Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No free school meals during Feb half term

771 replies

noblegiraffe · 14/01/2021 13:27

The new guidance on free school meals says that schools should not provide food or vouchers during Feb half term.

This won’t be needed as some general funding is going to LAs and they will be expected to provide food/support for the week schools are off.

This is bonkers, right? They’ve only just sorted it so that kids get more than a manky banana, cheese and dry bread for lunch and they’re going to switch to a different system for a week?

Does this government just really hate feeding hungry kids?

YANBU: sticking with one system for feeding disadvantaged kids would be best

YABU: it’ll be fine, no one will fall through the cracks and the transition will be seamless.

No free school meals during Feb half term
OP posts:
Bookworming · 17/01/2021 08:05

@Fortnumhamper which world do you live in? Do you not believe in sex before marriage? Do you not understand that people are not all in well paid jobs? Do you not think that it's as important to have income protection as it is critical illness cover, go you not realise that some people can't afford either? Do you not realise that not everyone can buy a property?

You really are one of the most deluded people over ever stumbled across on MN!

FYI I did/had everything you say in your post but I do realise that not everyone is in the same position as I was. I'm not that bloody judgemental.

WhatWouldPhyllisCraneDo · 16/01/2021 21:39

@VinylDetective

Anyone else know where to begin with the appropriately named Fortnumshamper’s post because I sure as hell don’t.
I'll start with FOTTFSOFAWYGTFOSM Wink
Wheresmykimchi · 16/01/2021 21:05

[quote Parker231]@Fortnumhamper - have you ever volunteered at a foodbank?[/quote]
Only for married people who lost their jobs suddenly but only for one week while they get on their feet.

Parker231 · 16/01/2021 21:02

@Fortnumhamper - have you ever volunteered at a foodbank?

Wheresmykimchi · 16/01/2021 20:59

@VinylDetective

Anyone else know where to begin with the appropriately named Fortnumshamper’s post because I sure as hell don’t.
Spectacular cross post.
VinylDetective · 16/01/2021 20:58

Anyone else know where to begin with the appropriately named Fortnumshamper’s post because I sure as hell don’t.

Wheresmykimchi · 16/01/2021 20:58

@Fortnumhamper

It's not the Governments fault if parents aren't feeding children.

So many frustrating points in this thread. Parents don't know how to boil rice or an egg or make a stew?

Before you plan to have children you have a stable job, live in a secure property, have some savings, have life/ critical illness insurance in case you lose said job, be with your partner for a number of years and really question if you will be together forever. Work out how many children you can actually afford to have. Have a contingency plan for job loss.

All this complete crap about "I don't drive, can't afford the bus and the shops are 10 miles away" well what the actual hell did you think you were going to do when you had a child to feed then? You must have thought they would need feeding??

I think there are very few family with no gas, electric, internet or shops near by. Some yes and some with one or two if those factors. Those families that do exist need intervention to get the parents into work, learn to budget, learn to cook.

The problem is people fecklessly have kids without money, a home and a stable relationship and then expect subsidised rent, benefits, food handouts. So long as we keep making it easy to pick up after people they will keep doing it.

All this "my circumstances changed" I would ask by how much, were you a married home owner with money behind you before you had kids then life dealt a blow? In which case let's help you just whilst you get on your feet but I have no time for people that don't work then bleat that they can't feed the kids. Very few people can't work.

You haven't got a clue. Not a clue. I don't even know where to start Grin
Wheresmykimchi · 16/01/2021 20:57

@VinylDetective

She never had me on board but I did think she had enough common sense to realise that some families are living in bed and breakfasts and hostels. How privileged and out of touch do you have to be to write that?
Quite.

Well, back on board...more so that I actually saw where she was coming from compared to her precious posts.

Wheresmykimchi · 16/01/2021 20:56

[quote donewithitalltodayandxmas]@Wheresmykimchi do you know the tory funder doesn't actually work for them anymore and you also failed that la decide so if a labour or lib dem la chose chartwells that can't be blamed on the goverment , yet you solely want this put in the goverment.
Have you campaigned for fsm in holidays for the last 20 years or just last couple months ? Didn't lib dems have the idea of fsm for more ? [/quote]
I've always campaigned for it always yeah but more so on a pandemic.

I've never once said I want it solely put on the government.

The funder left in December shortly before the con was all unearthed how ... convenient.

noblegiraffe · 16/01/2021 20:48

[quote donewithitalltodayandxmas]@VinylDetective also there has been funding given to la for the holidays to cover , yet no one mentions this [/quote]
Literally there in my OP Hmm

OP posts:
Fortnumhamper · 16/01/2021 20:44

It's not the Governments fault if parents aren't feeding children.

So many frustrating points in this thread. Parents don't know how to boil rice or an egg or make a stew?

Before you plan to have children you have a stable job, live in a secure property, have some savings, have life/ critical illness insurance in case you lose said job, be with your partner for a number of years and really question if you will be together forever. Work out how many children you can actually afford to have. Have a contingency plan for job loss.

All this complete crap about "I don't drive, can't afford the bus and the shops are 10 miles away" well what the actual hell did you think you were going to do when you had a child to feed then? You must have thought they would need feeding??

I think there are very few family with no gas, electric, internet or shops near by. Some yes and some with one or two if those factors. Those families that do exist need intervention to get the parents into work, learn to budget, learn to cook.

The problem is people fecklessly have kids without money, a home and a stable relationship and then expect subsidised rent, benefits, food handouts. So long as we keep making it easy to pick up after people they will keep doing it.

All this "my circumstances changed" I would ask by how much, were you a married home owner with money behind you before you had kids then life dealt a blow? In which case let's help you just whilst you get on your feet but I have no time for people that don't work then bleat that they can't feed the kids. Very few people can't work.

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 16/01/2021 20:41

@VinylDetective also there has been funding given to la for the holidays to cover , yet no one mentions this

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 16/01/2021 20:39

@VinylDetective yet some won't see it like that , i don't vote for them but I am actually better off than I was under labour and we are not by any means high earners , I live in HA house and I have seen too many take the piss out if the system, whilst others struggle.
No one has ever called for fsm in holidays until now and lots who have been affected by covid and jobs won't qualify for fsm , yet no one seems to think those people may struggle to feed there children too and will be making huge sacrifices.
Its when people go its all tory voters fault and tory donars fault that we loose sight of it all.
Like those ignoring someone shouting loudly but avoiding taxes ?

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 16/01/2021 20:35

@Banoffeepies I agree some will get overlooked

VinylDetective · 16/01/2021 20:34

[quote donewithitalltodayandxmas]@Wheresmykimchi you blame just the tories . I struggled to feed my kids under labour , would marcus rashford not of been a child under a labout goverment at least some of it ? Successive goverments have not addressed all the issues , I don't believe any party is good for all and will fix all the problems [/quote]
The Tories are blamed because they’ve been in power for nearly 11 years and have impoverished a huge number of people in that time.

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 16/01/2021 20:33

@Wheresmykimchi do you know the tory funder doesn't actually work for them anymore and you also failed that la decide so if a labour or lib dem la chose chartwells that can't be blamed on the goverment , yet you solely want this put in the goverment.
Have you campaigned for fsm in holidays for the last 20 years or just last couple months ? Didn't lib dems have the idea of fsm for more ?

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 16/01/2021 20:29

@Wheresmykimchi you blame just the tories . I struggled to feed my kids under labour , would marcus rashford not of been a child under a labout goverment at least some of it ? Successive goverments have not addressed all the issues , I don't believe any party is good for all and will fix all the problems

VinylDetective · 16/01/2021 19:59

She never had me on board but I did think she had enough common sense to realise that some families are living in bed and breakfasts and hostels. How privileged and out of touch do you have to be to write that?

Wheresmykimchi · 16/01/2021 19:16

@Katyppp

Podgebod, i think it was said on the other thread actually, along with other nonsense about having no gas or electricity, no cooking pots, no ability to cook and, most memorably, no kitchen. One poster even wrote very emotionally about how priviledged they were because they had a kitchen and cookbooks. Such hand-wringing sentimentality gets us nowhere, and only makes people like me slap their head and call nonsense. As i have said before, i look at things in a very unemotionless way, and as soon as that sort of thing is spoken about as being very widespread, my response is to throw up my hands and stop listening.
Oh Katy you had me back onboard until this post.
PodgeBod · 16/01/2021 19:14

I want to add that my kids aren't starving, they don't go hungry. I wouldn't let that happen. But I can easily see how someone could fall through the holes and get in that position. The child maintenance I recieve makes all the difference

PodgeBod · 16/01/2021 19:08

@Katyppp very easy to be cool and detached by something that doesn't seem to effect you Hmm the scenarios you are sneering at are no stranger to me- when my mum had to leave her job due to her disability worsening, we frequently struggled to afford food, our gas and electric went off regularly and when our oven broke my mum couldn't afford to replace it for over a year. If you couldn't cook it on the hob or in the toaster, we just didn't have it. I receive FSM for my kids and I really struggle with finances, these vouchers have helped me immeasurably. You calling it "hand-wringing sentimentality" is very insulting to me.

Katyppp · 16/01/2021 18:02

Podgebod, i think it was said on the other thread actually, along with other nonsense about having no gas or electricity, no cooking pots, no ability to cook and, most memorably, no kitchen.
One poster even wrote very emotionally about how priviledged they were because they had a kitchen and cookbooks.
Such hand-wringing sentimentality gets us nowhere, and only makes people like me slap their head and call nonsense.
As i have said before, i look at things in a very unemotionless way, and as soon as that sort of thing is spoken about as being very widespread, my response is to throw up my hands and stop listening.

PodgeBod · 16/01/2021 16:31

@Fuzzywuzzyface

I work in a school office and we have provided substantial food hampers for families and next weeks will have even more food added. Less than half of the families entitled to the hampers bothered to collect them.

We are a primary school in a deprived area. Why on earth would you not come and get this food? The families are in walking distance. The families who have not bothered to respond to emails, texts and voice messages will now only be contacted once for future hampers. The amount of behind the scenes admin/work hours that have gone into this over the past couple of weeks has been unbelievable.

I would imagine this scenario has been replicated up and down the country..there have been numerous posts on this thread alone saying children are going hungry..the vast majority are not.

I don't think anybody has said the vast majority are going hungry. A lot of people are managing fine even on benefits but I'm sure that for some of those families that did come and get them they made a big difference. My school has stuck with vouchers throughout which I'm pleased with, I would just rather choose my own food for my child.
Fuzzywuzzyface · 16/01/2021 16:22

I work in a school office and we have provided substantial food hampers for families and next weeks will have even more food added. Less than half of the families entitled to the hampers bothered to collect them.

We are a primary school in a deprived area. Why on earth would you not come and get this food? The families are in walking distance. The families who have not bothered to respond to emails, texts and voice messages will now only be contacted once for future hampers. The amount of behind the scenes admin/work hours that have gone into this over the past couple of weeks has been unbelievable.

I would imagine this scenario has been replicated up and down the country..there have been numerous posts on this thread alone saying children are going hungry..the vast majority are not.

Katyppp · 16/01/2021 16:06

@WhatWouldPhyllisCraneDo

There has been help with heating bills for years. Only if the temp drops below a certain level for a set amount of days. But it does exist. I think I got the payment once when my dc were a lot smaller.
There has been free school meals for years also, but the latest calls are to expand the provision already in place.
Swipe left for the next trending thread