Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL, FIL and a kidney transplant (potentially sensitive content)

341 replies

muffinsinabox · 15/01/2021 13:57

I've name changed for this as there is absolutely no way I want this linked to my usual MN username.

FIL needs a kidney transplant. Well to be more precise FIL needs another kidney transplant. He had one about 10 years ago, but I dont know why exactly as MIL wont say. However FIL isn't the picture of a man in his 60's in good health. He drinks, denies he smokes, eats anything he wants (supposed to be on a renal diet). He's back on dialysis but his kidney function is dropping pretty quickly.

DH is fairly low contact with his parents. Phone calls for birthdays, christmases and token presents. I keep in more touch with the in laws only for the sake of the kids. MIL can be very trying at times, and if it wasnt for the kids I wouldn't want anything to do with her.

I'm absolutely 100% for organ donation. I've got a donor card and once I am dead they can take what they want for whatever they need it for. If it wasn't for a very real and serious needle phobia I would also give blood.

Mil's facebook feed is all full of things about live kidney donation. I gather FIL's transplant person has told her that someone once found a donor on facebook so she's gone with it. Her choice and all of that although I don't agree with the forceful tone of some of the stuff she posts, nor do I agree with being tagged in it. Part of the reason why I really don't like MIL is that it's her opinion and her opinion only that counts. Somehow MIL has found out that I am the same blood group as FIL and she has now gone all out on trying to get me tested as a potential donor for FIL. Tagging me in multiple posts, sending me stuff, blackmail (what would your dc do without FIL type stuff), trying to make appointments for me to speak to the transplant team, telling DH that he needs to 'sort me out' as I am being a silly little girl, getting other people who have donated kidneys to talk to me, crying down the phone...

Except I don't want to. I don't want to go for the initial testing as I just cant hack the blood tests, I dont even want to speak to the transplant team as I dont want to be talked into something I am so against. It's like I am being treated as a renta-kidney and MIL doesnt give a damn about me. I dont want to put myself through the risks of surgery as I have 2 small children myself and want to be there for them. I've told MIL bluntly that it just isnt going to happen, yet even today she has tagged me on fb for some stuff that only just falls short of emotional blackmail.

So AIBU for wanting MIL to shove off??

OP posts:
weleasewoderick23 · 16/01/2021 17:11

This has made my really angry for you op!

My sister needed a kidney transplant and I offered to donate mine, even though she kept insisting that I didn't need to. We went through the process of organising with the transplant team, I had loads of tests and counselling, she kept insisting that I didn't have to do it. She was only 48 and had been on dialysis for years and her kidneys were severely damaged.

I ended up donating my kidney ( really painful op and a lot of recovery time). They transplanted my kidney into her and her body rejected it. She spent a long and painful year in hospital and died at the age of 51. Despite my reassurances that we couldn't have predicted what would happen, she died feeling really guilty that I had lost a kidney for nowt.

Your MIL is deluded if she thinks it's as simple as taking a kidney from one person and transplanting to another. There are so many things that can go wrong even with a 100% match and there are many hoops to jump through before the operation is carried out, counselling being one of them.

If my sisters transplant team had even a whiff of me having any doubts they would've shut it down. I would ignore her shit, it's not as simple as a blood type match. If you really want her to sit up and take notice, offer to go to one of FIL's renal appointments and the consultations will shut it down immediately and she'll have to shut the fuck up!

Sorry for the rant. BTW, I'm fine at the moment with one kidney but I've been warned that I could have problems later in my life. I don't regret it either.

AlexisCarringtonColbyDexter · 16/01/2021 15:17

Really? If she would get along with her inlaws and he took care of his health she’d be unreasonable to say no? In my opinion she can always say no, just because it’s her body, but personally I would never ever donate to people I’m only related to by law

I agree. The second you start bringing in "should" or "unreasonable" in terms of organ donation is the moment you go down a very VERY unpleasant road.

We all have autonomy over our own bodies and thats the way it should be. I dont care if the reason you dont want to donate is due to something as trivial as her choice in shoes, it does not matter one jot. NO means no and noone ever needs to justify not wanting to lose an organ from their body that can have life limiting side effects down the road. It is a major operation with potentially huge health implications. Noone is obliged to go through that for anyone, relative or not.

MumW · 16/01/2021 14:45

I think you are being very generous offering her the opportunity to stop before cutting ties.
The questions I'd be asking is "Do my DC really need that kind of grandparent?", "When is this batshittery going to be directed at them?"

Lostinthemail · 16/01/2021 14:24

@HighSpecWhistle

YANBU.

If he was trying to help himself and you got along well then I'd say YABU. But as it stands, you're pretty confident he'll carry on his addictions after the transplant. Meanwhile it leaves you vulnerable should you have kidney issues in the future.

Stand firm. Say no. If she pushes further then give it to her straight; you are not risking your future health for someone who is not respecting their own body.

Really? If she would get along with her inlaws and he took care of his health she’d be unreasonable to say no? In my opinion she can always say no, just because it’s her body, but personally I would never ever donate to people I’m only related to by law.
Crocadilla · 16/01/2021 14:22

I truly hope it's gone well for you, your DH and DC today.

In my opinion, if this doesn't get through to her, you would be doing a huge disservice to your children by not going NC with the MIL and FIL regardless of whether or not they are the only grandparents left. They are toxic and seeing you tolerating and being bullied by them is not an example you want to set to your children. They need to see that it is never acceptable to allow yourself to be emotionally or physically abused by family or otherwise.

Cosyjimjamsforautumn · 16/01/2021 13:31

I have a family member who donated a living kidney in a "domino" so that someone else could donate to his wife. The recipient has fared very well but my donor relative was unfortunate to be very unwell after donation (unforseen complications) and its also affected his longterm health. He would do it again for his DW but advises caution.
He was willing and desperate to donate, you are not. Block your MIL on FB (or at least stop her tagging you without your approval). Glad your DH will clarify this with her.

Thedarknightsaredrawingin · 16/01/2021 13:15

Hope all goes well today.

CoraPirbright · 16/01/2021 12:41

Good luck to your DH. Hope it goes well (or as well as can be expected).

Santaiscovidfree · 16/01/2021 10:36

A dh to be proud of op. A rare breed on mn!

Frazzled2207 · 16/01/2021 10:01

Hope it goes well. Very pleased dh is on your side here that’s key.
Am surprised he is eligible for another transplant if he hasn’t put in effort to improve his health.
Surely they cost the nhs an enormous amount of money? Or theoretically can anyone who needs a new kidney be put on the list?

WhereYouLeftIt · 16/01/2021 09:32

Your MIL sounds like exactly the sort of person the phrase "Fuck Off" was designed for SadAngry.

"Basically she needs to accept it isnt going to happen or we will be cutting off all ties completely."
Cut them anyway. She adds nothing to your lives and never will.

CecilyP · 16/01/2021 09:25

Anyone calling me 'a silky little girl' for any reason, wouldn't be getting my used dental floss, let alone a kidney.

Agreed. Also think your MIL is a silly big girl if she thinks you are in any way likely to be a match simply because you share a blood group. After all, there are only 8 to choose from, and the 2 most common are each shared by 80% of the population. If it was so simple it wouldn’t be so hard find donor matches. Does MIL somehow think you’re related to her husband because you married her son?

If it was a close family member that needed a kidney but you really didn't want to do it then the transplant team are great at saying you're not suitable, family harmony us kept & you can support them in other ways. But in this situation I wouldn't waste their time.

Yes despite many posters advising it, I wouldn’t waste the time of busy medical professionals in this way. It isn’t their job to sort out family disagreements. It also gives MIL the idea that you are interested, rather than it being a ver firm no.

Thamigumathacharaid · 16/01/2021 08:43

YANBU. My "mother" needed a kidney transplant and signed me up to the organ donor register in the belief that she'd get mine if anything happened to me. Thankfully, she refused to give up smoking or lose weight/change diet so she could be on the renal list so my siblings and I were spared having to go through tests.

WitchesBritchesPumpkinPants · 16/01/2021 07:12

I've read your update.

I feel got your husband, he's already gone very low contact with his parents, but YOU decided you knew better & kept more contact & involved them in your lives & now he is having to deal with it. I'm pleased he is, but you shouldn't have created the space in your lives for her to behave like this.

She's not good for your children. Just go VKC with the bloody woman.

She's horrible & clearly quite thick.
No contact.

Anyone calling me 'a silky little girl' for any reason, wouldn't be getting my used dental floss, let alone a kidney.

If it was a close family member that needed a kidney but you really didn't want to do it then the transplant team are great at saying you're not suitable, family harmony us kept & you can support them in other ways. But in this situation I wouldn't waste their time.

She's like the gift that keeps giving Distance yourself from her bat shittery for once & for all!!

legalseagull · 16/01/2021 07:09

Your plan is good - apart from telling her what she posts on her Facebook. You can't control her. You can control yourself by blocking her or at least clicking 'see less' of her

CovidCakeConundrum · 16/01/2021 06:50

Are you at all worried that it is an inheritance genetic condition and that's why she won't tell you? Could it be that your DH or DC will need a kidney in the future?

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/01/2021 05:44

Good plan! Have a peaceful day....

lyralalala · 16/01/2021 05:06

@Sacredspace

Who the hell has got time to waste arranging and attending an appointment to talk to a transplant team having absolutely no intention of going ahead with a transplant! And presumably the appointment/transplant would be in a hospital setting in the middle of a pandemic! You should not have to go to these lengths to appease this unreasonable woman. You would just be buying into the crazy! Just no.
I actually would speak to them, very briefly, just to make sure MIL is not wasting their precious time telling them that "DIL is a blood type match, she'll be in touch soon"

Just in case they are expecting/waiting on a call.

Sacredspace · 15/01/2021 22:30

Who the hell has got time to waste arranging and attending an appointment to talk to a transplant team having absolutely no intention of going ahead with a transplant!
And presumably the appointment/transplant would be in a hospital setting in the middle of a pandemic! You should not have to go to these lengths to appease this unreasonable woman. You would just be buying into the crazy! Just no.

Carriemac · 15/01/2021 22:28

Well
Done

MaggieFS · 15/01/2021 22:25

A very measured and sensible plan of action, OP. I hope it goes as well as it can tomorrow and you are all able to move on.

Mif4 · 15/01/2021 22:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Dowser · 15/01/2021 22:20

Good lord!
I’ve had it all now.
It goes like this.
No and don’t you dare ask me again

maddening · 15/01/2021 22:16

Tell her you have a horseshoe kidney if you don't want the agro

muffinsinabox · 15/01/2021 22:08

Last update on this because I have had the worlds biggest curry takeaway* and I will be going to bed soon.

The key- MIL originally had one because we asked her to feed the cat while we were on holiday. However she kept hold of this key and/or had another one cut. It was a complete nightmare, she would just randomly let herself in to see 'my little baby' aka DC1. We took it back.
There was a lot bit of a kerfuffle over this, involving comments from her about me honey trapping DH. Added to the fact that she has as much maternal love as my slippers there is no love lost between them. FIL has always been distant and not really involved. This is when DH went low contact with her.

I've read Dh some of the points people made, especially those about coercion not being valid consent, kidney donation being pretty brutal, and there being more to a kidney transplant than just matching blood groups. And the points about the transplant co-ordinators who will pick up on everything quite quickly. DH said some other stuff as well but out of respect for him I dont want to post them.

And I have played with my fb settings as well so anyone who posts anything thats got me in it or tagged me has to get my approval first.

Dh backs me 100000% in this. As he put it, I'm not 'kidneys r us' and as FIL has already trashed 3 perfectly good kidneys, why should he get a fourth when the chances of him treating that one with respect are minimal. Tomorrow, I am going to take the dc to the park at the end of the street to feed the kids ducks some bread. and DH is going to ring his mother because if I have to speak to her it wont be polite. The only time I have ever seen DH even remotely cross is when dcat3 was a kitten and she used him as a climbing frame to get to a high up shelf. DH stays calm no matter what. He's going to make it absolutely perfectly clear to her that..

She is not to post anything about altrusitic kidney donation and tag/mention me in it
She is not to post anything about kidney donation and grandchildren needing grandparents
She stops giving my phone number to anyone who has given a kidney to a family member to try and persuade me of the benefits.
She is to stop trying to make me appointments with the transplant team
She is to stop posting us stuff about kidney donation, how people can live with only one kidney, what the operation is like
Plus the stuff about coercion, more than blood groups and I'm not kidneys r us

Basically she needs to accept it isnt going to happen or we will be cutting off all ties completely. And going from the last time DH had a falling out with her, I can pretty much predict exactly what is going to happen. And in some ways it'll be bliss not having to deal with her batshittery any more.

Thank you to everyone who has replied. I guess I posted more in desperation than anything else after the latest round of fb nonsense. Your replies have been useful, insightful and have helped us to form a way forward. And an especial thanks to the person who contacted me directly with some very specific and detailed information. And for those of you who have lost people through transplant, waiting for a transplant or transplant related complications then I am truly sorry for your loss.

*their lockdown special as they call it. You can choose lamb, chicken, veg or paneer and get a selection of whatever they have in the kitchen on the day plus rice, naan and poppadoms. Their already generous portions are now super generous- enough for me to be eating curry for tea tomorrow night as well, and probably Sunday as well if DH doesnt get there first.

OP posts: