we do get CMS (called CSS, Child Support Services) right. It is NOT "debtor's prison"! But CSS has investigators who do find out where unemployed fathers get their money for cars and rent, etc. If they use a company credit card, CSS gets copies of the charges which are considered income. If they get cash gifts from relatives or girlfriends they the gifts are income. If they claim "no money" and they have life insurance, they can be required to cash in the policy to pay child support. Yes, some men get by without paying, I am sure. But not as many as it seems from reports here.
TrulyOutrageousJem · 19/01/2021 20:47

@nancybotwinbloom

I complained and got a resolution via my MP. It was also expedited and moved through the system much quicker.
The whole system is a nightmare!

blahblahblah54321 · 19/01/2021 20:35

@2020canfuckitself

£5 a week! What can I do with £5?

I'm so angry and hurt. My kids don't deserve this

Bloody insulting isn't it
blahblahblah54321 · 19/01/2021 20:34

@Soubriquet

I think this is the only thing America has got right

That CSA is taken from the wages or they go to jail

If a resident parent left their child in dire poverty, dirty clothes, not enough food etc, that parent would be jailed

Yet the other parent can throw them £5 and they are fine to swan off and make more children

Totally bloody agree!

My ex pays most weeks, but not all. He sort of picks and chooses. November and December are sparse as he coincidently struggles to pay then presents lavish Christmas gifts Hmm

When I point it out he says what do I expect him to do? I say that maybe next year we'll not feed DS, pay for his college train fare, clothing etc, because we want to get him the biggest present..... Confused. Instead we have to manage it all, oh to have the luxury to choose to not support a child!

Knob..

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/01/2021 20:29

Dont feed the under the bridge dweller.

Cosy here you must be hungry Biscuit

nancybotwinbloom · 19/01/2021 20:24

@TrulyOutrageousJem

Your username is fab!

I loved Jem

Do you know of anyone who has complained to their MP and if it got them anywhere?

MeMarmiteYouJam · 19/01/2021 20:16

The prime minister himself doesn't even know how many children he has - you think he pays maintenance for the others? The system is rotten, from the top down. I have no hope of people suddenly waking up to the injustice and making good for women and children.

Cleverpolly3 · 19/01/2021 20:13

@Coseynightin

Id wager more NRP would pay more if they knew the money was being spent on the children instead of being thrown into the RP household pot.

50/50 should be the default and then this does not happen.

I bet when together though also you benefited from his self employed status.

At it again I see

Do you actually know the purpose of Child Maintenance?

TowandaForever · 19/01/2021 20:11

Do parents have any say in cms writing off maintenance debts?

TrulyOutrageousJem · 19/01/2021 20:07

Lodge a complaint and contact your local MP. It’s the only way to get CMS to listen.

RandomMess · 19/01/2021 20:01

If you believe he is cooking the books report to HMRC. You can also report him to CMS for lifestyle not matching his lifestyle.

2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 19:54

@HugeAckmansWife totally agree! My ex dp has 2 stepchildren and another son which brings my children's money right down anyway. The whole thing is ridiculous

OP posts:
Bleughbleughbleugh12 · 19/01/2021 19:53

@Coseynightin and let me guess if she spends a penny on herself it MUST have come from the maintenance 😂

Whatsmyusername30 · 19/01/2021 19:19

You said it... total dick. He sounds like an ass. Sadly it’s not uncommon.

HugeAckmansWife · 19/01/2021 19:15

Oh and Cosey maintenance to the nrps child should not be dropped because they choose to move in with someone else's child. If the mother of the 2nd child loses some UC as a result, that is for them to consider in advance. Its not compulsory to live together and an NRP should not be supporting a step family at the expense of the first. Maintenance should be the first financial obligation an NRP has to fulfill. All else, rent, bills, etc should be 2nd priority so wage - cms = what you can afford rent wise etc. If you need more, find a way to earn it, you don't dump the shortfall on the RP to make up.

BlowDryRat · 19/01/2021 19:12

Yes, of course single mums are all benefit scroungers popping out kids with as many men as possible to 'milk the system' Hmm Ignore the ignorant troll OP.

The child maintenance system in this country is a joke. I have no idea why it proper reform isn't prioritised so that NRPs pay their fair share (except it's benefit-scrounging wimmin and their offspring, so who cares? Hmm). If you spent £5 a week on your kids then you'd be jailed.

FWIW, I out-earn my ex 4 times over and pay 10 X more in tax than I receive from him. He pays the CMS amount to the penny and no more. I think he's a dick.

formerbabe · 19/01/2021 19:09

Its disgusting.

Should be an inprisonable offence.

There should also be a separate charge of child neglect. If a resident parent refused to spend money on the child, they would be in serious trouble as the child wouldn't be fed, warm or clothed. It would be neglect. I see no reason why a nrp should be able to get away with it.

HugeAckmansWife · 19/01/2021 19:05

cosey what on earth are you talking about? First of all, the OPs ex is a man as are 90 something % of nrps, so enough with the 'women are shit too'. We know thanks, but saying that in no way changes the above statistic or the sex of the nrps people on this thread are talking about. Secondly, if a single parent gets benefits, the child gets fsm etc it's because they are entitled to them.. Probably because their earning potential is severely limited by those pesky dependent children who insist on being kept fed, warm and safe at all times. On another thread today, a (male) poster is moaning about his ex having a new partner and missing his kids who he sees eow. He can't possibly have them 50/50 though because of his all important job. Plenty of single mums, me included work full time and only get CB. I earn a decent salary. Those that don't, usually are prevented from doing so by childcare issues... But you carry on and believe we're all workshy lazy fuckers living on handouts, microwaving burgers for the kids once every few days and getting our nails done with your money. Twat. OP, I absolutely believe there needs to be a high level review of all things cms related.. It should be an outpost of HMRC with all info shared for a start.

Notenoughchocolateomg · 19/01/2021 17:20

It's a joke. I get £7.04 a week in total for my 2 children. He doesn't work, but could easily afford more, but he chose to spend it on alcohol and prescription drugs. He was originally paying £20 a week, but he cancelled it so I went through cms. He then said he didn't cancel it and if I'd just told him about it, he'd have reinstated it to £20, but the cms only told him to pay that so that's what he pays. Selfish pricks the lot of them.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 19/01/2021 15:55

@Coseynightin

I see the hypocrisy is outstanding on here. Parents who dodge Child Maintenance should be jailed however lets not pretend that mothers dont milk the system cos they do.

Maintenance + Benefits + other perks like fsm, child benefit etc

I read from a poster they don't think it is fair that money should be dropped if they move in with another partner and child. Why not?

Everyone gets child benefit unless you are a high earner, couples as well as single parents.

No one "milks" the system. People claim what they are entitled to if on a low wage. And not all single mothers get benefits. I am a single mum and my DS doesn't get free school meals!

Hankunamatata · 19/01/2021 15:48

Would is be possible to report him for tax evasion and get him investigated?

2020canfuckitself · 19/01/2021 15:40

@Coseynightin so because some single parents receive those that means we're all some how conning the system? What are you on?

OP posts:
Doublefaced · 19/01/2021 15:40

As long as there are women prepared to stand by and encourage men who fail to maintain their financial obligations to their children, then they will continue to do so.
If an RP failed to provide heat, shelter, food and clothing for their child then social services would rightly be involved.

Coseynightin · 19/01/2021 15:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.